Should we shut the hypothetical street corner porn booth


  • Total voters
    11
I don't think so. As I opined, I think voters are rejecting what you are saying between the lines, and the extrapolation you are assuming.
??? Unless you spell it out I won't be clear what you are saying.
Porn on every street corner is a problem for reasons other than children possibly accessing it, in the same way that kids will experiment with sex or masturbation, but not making public establishments on every street corner for doing so in full view.
Okay, but I just don't see this as relevant. The issue in the poll is children seeing porn.
I dunno. Kids seeing porn is not much different from kids having sex, in the "should we allow this" sense. We understand that it is happening, and has been for many years. Maybe being sane about it is a better resolution than trying to ban what can't be banned?
Your framing is curious. Who saturated the internet with porn? Who is it that effectively demands that it be facilitated? Kids seeing porn videos ad nauseam has never occurred in the history of mankind. It can happen now. Why?

Effectively, you are just accepting the status quo. Effectively, that street establishment continues to show porn to youngsters under society's watch.
 
??? Unless you spell it out I won't be clear what you are saying.
I don't know what else I could possibly say to spell it out any more clearly. You seem (to myself snd many others) to be equating porn establishments on every street corner to online availability. They are not comparable. One is very publicly in your face, the other is very private. That's much like the Masturbation Stations I alluded to earlier- someone masturbating in the privacy of their own home is worlds away from walking into public establishments on every street cornerset up for that purpose. Same with pornography use.
Okay, but I just don't see this as relevant. The issue in the poll is children seeing porn.
Thats how you view it. Its not how anyone else is viewing it. Back in the pre-Web days, kids would look at Playboy mags. Then home video gained traction, and VHS porn got passed around, along with cable pay-per-views. Now the Net puts literally everything at our fingertips. So we move with the times, and adapt to the changing world. I'm not up on the current laws, but it's my understanding that age verification has been introduced? That's a good thing, I suppose, although I have serious qualms about abuses regarding identity theft and selling personal info online.
Your framing is curious. Who saturated the internet with porn?
People that wanted to make it, fueled by people who wanted to view it?
Who is it that effectively demands that it be facilitated?
People who want to make it, and people who want to view it?
Kids seeing porn videos ad nauseam has never occurred in the history of mankind. It can happen now. Why?
...the internet?
Effectively, you are just accepting the status quo. Effectively, that street establishment continues to show porn to youngsters under society's watch.
It does not effectively do so. That's a POV you are entranced with, to the point of not even understanding why others don't see it that way.

Everything is at our fingertips now. That is the status quo, like it or not. Any minor can have their devices age/content restricted by their guardians. It's not difficult to do. We probably should implement tight IDing, much like we do for alcohol purchases, but suggesting that it should be outlawed seems unreasonably puritanical.
 
Last edited:
Who saturated the internet with porn?
Nobody. The Internet is manifestly not saturated with porn. There are ~112,896,000,000,000 hours of content up on YouTube. Very little of it is porn - perhaps an infinitesimal proportion. LinkedIn claims 1.3 billion accounts, very few of which are serving porn via the platform. There's almost 150k games on Steam, and only about 6% of them are porn. There's more games on Steam that used AI development than there are adult games on Steam.

It's true that some parts of the Internet are absolutely saturated with porn. Pornhub, for example. Wall to wall pornography. Total saturation of that platform.

I was going to ask if you knew what "saturated" means, but I think you do know what it means. I think you're using the word incorrectly on purpose, to try mislead your audience.
 
Some interesting stats from Statista:

20 percent of all mobile searches are for el-porno. That's dramatically higher than I would have thought, considering how much we use our phones to search. They do acknowledge that accurate data is fraught with difficulty. I mean, Reddit is not considered a porn site, but it certainly has some in it.

A whopping 87% of guys 18-35 view porn regularly.
1000001285.jpg
 
Last edited:
Wait, we're supposed to be surprised that men consume porn? Where did we think the porn industry came from? Women? Alien space robots? It's no secret that men have strong sexual urges, and have made a society that caters to those urges.

But does Poem preach self-discipline? A Stoic approach to the needs of the flesh and the urges of the mind? Or any other similar gospel of healthful masculinity? Does Poem preach anything as sophisticated as epicurianism, or even principled hedonism? No. For Poem, the only solution is a blanket ban of all pornography, and even of all sexual imagery or discussion, even when it's not pornographic.

This is the kind of sermon I'd expect from a man struggling with a porn addiction, who'd rather try to ban all the sources of temptation, than accept responsibility for his urges and develop manly self-discipline.
 
Wait, we're supposed to be surprised that men consume porn?
No. Why do you ask? The planet is roughly half men, so I'd be a bit surprised if none were represented.
Where did we think the porn industry came from? Women?
According to Statista, nearly a third of women watch porn regularly. That, too, is a pretty stunningly large market share, I would think.
Alien space robots? It's no secret that men have strong sexual urges, and have made a society that caters to those urges.
I think I mentioned before that pornography is more for those with lower sexual urges? If you're hot for some tail, you don't charge up the ol' cel phone. You get cleaned up and work your wiles. Watching other guys getting busy is about as passive and reflecting of weak sexual urges as I can comfortably imagine. It's for those who like to watch TV, not actually do it.

That's why the volume surprises me. Maybe I'm alone in this one, but I rate someone with a really strong passion for football by how often they grab a ball and play. If they just wear another guy's jersey and watch them on TV, they don't have a passion for football. They are cheerleaders.
But does Poem preach self-discipline? A Stoic approach to the needs of the flesh and the urges of the mind? Or any other similar gospel of healthful masculinity? Does Poem preach anything as sophisticated as epicurianism, or even principled hedonism? No. For Poem, the only solution is a blanket ban of all pornography, and even of all sexual imagery or discussion, even when it's not pornographic.
Agreed, AFAICT.
This is the kind of sermon I'd expect from a man struggling with a porn addiction, who'd rather try to ban all the sources of temptation, than accept responsibility for his urges and develop manly self-discipline.
Well, yeah, but it could be fueled from other obsessions too. I wasn't following the earlier thread and have no idea what the vibe is/was, so I'm still finding my feet with Mr Poem.
 
Last edited:
Kids seeing porn videos ad nauseam has never occurred in the history of mankind. It can happen now. Why?
Because for the vast majority of the history of humankind porn videos did not exist.

It's worth noting that practically as soon as motion pictures were invented, they were used to make erotic content. Le Coucher de la Mariée was first screened in 1896, only one year after the Lumière Brothers showed their first short films publicly.

But that's not the point. It has been shown that erotic artwork has existed throughout history, from Roman and Greek antiquity all the way back to the stone age. It is, in fact, only relatively recently that we've had actual laws prohibiting children from seeing it.
 
Nobody. The Internet is manifestly not saturated with porn. There are ~112,896,000,000,000 hours of content up on YouTube. Very little of it is porn - perhaps an infinitesimal proportion. LinkedIn claims 1.3 billion accounts, very few of which are serving porn via the platform. There's almost 150k games on Steam, and only about 6% of them are porn. There's more games on Steam that used AI development than there are adult games on Steam.

It's true that some parts of the Internet are absolutely saturated with porn. Pornhub, for example. Wall to wall pornography. Total saturation of that platform.

I was going to ask if you knew what "saturated" means, but I think you do know what it means. I think you're using the word incorrectly on purpose, to try mislead your audience.
From that perspective (the internet) I guess you are right; from a child's perspective, not so much. A child could theoretically watch 24/7 until they died - about 700,000 hours - and they wouldn't even cover just one of the major site's content. Add to that the fact that new uploads outpace maximum consumption rate by orders of magnitude.

Given that the content is free and easily accessible from a mobile phone then it sure looks like saturation.
 
Last edited:
From that perspective (the internet) I guess you are right; from a child's perspective, not so much. A child could theoretically watch 24/7 until they died - about 700,000 hours - and they wouldn't even cover just one of the major site's content. Add to that the fact that new uploads outpace maximum consumption rate by orders of magnitude.

Given that the content is free and easily accessible from a mobile phone then it sure looks like saturation.
Content about gardening, cooking or motorcycle repair (just to name a few) is free and easily accessible from a mobile phone, and it sure doesn't look like saturation. But for porn it suddenly does? Your continued insistence that it does is hyperbole. If you need hyperbole to make your point, your point might not be as good as you think it is.
 
Wait, we're supposed to be surprised that men consume porn? Where did we think the porn industry came from? Women? Alien space robots? It's no secret that men have strong sexual urges, and have made a society that caters to those urges.
You said you think porn is harmful and unnecessary. Do you know what you think?

Strong sexual urges could and can be assuaged in a healthy relationship couldn't they? You know, the ones that make a positive contribution to society.
But does Poem preach self-discipline? A Stoic approach to the needs of the flesh and the urges of the mind? Or any other similar gospel of healthful masculinity? Does Poem preach anything as sophisticated as epicurianism, or even principled hedonism? No. For Poem, the only solution is a blanket ban of all pornography, and even of all sexual imagery or discussion, even when it's not pornographic.

This is the kind of sermon I'd expect from a man struggling with a porn addiction, who'd rather try to ban all the sources of temptation, than accept responsibility for his urges and develop manly self-discipline.
Sure looks like an ad hominem...a tu quoque even. You are actually making a case suggesting I am a liar; a monumental hypocrite.

I have already stated my previous relationship with porn.
 
Content about gardening, cooking or motorcycle repair (just to name a few) is free and easily accessible from a mobile phone, and it sure doesn't look like saturation. But for porn it suddenly does? Your continued insistence that it does is hyperbole. If you need hyperbole to make your point, your point might not be as good as you think it is.
You don't think the kid accessing porn 24/7 over 700,000 hours and never having to watch the same video twice (and in doing so not even covering a fraction of that available) is not experiencing porn saturation?
 
No. Why do you ask? The planet is roughly half men, so I'd be a bit surprised if none were represented.

According to Statista, nearly a third of women watch porn regularly. That, too, is a pretty stunningly large market share, I would think.

....snip...
Include all pornography I'd be very surprised if there is much difference in regular porn user numbers between the sexes. It wasn't men who made 50 Shades of Grey a best seller...
 
You don't think the kid accessing porn 24/7 over 700,000 hours and never having to watch the same video twice (and in doing so not even covering a fraction of that available) is not experiencing porn saturation?
There you go again with the hyperbole And it was the internet that was supposed to be saturated, not the viewer.
 
Last edited:
From that perspective (the internet) I guess you are right; from a child's perspective, not so much. A child could theoretically watch 24/7 until they died - about 700,000 hours - and they wouldn't even cover just one of the major site's content. Add to that the fact that new uploads outpace maximum consumption rate by orders of magnitude.

Given that the content is free and easily accessible from a mobile phone then it sure looks like saturation.
You choosing to take a childish view of the issue explains a lot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom