Does it require intelligence to be a skeptic?

Whilst I broadly agree with the point you are making, we should be careful about making sweeping generalisations. It could just be that the relatively uneducated person who left school at sixteen, has less disposable income to spend on 'luxury' goods, whereas the seemingly 'smart' (read = educated) person might just not care if the toy you are flogging turns out to have a one-day novelty value for the kids as what is worth $1 to the poor, is a cent to the richer person.

In addition, there is the concept of empathy, which may or may not be related to being easily manipulated. It is possible that some people bought the toys you were offering because they felt sorry for you and your obvious sales pitch. I once made the mistake of equating gullibility with class (read = education level; well-spokeness; well-dressed/heeled) so I was pleasantly disabused of this notion when I once went around local pubs to raise money for striking journalists (NUJ). The sheer number of ordinary 'common people' who put their hands in their pocket with nary a murmur or a second thought, was truly touching, especially when one assumes that these were people hwo had struggles with bills, housing and employment, etc. I was diffidently expecting people to tell me to '**** off and tell those lazy bastards to get back to work!' so moral learned: kindness and empathy is not correlated with wealth, intelligence or level of education.

A bit of a correlation of your first point, I think, is how often we hear crackpot schemes and pursuits advocated because supposedly smart and rich sponsors have signed on and thrown in funding. If a scheme promises enormous payouts in return for an investment of tax deductible pocket change, you can afford to be careless and to abandon skepticism.

Of course it can get complicated, as Axxman suggests, because if you base your opinion on what someone supposedly smart and savvy supports, that can be pretty stupid, so round and round we go.
 
I don't think you have to be particularly "smart", whatever that means, to be a skeptic. But it helps. You'd be a better skeptic if you have a lot of data in your memory, and can manipulate it well, and provide a more detailed analysis. But I think it's pretty easy for a lower watt bulb to have a powerful BS detector, even if he doesn't know the Latin phrases and fifty cent words to describe why it's BS.
 
I am not even sure if it is to do with having a lot of data in your memory. Schools can teach 'critical thinking', logic and how to spot fake news and disinformation. IMV the true path to scepticism is via the school of life. So, come teenage years, there is a light bulb moment, 'Hey, they lied to me. Father Christmas isn't real. England isn't the only country in the world. Superman is ridiculous, with his "truth, justice and the American way", as he flies through the air eliminating the baddies.'

All those years you savoured your comics and tv shows and then you see behind the veil as it were, and as one moment of so-called 'truth' turns out to be a lie, then one begins to question everything. It's no coincidence that the great rebels of our day, Rimbaud, Icarus, Extinction Rebellion, CND, Jobs not Bombs, let's go to San Franscisco, etcetera, are the young generation, exhilarated in discovering that they world isn't what it was claimed to be and they lied about going to hell if you did x y or z.


I recall an amusing moment when I was at the cinema, when a group of kids behind me started shouting out sarcastic comments at the screenplay. I realised that the ring leader was...my own 14-year-old kid. Of course, I didn't mortify him by letting him know I was there!
 
Yeah, and we all know people with street smarts who can see right through a hustle. True skeptics by any measure, sophisticated or not.
 
I'm sure there's some lower bound but there is no evidence to my knowledge that smarter people are better sceptics. There is evidence that smarter and better educated skeptics are better rationalizers of false beliefs though.
 
I used to provide construction reports for low-rent litigations. Never ceased to amaze me how transparent the ruses were, both with very smart and successful customers getting fleeced, and the adversary's expert transparently lying. I mean, the smell of the bull **** was choking.

There was one binding arbitration where our adversary gave detailed testimony about a structural foundation crack 3/4" wide. That's serious. The engineer he hired as an expert provided pictures which, sure enough, showed a monster wide gap (the pics were admitted into evidence on the fly and were not previously disclosed during discovery. All parties agreed to allow them in anyway). I was panicking, trying to figure out how I had missed this. By comparing two different pictures, I was able to show (using their own submissions) that the engineer staged the lighting to create a long shadow that appeard to be a wide gap. The arbitrator agreed and my client won on that point, with the adversary's expert's opinions rejected rather harshly.

I joked with the attorney afterwards about how they could have thought such a slapstick vaudeville routine would have worked. He said the brazenness was what fools everyone (and he reminded me that I was initially questioning my own findings when I saw the pics), and that a lot of people simply don't have their radar tuned in to being blatantly scammed, and that lack of critical thinking was what was keeping our kids in college.
 
Being "intelligent" and "smart" doesn't mean you can't believe crap. It should be pointed out, more often than it is, that very "smart" "intelligent" people are very good at rationlizing, justifying belief in utter nonsense and bluntly the more "smart" "intelligent" you are the better such people are at such rationlization.
 
...snip.. and that a lot of people simply don't have their radar tuned in to being blatantly scammed, and that lack of critical thinking was what was keeping our kids in college.

Randi used to say that the frauds managed to fool scientist during the 60s and 70s because scientists were not used to their experiments lying to them.
 
I used to provide construction reports for low-rent litigations. Never ceased to amaze me how transparent the ruses were, both with very smart and successful customers getting fleeced, and the adversary's expert transparently lying. I mean, the smell of the bull **** was choking.

There was one binding arbitration where our adversary gave detailed testimony about a structural foundation crack 3/4" wide. That's serious. The engineer he hired as an expert provided pictures which, sure enough, showed a monster wide gap (the pics were admitted into evidence on the fly and were not previously disclosed during discovery. All parties agreed to allow them in anyway). I was panicking, trying to figure out how I had missed this. By comparing two different pictures, I was able to show (using their own submissions) that the engineer staged the lighting to create a long shadow that appeard to be a wide gap. The arbitrator agreed and my client won on that point, with the adversary's expert's opinions rejected rather harshly.

I joked with the attorney afterwards about how they could have thought such a slapstick vaudeville routine would have worked. He said the brazenness was what fools everyone (and he reminded me that I was initially questioning my own findings when I saw the pics), and that a lot of people simply don't have their radar tuned in to being blatantly scammed, and that lack of critical thinking was what was keeping our kids in college.


Randi used to say that the frauds managed to fool scientist during the 60s and 70s because scientists were not used to their experiments lying to them.


"Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me."
 
I don't think you have to be particularly "smart", whatever that means, to be a skeptic.

I'm guided by without question the two smartest blokes I ever met.

One is a theoretical neuroscientist who's led research teams across Europe and Australia.

The other makes guys like Dr Adequate look like first-graders in maths. He's a Saffer who moved to NZ and made national news as the Human Computer. He has about eight degrees.

They are both staunch christians.

Your comment about street smarts is a lot more like it.
 
Well...

(snip)
This will show the age of what I'm remembering, it's my best recollection of a bit of critical thinking from a very young girl that came out of the program.



I hope I'm remembering the details correctly.

I assumed at the time, that the girl must be responding to advertising for Twinkies, and it was many years later that I found out what Twinkies are.

(And Howard Cosell was a famous sports journalist at the time, so I'm guessing he was hired to advertise Twinkies.)
(snip)

Possibly Euell Gibbons, not Cosell. Gibbons was a natural-foods enthusiast who did TV ads for Grape-Nuts that began, "Did you ever eat a pine tree? Many parts ARE edible."
 
Whilst I broadly agree with the point you are making, we should be careful about making sweeping generalisations. It could just be that the relatively uneducated person who left school at sixteen, has less disposable income to spend on 'luxury' goods, whereas the seemingly 'smart' (read = educated) person might just not care if the toy you are flogging turns out to have a one-day novelty value for the kids as what is worth $1 to the poor, is a cent to the richer person.

And here you are making sweeping generalizations.

At the time I lived and worked in Carmel, California. Education does not always equal wealth. Two of my wealthiest customers, Steve Jobs, and Lindsey Buckingham, were college dropouts. My "educated" customers (doctors, lawyers, architects) tended to be the ones who were less likely to waste money, and tended to buy thoughtful toys such as puzzles, board games, and stuff from the science table.

In addition, there is the concept of empathy, which may or may not be related to being easily manipulated. It is possible that some people bought the toys you were offering because they felt sorry for you and your obvious sales pitch. I once made the mistake of equating gullibility with class (read = education level; well-spokeness; well-dressed/heeled) so I was pleasantly disabused of this notion when I once went around local pubs to raise money for striking journalists (NUJ). The sheer number of ordinary 'common people' who put their hands in their pocket with nary a murmur or a second thought, was truly touching, especially when one assumes that these were people hwo had struggles with bills, housing and employment, etc. I was diffidently expecting people to tell me to '**** off and tell those lazy bastards to get back to work!' so moral learned: kindness and empathy is not correlated with wealth, intelligence or level of education.

I ran the hobby department. I sold LGB garden railroad items which started at $150 and ran up to $1500. Nobody needs a huge model train. Nobody bought one because they felt sorry for me. They bought them because they were (at the time) the best, and most unique model railroad option. It was like selling Ferraris.

I should also point out that at this time, I attended monthly UFO meetings at the local metaphysical bookstore. There were between 12 and 20 people attending these meetings, I was one of three who did not have a college education. Members ran the range from comptrollers, real estate agents, insurance claims adjusters, artists, and office workers. I was eventually asked to leave because I had the nerve to ask for some kind of physical evidence.
 
Last edited:
And here you are making sweeping generalizations.

At the time I lived and worked in Carmel, California. Education does not always equal wealth. Two of my wealthiest customers, Steve Jobs, and Lindsey Buckingham, were college dropouts. My "educated" customers (doctors, lawyers, architects) tended to be the ones who were less likely to waste money, and tended to buy thoughtful toys such as puzzles, board games, and stuff from the science table.
The difference does seem to be that higher education leads to more curiosity, more questions, more seeking, deeper play.



I ran the hobby department. I sold LGB garden railroad items which started at $150 and ran up to $1500. Nobody needs a huge model train. Nobody bought one because they felt sorry for me. They bought them because they were (at the time) the best, and most unique model railroad option. It was like selling Ferraris.

I should also point out that at this time, I attended monthly UFO meetings at the local metaphysical bookstore. There were between 12 and 20 people attending these meetings, I was one of three who did not have a college education. Members ran the range from comptrollers, real estate agents, insurance claims adjusters, artists, and office workers. I was eventually asked to leave because I had the nerve to ask for some kind of physical evidence.
A witch!!! BURN!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom