does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

"occasionally" is here and now

I shared the analysis ...
Do you have evidence yet?
What about evidence we are shills?
... it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.

Here to expose to lurkers you have zero evidence to support any of your claims.

We are all shills, or only some of us? Are you as paranoid as this post, or was this a weak attack? Who are we shills for?
 
Last edited:
I shared the analysis with the girder below at ambient temperature and then explained that a temperature of 500 degrees C drops the yield strength down to 70% of room temperature. Since the factor of safety at room temp was about 3 to 1, then at 500 C it would still be 2 to 1 against failure. This isn't very hard to understand and you are blowing a lot of smoke now.


What do you think caused the buckling of WTC 7 prior to its collapse?
 
I shared the analysis with the girder below at ambient temperature and then explained that a temperature of 500 degrees C drops the yield strength down to 70% of room temperature. Since the factor of safety at room temp was about 3 to 1, then at 500 C it would still be 2 to 1 against failure. This isn't very hard to understand and you are blowing a lot of smoke now.

With all due respect, this discussion over WTC 7 is completely stupid. You don't give a GOD DAMN **** about any explanation of why WTC 7 fell. You want to say no one has completely explained to your satisfaction, the collapse of WTC 7 and that proves it fell due to CD.

GOOD GOD. How GOD DAMN dumb can you get!

This is more than stupid this is pure evil. The more you and others promote this horse crap, the more you allow the CIA and FBI HQ's agents who were responsible in shutting down the criminal investigations of Mihdhar and Hazmi to escape accountability.

Both agencies knew full well when they shut down FBI Agent Steve Bongardt's investigation of Mihdhar and Hazmi, that the result of their direct actions would be to allow a huge al Qaeda terrorist attack to take place inside of the US and allow the murder of thousands of Americans. I have presented the iron clad proof of this, proof that comes right out of official US government documents.

Your and others insistence that bombs took down WTC 7 is not only stupid, and completely moronic, but is responsible in allowing the people in the US government who had deliberately allowed these attacks to take place to completely escape accountability.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Ziggi
Pay attention, "dude" and dont change the subject again...I asked u
...so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy

..referring to this
Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg
I'm not going down a wormhole and wasting my time debunking numbers you pulled out of thin air 5 posts ago. ..

U are trying to change the subject again, like u do every single time u get caught bs-ing, which means your every post so far. The only one here that tried to pull some nbrs out of..some region...is u , and now u are refusing to admit it and trying to make it go away by ignoring it..like a child:

Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
...I told u that U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook...can u refute that? What did u think u were refuting? I told u nist went 50% over 20 to 30, about mid point between the 20 and 40. OK it 32 not 30 but that detail does not really change anything or refute anything i said ..so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy?

FYI: next time playing with things u do not understand gets u cornered, it would be much less embarrassing for u to just disappear; making up gibberish in an attempt to divert attention just hilites your bs-ing MO and raises questions about your state of mind
 
U are trying to change the subject again, like u do every single time u get caught bs-ing, which means your every post so far. The only one here that tried to pull some nbrs out of..some region...is u , and now u are refusing to admit it and trying to make it go away by ignoring it..like a child:



FYI: next time playing with things u do not understand gets u cornered, it would be much less embarrassing for u to just disappear; making up gibberish in an attempt to divert attention just hilites your bs-ing MO and raises questions about your state of mind

Yes, yes--pointing out that you have yet to offer any justification for Korol's clearly erroneous omission of pre-heating and use of an arbitrarily truncated timeline is "gibberish" to you. If you have an actual defense of Korol's clearly erroneous paper, you're welcome to post it. We're almost ten posts into this exchange now and you haven't come up with anything yet. You know why Tony doesn't defend it any more? It's because it's indefensible. He's wrong about a lot, but he's quicker on the uptake than you.
 
Last edited:
Why would anyone want to debate an individual who has already demonstrated intellectual dishonesty?

That would be an exercise in futility.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
U are trying to change the subject again, like u do every single time u get caught bs-ing, which means your every post so far. The only one here that tried to pull some nbrs out of..some region...is u , and now u are refusing to admit it and trying to make it go away by ignoring it..like a child....
....FYI: next time playing with things u do not understand gets u cornered, it would be much less embarrassing for u to just disappear; making up gibberish in an attempt to divert attention just hilites your bs-ing MO and raises questions about your state of mind
Yes, yes--pointing out that you have yet to offer any justification for Korol's clearly erroneous omission of pre-heating and use of an arbitrarily truncated timeline is "gibberish" to you. ....
.

Try to focus..if you really need this much help to grasp subject at hand and stay on topic just admit it and drop the pompous blowhard act. The comment this is about:

Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg/m3 (and NIST never claims this was some sort of high-end, worst case scenario load, by the way). It only says so right there on page 60 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9.

I answered here and called out your bs-ing:
I already told you NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline...add 50% to 20 and u get 30...That NIST chose to assume 32kg or extra 12kg over the std 20kg does not change that 20 is std and 40 is double that
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670394&postcount=1523
When u tried to change the subject I called out your bs again

told u that U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook...can u refute that? What did u think u were refuting? I told u nist went 50% over 20 to 30, about mid point between the 20 and 40. OK it 32 not 30 but that detail does not really change anything or refute anything i said ..so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy?http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670424&postcount=1527

U have continued to change the subject when asked about the point of that bs-ing ever since then..

Originally Posted by Ziggi
Pay attention, "dude" and dont change the subject again...I asked u

...so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy

..referring to this
Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg

This goes over your head? U gonna evade answering again?
 
Try to focus..if you really need this much help to grasp subject at hand and stay on topic just admit it and drop the pompous blowhard act. The comment this is about:



I answered here and called out your bs-ing:

When u tried to change the subject I called out your bs again



U have continued to change the subject when asked about the point of that bs-ing ever since then..



This goes over your head? U gonna evade answering again?

Interesting Ziggi doesn't understand the basics of fire.
The fuel load is the fuel on the floor on fire, NIST did not calculate in the fuel transported in the air stream.

That is what Ziggi does not understand.

Interesting very interesting.
 
I disagree that any such investigation is needed. If you ever wish to debate this critical question, you know where to find me.

What's fascinating is that there is absolutely nothing stopping him from conducting this investigation himself. well, the time he wastes here posting is a little.
 
What's fascinating is that there is absolutely nothing stopping him from conducting this investigation himself. well, the time he wastes here posting is a little.

It is a suckers game and Tony is looking for suckers to fleece, for his master Gage.

He has no interest in Investigation of the truth and never has, that is what is clear from his years of posting.
 
Like I said.
FEMbot. He has no idea what any of the stuff he does really means, or what its telling him.
But it is possibly a good model of that slice of the system at that particular time. Now he just needs to do it for the other 100's of thousands of beams, columns, trusses, and assorted structure, then put them all together...

Can we get a free body diagram of your head? It seems out of balance. Your reactions seem excessive.
 
Try to focus..if you really need this much help to grasp subject at hand and stay on topic just admit it and drop the pompous blowhard act. The comment this is about:



I answered here and called out your bs-ing:

When u tried to change the subject I called out your bs again



U have continued to change the subject when asked about the point of that bs-ing ever since then..



This goes over your head? U gonna evade answering again?

Last time I checked, the point was that you cannot defend Korol's clearly erroneous paper. The discussion about it has now gone on for over three weeks and no one has offered any theoretical or experimental bases for his flawed methodologies. Yes, I realize you want to go into a stupid tangent about fuel loading, and, yes, I almost gave you the benefit of the doubt and went down that path with you, but I quickly realized there is nothing about Korol's fuel load modeling that saves his paper from the errors I pointed out, and so I don't care. All you can do is whine that's all gibberish to you. I don't know whether that's true or whether you're lying to dodge the point. I'd believe either, actually.
 
Can we get a free body diagram of your head? It seems out of balance. Your reactions seem excessive.

Tony--do you realize how crazily hypocritical it is for you, the guy who for 8 years has called the NIST report "invalid" for omitting stiffener plates, etc., to claim you, with a model of a single girder at a single temperature, have proven that no more than one consecutive floor of WTC7 could have possibly collapsed? Can you think of anything your model omits? Is your model "invalid"? Does it at all register how ridiculously strained you are? Wouldn't it just be better to dispense with the cognitive dissonance, acknowledge you were wrong about Korol's paper, and acknowledge that you actually have no basis to attack the WAI paper as you do?

I actually respect that you at least try to approach these problems with your experience. But you need to own up to your limits. Remember how the whole Korol chain began in earnest with you commenting that you felt it your obligation to get people good information?
 
Tony--do you realize how crazily hypocritical it is for you, the guy who for 8 years has called the NIST report "invalid" for omitting stiffener plates, etc., to claim you, with a model of a single girder at a single temperature, have proven that no more than one consecutive floor of WTC7 could have possibly collapsed? Can you think of anything your model omits? Is your model "invalid"? Does it at all register how ridiculously strained you are? Wouldn't it just be better to dispense with the cognitive dissonance, acknowledge you were wrong about Korol's paper, and acknowledge that you actually have no basis to attack the WAI paper as you do?

I actually respect that you at least try to approach these problems with your experience. But you need to own up to your limits. Remember how the whole Korol chain began in earnest with you commenting that you felt it your obligation to get people good information?

You are just blowing smoke and rambling incoherently here, throwing anything you can think of at the wall in your attempt to rehabilitate Nordenson, and it is obvious you don't know what matters.

It is actually the girder seat that needs to be sheared to break through the next floor down. and it is welded to column 79's side plates. The columns never get hotter than 300 degrees C in NIST's thermal analysis. That is because they are transferring heat to cooler areas.

At 300 degrees C steel has lost virtually no yield strength, so the ambient temperature analysis is actually representative. The reality is the seat couldn't even be sheared at 600 degrees C as even then there would still be a factor of safety of 1.5.
 
Last edited:
Your and others insistence that bombs took down WTC 7 is not only stupid, and completely moronic, but is responsible in allowing the people in the US government who had deliberately allowed these attacks to take place to completely escape accountability.

Please, please, please take Tony up on his challenge, paloalto. This could be the most entertaining debate on the subject ever.

Dave
 
You are just blowing smoke and rambling incoherently here, throwing anything you can think of at the wall in your attempt to rehabilitate Nordenson, and it is obvious you don't know what matters.

It is actually the girder seat that needs to be sheared to break through the next floor down. and it is welded to column 79's side plates. The columns never get hotter than 300 degrees C in NIST's thermal analysis. That is because they are transferring heat to cooler areas.

At 300 degrees C steel has lost virtually no yield strength, so the ambient temperature analysis is actually representative. The reality is the seat couldn't even be sheared at 600 degrees C as even then there would still be a factor of safety of 1.5.

What was the energy of impact versus the energy to break the set?

Did you include the maxwell equation in your model?
 
You are just blowing smoke and rambling incoherently here, throwing anything you can think of at the wall in your attempt to rehabilitate Nordenson, and it is obvious you don't know what matters.

It is actually the girder seat that needs to be sheared to break through the next floor down. and it is welded to column 79's side plates. The columns never get hotter than 300 degrees C in NIST's thermal analysis. That is because they are transferring heat to cooler areas.

At 300 degrees C steel has lost virtually no yield strength, so the ambient temperature analysis is actually representative. The reality is the seat couldn't even be sheared at 600 degrees C as even then there would still be a factor of safety of 1.5.

Unless the structure, was prestressed by damage you mean, did you take damage induced prestressing into consideration of your model?

Oh and on how to draw a free body diagram, here is a good paper, that shows you wrong, if you don't understand why, than that shows your limited understanding of engineering.

MAXWELL'S RECIPROCAL THEOREM
ssu.ac.ir › fileadmin › MofidOther › Jozve
design the engineer must verify that these deflections are within the limits ... Example : For the cantilever beam in figure establish the equations for slope and ...

The Maxwell's Reciprocal Theorem shows why you are wrong Tony.


Can anyone figure out why Tony's Ideas are wrong, it has to do with an ancient Idea?

Here is a clue, https://www.math.nyu.edu/~crorres/Archimedes/Lever/LeverLaw.html
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom