Does it require intelligence to be a skeptic?

A witch!!! BURN!!

I had read all the books going back to the 1960s, and I noticed a significant pattern change. All the way through the early 1980s, UFOs landed. UFOs had landing gear, and left "scorch marks". Not just in North America, but globally. And then for some reason they just started hovering over the ground, no longer using landing gear.

I wondered why. Seemed like a huge change. I suggested that maybe people's imaginations had evolved from the 1950s movies, where the alien spaceships landed, to the 1970-1990s movies where they floated (thanks to improved special effects).

Another question that cost me any popularity was why none of the aliens ever drop anything, or left garbage behind? Just look at the stuff left in the Antarctic from every expedition, and look at the stuff we left on the moon.

Nobody in the UFO group was that open-minded.
 
I had read all the books going back to the 1960s, and I noticed a significant pattern change. All the way through the early 1980s, UFOs landed. UFOs had landing gear, and left "scorch marks". Not just in North America, but globally. And then for some reason they just started hovering over the ground, no longer using landing gear.

I wondered why. Seemed like a huge change. I suggested that maybe people's imaginations had evolved from the 1950s movies, where the alien spaceships landed, to the 1970-1990s movies where they floated (thanks to improved special effects).

Another question that cost me any popularity was why none of the aliens ever drop anything, or left garbage behind? Just look at the stuff left in the Antarctic from every expedition, and look at the stuff we left on the moon.

Nobody in the UFO group was that open-minded.

It's the same as to what the aliens look like - there's a graphic that charts the evolution of the aliens over the decades I'll see if I can find it online.
 
I don't think you need enormous intellect, or intelligence about everything to do an intelligent thing, but more or less by definition doing something intelligent is not a stupid act. So yes, I think it requires at least a modicum, at least occasionally, of intelligence to approach an issue intelligently, but I also think saying so is not saying very much.


My view is that to be a good sceptic requires a number of attributes:

1) A threshold level of innate intelligence (prob an IQ and EQ over around 120)

2) A high capacity for watching, listening, touching, hearing and learning

3) Parenting from a young age which stimulates & encourages (2) above

4) A good general primary & secondary education, including a reasonable level of proficiency in both arts and sciences (a tertiary and quaternary education is better still)

5) Some level of education/learning/training in critical thinking techniques

6) A natural curiosity in one's daily life

7) A willingness to observe and absorb information & opinion and to be able to integrate these into an overall "picture of the universe"

8) Above-average communication skills

9) A constant open mind, free of reactionary thinking or preconceived/fixed beliefs


That about covers it :D
 
I always thought it a bit odd that though we need elaborate space suits to go anywhere, aliens don't.

In real life it would be "what did the aliens look like?" "I don't know, but they had these really weird helmets."
 
Starting to realize that those who claim skepticism requires no intelligence are likely correct. Ample evidence in this very thread.


LOL

I've lost track (genuinely) of the number of times I've observed - with good reason - that there seem to be quite a few people on these sorts of forums who'd like to think they're truly sceptical, and who somehow appear to believe that simply participating on a sceptics' forum somehow magically imbues (and validates) them with sceptical skills.

In an ideal (but somewhat creepy and weird :p) world, people would be required to provide evidence of critical thinking and scepticism before they were allowed to participate in these sorts of forums......
 
My view is that to be a good sceptic requires a number of attributes:


A decent list, but IMHO, there are only two very basic ones:

1) A modicum of intelligence, insomuch as they have the ability to comprehend and learn.

2) They are reasonable.


Everything else is window dressing.
 
A decent list, but IMHO, there are only two very basic ones:

1) A modicum of intelligence, insomuch as they have the ability to comprehend and learn.

2) They are reasonable.


Everything else is window dressing.


I suppose it depends on one's perspective and one's definition of "sceptic". I totally agree that the two qualities you list will equip someone to engage in reasoned, intelligent debate*. But I suppose I was thinking about a higher level.

And don't forget that back in ancient Greece - arguably where scepticism truly developed as a concept - people had to study under the masters at the Academy for many years until they could call themselves proficient.


* Although the two qualities you list might reasonably be present in people who are antivaxxers, climate change deniers, or 9/11 Truthers. Which is where I'd argue that many of my additional listed qualities might effectively weed out such people.
 
I suppose it depends on one's perspective and one's definition of "sceptic". I totally agree that the two qualities you list will equip someone to engage in reasoned, intelligent debate*. But I suppose I was thinking about a higher level.

And don't forget that back in ancient Greece - arguably where scepticism truly developed as a concept - people had to study under the masters at the Academy for many years until they could call themselves proficient.


* Although the two qualities you list might reasonably be present in people who are antivaxxers, climate change deniers, or 9/11 Truthers. Which is where I'd argue that many of my additional listed qualities might effectively weed out such people.

And sadly, the philosophical skeptics didn't believe anything existed, and tended to feature highly on the 'stupid deaths' scale for doing things like throwing themselves in front of chariots to prove that the chariots and horses didn't exist.
 
I don't think so. I don't consider myself particularly intelligent at all but I'm a decent skeptic.
 
* Although the two qualities you list might reasonably be present in people who are antivaxxers, climate change deniers, or 9/11 Truthers. Which is where I'd argue that many of my additional listed qualities might effectively weed out such people.


My position is that such people are NOT reasonable, as ignoring mountains of evidence to promote cherry-picked snippets and out-of-context statements/data in support of an alternative view have no affiliation with what anyone should consider as a reasonable mind-set.
 
My position is that such people are NOT reasonable, as ignoring mountains of evidence to promote cherry-picked snippets and out-of-context statements/data in support of an alternative view have no affiliation with what anyone should consider as a reasonable mind-set.


Yes, but your definition of "reasonable" more-or-less demands that the person has - either implicitly or explicitly - been trained in the art/skill of assessing the available evidence, having an accurate worldview, and making evidence-based arguments/conclusion. It's not something that most (maybe any) people are just born with.

And it's these training/learning processes, plus some self-improvement processes, that I believe are absolutely necessary if one is to become a good (effective, thoughtful, evidence-based) sceptic. This in turn is precisely what is driving most of the other bullet points in my list.
 
The Good Sceptic

Whilst having a good education and being bright might well indeed facilitate the powers of scepticism, I don't think they are the cause of it nor necessarily even give rise to a sceptical nature. I tend to agree with Axxman that some people have a well-developed BS detector which is not altogether contingent on their being clever or wealthy.
Likewise, there are many people who consider themselves a sceptic yet in reality, only think they are. What happens is, they know the buzzwords, such as 'psychic' and 'medium', equals "woo" but when one scratches the surface, it becomes apparent they've never actually really thought about it; they are simply repeating the given mantra. I say this because the same aforementioned people are astonished to hear that psychotherapy is also woo*. As psychotherapy is socially acceptable and claiming to be a psychic is not, it has never crossed their mind to actually question their assumption that they know what woo is. However, the idea that little boys wanting to kill their fathers and sleep with their mothers, whilst little girls have penis envy and suffer from hysteria has never been scientifically proven either and this, together with the concepts of ego, id, superego, thanatos and libido (such as is the school of Freudian thought) is just as much woo-based as communicating with dead spirits or astrology, palmistry, numerology or tarot reading. Ask any scientifically-trained psychologist if this astonishes you. The true sceptic IMV, weighs up each case on their own merits; in many cases we can dismiss the claim almost immediately. In the case of conspiracy theories, because intelligence agencies are so secretive - often with documents locked up for 75 years - then this arouses people's curiosity as to what exactly is being hidden. Take UFO's for example. Absolutely no disrespect to anyone but wondering why aliens never seem to wear space suits or leave behind debris is a 12-year-old's level of scepticism. Think about it. The CIA have taken the issue of UFO sightings seriously. So if these highly intelligent, well-educated guys are allowed to watch out for UFO's, why not anyone else? Whilst I don't believe there are little green men from Mars or spaceships floating around á la IT-call-home, I did once have a desire to visit Joshua Tree Desert at night to chill out with friends to watch out for the famed UFO's in that region, more as an interesting watching of the skies, such as looking out for the northern lights or Orion's Belt. When people say 'UFO', this is likely to be due to some kind of easily explicable phenomenon, such as electromagnetic activity or meteor showers or some such. Knee-jerk head shaking is not scepticism, it is cynicism.

As for the issue a poster mentioned earlier about how his two favourite 'smartest guys I ever met' were both non-atheists, can I just say here that I don't think being an atheist or non-atheist defines a 'true sceptic'. Often, a person's religious affiliation is just an affirmation of their cultural roots and separate from their powers of scepticism. I have known quite a few atheists who are atheist because they were brought up as atheist so really not that different from someone identifying as Muslim, Christian or Jewish because that is their background and not a reflection on their powers of scepticism.

So, to sum up then, scepticism is more than a knee-jerk response of shouting 'rubbish' mindlessly at any unconventional claim (read: not yet approved by Murdoch) like uncouth teenagers yelling abuse at every crap pop song on TOTP, just because a high proportion absolutely are, and because 'Uri Geller'. So someone being well-educated and intelligent, doesn't make them a true sceptic, just because they read Private Eye and watch HIGNIFY, occasionally lobbying brickbats at dodgy politicians; and yet at the same time are perfectly happy with the status quo and one's position in it.

That is not to say I think scepticism cannot be trained. I would say training of the sort police, detectives, barristers and official examiners have, being suspicious of everything, being observant, having a good BS detector, knowing how to place yourself in another's shoes and understanding their M.O. and what makes them tick, asking the right questions, making the right suggestions and being two steps ahead, is what makes for a good sceptic.


*That's not to say that counselling of itself - offloading one's troubles onto a sympathetic ear - is not effective as a form of therapy.
 
My view is that to be a good sceptic requires a number of attributes:

1) A threshold level of innate intelligence (prob an IQ and EQ over around 120)

2) A high capacity for watching, listening, touching, hearing and learning

3) Parenting from a young age which stimulates & encourages (2) above

4) A good general primary & secondary education, including a reasonable level of proficiency in both arts and sciences (a tertiary and quaternary education is better still)

5) Some level of education/learning/training in critical thinking techniques

6) A natural curiosity in one's daily life

7) A willingness to observe and absorb information & opinion and to be able to integrate these into an overall "picture of the universe"

8) Above-average communication skills

9) A constant open mind, free of reactionary thinking or preconceived/fixed beliefs


That about covers it :D

For the "Good Skeptic" that practices Critical Thinking, I'd add self examination and self awareness.
As Richard Feynman once said, "the person easiest to fool is yourself."
You must be able to question your own assumptions and why some particular matter may especially evoke a skeptical reaction, while another may be ignored.

Beliefs are preferential, and we do a lot of rationalizing to hold onto them.
Beliefs we are culturally accustomed to seem more plausible to even the skeptic eye, and are often held unconsciously.

Our skeptic eye may take positions reactively in order to distance ourselves from overt woo-woo. For example there was a person on this board years back who was highly skeptical of Quantum Theory. He wanted a return to the woo-less ground of Newtonian Physics. This was because he didn't want to give any possible quarter to the "Consciousness" woo-woo of Depak Chopra, et al. Another may insist there is no evidence of an historical Jesus, in the end to absolutely dismiss all Christianity.

Critical Thinking isn't a posturing and identifying oneself as a "Skeptic." It's simply "Right Thinking" (If a can cockroach a little Buddhism, or some "Know Thyself," if you can better stomach Stoicism).
 
Yes, but your definition of "reasonable" more-or-less demands that the person has - either implicitly or explicitly - been trained in the art/skill of assessing the available evidence, having an accurate worldview, and making evidence-based arguments/conclusion. It's not something that most (maybe any) people are just born with.

And it's these training/learning processes, plus some self-improvement processes, that I believe are absolutely necessary if one is to become a good (effective, thoughtful, evidence-based) sceptic. This in turn is precisely what is driving most of the other bullet points in my list.


No demand necessary. I don't deny the items in your post and previous list help, but they are still mostly window dressing, as most of them are either things a reasonable person does, or things that can also be done by a bad skeptic, who remains unreasonable.

A reasonable person knows when they are out of their depth on a subject, and either acknowledges so, or makes the effort to study it to the point they can make an informed conclusion. You can't bullet point every topic with which a person should be educated in in order to be a good skeptic. There are no academic and/or upbringing criteria that guarantees a good or bad skeptic. It is all based on their reasonable uses of their knowledge AND their reasonable recognition of their limitations.


Now, if you are trying to identify an environment ripe for producing a person with good skeptical qualities in relatable ways, then your list does offer that setting, but again, is not entirely prerequisite for just being a good skeptic.
 
I'd say that the willingness to acquire knowledge and be corrected by it is a more important prerequisite than intelligence for a sceptic. I've known a few pretty intelligent people who were wrong about a lot of things because they never bothered to properly inform themselves, assuming that their intuition and subjective experiences were sufficient to reach reliable conclusions. They didn't know about cognitive biases, so they didn't know they needed to take them into account.
 
For reasons that aren't important here, I have been rereading some of the old Million Dollar Challenge threads. Of particular relevance here, I think, is the one started by Cassidy.*

Despite being given example after example of pareidolia, Cassidy was adamant about refusing to even look at the possibility that she was not in contact with spirits.


*A reminder that Cassidy is still a member of ISF, so all the rules apply.
 
I worked as a salesman in a high-end toy store for 14 years. I found my sales-manipulation skills worked better on educated people than on "Joe Sixpack". Smart people are often easier to deceive than less-smart people because, because they often don't have good BS filters. Less-than-smart people usually have over-developed BS filters that require creativity to manipulate.


Can you be more specific? What did you tell your potential customers that was believed by smart people but not by "Joe Sixpack"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom