Does It Really Matter?

Yes, and according to Planck

So, this would pretty much invalidate his whole career as a scientist, don't you think? If he is so prone to "wishful thinking," as you suggest, then how could he be trusted to exercise any sort of anlaytical judgment in the field of science? Either that, or he must have been one heck of an awfully "good guesser." If that were the case I would be impresssed, and suspect that his "guesses" about God were equally as valid. So much so, that I probably wouldn't have to question it myself.

Plank was a human being.
Plank was a good scientists because experimentation and discovery has bore him out to be correct concerning his theories. He did not guess so much as had good intuition.
Plank made a disticntion between science and religion. He knew that science could not know anything about god. His religious beliefs were not up to scrutiny because he knew there was no way to prove or verify them. Nor did want to I suspect. Faith means that you do not require or want proof.
 
So does the body.
Well, at least this body exists...
michellelee_narrowweb__200x332.jpg
 
The spirit exists.
Pure assertion. In the absence of a coherent definition of spirit (do you mean this metaphorically? Literally? Which version of "spirit", as it has been used through the centuries, do you mean?), your assertion is meaningless.

I am certain you believe that "the spirit exists". I am also aware that your posting history here suggests that you believe quite a few things that cannot be supported with either logic or evidence.

I eagerly await the time you actually support one of your assertions.
 
I eagerly await the time you actually support one of your assertions.
Does the tail wag the dog? No. So, until you can begin to fathom what I'm saying with respect to this, that time will probably never come.
 
Does the tail wag the dog? No. So, until you can begin to fathom what I'm saying with respect to this, that time will probably never come.

Ah the old "I'm too smart for the room" defense. I wouldn't be so confident if I were you. You have still failed to grasp something as simple as the scientific method.

It's simple:

1) Define spirit.

2) Give evidence of the spirit.
 
Ah the old "I'm too smart for the room" defense. I wouldn't be so confident if I were you. You have still failed to grasp something as simple as the scientific method.

It's simple:

1) Define spirit.

2) Give evidence of the spirit.
Just to help a little here, this is not the kind of spirit he means.

unbranded-bombay-sapphire-gin-70cl-bottle.jpg

or this
bourbon.jpg

or even this
absinth-big.gif


They're all tasty, and, if you consort with them too much, you might wish there was a god to pray to, but it's not what he means.
 
Are we talking about the kind of spirit KingMerv00 means or the kind of spirit that seems to inspire Iacchus's thought processes?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom