Ear Candle Worked?

Yeah, I should have known better, but honestly, I didn't know where else to ask.

The problem is not where to ask, it's that you don't appear to actually have a question to start with. You have no evidence that anything actually happened, and even if we assume something actually did you have none of the information that would be required to determine what it was.

It's similar to many UFO reports really. Someone says they saw a light moving in the sky. Even if we accept that they did indeed see a light, without having accurate measurements of distance, size, speed, duration, and so on, there is simply no way to ever tell what it was. Compare that to your case. We don't have any objective measure of your hearing before or after, we don't have any record of what you actually did or when you did it, we don't have any record of anything else that might have been happening at the same time. So there's simply nothing any of us can say. All we know is that ear candling doesn't work in theory and has been shown not to work in practice, so whatever might have happened certainly wasn't due to that.
 
I had no interest in starting a thread devoted to methods of ear care.

As for my sister's experience, she said the doctor was not very gentle with the syringe and the sensation of the water was generally unpleasant. This link http://forums.webmd.com/.eec1bf8 has a doctor pointing this out:
If the medical provider was not careful, the extremely-sensitive ear canal could have been scratched, or the eardrum injured.

How could I? You didn't even give me a link. Regardless, it's been studied multiple times and the conclusion is always the same; bogus with a capital B.
I told you where to easily find the video. I had to post 15 times before I was allowed to include a link. Here it is now: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=80uY0tXvnS4

MRC Hans - Thank you for being the only one who offered me any information on the question I was actually asking.

I'm so disappointed with all this. I thought the point of this forum and skepticism was to ask questions, to learn things, to discuss ideas. Not summarily dismiss anyone who dares to even gently poke at your preconceived notions that every "holistic cure" couldn't possibly do anything other than harm. What is so wrong with even proposing that some people's accounts of the beneficial effects of ear candling could be accurate, with a caveat that the danger outweighs the potential benefit especially when faced with other commonly accepted methods? Why do you so strongly assume everyone has to be a liar, delusional, or simply mistaken even when they are trying to find a non-woo explanation by seeking out the validity of a somewhat specific non-woo proposal? To go with the alien analogy, it's as if I described something in the sky, said I do not believe that what I saw was anything alien or supernatural, then asked if a plane could behave in such a way. And all you replied is, "It's not aliens." "You didn't see anything." "You were hallucinating." Very helpful, thanks guys.
 
What is so wrong with even proposing that some people's accounts of the beneficial effects of ear candling could be accurate, with a caveat that the danger outweighs the potential benefit especially when faced with other commonly accepted methods?


Anecdotes often tend to mislead others and could have a detrimental effect on them. The following essay about alternative medicine and common errors of reasoning is worth a read:
http://www.sram.org/0302/bias.html
 
I'm so disappointed with all this. I thought the point of this forum and skepticism was to ask questions, to learn things, to discuss ideas. Not summarily dismiss anyone who dares to even gently poke at your preconceived notions that every "holistic cure" couldn't possibly do anything other than harm. What is so wrong with even proposing that some people's accounts of the beneficial effects of ear candling could be accurate, with a caveat that the danger outweighs the potential benefit especially when faced with other commonly accepted methods? Why do you so strongly assume everyone has to be a liar, delusional, or simply mistaken even when they are trying to find a non-woo explanation by seeking out the validity of a somewhat specific non-woo proposal? To go with the alien analogy, it's as if I described something in the sky, said I do not believe that what I saw was anything alien or supernatural, then asked if a plane could behave in such a way. And all you replied is, "It's not aliens." "You didn't see anything." "You were hallucinating." Very helpful, thanks guys.

Well, I have to agree. Again, I do understand the reactions, because we all get this 'oh no, not another one' feeling, but may I suggest that those who get that simply move on (I plead guilty to also at times succumbing the knee-jerk reaction, but we can try)? Usually someone will bother to give a balanced reply and occasionally, sensible debate may follow.

There are some kinds of woo that are so basically silly that it is fair to dismiss them out of hand, but those things that actually have a physical effect (and ear candling obviously has), may also do something, good or bad or immaterial.

Anyway, auntysocial, do hang in here. The tone may be rough sometimes, but you will inevitably learn something.


Hans
 
Let's go to Silly Land for a second and pretend that it could actually work. Why the hell would I even consider such a silly thing when I could just use a damn Q Tip? I can't think of too many things that are more pointless and unneeded than an ear candle. What dumb ass even thought this up anyway? What could he have been doing that somehow caused him to think a candle should go up to his ears? Jesus, that is ****** retarded.

Link
 
The snake oil peddler then places a lit candle on top of the other ear in vertical position, with the bottom resting on something like a plate that also rests over the ear. The typical claim that the heat from the top of the candle causes a "reverse pressure" that sucks out the wax (which blatantly violates the laws of physics, but whatever).

Auntysocial on the other hand is saying that the smoke and heat caused the clearing. What I don't understand is how the actual smoke from the flame traveled downward from the top of the candle and entered her ear canal. Here's a picture to demonstrate.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0b/Ear_Candling.jpg

I'm going to put aside the fact that a typical candle flame doesn't produce enough smoke at any given time to somehow cause earwax to melt or evaporate (not without enough exposure that would also cause burns anyway) for a second so I can just understand how you got the smoke into your ear.

I think that's a fairly atypical way to use an ear candle - most of the examples I've seen are used by having the end placed directly into the ear canal (albeit not very far inside). I'm guessing that your picture demonstrates a newer "technique" that avoids the criticism that the normal way of doing things runs the risk of dripping hot wax or ash onto the eardrum.

Additionally, despite the name they're not like ordinary candles at all, which don't produce much smoke while burning, true; they're more like tubes of waxed paper. Which do. Like mrc_hans I have no problem believing that smoke could be emitted from the bottom of such a tube.

Edit: Furthermore the suggestion of sticking "a damn Q-tip" into your ear in order to clear wax is frowned upon by medical types, for what ought to be pretty bloody obvious reasons.
 
Last edited:
To add my thoughts on AuntySocial's anecdote; I'm sure your ear felt better after the candling, but it's hard to see a mechanism through which the candling per se could have helped. I just don't think that there's enough heat coming into the ear to make any difference, and even if the smoke hardened the wax it's hard to see how that would do anything other than make the problem worse.

I'm going to vote with the "blockages can be cyclical and lying still on your side probably helped" group :) (yes, even though you sleep on your side - so still and for so long?)
 
Clogged ears is a self-limiting condition. It eventually goes away. On its own. Without doing a thing. There hasn't been any evidence to suggest that anything other than this happened.
 
I too have done this myself - after all, there's really no difference whether it's done by a doctor, nurse or oneself.

To do this, I took the shower-head off my shower, and held the shower hose as tight as I could with a hand onto an empty "BIC"-type pen with the narrow end in the ear. Use as hot water as you can be comfortable with - very easy, and not at all painful, in fact quite pleasant !

I attend the Royal National Throat, Nose, and Ear Hospital (incidentally, when did the term switch from "ear, nose and throat" to the other way round?) whenever my ear gets blocked up with wax. They do not recommend syringing the ears, instead they use a micro-suction technique to suck out the wax while leaving the eardrum dry.

This is noisy and slightly uncomfortable but again, it does not cause any lasting pain.
 
I told you where to easily find the video. I had to post 15 times before I was allowed to include a link. Here it is now: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=80uY0tXvnS4
The fact is that there is evidence that ear candles do not work (see the previous links).
And yes there is smoke from the bottom of the candle. This is because the candle is actually a chimney. The heat at the top seals the top of the chimney leaving only the bottom available for the smoke to leave.
This is a bad thing! You do not want smoke of an unknown composition and temperature in contact with a sensitive area such the inside of your ear.
 
Has anyone considered making an ass candle to cure constipation?
 
Has anyone considered making an ass candle to cure constipation?

You, sir, must be some kind of genius. There's BIG money in bogus medicine. I'd bet you could market that and make millions.

The only real problem here is that you probably have a conscious. It might be hard to sleep at night knowing that you've turned to the Dark Side and joined the ranks of faith healers and snake oil salesmen... on the other hand, you'd be able to afford top shelf booze and could probably just drink yourself to sleep each night. I say go for it. :D
 
I'm so disappointed with all this. I thought the point of this forum and skepticism was to ask questions, to learn things, to discuss ideas. Not summarily dismiss anyone who dares to even gently poke at your preconceived notions that every "holistic cure" couldn't possibly do anything other than harm. What is so wrong with even proposing that some people's accounts of the beneficial effects of ear candling could be accurate, with a caveat that the danger outweighs the potential benefit especially when faced with other commonly accepted methods? Why do you so strongly assume everyone has to be a liar, delusional, or simply mistaken even when they are trying to find a non-woo explanation by seeking out the validity of a somewhat specific non-woo proposal? To go with the alien analogy, it's as if I described something in the sky, said I do not believe that what I saw was anything alien or supernatural, then asked if a plane could behave in such a way. And all you replied is, "It's not aliens." "You didn't see anything." "You were hallucinating." Very helpful, thanks guys.

Firstly, a lot of skeptics are dicks. That's just a fact. A lot of people come to forums like this specifically for the opportunity to sink the boot into an easy target like a homeopath or a psychic. It's an intellectual battle that you are guaranteed to win, because these people are irrational, deluded and just plain wrong.

(Of course as soon as those skeptics get off easy topics like homeopathy and discuss things that are a little more complicated, they tend to do rather badly).

Secondly, your story wasn't very interesting. You had a self-limiting condition and it fixed itself. I've had blocked ears once or twice and they just go away of their own accord, sometimes quite suddenly. Yours happened to go away when you candled your earhole, but so what? It's not exactly a large-scale controlled trial, is it? If it went away when you ate a ham sandwich you wouldn't have bothered posting about it, but because it happened when you tried a woo remedy you thought that might be evidence of causation. It's not, or rather it's very, very weak evidence of causation which is directly opposed to the actual research done on the topic which shows no causation at all.
 
You, sir, must be some kind of genius. There's BIG money in bogus medicine. I'd bet you could market that and make millions.

The only real problem here is that you probably have a conscious. It might be hard to sleep at night knowing that you've turned to the Dark Side and joined the ranks of faith healers and snake oil salesmen... on the other hand, you'd be able to afford top shelf booze and could probably just drink yourself to sleep each night. I say go for it. :D

I do sometimes think "someone's going to make money off these muppets, why shouldn't it be me?" Then I think "I wouldn't be able to live with myself." Maybe if I could come up with a way to sell the ass candle while freely admitting it doesn't work?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom