Does It Really Matter?

Well, obviously it didn't interfere with his work as a scientist.

The father of quantum theory, huh?

While I'm wondering how can such a brilliant mind come to the distinction that God exists? Was it just a matter of what he believed or, was there more to it than that?
I'd say it probably had more to do with his upbringing than anything else.
Scientists are human beings and just as suceptable to any line of thinking as the next layman. Heck, even Einstien married his cousin, Elsa, not long after his divorce with Mileva. First, Elsa was nowhere near the intellectual equivelent of Mileva or himself. And secondly, EEEWWWW, his cousin!!!
Just Because your very smart or intellegent or in the history books make you some sort of infallible demigod or protect you from being absolutly wrong.

Planck made a distinction between science and religion. Alot of scientists that are religious also do. The nature of the religious is maintain that belief reguardless of what is presented to them. Religious scientis usualy find no problem integrating science and religion into thier lives. (just so long as you or they don't press the point too hard)
 
Planck made a distinction between science and religion. Alot of scientists that are religious also do. The nature of the religious is maintain that belief reguardless of what is presented to them.
Oh, do you mean that scientists can be wishful thinkers too? Even someone as brilliant as Max Planck?
 
Iacchus - It appears that Planck was right about physics and wrong about religion.

Deal with it.

By the way, Elvis is still dead.
 
Oh, do you mean that scientists can be wishful thinkers too? Even someone as brilliant as Max Planck?

Max Planck was brilliant (IMO) and he DID believe in God.

Carl Sagan was brilliant (IMO) and did NOT believe in God.

One of these brilliant men must have been wrong. Believe it or not, intellectual giants aren't perfect.
 
Iacchus - It appears that Planck was right about physics and wrong about religion.
Yes, if he believed in it blindly. Yet according to his statement, he seemed to be quite sober and spoke with a clear mind about the whole thing.
 
Max Planck was brilliant (IMO) and he DID believe in God.

Carl Sagan was brilliant (IMO) and did NOT believe in God.

One of these brilliant men must have been wrong. Believe it or not, intellectual giants aren't perfect.
I was never really impressed much with Sagan.
 
Even more reason to respect Sagan.

But seriously Iacchus, that isn't the point. The point is that there are very intelligent people who do believe in god, and very intelligent people who do not. Neither fact should sway our views one way or the other. Rather, it's the arguments themselves that should impress us.

As you are making an argument from authority, but by what weight do you suggest that Plank was an expert on God?
 
Yes, if he believed in it blindly. Yet according to his statement, he seemed to be quite sober and spoke with a clear mind about the whole thing.
Speaking clearly, and making a meaningful argument are two different things. Assuming for the moment that he actually did say it (which again, you've failed to show), where is the strength of his argument?

All it says is "we don't know how something works, therefore god is behind it." it's God of the Gaps. That Plank said it and not a televangelist doesn't change that. And that's assuming Plank did say it.
 
I was never really impressed much with Sagan.

He the primary creator of the language on the golden disk (I think). He took great efforts to ease scientific and religious tensions. Doesn't impress you huh? Oh well, to each his own. Do you know any brilliant atheist scientists? There are plenty out there.

The point remains the same. Brilliant people contradict each other and they can speak calmly, soberly, and with great conviction. Does that mean they are both right?
 
Oh, do you mean that scientists can be wishful thinkers too? Even someone as brilliant as Max Planck?
Of course, scientist are people too and just as supceptable to "wishfull thinking" as the next. The difference is that science has a mechinizim that tries to filter out "wishfull thinking". It separates what "is" from what we "wish" there to be. The Michelson/Morely experiment is a great example of that. Einstein was also guilty of "wishfull thinking" with his "Cosmological Constant" fudge. Though he later owned up to it.

Religion is a matter of faith. Blind faith. Faith that prevents you from asking too many questions. Max Planck grew up in a family that was strong on faith and therfore believed in religion blindly.
But Planck himself said that religion is outside the bounds of science and therefore not understandable by science. Which is what most religious scientists believe. That's how most integrate the two by keeping a clear distance between them. Science deals with he world we live. Religion deals with a different area not bound or explainable by science.

Max Planck was a brilliant scientist/thoeritician, but he was also strong on religious faith. Does one affect the other? I think not. Religion is not a matter of intellect but of "heart" and faith. It does not require a whole lot of brain power to be religious or to have faith. Just a lot of will.
 
Yes, and according to Planck

As a man who has devoted his whole life to the most clear-headed science, to the study of matter, I can tell you as the result of my research about atoms this much:

THERE IS NO MATTER AS SUCH!
So, this would pretty much invalidate his whole career as a scientist, don't you think? If he is so prone to "wishful thinking," as you suggest, then how could he be trusted to exercise any sort of anlaytical judgment in the field of science? Either that, or he must have been one heck of an awfully "good guesser." If that were the case I would be impresssed, and suspect that his "guesses" about God were equally as valid. So much so, that I probably wouldn't have to question it myself.
 
Last edited:
Yes, and according to Planck

So, this would pretty much invalidate his whole career as a scientist, don't you think? If he is so prone to "wishful thinking," as you suggest, then how could he be trusted to exercise any sort of anlaytical judgment in the field of science? Either that, or he must have been one heck of an awfully "good guesser." If that were the case I would be impresssed, and suspect that his "guesses" about God were equally as valid. So much so, that I probably wouldn't have to question it myself.

Ahem....NO

I have decided you are a troll. A troll with over 7,500 posts. (I am impressed) Why do I think that? Because no human could possibly spend as much time as you have on a skeptic forum and not pick up even a twinkling of how the scientific method works.

I guess I'll answer your post anyway:

Max Planck helped developed quantum theory. It made predictions, it was testable, and it was falsifiable. It was good science. There was much rejoicing (yay).

Science isn't about being good at guessing, it's about forming a idea and testing it until your eyes bleed. Then other people test it, their eyes bleed. This continues until the tests reject or confirm your hypothesis. Wishful thinking is beat to death. Appeals to authority are stomped.

Scientists, even Nobel Prize winners, are right some of the time and wrong some of the time. Einstein, Newton, and Dalton all screwed up in some way, and that's ok. Humans do that. They pick themselves up and learn from their mistakes.

(Glares at Iacchus) Well MOST humans learn from their mistakes.
 
Last edited:
Ahem....NO

I have decided you are a troll. A troll with over 7,500 posts. (I am impressed) Why do I think that? Because no human could possibly spend as much time as you have on a skeptic forum and not pick up even a twinkling of how the scientific method works.

I think what he is doing, and he is not alone in doing this, is decide that he KNOWS something is true and looks everywhere for "flaws" in reputable scientist's statements that he believes prove him right. Nothing very unusual in this approach.

Keeps him happy and provides amusement to others. No real problem.
 
Ahem....NO

I have decided you are a troll. A troll with over 7,500 posts. (I am impressed) Why do I think that? Because no human could possibly spend as much time as you have on a skeptic forum and not pick up even a twinkling of how the scientific method works.
Have you read my book yet?

I guess I'll answer your post anyway:

Max Planck helped developed quantum theory. It made predictions, it was testable, and it was falsifiable. It was good science. There was much rejoicing (yay).
Great.

Science isn't about being good at guessing, it's about forming a idea and testing it until your eyes bleed. Then other people test it, their eyes bleed. This continues until the tests reject or confirm your hypothesis. Wishful thinking is beat to death.
Well, judging by the quote, Mr. Planck sounded awfully sure of himself.

Appeals to authority are stomped.
Really? Then you think Mr. Planck would have understood this and not bothered to say anything. It doesn't sound like good science to me.

Scientists, even Nobel Prize winners, are right some of the time and wrong some of the time. Einstein, Newton, and Dalton all screwed up in some way, and that's ok. Humans do that. They pick themselves up and learn from their mistakes.
Yes, and this is all part of the "experience" we call learning, correct?

(Glares at Iacchus) Well MOST humans learn from their mistakes.
And, as sure as I am typing at the keyboard, I know what I know.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom