Ear Candle Worked?

Never said it removed the wax, just that it cleared my ear, so I could hear again. Two different things. My assumption was that it shifted or broke up the wax, much in the same way laying on your side would.


Did you lie on your side while using the ear candles?
 
In other word , while you have no basis and could not check what action might have cleared your ear, you chose to believe it was the candling action, as opposed to the other possible explanation, despite being told above that ear candling doesn't do anything
I entertained the thought yes. Those other options occurred to me as well. Except the possibility for it being the insertion alone was diminished since similar techniques were tried previously and repeatedly. How are you so sure it wasn't the smoke, have you studied the use of multiple candles on a very clogged ear? How about a study that looks at he effect the smoke and heat could have on ear wax? They all just focused on the claims made by the people selling the things. Why is it so impossible something might have been overlooked and there could be some truth to the claims that it has worked for some people? (not saying that means they should be used)
 
Yes, I understand how you feel. However, you did, probably accidentially follow a pattern we have come to recognize all too well:

1) I'm really skeptical of [insert particular mode of woo].

2) However, I/my friend/my aunt/other person tried the following [insert anecdote of woo], and it worked!

3) What do you people think happened?

This may surprise you, but nine out of ten (at least) the person posting like this is far from a skeptic. Instead she/he is a hardcore woo who just thinks this is a clever trick to win proselytes, or at least shake skeptics a bit.

One further sign that you may belong to this chategory is the fact that you report using several candles. Now a real skeptic might try such a thing (pressure form others, curiosity, etc.), but having no effect after one try, the typical skeptic would have their skepticism confirmed and left it at that. ... But to keep trying.... :dio:


A further red flag is the claim that the orthodox (and effective) treatment has unpleasant side-effects (described in the O/P as a "very unpleasant and painful experience ... that caused several days of soreness").
 
Again, there was no smoke going into your ear.

Think about it; How often do you see smoke flow downward from a burning flame and then squeeze into some small crevice?
 
How does that work? Smoke from the flame of a candle is only going to travel downward if an opposing force, like wind, pushes or pulls it. This fact doesn't change regardless of whether it's from a candle that's sitting on your ear or from a fire that's burning down your house. Unless a small fan is also running under the candle and sucking the smoke downward (again this is ridiculous),

Actually, this happens under certain conditions. Just try to roll a sheet of paper into a tight roll, hold it upright and light the top. You will often see smoke coming out of the bottom while the top burns.

I think that what happens is that some of the smoke generated has to compete for space with the hot gasses produced by the flames and the air sucked in to feed the fire, so a small overpressure is created at the burning end, pressing smoke downwards inside the roll. After all, as the paper/wax burns, the resultant gasses take up many times the volume of the burnt material (hundreds of times, in fact), so some overpressure in the combustion area is not unlikely.

Hans
 
Did you lie on your side while using the ear candles?
Yep, as I said that's a potential solution, but I sleep on my side so that was tried for many hours several times. It is possible my ear was just ready to clear when I used the candle, although that sounds, not impossible certainly, but impressively well timed.
 
Actually, this happens under certain conditions. Just try to roll a sheet of paper into a tight roll, hold it upright and light the top. You will often see smoke coming out of the bottom while the top burns.

I think that what happens is that some of the smoke generated has to compete for space with the hot gasses produced by the flames and the air sucked in to feed the fire, so a small overpressure is created at the burning end, pressing smoke downwards inside the roll. After all, as the paper/wax burns, the resultant gasses take up many times the volume of the burnt material (hundreds of times, in fact), so some overpressure in the combustion area is not unlikely.

Sure, those conditions being when an opposing force acts on it. And what you're saying here is basically the same explanation that ear candlers will give to their patients. They claim that the burning candle essentially creates a vacuum which causes the smoke to flow downward and enter the ear canal. This claim has actually been studied, and one of those studies is referenced here.

http://altmedicine.about.com/cs/govtregulation/a/EarCandle.htm

Evidence

One study published in the journal Laryngoscope evaluated the efficacy and safety of ear candles. The researchers concluded that ear candles did not produce a vacuum. This small preliminary study with eight ears showed that ear candling didn't result in the removal of ear wax from the ear canal and even caused candle wax to be deposited in some ears.

The evidence for this stuff just doesn't exist. Like most alternative medical BS quackery, it comes down to false claims and outright deception.
 
Last edited:
Yep, as I said that's a potential solution, but I sleep on my side so that was tried for many hours several times. It is possible my ear was just ready to clear when I used the candle, although that sounds, not impossible certainly, but impressively well timed.


See post #3, maybe adding a little confirmation bias (if you were using the candles, presumably you were hoping they would work).
 
Yes, I understand how you feel. However, you did, probably accidentially follow a pattern we have come to recognize all too well:

1) I'm really skeptical of [insert particular mode of woo].

2) However, I/my friend/my aunt/other person tried the following [insert anecdote of woo], and it worked!

3) What do you people think happened?

This may surprise you, but nine out of ten (at least) the person posting like this is far from a skeptic. Instead she/he is a hardcore woo who just thinks this is a clever trick to win proselytes, or at least shake skeptics a bit.

One further sign that you may belong to this chategory is the fact that you report using several candles. Now a real skeptic might try such a thing (pressure form others, curiosity, etc.), but having no effect after one try, the typical skeptic would have their skepticism confirmed and left it at that. ... But to keep trying.... :dio:

Of course you are entitled to the benefit of doubt, so here is my reply to your question:

1) You problem may have vanished independently of your candling.

2) Your problem may have vanished due to you spending what? Some ten minutes in an awkward position with something in your ear. Some wax problems and many pressure problems might be affected by this.

Now comes the acid test: You now have received mine and a couple of other's rational explanation (admittedly among some flak, but so is life). Your reaction to this will tell us whether you are really skeptical or not. :cool:

Hans
Yeah, I should have known better, but honestly, I didn't know where else to ask. If I had asked a holistic healer they would have just fed me the vacuum explanation. I found it kind of cool and thought provoking that this thing, which has claims that are obviously bunk, seemed to work and I wanted to mull over ideas of why it might have. If I made a post without all the tell-tale signs and simply said I stuck a candle in my ear and I can hear again. Do you really think anyone would have treated me differently? I wanted to give the events that led to my decision to use it in case anyone chose to believe me.
 
See post #3, maybe adding a little confirmation bias (if you were using the candles, presumably you were hoping they would work).
Hoping yes, just so I didn't have to pay $50+ to have my ear torn up. I realize this is my sister's personal experience, though and apparently not the norm (except for the cost). At best I really thought the candle would do no harm, since I knew of other people who have used them. I know now that's not the case.
 
Again, there was no smoke going into your ear.

Think about it; How often do you see smoke flow downward from a burning flame and then squeeze into some small crevice?
Did you look at the video? Have you burned an ear candle? The smoke comes out of the bottom!
 
Hoping yes, just so I didn't have to pay $50+ to have my ear torn up. I realize this is my sister's personal experience, though and apparently not the norm (except for the cost). At best I really thought the candle would do no harm, since I knew of other people who have used them. I know now that's not the case.


Not quite sure why your sister had such a bad experience and needed a GP to clean out her ear?

Normally if you have ear wax that is impacted, you will be told to use oil in your ear for at least a week to soften the wax that can then be removed by a procedure called ear syringing - a large metal syringe is used with tepid water that is then syringed in and then straight back out and that normally clears the blockage.

This can be done by an RN though and does not need a doctor.

Next time this happens, try going and getting your ear syringed at your doctors surgery.
 
Did you look at the video? Have you burned an ear candle? The smoke comes out of the bottom!

How could I? You didn't even give me a link. Regardless, it's been studied multiple times and the conclusion is always the same; bogus with a capital B.
 
Yeah, I should have known better, but honestly, I didn't know where else to ask. If I had asked a holistic healer they would have just fed me the vacuum explanation. I found it kind of cool and thought provoking that this thing, which has claims that are obviously bunk, seemed to work and I wanted to mull over ideas of why it might have. If I made a post without all the tell-tale signs and simply said I stuck a candle in my ear and I can hear again. Do you really think anyone would have treated me differently? I wanted to give the events that led to my decision to use it in case anyone chose to believe me.

Unlike some here, I accept the possibility that smoke may have come downwards (I have seen smoke come out of the bottom of burning objects often). Smoke in your ear might heat and possibly irritate the skin. This will increase the bloodstream under the skin and possibly make it sweat. Both might work to loosen earwax. Actually, the mere stress of having a burning candle in your ear (well, it would stress me), could make you sweat.

So the action of burning a candle in your ear might trigger events that could loosen earwax. Of course, holding a warm, moist towel over your ear would accomplich the same, cheaper and safer.

As Mojo noted, the notion that removal of wax by conventional processes is painful is another suspicious claim. Having had it done a number of times (and done it myself, also), I fail to see the pain in having your ear flushed out with watm water. It is a slightly queazy sensation, to be sure, but painful?

Hans
 
Yeah, I should have known better, but honestly, I didn't know where else to ask.

That's OK. Just don't be too miffed by the reaction.

If I had asked a holistic healer they would have just fed me the vacuum explanation.

Then you would surely not have been a skeptic.

I found it kind of cool and thought provoking that this thing, which has claims that are obviously bunk, seemed to work and I wanted to mull over ideas of why it might have.

All quite reasonable. After all, much woo stuff has a kernel of reality.

If I made a post without all the tell-tale signs and simply said I stuck a candle in my ear and I can hear again. Do you really think anyone would have treated me differently? I wanted to give the events that led to my decision to use it in case anyone chose to believe me.

Actually, it would probably have been better not to declare yourself a skeptic, but you did nothing wrong. I just explained you the reason for the initial reaction. As I said, an estimated 9 of 10 people posting like that in the past have been hard-core woos, but some of the rest are still here, now well-established members of the skeptic community.

Hans
 
Last edited:
Normally if you have ear wax that is impacted, you will be told to use oil in your ear for at least a week to soften the wax that can then be removed by a procedure called ear syringing - a large metal syringe is used with tepid water that is then syringed in and then straight back out and that normally clears the blockage.

This can be done by an RN though and does not need a doctor.

Next time this happens, try going and getting your ear syringed at your doctors surgery.

As Mojo noted, the notion that removal of wax by conventional processes is painful is another suspicious claim. Having had it done a number of times (and done it myself, also), I fail to see the pain in having your ear flushed out with watm water. It is a slightly queazy sensation, to be sure, but painful?

Hans


I too have done this myself - after all, there's really no difference whether it's done by a doctor, nurse or oneself.

To do this, I took the shower-head off my shower, and held the shower hose as tight as I could with a hand onto an empty "BIC"-type pen with the narrow end in the ear. Use as hot water as you can be comfortable with - very easy, and not at all painful, in fact quite pleasant !
 
Last edited:
I too have done this myself - after all, there's really no difference whether it's done by a doctor, nurse or oneself.

To do this, I took the shower-head off my shower, and held the shower hose as tight as I could with a hand onto an empty "BIC"-type pen with the narrow end in the ear. Use as hot water as you can be comfortable with - very easy, and not at all painful, in fact quite pleasant !

Or you can buy an ear flusher. A rubber ball with a long spout. Fill with warm water, flush your ear. You cal buy some oil to put in the ear a day or more before, to soften difficult clots. You can also get something to add to the water, as pure tap water can cause slight skin irritation.

Hans
 
I had tried those anti-wax solutions. But I think the stuff just softened and rehardened. Couldn't hear well for days.

Then I had my ear cleaned by a GP. "high" pressure water. Blasted the stuff out. I must admit I was surprised at how much force they could use and not damage the eardrum. But it worked.

The difference in my case is that there is no question about how it worked, since it's obvious.
 
Rubber ear syringe? OK, that must be the instrument I mentioned, didn't know the English term.

I had tried those anti-wax solutions. But I think the stuff just softened and rehardened. Couldn't hear well for days.

Then I had my ear cleaned by a GP. "high" pressure water. Blasted the stuff out. I must admit I was surprised at how much force they could use and not damage the eardrum. But it worked.

The difference in my case is that there is no question about how it worked, since it's obvious.
Well, that is one for using the GP: She should know exactly how much pressure can be used. Damn noisy procedure, btw.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom