Spektator
Is that right?
I hope the protocol isn't along the lines of "I'll go out and find some gold." It has to be a controlled, double-blind test, and there's no way that going out in the field would meet that requirement.
Further evidence that Edge should contemplate conventional metal detecting methods?I can assure that no matter how you're tested by JREF, it will always be a controlled test. It will be designed with the tightest controls possible whether it's in the field or in Randi's office.
Edge, dowsing doesn't work.
The thing about impartial observers is that impartiality generally means not taking part in the experiment or accepting money off people who are.
As you know, JREF says that applicant pays all expenses. They volunteer their time. They don't donate their money. I don't want your gold, Edge, but neither do I wish to spend several hundred dollars on a trip which has only a tiny chance of curing you of your misconceptions.
Let me ask you. If you fail a second test, will you agree to admit, with no excuses or rationalizations, that dowsing doesn't work? If not, then why should I bother?
I hope the protocol isn't along the lines of "I'll go out and find some gold." It has to be a controlled, double-blind test, and there's no way that going out in the field would meet that requirement.
It's not "taking a chance" Edge. It's "throwing money down a rat hole". Considering that you've been doing this for some years and still no big success, I wouldn't call what you do "brave". There's another word for it.They expect me to pay for their expenses, I can in gold or cash.
When it's mined at the time.
It looks like no one here has a brave heart, to willingly volunteer, to take a chance.
LOL. There's one way to show our cynical fat asses who's right.Nothing but cynical skeptics, to fat sitting here day after day, being cynical.
LOL. If you think I'm getting rich, you're wrong. I just have a job. I don't own any oil, and I'm definitely not an executive-type. You have a grave misconception about the real world, Edge. Maybe if you lived there for a while, you'd see that.I have a hard time believing that you are so hung up on the money thing tricky, especially with all the money you make working for the Oil Company as a geologist. I would think you would be happy just to get where real geology gets interesting? You should be rolling in the dough, and bored with that flat smelly ground of Texas.
I suppose your too tender to camp and I’ll have to put you up in a local motel?
Could have been luck. Or maybe he just knew more than you.As any geologist knows most placer gold is on the bottom unless it just blew in. This is why that guy found that nugget, it had to be a fluk it must have just been deposited and not had time to sink.
I don't want a percentage of your take, Edge. From what I can see, that wouldn't even pay for the trip. Besides, it looks like you need anything you can get. I'm not going to spend time reinforcing your delusions.Why should you bother? because what you will make after the expenses are paid for is profit,either during the test or if jref says you can't then if you want to stay longer after the test, you see because if I pay for your trip then you will get a percentage for being here at least after the test.
You do realize, don't you Edge, that JREF is not going to approve a protocol where the certainty of the existance and location of the target is not known, with 100% accuracy, in advance? This is why you need to submit your application so you can work out the protocol. If you don't, you are simply wasting your time.I don’t intend to waste your time that is why I’m making sure it’s the right ground verified by dowsing, the first time I hit will be a verification that the ground is good enough to pay five people instead of two. You see I already know that with out mining it first.
If you think JREF (or any volunteers) are going to agree to a two-week test, you are crazy. How about this. Just have a volunteer bury a lump of gold in several of the spots you have already dowsed and determined had no gold. What could be simpler? Give me a reason why your "skill" can't detect this gold?Your time is valuable and this is not a bribe but honesty for standing in the heat of the day watching us if jref says it’s OK.
But you will, if you volunteer have to live it like me, on the creek for at least 2 weeks, camping, roughing it.
I don’t know if any one here on this forum can handle that.
This is total BS, Edge. Have you or have you not been dowsing for gold there for two years. Just go to one of the places you've already found gold (but is now depleted). Natural setting, right? Not enough gold there to set off your dowsing rod anymore, right?I’m waiting for permission from a certain land owner and the spot that I chose is to make sure that it will still bring a profit for myself and the whole operation.
LOL. If you're trying to make this sound like a vacation paradise, it's not working.You guys after all have to eat while your here, have ice and drinks and if I’m there you will be as comfortable as possible. You may even walk out with a nugget or two for yourselves.
I found that woman are better at this than most men.
Being there every day.
So they are not excluded from this test if it is accepted.
Having exchanged posts with Edge for quite some time, I have to say that he is definitely not a con artist. At no point has he ever asked for money or promised that he could help them get rich or anything. He is actually a nice, affable guy who is simply and sadly deluded. It is because of his good nature that I continue to exchange posts with him. Yes, it can be frustrating but it is not wasted.I won't do that any longer. Edge is either self-deluded or a con artist.
They expect me to pay for their expenses, I can in gold or cash.
When it's mined at the time.
It looks like no one here has a brave heart, to willingly volunteer, to take a chance.
[snip]
Why should you bother? because what you will make after the expenses are paid for is profit,either during the test or if jref says you can't then if you want to stay longer after the test, you see because if I pay for your trip then you will get a percentage for being here at least after the test.
[snip]
I don’t intend to waste your time that is why I’m making sure it’s the right ground verified by dowsing, the first time I hit will be a verification that the ground is good enough to pay five people instead of two. You see I already know that with out mining it first.
What you are suggesting is not a test of your dowsing abilities but your abilities as a surveyor for gold. If there is actually anything found there, how would we know that it was not the colour of the soil or whatever that tipped you off (subconsciously) rather than the movement of your divining rod?I don’t intend to waste your time that is why I’m making sure it’s the right ground verified by dowsing, the first time I hit will be a verification that the ground is good enough to pay five people instead of two. You see I already know that with out mining it first.
What you are suggesting is not a test of your dowsing abilities but your abilities as a surveyor for gold. If there is actually anything found there, how would we know that it was not the colour of the soil or whatever that tipped you off (subconsciously) rather than the movement of your divining rod?
That problem can be circumvented, though it is a bit of work. Simply have Edge dowse an area in his "natural setting" where he had determined that there is no gold (or not enough to affect his dowsing rod) or better still, an area where he found gold before but now has determined it is gone. Use that site for the test. It would be simple to just put the gold target under cups, but since Edge has already declared he must find it in natural settings, you may have to bury the target in order to please him.
That problem can be circumvented, though it is a bit of work. Simply have Edge dowse an area in his "natural setting" where he had determined that there is no gold (or not enough to affect his dowsing rod) or better still, an area where he found gold before but now has determined it is gone. Use that site for the test. It would be simple to just put the gold target under cups, but since Edge has already declared he must find it in natural settings, you may have to bury the target in order to please him.
Any number of ways. You can place ten targets, only one of which is gold, or you can dowse the exact same site ten times, nine times with a non-gold target and once with a gold target. They will all look dug-up.How would you conceal the digging site so he can't recognise it visually?
Yep. That's where I got the idea. I love that video.Looks pretty straight-forward, Tricky. Reminds me of the Australian Mitta Water Challenge.
Oh yes, the "open test" is de rigeur. As on his first failed test, Edge can provide a target that he knows gets a response.I'd add; have edge provide several nuggets that are "detectable". Have him detect them above ground as a "test run". Then bury them. Have him detect again. Check results. Easy!
Pick your excuse, the ground is too wet, the ground is to dry, the sky is too cloudy, the sky has no clouds, the gold is too deep, the gold is not deep enough, the gold is not the pure, it is too pure etc etc and I know you will think of more.
You know better than that, or you ought to. The test you did at the JREF was a controlled, double-blind test. Going out into the field and hunting gold is not double-blind. It isn't even a test.
Edge is obviously not serious. I've purposely reserved judgment and have encouraged him.
I won't do that any longer. Edge is either self-deluded or a con artist.
Dowsing does not work.
That ends it for me.
No, there will be 10 (or however many) coffee cans, 9 of them empty, one with black sands. Edge claims he will find that full coffee can 50% of the time.
A small piece of advice here.
Black sand generally contains iron and a hidden magnet will show which can it is.
That's probably why he wants to use that specific container