Should we shut the hypothetical street corner porn booth


  • Total voters
    11
Another ad hominem.
Not at all.

Ad hominem is a fallacy where judge the argument by the person making it.

This is the other way around. Further, it's an overall assessment of the arguments you're making, and the value system that motivates those arguments.

Only a child would think the internet is saturated with porn, simply because they can find a large collection of the stuff in one place on the internet. You're choosing to look at the issue through a childish viewpoint. That's not a complimentary choice, for you or your goals.
 
Not at all.

Ad hominem is a fallacy where judge the argument by the person making it.
That makes sense?
This is the other way around. Further, it's an overall assessment of the arguments you're making, and the value system that motivates those arguments.

Only a child would think the internet is saturated with porn, simply because they can find a large collection of the stuff in one place on the internet. You're choosing to look at the issue through a childish viewpoint. That's not a complimentary choice, for you or your goals.
You keep posting and meanwhile kids can keep right on immersing themselves in porn - so much of it they would need multiple lifetimes to consume it.

You fiddle and fuss and nitpick.
 
From that perspective (the internet) I guess you are right; from a child's perspective, not so much. A child could theoretically watch 24/7 until they died - about 700,000 hours - and they wouldn't even cover just one of the major site's content. Add to that the fact that new uploads outpace maximum consumption rate by orders of magnitude.

Given that the content is free and easily accessible from a mobile phone then it sure looks like saturation.
And Spotify alone has over 2 million hours of music in their library. YouTube has some 156 million hours of videos. Reddit has incalcuable millions of postings on anything imaginable. 700,000 ain't really jack ◊◊◊◊ on the Big Bad Net.
 
And Spotify alone has over 2 million hours of music in their library. YouTube has some 156 million hours of videos. Reddit has incalcuable millions of postings on anything imaginable. 700,000 ain't really jack ◊◊◊◊ on the Big Bad Net.
You are quibbling (and 700,000 represents a human lifetime, not what you think you thought it meant).
 
You are quibbling (and 700,000 represents a human lifetime, not what you think you thought it meant).
What's the difference? There's a lot of everything on the internet, because we live on a planet of 8 billion, and we keep the internet submissions indefinitely. Of course there is a metric ◊◊◊◊ ton of everything.

Eta: you are arguing like the amount a person could view in their lifetimes constitutes "saturation". I am countering that by your standard, the Net is "saturated" with a lot of things.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what else I could possibly say to spell it out any more clearly. You seem (to myself snd many others) to be equating porn establishments on every street corner to online availability. They are not comparable. One is very publicly in your face, the other is very private. That's much like the Masturbation Stations I alluded to earlier- someone masturbating in the privacy of their own home is worlds away from walking into public establishments on every street cornerset up for that purpose. Same with pornography use.
You keep digressing - the poll askes a simple question and people mostly want to keep the place that shows porn to kids open.
Thats how you view it. Its not how anyone else is viewing it. Back in the pre-Web days, kids would look at Playboy mags. Then home video gained traction, and VHS porn got passed around, along with cable pay-per-views. Now the Net puts literally everything at our fingertips. So we move with the times, and adapt to the changing world. I'm not up on the current laws, but it's my understanding that age verification has been introduced? That's a good thing, I suppose, although I have serious qualms about abuses regarding identity theft and selling personal info online.
You keep framing it as if we don't have a choice in this. How about admitting children have become an afterthought? Extraordinary.
People that wanted to make it, fueled by people who wanted to view it?
That is right.
People who want to make it, and people who want to view it?
Indeed.
...the internet?
Indeed.
It does not effectively do so. That's a POV you are entranced with, to the point of not even understanding why others don't see it that way.
We don't have a choice but let kids watch porn?
Everything is at our fingertips now. That is the status quo, like it or not. Any minor can have their devices age/content restricted by their guardians. It's not difficult to do. We probably should implement tight IDing, much like we do for alcohol purchases, but suggesting that it should be outlawed seems unreasonably puritanical.
Maybe there is no point continuing to debate. I'm railing against the status quo and you aren't. As you wish.
 
What's the difference? There's a lot of everything on the internet, because we live on a planet of 8 billion, and we keep the internet submissions indefinitely. Of course there is a metric ◊◊◊◊ ton of everything.
Again, you just roll over and throw your arms in the air.
 
You keep digressing - the poll askes a simple question and people mostly want to keep the place that shows porn to kids open.
I doubt that. I think people are not playing along with the obvious Socratic lead.

I've already responded to the poll- from the Social Issue standpoint, there isn't enough information in the posit to give a meaningful answer, so I haven't lodged a vote. Other voters have likely filled in their own blanks, so you'd have to figure out how they filled them to understand their vote. You are not doing so, and just interpreting their vote consistent with your Socratic lead.
You keep framing it as if we don't have a choice in this. How about admitting children have become an afterthought? Extraordinary.
I have said rather plainly that age verification and parental controls are a good thing, and workable as a resolution. Any particular reason you are ignoring that to pretend I am saying otherwise?
That is right.

Indeed.

Indeed.

We don't have a choice but let kids watch porn?
No, we have choices. We also have choices about them having sex, drinking alcohol, smoking pot, etc. What these choices don't demand is that adults remove these things entirely from the face of the earth.
Maybe there is no point continuing to debate. I'm railing against the status quo and you aren't. As you wish.
You're not listening to anything that doesn't follow your Socratic lead. That ain't my doing, baby.
 
Last edited:
The most distasteful stuff I've seen lately was while looking for old smutty fanart archived on paheal, which isn't age/account blocked here even though all the major porn sites are. It's not even the content; it's just that there is some weirdass AI generated stuff in the ads over there.

Back in the day before the various content purges of the 2000's, you could find the fanart on fansites, without all the gross monetizing porn ads.

The smut bans ARE what drove the silly or fun or hot pornographic fan stuff that teens might want to search for, off of safer platforms and onto grossnasty ad filled ones.
 
What separates human from animal? - or are you saying there is nothing that does so?
What do you mean, "separates"? Humans are animals, just as dogs and spiders and secretary birds and quokkas are animals. And so are African poncho rats, which I have just watched being taught how to find mines. All animals have different characteristics, but they're still animals.
 
I doubt that. I think people are not playing along with the obvious Socratic lead.
If it's alcohol, we close it down.
I've already responded to the poll- from the Social Issue standpoint, there isn't enough information in the posit to give a meaningful answer, so I haven't lodged a vote. Other voters have likely filled in their own blanks, so you'd have to figure out how they filled them to understand their vote. You are not doing so, and just interpreting their vote consistent with your Socratic lead.
Let's see if anyone does explain their position.
I have said rather plainly that age verification and parental controls are a good thing, and workable as a resolution. Any particular reason you are ignoring that to pretend I am saying otherwise?
I'm not the only one to post here that VPNs are an easy workaround...failing that, I think USBs would be another option.

Kids remain an afterthought and these measures look like virtue signalling.
 
If it's alcohol, we close it down.
No, bars and liquor stores alcohol remain legal. What you are suggesting is banning online adult content in its entirety. We don't shut down alcohol in its entirety.
Let's see if anyone does explain their position.
Okey doke.
I'm not the only one to post here that VPNs are an easy workaround...failing that, I think USBs would be another option.
That's not what we were talking about. You said I "threw up my hands" in resignation. I did not. I suggested the same efforts we employ to keep kids away from other adult activities.

To your point, there might always be a workaround. Kids, surprisingly, have found a way to partake in adult matters for generations. We deal with them in practical ways. We don't ban alcohol because there might be a way for some kids to get a beer.
Kids remain an afterthought
"Think of the children" is not a reasonable resolution to ban adult entertainments.
and these measures look like virtue signalling.
Some certainly do, yes. Like banning adult videos online because there might be a way a minor could see some boobies.
 
If it's alcohol, we close it down.

(...)

I'm not the only one to post here that VPNs are an easy workaround...failing that, I think USBs would be another option.
And if you close down every store openly selling alcohol to minors, minors can still get their hands on alcohol. Banning alcohol entirely as a solution to the problem of kids getting it, is usually both unpopular and untenable.
 
Last edited:
And Spotify alone has over 2 million hours of music in their library. YouTube has some 156 million hours of videos. Reddit has incalcuable millions of postings on anything imaginable. 700,000 ain't really jack ◊◊◊◊ on the Big Bad Net.


OMG, some kid out there might spend their entire life listening to Spotify 24 hours a day 7 days a week for their entire life and never hear the same song twice!!😲😲
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom