Does it require intelligence to be a skeptic?

So, come teenage years, there is a light bulb moment, 'Hey, they lied to me. Father Christmas isn't real. England isn't the only country in the world. Superman is ridiculous, with his "truth, justice and the American way", as he flies through the air eliminating the baddies.'


I discovered that Santa wasn't real when I was three or four. His beard was obviously fake. I became suspicious when I noticed that his face was much too young for his beard to have turned white, and a closer inspection revealed the elastic band fastening it to his ears.

It's possible that I might have believed in Santa for a few more years if they hadn't hired somebody too young to play the role in a convincing way, but I pity children who don't have the "light bulb moment" until their teenage years.
:santa4:
 
Last edited:
Another question that cost me any popularity was why none of the aliens ever drop anything, or left garbage behind? Just look at the stuff left in the Antarctic from every expedition, and look at the stuff we left on the moon.


You can't blame the aliens for being environmentalists!
Unless they've come to invade us, they always blame us for the way we abuse Earth and each other. :alien004:
 
...snip...

Another question that cost me any popularity was why none of the aliens ever drop anything, or left garbage behind? Just look at the stuff left in the Antarctic from every expedition, and look at the stuff we left on the moon.

Nobody in the UFO group was that open-minded.

There is a good little novel from Murry Leister that makes use of that idea and it has the heroes looking through the rubbish left behind by a visiting spaceship, which reveals dark secrets: The Greks Bring Gifts
 
Starting to realize that those who claim skepticism requires no intelligence are likely correct. Ample evidence in this very thread.
Certainly doesn't take any to claim to be a skeptic. Look at me.
 
Can you be more specific? What did you tell your potential customers that was believed by smart people but not by "Joe Sixpack"?

Fair question.

The LGB G-Scale train is indoor-outdoor and all-weather. The slower set refused to believe you could run a model railroad in the rain or snow. We had a hardcore demo too. The solid brass rails were powered by low-voltage DC current. We'd poor a glass of water on them, and put out hands on the tracks while the train continued to run. They still didn't believe it was safe, even after a few of the brave ones placed their hand on the wet tracks.

And the trains were tough. We had a roof from the passenger car included in the starter set that we'd bang like a hammer on the counter to demonstrate how solid the BASF designed plastic was against abuse. The slower folks would counter with a list of "what ifs". LGB used to bring in an elephant for the Nuremberg Toy Show to walk on their tracks to demonstrate how strong they were. We'd show them that picture, and we'd show them photos taken by our customers of cars parked on the LGB tracks. The slow folks still balked.

There was nothing we could physically demonstrate which would change their mind about the perceived quality.

This was the 1980s and 1990s. Today you can find hundreds of garden railway videos on Youtube.
 
I had read all the books going back to the 1960s, and I noticed a significant pattern change. All the way through the early 1980s, UFOs landed. UFOs had landing gear, and left "scorch marks". Not just in North America, but globally. And then for some reason they just started hovering over the ground, no longer using landing gear.

I wondered why. Seemed like a huge change. I suggested that maybe people's imaginations had evolved from the 1950s movies, where the alien spaceships landed, to the 1970-1990s movies where they floated (thanks to improved special effects).

Another question that cost me any popularity was why none of the aliens ever drop anything, or left garbage behind? Just look at the stuff left in the Antarctic from every expedition, and look at the stuff we left on the moon.

Nobody in the UFO group was that open-minded.

Tangent but, I wonder what the venn diagram of moon landing hoax believers and Alien visitation believers looks like. I'm sure its none zero overlap but they are kind of contradictory beliefs aren't they?
 
The LGB G-Scale train is indoor-outdoor and all-weather.


When I was a kid, I had Märklin. It was pretty solid, but it never occurred to me to take it outside, pour water on it or have elephants walk on the tracks. :)
 
When I was a kid, I had Märklin. It was pretty solid, but it never occurred to me to take it outside, pour water on it or have elephants walk on the tracks. :)

Märklin 1-Gauge is not indoor-outdoor. That would have been expensive. Their HO and Z-gauge trains are fantastic, but their HO was hard to sell due to it being proprietary. And American model train buffs tend to be hands-on, kit-bashing types. I loved their tracks and track systems.
 
Critical thinking can definitely be taught, but I think the stuff about people being willing to research is a little off the track.

Believers in alternate reality do a lot of research, but do not understand that the material they are reading is garbage.

Source reliability is much more important, and probably harder to teach, especially once someone has gone down the 'big' hole (i.e. big pharma, military-industrial complex, big media etc.)
 
Tangent but, I wonder what the venn diagram of moon landing hoax believers and Alien visitation believers looks like. I'm sure its none zero overlap but they are kind of contradictory beliefs aren't they?

Back in the day, there was one fairly notable guy I talked to whose position was literally, "The astronauts did not actually go to the Moon. But while they were there, they found evidence of alien visitation." I can't remember his name, but that's probably for the best. It doesn't take much to be properly skeptical of that claim.
 
Here's the flip-side to this statement:

I worked as a salesman in a high-end toy store for 14 years. I found my sales-manipulation skills worked better on educated people than on "Joe Sixpack". Smart people are often easier to deceive than less-smart people because, because they often don't have good BS filters. Less-than-smart people usually have over-developed BS filters that require creativity to manipulate.

Where you are right, in your perception of the slower set, is that these over-developed BS filters take the place of reason, and knowledge. This leaves them immune to facts. Their information must travel through a narrow path of "trusted" sources, and this path does not extend into deep or serious thinking skills.

But the fact is that smart-people can be manipulated into believing crazy things with the right buzzwords, presented in the right format, by sources who appeal to their intellectual egos. A prime example of this is Robert Kennedy Jr. A highly educated man who is deep in the woo. In the same way the less-smart people are obtuse to reason, his ego and intellect blind him from basic, big-picture facts.

IMO, a good skeptic frequently questions their own intelligence more than anything else.


We assume fooled intelligent researchers are making an honest attempt at testing, and are not just playing along to raise the value of their own coin.
 
Back in the day, there was one fairly notable guy I talked to whose position was literally, "The astronauts did not actually go to the Moon. But while they were there, they found evidence of alien visitation." I can't remember his name, but that's probably for the best. It doesn't take much to be properly skeptical of that claim.


Well, Neil Armstrong discovered a giant robot space ship, that dominated secret government efforts ever since. At least until a strange rectangular artifact was discovered well over 20 years ago.
 
Fair question.

The LGB G-Scale train is indoor-outdoor and all-weather. The slower set refused to believe you could run a model railroad in the rain or snow.
Is that really what they refused to believe, or was it just that they were skeptical of a salesman's spiel?

We'd poor a glass of water on them, and put out hands on the tracks while the train continued to run. They still didn't believe it was safe, even after a few of the brave ones placed their hand on the wet tracks.
How does putting your hands on the tracks prove the insulation and clearance distances on the mains transformer are safe?

Few people have the knowledge and understanding of electricity to know whether an electrical condition is safe or not. To make matters worse they are regularly misinformed by the media. How many movies have you seen where someone gets electrocuted by a 12 V battery connected to a pool of water?
 
I wonder what the venn diagram of moon landing hoax believers and Alien visitation believers looks like. I'm sure its none zero overlap but they are kind of contradictory beliefs aren't they?
Not at all. You see, we didn't go to the Moon because we didn't have to. NASA just asked some aliens to go there and pretend to be astronauts. Much cheaper than doing it ourselves!

But why would someone believe both in aliens and the Moon hoax? Because they are both 'beliefs' that make their lives a bit less dreary. Some people deliberately hold contrary 'beliefs' just to assert their individuality. This is why they are immune to logic and evidence - they don't want to know the truth.
 
I would disagree. First off, "knowing things" is not synonymous with being intelligent. Moreover, skepticism is more about knowing how to assess the reliability of information. I don't know all that much about sub-atomic particle physics, but I can still reach "skeptically sound" conclusions about cold fusion.

Skepticism is a process, not an intelligence measure.
True. But skepticism is a thought process.
 
Back in the day, there was one fairly notable guy I talked to whose position was literally, "The astronauts did not actually go to the Moon. But while they were there, they found evidence of alien visitation." I can't remember his name, but that's probably for the best. It doesn't take much to be properly skeptical of that claim.


A prominent Targeted Individual, Len Ber, claims that the "High power pulsed microwave weapon" that he imagines he's being attacked with leaves "markings on the glass closet door" at his residence.

When I asked him, "Why assume that it was caused by microwaves?! Think :horsehead, not :zebra: or :unicorn:," he answered:
Because this is where I get my directed energy attacks. My diagnosis is made by the dr Hoffer one confirmed by Dr Giordano.


Just two months ago, he claimed that
It does happen in different places, and at this point anywhere. I travel to different states or a hotel. You rent an apartment. I thought maybe it would be easier there. But no, anywhere I go, it reaches me out.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=14022521#post14022521


He considers himself to be "scientifically minded" and "a man of evidence."
 
Source reliability is much more important, and probably harder to teach, especially once someone has gone down the 'big' hole (i.e. big pharma, military-industrial complex, big media etc.)


Source reliability is good, but how do you know if sources are reliable or not? If you believe that Big Pharma, the DoD and the mainstream media are always reliable, I wouldn't call you a skeptic.
For a couple of years, we have been told by the CIA and mainstream media that a number of U.S. spies and diplomats were victims of directed-energy-weapon attacks. Very recently, we were told by the same agency and media that they weren't. (The DoD still hasn't entirely given up hope that they were.)

Sometimes, it takes a lot of effort to find out when sources are reliable and when they aren't. What seems to be consistent or inconsistent in the explanations and alleged facts we are presented with and what doesn't? For a couple of years, we were actually presented with a reason for going to wage war that turned out not be true.
And it's far from the first time this has happened.

Things like the alleged fake moon landing are fairly innocuous in comparison to this.

Look at the number of lives that have been lost to the pandemic because TPTB think it's cheaper to ignore (= tell people to 'learn to live with') the virus than to follow the example of countries that base their pandemic strategies on science instead of ideology. It takes quite an effort to even become aware that such countries exist. It's not as if it's something the media wants to tell us about.
 
You don't understand. People don't join UFO groups to critically examine the subject. They are there to put a little magic in their lives. They don't want to find out the truth about UFOs, they want a fantasy.


But it's more than that. If you just want a fantasy, you can watch a Disney movie. If you look at communities like QAnon, it is also about being in on something significant, of being the member of a kind of elite, a group of people who (imagine that they) know something that ordinary people don't. It's about being more than mere sheeple.

The irony being that it's what they themselves are while actively 'doing their own research'.

It is not unlike being a member of communities like the Masons or other secret societies. It makes you feel powerful, in charge. An ordinary fantasy doesn't give you that feeling of being important, even if the importance is only imaginary and helps you remain sheeple - with the exception of the (relatively) few conspiracy nuts who decide to seize the day, to live out the fantasy to the fullest and attack the Capitol.
 
Is that really what they refused to believe, or was it just that they were skeptical of a salesman's spiel?

I was literally banging the roof of a $125 passenger car against the counter.

How does putting your hands on the tracks prove the insulation and clearance distances on the mains transformer are safe?

You pour water onto the tracks and place one or both hands on that spot. And then don't die. There's no shock because it's low-voltage DC. The opposite demonstration would be to unplug your old Lionel AC-powered transformer, and touch the prongs of the plug (this was my introduction to electrical shock when I was four, not recommended).

Few people have the knowledge and understanding of electricity to know whether an electrical condition is safe or not. To make matters worse they are regularly misinformed by the media. How many movies have you seen where someone gets electrocuted by a 12 V battery connected to a pool of water?

They didn't need to know that stuff. They just needed to know they could put their train out in the backyard, even if they lived in Vermont.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom