does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

My favorite is how they presuppose all of these extremely complicated, multi-week black-ops missions to install explosives all while presuming the explosives were installed to destroy documents in the building (something that isn't even guaranteed by destroying the building).

If they had access to the building for all of these covert ops, why not just take and destroy the documents directly?

SO DUMB.


That would make far too much sense and would require knowledge on how to use a paper shredder, so they figured that it would be much easier to used B-767s, explosives, and thermite/nano-thermite to destroy documents.

Take a look how effective their method for destroying documents really is.


Photo 1

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/ter/terror1.jpg


Photo 2

http://www.drjudywood.com/articles/why/whypics/04_StreetDust_1479.jpg


Photo 3

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/ter/terror6.jpg


Photo 4

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/ter/terror7.jpg
 
Another possibility for how charges could have been placed in WTC 7 is with a cover story. It is well known that in the late 1990's mayor Rudy Giuliani insisted on putting his newly created Office of Emergency Management headquarters on the 23rd floor of WTC 7 and the contractor for the 13 million dollar project had access to the entire building for backup power and life systems.

The same can be said of the Twin Towers with the ACE elevator upgrade which was occurring in the eight months prior to Sept. 11, 2001.

Why not must remove some fireproofing, load the area with fuel, control the air flow, and hang chicken wire that will heat and cause catalytic, combustion of carbon black soot under the metal you need to fail?

Of how about just taking an Oxyacetylene torch and compromising the girder, seat, and stiffeners?

That way NIST can claim it felled by fire?

Over complicated thermite ************ is not need even in A CC (Conspired Collapse)!
 
Wonder when AE911T (Tony) will run a CD simulation that will duplicate what was observed regarding the collapse of WTC7? Of course the CD sim would have to account for the active fire, lack of noise from charges going off. etc.

After all these years and not one concise CD explanation that explains in detail how it was done.
 
My favorite is how they presuppose all of these extremely complicated, multi-weekETA: or years) black-ops missions to install explosives all while presuming the explosives were installed to destroy documents in the building (something that isn't even guaranteed by destroying the building).

If they had access to the building for all of these covert ops, why not just take and destroy the documents directly?

SO DUMB.

Hell, if they had access to the buildings to install explosives then why not simply make this a repeat, triple down, of the first WTC bombing?
terrorists installed explosives in three of the seven WTC structures?
No need to cover up due to hijacked aircraft.

So often are the machinations the truthers dream up (and that is where these things originate) really, truly are DUMB.
 
It's just the usual woo baloney. If one can in any way undermine other explanations, then one's pet fantasy becomes true by default.

Creationists do it, homeopathy nuts do it, and so on.

The real point is that even if NIST, ARUP, WAI, et al were falsified and even if TS "won" some debate on any obscure website it would not "prove" CD in any way. It doesn't matter if they are all wrong. CD is no closer to being demonstrated.
 
The fall of the east penthouse is not indicative of where columns 77 and 79 failed vertically, only that they did so. It is very likely that they only failed high in the building and that the east penthouse only fell a couple of stories into the building. I would hope you are aware that

1. The shock wave goes top to bottom from the roof down.
2. The windows are only broken 15 stories down from the roof.
3. There is no dust emanating from the east side until the exterior comes down.
4. There is no deformation of exterior columns which would occur in a full depth east side interior collapse.
5. Daylight is only visible in the top most story after the penthouse collapses. The building was 144 feet wide and if a full interior collapse had occurred light would have been visible well below that.
Are you after a prize for the most inane claims regarding WTC7?

Whether you are or you aren't, the prize goes to #5. Look at the inner side of an opaque vase for a quick refutation.
 
Are you after a prize for the most inane claims regarding WTC7?

Whether you are or you aren't, the prize goes to #5. Look at the inner side of an opaque vase for a quick refutation.

#4 is patently in error as the 'kink' forms, full depth of the structure (as far as can be seen) and at THAT time the entire structure bows/tilts towards that kink, which just happens to be aligned with column 79.:eek:
 
I will once again, invite you to address the list that I have posted for you here.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11665527&postcount=1294


If you continue to evade addressing my list, it will further highlight your CD claim as baseless, which explains your failure to address my list. You have been placed high on a pedestal and I'm am waiting for you to respond.

.
Actually, what the last few pages demonstrate is that while possibly (albeit an unproven assertion) Tony may be a competent FEMbot, he and his ilk are certainly not Engineers.
Anyone who cannot extrapolate from known data and known behavior of materials is a programmer, at best.
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi
Everytime u post something I catch u lying and evading, and your response every time is changing the subject again and lying more...and now it is time to stop allowing u changing the subject again...and backtrack instead
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg/m3 (and NIST never claims this was some sort of high-end, worst case scenario load, by the way). It only says so right there on page 60 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9.
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
...I told u that U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook...can u refute that? What did u think u were refuting? I told u nist went 50% over 20 to 30, about mid point between the 20 and 40. OK it 32 not 30 but that detail does not really change anything or refute anything i said ..so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy?
You are claiming Korol's erroneous choices ......


Pay attention, "dude" and dont change the subject again...I asked u
...so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy


..referring to this

Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg
 
Tony, Tony, Tony. Guess who had access to all of the WTC7 building modification records? It was the plaintiffs in the Aegis Insurance case, a collection of US and foreign insurers and reinsurers who were taking billions in loses due to the collapse of the building. As you know, they hired some of the worlds foremost tall building and fire science experts to examine those building records, and those experts even retained the world's foremost forensic engineering firm (ARUP) to assist them. Did these people, with every motivation to do so and the expertise to do so, unearth evidence of your fantasy scenario of explosives being installed during renovations for the emergency management headquarters?
No, and they concluded that the building modifications played no role in the fire induced collapse.

It sounds like in your world people who provide a legal cover to do something illegal would document the illegal portion of the job.

Just outstanding logic on your part. Who would have thought?
 
Last edited:
It sounds like in your world people who provide a legal cover to do something illegal would document the illegal portion of the job.

Just outstanding logic on your part. Who would have thought?
Tony:

Would you be interested in a debate where you defend your top down demolition theory? It is after all an affirmative claim on your part.
 
Last edited:
Pay attention, "dude" and dont change the subject again...I asked u



..referring to this

I'm not going down a wormhole and wasting my time debunking numbers you pulled out of thin air 5 posts ago. If you think that Korol's use of different fire loads saves him from the clear errors he made in omitting all preheating and arbitrarily shortening the direct heating phase, then go ahead and explain it. If not, Korol's method still remains demonstrably flawed, which is why the beam in his worst case scenario (45kg/m3) wasn't heated as much as the protected beam in the Cardington compartmental fire test with an even lower file load (40kg/m3). Which do you think is right--the actual measured temperature reached in the real world, or the temperature reached in the paper that arbitrarily shortened the heating time frame? (And again, in the context of wtc7, that direct heating error is exclusive of the fact that Korol also does not account for pre-heating.)
 
Last edited:
It sounds like in your world people who provide a legal cover to do something illegal would document the illegal portion of the job.

Just outstanding logic on your part. Who would have thought?

Better to just make up wild theories of people destroying buildings to destroy documents despite having zero evidence of it happening and rely on fundamentally flawed papers to fill in the gaps, I guess?
 
Last edited:
It sounds like in your world people who provide a legal cover to do something illegal would document the illegal portion of the job.

Just outstanding logic on your part. Who would have thought?

It sounds like in your world every un-evidenced claim must be taken remotely seriously.

Where is the CD evidence? Where is the vast cover up exposed? Nowhere? OK then.

Oh, I forgot. TS has me on ignore.
 
It sounds like in your world people who provide a legal cover to do something illegal would document the illegal portion of the job.


Please clarify what you meant when you said; "provide a legal cover to do something illegal would document the illegal portion of the job."

Since you have claimed the WTC buildings were demolished with explosives, who are those people and for what reason would they have for demolishing the WTC buildings with explosives that defy the laws of physics when detonated?

Did the US immediately go to war after terrorist bombed WTC 1 in 1993, even though one of the terrorists arrived in the US with an Iraqi passport stolen by Iraqi intelligence, who then fled to Pakistan via Iraq? Explain why the US did not immediately go to war with Iraq after the 1993 WTC 1 bombing.

Did the US invade Libya after Libya bombed Pan Am 103 out of the sky?
 
It sounds like in your world every un-evidenced claim must be taken remotely seriously.

Where is the CD evidence? Where is the vast cover up exposed? Nowhere? OK then.

Oh, I forgot. TS has me on ignore.

He has reality and valid evidence on ignore too.
 
...we simply don't presently have a plausible theory on how the WTC 7 building collapsed to the ground.

Thanks for finally admitting that you, AE911Truth and the entire Truth Movement have no plausible theory on how the WTC 7 building collapsed to the ground.

#oysteinbookmark
 
He has reality and valid evidence on ignore too.

The reason I don't put you on ignore is it is hard to believe you actually take yourself seriously. Your rants could be taken as sarcasm, and I think deep down you are probably a nice guy as that seeps through the rant on occassion.
 
Thanks for finally admitting that you, AE911Truth and the entire Truth Movement have no plausible theory on how the WTC 7 building collapsed to the ground.

#oysteinbookmark

You surely realize by we I meant everyone, including you and all the others here.

We need an investigation that provides one and explains the observations.
 
Last edited:
CD is a joke, spreading lies about NIST, CD remains a lie

The reason I don't put you on ignore is it is hard to believe you actually take yourself seriously. Your rants could be taken as sarcasm, and I think deep down you are probably a nice guy as that seeps through the rant on occassion.

You lie about 9/11, have no clue Oswald killed JFK, and most likely think McVeigh did not do OKC. Your peers in 9/11 CD BS are the Boston bombers; you have no clue why the missing jolt paper is BS, no idea what the difference is between models and real world is.

You lie about 9/11, pushing the fantasy of CD; you can't say how, who, or why. Never will (there is no evidence, but you don't know it? wow)

Look up at the top of the screen;, we are in the 9/11 CT subforum, and you can't post your failed claims in the reality sections of any forum.

At least you got on CNN to spread the lies. Got some evidence for CD? No,
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom