Should we shut the hypothetical street corner porn booth


  • Total voters
    11
What do you mean, "separates"? Humans are animals, just as dogs and spiders and secretary birds and quokkas are animals. And so are African poncho rats, which I have just watched being taught how to find mines. All animals have different characteristics, but they're still animals.

We're the weak and squishy ones with bugger all built in weapons or armour? Hell, we can't even fly!
 
No, bars and liquor stores alcohol remain legal. What you are suggesting is banning online adult content in its entirety. We don't shut down alcohol in its entirety.
I have said before that I am willing to go with that - that (as we do with we establishments illegally supplying alcohol to children) we shut down establishments doing the same with porn.

You seem to have made my point for me.
Okey doke.

That's not what we were talking about. You said I "threw up my hands" in resignation. I did not. I suggested the same efforts we employ to keep kids away from other adult activities.
Except we don't shut down porn 'establishments' do we? The poll may be flawed, but it's pretty stark at 9/2.
To your point, there might always be a workaround. Kids, surprisingly, have found a way to partake in adult matters for generations. We deal with them in practical ways. We don't ban alcohol because there might be a way for some kids to get a beer.
See above.
"Think of the children" is not a reasonable resolution to ban adult entertainments.
Yes it is. There is no keener revelation of a society's soul than the way in which it treats it's children.
Some certainly do, yes. Like banning adult videos online because there might be a way a minor could see some boobies.
See above.
 
Last edited:
I have said before that I am willing to go with that - that (as we do with we establishments illegally supplying alcohol to children) we shut down establishments doing the same with porn.

You seem to have made my point for me.
I don't know where you are coming from, here. Bars get popped for serving underage people all the time. They are fined or otherwise temporarily penalized, not shut down.

You seemed to have made my point for me.
Except we don't shut down porn 'establishments' do we? The poll may be flawed, but it's pretty stark at 9/2.
Adressed repeatedly. The poll is not "flawed"; its borderline meaningless.
See above.
Addressed above, and not for the first time.
Yes it is. There is no keener revelation of a society's soul than the way in which it treats it's children.
Ok. We treat our children pretty well, on the whole, I would think. If they elect, on their own, to explore some adult matters, that may be more an issue with their supervision, not our treatment of them.
See above.
Saw it the first time. Addressed it squarely, and not for the first time.
 
I don't know where you are coming from, here. Bars get popped for serving underage people all the time. They are fined or otherwise temporarily penalized, not shut down.

You seemed to have made my point for me.
An establishment that continues to supply alcohol to children even after it has been warned (perhaps a few times) won't be shut down?

Nah.
Ok. We treat our children pretty well, on the whole, I would think. If they elect, on their own, to explore some adult matters, that may be more an issue with their supervision, not our treatment of them.
Nonsense - we have a duty under the UNCRC: they should have access to mass media and should be able to do safely....in other words, don't fob them off by restricting their access just because society is unwilling to do due diligence and make that right of access safe.

Again, you make my point for me. Appreciated.
 
What do you mean, "separates"? Humans are animals, just as dogs and spiders and secretary birds and quokkas are animals. And so are African poncho rats, which I have just watched being taught how to find mines. All animals have different characteristics, but they're still animals.
Put it this way: Why do we hold humans to a unique moral standard, that we don't apply to any other animals?
 
You don't think the kid accessing porn 24/7 over 700,000 hours and never having to watch the same video twice (and in doing so not even covering a fraction of that available) is not experiencing porn saturation?
There's about the same amount of Minecraft content, and I don't hear you complaining about Minecraft saturation.

What separates human from animal? - or are you saying there is nothing that does so?
That's a different issue. Feel free to start a thread about it.

If it's alcohol, we close it down.
Prohibition worked very well, and didn't cause any problems at all.

We don't have a choice but let kids watch porn?
You have a choice to not let your kids watch porn. You don't get to make that choice for my kids[/i].
 
Put it this way: Why do we hold humans to a unique moral standard, that we don't apply to any other animals?

Interesting question. We kill animals that attack/kill humans or other animals that we consider useful/valuable. Is that a moral standard?

I consider my dog to be particularly well behaved (I don't claim credit for this he's a weird dog in ways that work out well), is his good behaviour moral? What about humans who have a problem with the moral code most of us subscribe to?

I'm not going for a gotcha, I don't have one anyway, I just think there may be a grey area.
 
One bar? And police had it linked to a shopping list of other illegal offenses? Seriously?

I can take you to a dozen bars and liquor stores within walking distance of my house that have been popped on and off for serving minors. All remain in business, except one, who very famously featured a 16 year old girl in their wet t-shirt contest who went topless for the patrons.
 
Put it this way: Why do we hold humans to a unique moral standard, that we don't apply to any other animals?
Herd/pack animals hold each other to the rules of their group, but it only applies to those within the group. That is at the heart if what we call morality, I believe; an evolutionary result of if living in groups. And of having mirror neurons.
 
In the UK we have put in place age verification to stop under 16 years old from accessing porn sites, this means that even the children of bad parents can't access porn.

Yes there are ways around the age verification but that is the same as with most laws, allowing the perfect to be the enemy of the good would mean we would do nothing about children viewing porn on the internet. Even a total ban on porn in the UK wouldn't be a perfect solution.
 
In the UK we have put in place age verification to stop under 16 years old from accessing porn sites, this means that even the children of bad parents can't access porn.

Yes there are ways around the age verification but that is the same as with most laws, allowing the perfect to be the enemy of the good would mean we would do nothing about children viewing porn on the internet. Even a total ban on porn in the UK wouldn't be a perfect solution.
Under 18s. Under 16s will be for social media.
 
One bar? And police had it linked to a shopping list of other illegal offenses? Seriously?

I can take you to a dozen bars and liquor stores within walking distance of my house that have been popped on and off for serving minors. All remain in business, except one, who very famously featured a 16 year old girl in their wet t-shirt contest who went topless for the patrons.
No, not one bar - why did you think that? And would it come as any surprise that offending weren't limited purely to selling to minors? Seriously?

I think you are missing the point - no one in this line of work will be under any illusion that they can get away with persistently breaking the law. That's the point isn't it? We shut them down.

Your:
No, bars and liquor stores alcohol remain legal. What you are suggesting is banning online adult content in its entirety. We don't shut down alcohol in its entirety.
is only the case (ie they remain open) because they don't keep selling to minors.

What do you say we should do if one of those establishments just keeps ignoring the law and supplies alcohol to children? Are you going to shut them down or let them reap the profits from getting kids drunk?
 
Prohibition worked very well, and didn't cause any problems at all.
Let's go with just one establishment that keeps breaking the law by supplying alcohol to minors....like repeatedly...ignoring all the warnings - what are you going to do?
 
Last edited:
Let's go with just one establishment that keeps breaking the law by supplying alcohol to minors....like repeatedly...ignoring all the warnings - what are you going to do?

Let's not. Let's not fiddle with useless analogies and discuss your issue directly. Oh, sorry, that was getting you zero traction, so instead you have to try and 'gotcha' people into adopting your rather ... unique morality via leading questions and inapplicable comparisons to hypothetical other things.
 
No, not one bar - why did you think that?
Because you posted, without any words or explanation, an article where a lone bar was shut down for a variety of offenses. Did you not notice that you posted that?
And would it come as any surprise that offending weren't limited purely to selling to minors?
It is not surprising, for exactly the reasons I said. The bar was not shut down because it sold to minors. It was shut down for multiple offenses. That is not surprising at all. What is surprising is that you would think it illustrates your point. It doesn't. It illustrates mine.
Seriously?
Yes. Your analogy continues to fail, now on even more points.
I think you are missing the point - no one in this line of work will be under any illusion that they can get away with persistently breaking the law. That's the point isn't it? We shut them down.
Which again, is not analogius to online porn. A bar might be shut down for knowingly, willfully serving minors. They would not be shut down for a minor with a decent fake ID, because they were not knowingly, willfully breaking the law..

In your flawed porn analogy, the website is not knowingly, willfully breaking the law. it is up to the parents who provide the minor with the device to determine if it will be age/content restricted.
Your:

is only the case (ie they remain open) because they don't keep selling to minors.
Knowingly and willfully, yes.
What do you say we should do if one of those establishments just keeps ignoring the law and supplies alcohol to children? Are you going to shut them down or let them reap the profits from getting kids drunk?
If they do so knowingly and willfully, yes, they would likely lose their alcohol license and no longer be able to sell alcohol. That's because minors can actually die in alcohol related driving, etc. Yet again, not analogous to your fear of a kid seeing boobies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom