does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Are you saying the secret repair of the Citicorp building in 1978 didn't occur?

You're very bad at reading comprehension if you think I'm saying that. Perhaps your comprehension of the various reports on WTC7 is as bad as your comprehension of my much simpler and more understandable one-line posts.

Dave
 
Your claim that there are no real world examples of something done covertly to a large building over time is refuted by the secret repair of the Citicorp building in 1978. The repair was done at night over a three month period without public knowledge and would never have even been publicly known without those who managed it choosing to make it known in the late 1990's.

Planting charges on core columns, via the elevator shafts, which allow access to them, is not observable.

Ignorance is bliss isn't it Tony, the workers in the building knew about the repairs, to the Citicorp building it was the Rumors that leaked to the public that caused the owners to come forward and admit the repairs!

Charges would not survive the fires Tony especially both thermate, which is unstable when heated. Cole as I needed an oxygen Jet to get his cutters to work Tony, the barium nitrate would produce a gas causing any container to rupture when the container reached over 350C.

Cole had to use a thermally dirived oxydant in his experiments and like Monrue effect cutter charges it has to be placed in dirrect contact with the steel. So no a CD in a fire will not work as you propose it was done, nothing you say can change that!

A CD of the buildings could have been accomplished but not by any theories You Jones, Cole, or any Cter propose!
You are totally clueless on how to do it!
 
You're very bad at reading comprehension if you think I'm saying that. Perhaps your comprehension of the various reports on WTC7 is as bad as your comprehension of my much simpler and more understandable one-line posts.

Dave

Dave, it is not hard to imagine that WTC 7 could have been covertly rigged for demolition at night without public awareness. If you were part of an investigation team your comments attempting to belittle that suggestion would raise eyebrows and cast some level of suspicion on you.
 
Last edited:
Dave, it is not hard to imagine that WTC 7 could have been covertly rigged for demolition at night without public awareness. If you were part of an investigation team your comments attempting to belittle that suggestion would raise eyebrows and cast some level of suspicion on you.

And it's back to the veiled accusations as usual. Wouldn't your time be better spent looking for that floor plan that shows how columns 77-79 were accessed from the elevator shafts?

Dave
 
Dave, it is not hard to imagine that WTC 7 could have been covertly rigged for demolition at night without public awareness. If you were part of an investigation team your comments attempting to belittle that suggestion would raise eyebrows and cast some level of suspicion on you.

Oh I am so glad you put me on ignore when the new data is out we will be laughing at you and you will not even know why.

Poetic Justice!:D
 
And it's back to the veiled accusations as usual. Wouldn't your time be better spent looking for that floor plan that shows how columns 77-79 were accessed from the elevator shafts?

Dave

The fall of the east penthouse is not indicative of where columns 77 and 79 failed vertically, only that they did so. It is very likely that they only failed high in the building and that the east penthouse only fell a couple of stories into the building. I would hope you are aware that

1. The shock wave goes top to bottom from the roof down.
2. The windows are only broken 15 stories down from the roof.
3. There is no dust emanating from the east side until the exterior comes down.
4. There is no deformation of exterior columns which would occur in a full depth east side interior collapse.
5. Daylight is only visible in the top most story after the penthouse collapses. The building was 144 feet wide and if a full interior collapse had occurred light would have been visible well below that.
 
Another possibility for how charges could have been placed in WTC 7 is with a cover story. It is well known that in the late 1990's mayor Rudy Giuliani insisted on putting his newly created Office of Emergency Management headquarters on the 23rd floor of WTC 7 and the contractor for the 13 million dollar project had access to the entire building for backup power and life systems.

The same can be said of the Twin Towers with the ACE elevator upgrade which was occurring in the eight months prior to Sept. 11, 2001.
 
Last edited:
The fall of the east penthouse is not indicative of where columns 77 and 79 failed vertically, only that they did so. It is very likely that they only failed high in the building and that the east penthouse only fell a couple of stories into the building. I would hope you are aware that

1. The shock wave goes top to bottom from the roof down.
2. The windows are only broken 15 stories down from the roof.
3. There is no dust emanating from the east side until the exterior comes down.
4. There is no deformation of exterior columns which would occur in a full depth east side interior collapse.
5. Daylight is only visible in the top most story after the penthouse collapses. The building was 144 feet wide and if a full interior collapse had occurred light would have been visible well below that.

Unless the dust trapped by air pressure in the facade, blocks the light, wouldn't expect that much dust to go into that side of the building as the air currents already produce a high pressure area on the camera facing side.

Dust travels from high pressure to low pressure not the reverse, so this only proves you are inept at determining air flow in buildings or fires!

Someone please Quote this so Tony can see it please.
 
Unless they dust trapped by air pressure in the facade, blocks the light, wouldn't expect that much dust to go into that side of the building as the air currents already produce a high pressure area on the camera facing side.

Dust travels from high pressure to low pressure not the reverse, so this only proves you are inept at determining air flow in buildings or fires!

Someone please Quote this so Tony can see it please.

It is painful to read 95% of what you say, as the likelihood is so low that it is essentially insignificant and much of it is simply incoherent.
 
The fall of the east penthouse is not indicative of where columns 77 and 79 failed vertically, only that they did so.

You're very good at changing the subject. You claim the failures were caused by explosives planted via the elevator shafts; it's clear that columns 77-79 were the first to fail, so their failures can't have been caused by cascade failure initiated by explosives elsewhere. How were columns 77-79 accessed from the elevator shafts?

Dave
 
It is painful to read 95% of what you say, as the likelihood is so low that it is essentially insignificant and much of it is simply incoherent.

You do know that I know of three scientific studies of 9/11/2001 going on now, that may be published this year where I have been asked to comment?

Thanks to the European Physics Journal Article, You have achieved enough attention to once and for all prove Jones and Harrit were not just incompetent, they were actually lying and misrepresenting fact.
You also know that Tony, and have known that for years.

PS, it is hard to write when I am laughing so hard my sides hurt!
 
Last edited:
The last few pages here highlight the reality that there are no legitimate engineering analyses that can show WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The three reports we have that make that claim require impossible situations and actually refute one another.
You clearly have been paying selective attention, or you would have realized that the three reports are not exclusive and do not refute one another.

They are three different hypotheses on the cause of the collapse. The specific initiation event is always a cause of speculation, and even if one of the reports went too far in the assumptions as to make them unrealistic, it still goes on to show how that could have lead to disproportionate collapse.


The ARUP analysis shows the NIST alleged walk-off of girder A2001 to the west was impossible, the Weidlinger report shows both NIST's and ARUP's alleged floor cascades were impossible and I had independently verified this before even seeing the Weidlinger report. Finally, the Weidlinger report needs to claim extreme steel temperatures not contained in either of the two earlier reports and which are not substantiated publicly.
I know you have said that, but you never supported your claim with anything but incredulity. The Korol paper that you cited in support has been shredded to pieces, and you have not been able to defend it; in fact, the Cardington study supports these high temperatures even without pre-heating, something you have ignored all this time because it stands in your way for pushing your politically-biased view.


It is clear from the last several pages here that those who still insist on believing that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire cannot provide a plausible hypothesis for their claim and are reduced to babbling things like "there were fires in the building and we know it distorts steel".
Babbling? That's reality. Were there explosives in the building? If you can't support their presence with evidence, your burden of proof won't be met until you show that each and every possible way that fires could have brought down the buildings is impossible. And here's where you go wrong: the three existing reports mention only three of the myriads of possible ways that fire could have caused the collapse, and you need to refute all these myriads in order to claim it's impossible. Obviously you can't, there are too many. Refuting only the three existing reports won't get you any closer to proving that impossibility than removing three drops would get you in draining a swamp. The next best for you is to offer positive proof of the presence of explosives, something that you haven't even begun to try.

But there's actually a much deeper issue here: your lack of scientific integrity. You don't make even a minimal effort to analyse and refute the scenarios that don't support your views:

Details that could throw doubt on your interpretation must be given, if you know them. You must do the best you can—if you know anything at all wrong, or possibly wrong—to explain it. If you make a theory, for example, and advertise it, or put it out, then you must also put down all the facts that disagree with it, as well as those that agree with it.
​
And it's immediately evident to any person who reads your work with scientific eyes, that you don't make that effort. That makes it cargo cult science, as Richard Feynman, who wrote the above quote, calls it. Your lack of scientific integrity ensures that your work will never be taken seriously, and that's a hole you've dug for yourself.


It is also clear why none of these individuals will debate the issue in a one-on-one situation. They simply can't and know they will suffer the same ignominious fate as tfk.
That's rich, given that I offered you a one-on-one discussion and you rejected it.
 
Last edited:
I'm a little more cautious about that. We can at least say that any alien spaceships involved needed cloaking technology. And any explosives they used needed some equivalent technology to stop them going "bang".

No blood wine was found it is well known even Cloaked Klingons toast victory, success with blood wine.
 
In the real world, working a problem using 3 different methods and assumptions and getting the same result [bold]every time[\bold] is indicative that the occlusion drawn from those results is indeed valid.
 
You clearly have been paying selective attention, or you would have realized that the three reports are not exclusive and do not refute one another.

They are three different hypotheses on the cause of the collapse. The specific initiation event is always a cause of speculation, and even if one of the reports went too far in the assumptions as to make them unrealistic, it still goes on to show how that could have lead to disproportionate collapse.



I know you have said that, but you never supported your claim with anything but incredulity. The Korol paper that you cited in support has been shredded to pieces, and you have not been able to defend it; in fact, the Cardington study supports these high temperatures even without pre-heating, something you have ignored all this time because it stands in your way for pushing your politically-biased view.



Babbling? That's reality. Were there explosives in the building? If you can't support their presence with evidence, your burden of proof won't be met until you show that each and every possible way that fires could have brought down the buildings is impossible. And here's where you go wrong: the three existing reports mention only three of the myriads of possible ways that fire could have caused the collapse, and you need to refute all these myriads in order to claim it's impossible. Obviously you can't, there are too many. Refuting only the three existing reports won't get you any closer to proving that impossibility than removing three drops would get you in draining a swamp. The next best for you is to offer positive proof of the presence of explosives, something that you haven't even begun to try.

But there's actually a much deeper issue here: your lack of scientific integrity. You don't make even a minimal effort to analyse and refute the scenarios that don't support your views:

Details that could throw doubt on your interpretation must be given, if you know them. You must do the best you can—if you know anything at all wrong, or possibly wrong—to explain it. If you make a theory, for example, and advertise it, or put it out, then you must also put down all the facts that disagree with it, as well as those that agree with it.
​
And it's immediately evident to any person who reads your work with scientific eyes, that you don't make that effort. That makes it cargo cult science, as Richard Feynman, who wrote the above quote, calls it. Your lack of scientific integrity ensures that your work will never be taken seriously, and that's a hole you've dug for yourself.



That's rich, given that I offered you a one-on-one discussion and you rejected it.

Tony is confusing Insulation with Vacuum, in his analogy of how heat transfers though steel,
The insulation only slows conduction it does not prevent it, when a total vacuum is achieved only radiative heating though the vacuum can occur.

A vacuum bottle conposed of high temp ceramic of sufficient size with thermally reflective radiation shielded insulation could be used in CD, could be used but only one way, and Tony doesn't even understand how!

No evidence of such a device was ever found, no evidence of such a device being used has ever been found.

Tony's constant claims that insulation could have been used to shield charges is not only false it is insulting to anyone who understands the use of thermite or explosives!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom