Does It Really Matter?

So what do you guys plan to do on these Iacchus-free days?

Maybe I'll start a thread on some issue and NOT have it side tracked by his swishy new age crap!!
 
I tried to do that in the post-Franko days, but you know what I got? Shocked silence!
 
Another ranting solipsist. I went through that phase for about a month until I realized it was completely stupid. And I was in high school.
 
Exactly. The only way solipsism is coherent is when it acknowledges that we do not control our experiences - in which case, it is then indistinguishable from any other description of reality.

People who say they're solipsists, and insist that they're making an important and meaningful statement about the nature of reality, and almost always idiots. If not, they're completely philosophically naive. Or they're philosophy professors (see contigency #1).
 
Interestingly Planck made a clear distinction between his religious beliefs and science.
Well, obviously it didn't interfere with his work as a scientist.

Here is a quote from this site:

http://www.thermalphysics.org/planck/planckessey.html

Max Planck. A man of his time.

This just goes to show that even Iaachus can get sorta lucky sometimes.
The father of quantum theory, huh?

While I'm wondering how can such a brilliant mind come to the distinction that God exists? Was it just a matter of what he believed or, was there more to it than that?
 
While I'm wondering how can such a brilliant mind come to the distinction that God exists? Was it just a matter of what he believed or, was there more to it than that?
Well we can't really ask him, can we? But we can read the quote provided by uruk:
"Religion belongs to that realm that is inviolable before the laws of causation and therefore closed to science" (Planck 1959, p. 121).
Seems to me he is saying that religion can't be explored by science, so his belief in God would be purely a belief.
According to the woo program I saw on TV the other night, it happened during his Nobel acceptance speech. But then again, in looking around, I can't find anything "non-woo" to corroborate this.
Good thing the Nobel Prize website has both his Nobel Lecture and his Banquet Speech online. Do you see the quote there?
 
Yes, this is one of the first places I looked. And no, I couldn't find it in the Nobel Lecture. However, the Banquet Speech is in German, so? ... Is this something that they normally do, not offer up a translation of it? It seems a bit odd.
I have no idea. Let's see if someone who speaks German is kind enough to look for the quote there. Perhaps you could use an automatic translator and do a preliminary search.
 
I have no idea. Let's see if someone who speaks German is kind enough to look for the quote there. Perhaps you could use an automatic translator and do a preliminary search.
Actually, I just tried doing this using Babel Fish, and I don't think it's there.
 
Yeah, that's true. I've actually changed my opinion of Iacchus somewhat lately. Sometimes he does seem to try to make sense and even to understand what other posters are saying. Except of course if doing so conflicts with his metaphysical ideas.
But that's more than can be said about some. And it's more than I thought was there when I was first reading his posts.

These days I would say this of Iacchus: he's a relatively intelligent guy, not blind to reason, who thinks he knows all the answers, and has become very attached to those answers that he has found for himself.
I could be wrong, Iacchus. I don't know you. But anyway, it's more that I would have said of you in the past.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom