Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Beachnut, this is a little painful to watch. It is like watching a fish out of water, flopping around on the ground.
 
Beachnut, this is a little painful to watch. It is like watching a fish out of water, flopping around on the ground.
You make a claim based on nothing but your inside job belief. No wonder 911 truth has failed, going on 10 years.

You fail to comprehend a gravity collapse caused by terrorists impacting planes, and can't tie your theory to the failed work here.

Prove WTC 7 was not a gravity collapse. There will be no help from this work in this thread. Prove your acceleration claim is true, you made it. Prove this is not the normal acceleration for a chaotic gravity collapse like the WTC 7 was. Good luck.

You make the claim, the reality based engineering world knows WTC 7 was a gravity collapse, you prove your point. Will you use engineering, or your TLAR method using video?

femr2 can't help you, he can't figure out WTC 7 was a gravity collapse, and the accelerations are normal for WTC 7 collapse. It is ironic, but then you guys are the best 911 truth has, you say stuff, and then can't back it up with math or logic. What will you do now, attack Bazant, or punt?
 
you will now ask me to show a normal gravity collapse
Of course...show me acceleration data for a building collapse which proves the acceleration profile for WTC 7 is normal aka common.

and it is already done.
Great. Where ? Link please.

Once you have provided the link I must request you get back on topic.
 
Of course...show me acceleration data for a building collapse which proves the acceleration profile for WTC 7 is normal aka common.


Great. Where ? Link please.

Once you have provided the link I must request you get back on topic.
WTC 7, a gravity collapse, and the accelerations are normal. Too bad you can't prove otherwise, your inside job has failed, Major Tom's claim has failed. But try to prove Major Tom right. You have had problems with math before, and this is the same kind of logical error. You want to support Major Tom's nonsensical claim, but you instead you have to ask for proof. WTC 7 collapse is proof. If you don't understand, I may be due to the fact you are not an engineer, but non-engineers understand WTC 7 is a gravity collapse.

I think your inside job beliefs are keeping you from exercising the knowledge and skills you have to comprehend WTC 7 is a gravity collapse. If you have something to prove WTC 7 was not a gravity collapse you would present it; you have failed to do that.
 
Last edited:
... But if you think you know squat when you casually brush off the extreme acceleration changes as "normal", you are living in a dream. ...
Prove the accelerations are not normal for the gravity collapse of WTC 7. Prove it. Simple, you make the statement, prove it.
 
Beachnut, this is a little painful to watch. It is like watching a fish out of water, flopping around on the ground.
Indeed it is.

Major_Tom and femr2 are flopping around because they ignored the faster-than-1g acceleration seen in the fire-induced gravity collapse posted by pgimeno in post #1574.

At about 8 seconds into that video, you can see loose material near the top of the collapsing wall falling slower than the top portion of the wall immediately underneath it. That's because the loose material is accelerating downward at 1g while the top portion of the wall immediately underneath accelerates downward at a little more than 1g.

The collapse shown in pgimeno's video is a real-life example of the well-known phenomenon illustrated by videos of lab experiments in beachnut's post #1606.

As Myriad explained nearly two years ago, but I figured out only last year, there's nothing at all odd about accelerations of a little over 1g for portions of a structure whose center of gravity is falling at close to 1g.
 
Major_Tom and femr2 are flopping around because they ignored the faster-than-1g acceleration seen in the fire-induced gravity collapse posted by pgimeno in post #1574.
You compare a brick wall falling over to the near vertical descent of WTC 7 ? That's it ? Hilarious. No doubt there was a ruler in that building :D

So, W.D.Clinger, is that event your cited evidence that over-g acceleration profile for the North facade of WTC7 is normal ? Is that it ? That's all ?

Note my responses by the way...
Please point me to position/time data for a number of collapsing buildings.
You claimed it was normal. I've not said either normal or not. Point me to data showing that it is normal...aka common...
Awesome, so post me an example or two with their corresponding acceleration profiles.
Awesome. I note that you have not actually provided me with any data from building collapse events to support your assertion
Of course...show me acceleration data for a building collapse which proves the acceleration profile for WTC 7 is normal aka common.
Great. Where ? Link please.
Awesome. What building collapse are you comparing to ?

Flapping around ? Moi ? Nah :)

You forgot the number of times I've specifically suggested the reason for the over-g period ?

What is being questioned is the silly assertion that such behaviour is normal. Normal ? :eye-poppi Yikes !
 
If it would make you happier, I'll admit that the logical conclusion to be drawn from those premises is that the collapse of WTC 7 was not a demolition unless you're crazy enough to expand the meaning of the word "demolition" to include events that do not resemble any known or measured demolition.

If you are saying that you and/or Major_Tom are crazy enough to adopt the italicized redefinition above and to assume that everybody else is so stupid that they'll accept your redefinition, then you might have a point.

I didn't assume anyone was "so stupid". Actually I am a bit surprised at how stupidly the posters have taken it.

You are imploding as a group at at a drop rate close to g, but the implosion was self-induced.

I offered pretty simple comments, but the posters have seemed to twist them into a logical pretzel, choked on their own pretzel and imploded before my eyes.


I didn't desire that nor do I find it very pleasant to look at.
 
Last edited:
You claimed it was normal. I've not said either normal or not. Point me to data showing that it is normal...aka common...
I see a semantic problem here.

In Spain we have an authoritative source for semantics, the Real Academia Española de la Lengua. Their semantic dictionary is online. Here's the link to the meaning of the word:

http://buscon.rae.es/draeI/SrvltGUIBusUsual?LEMA=normal

From the discussion, it follows that the only meanings that apply are 1 to 3. Let me translate them for you.

1. adj. (Told about a thing.) Something that is in its natural state.
2. adj. Something that serves as a norm or rule.
3. adj. (Told about a thing.) Something that, because of its nature, form or magnitude, fits certain rules already established.

It's quite obvious to me that meaning 3 is applicable to Beachnut's assertions of normality. It follows the rules of the physics of a collapse, therefore it's normal [=not unexpected, ≠common].
 
Last edited:
I didn't assume anyone was "so stupid". Actually I am a bit surprised at how stupidly the posters have taken it.

You are imploding as a group at at a drop rate close to g, but the implosion was self-induced.

I offered pretty simple comments, but the posters have seemed to twist them into a logical pretzel, choked on their own pretzel and imploded before my eyes.

I didn't desire that nor do I find it very pleasant to look at.
Since femr2 has already admitted that the evidence doesn't exist, it cannot be used to support any point derived from it.
 
I see a semantic problem here.
You're making a point of semantics ? The barrel running that dry already. Lordy...

From the discussion, it follows that the only meanings that apply are 1 to 3.
I prefer this one...

  • In behavior, normal refers to a lack of significant deviation from the average.

(If I could make it flash, I would ;) )

Average. Excellent word that in this context, which is why I keep asking for examples...the response ? Semantics. Rulers. A brick wall. :rolleyes:

3. adj. (Told about a thing.) Something that, because of its nature, form or magnitude, fits certain rules already established.
Awesome. Where might I find these rules in a context applicable to a building ? Any example of a building collapsing with near-at-over g acceleration profile of a significant portion of the whole will do just fine and dandy. (Yes, one wall and no roof does not a building make. Excuse the Tolkien reference. ;) )

It's quite obvious to me that meaning 3 is applicable to Beachnut's assertions of normality.
Wow.

It's quite obvious to me that my italicised, bolded, coloured and hi-lighted meaning above is much MORE applicable.

It follows the rules of the physics of a collapse, therefore it's normal [=not unexpected, ≠common].
Awesome. Please point me to the documented examples of building collapse physics which reiterate your point...of course, that means buildings other than those with a WTC name prefix.
 
I see a semantic problem here.

In Spain we have an authoritFrom the discussion, it follows that the only meanings that apply are 1 to 3. Let me translate them for you.

1. adj. (Told about a thing.) Something that is in its natural state.
2. adj. Something that serves as a norm or rule.
3. adj. (Told about a thing.) Something that, because of its nature, form or magnitude, fits certain rules already established.

It's quite obvious to me that meaning 3 is applicable to Beachnut's assertions of normality. It follows the rules of the physics of a collapse, therefore it's normal [=not unexpected, ≠common].


Yep. That's why in my explanation from nearly two years ago, I used the following wording: "...while it [the acceleration profile of the facade collapse] might be an unusual phenomenon, is not unexpected or unexplainable given the known circumstances..." (Emphasis added.) It's almost as if I predicted that to just call it "normal," even though technically correct, would be to invite a festival of equivocation.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
while it [the acceleration profile of the facade collapse] might be an unusual phenomenon, is not unexpected or unexplainable given the known circumstances..."
Could you point me to where I have said such is unexplainable ? Unexpected ? Even unusual ?

I can point you to numerous instances of me suggesting what the cause is...

I'm simply asking for examples from beachnut given his repeated claims that it is normal...

It is normal
Good luck proving it is not normal
It is normal
accelerations measured are normal
it is normal
...from ONE singular, isolated post :jaw-dropp

call it "normal," even though technically correct
Great. Normal will mean plenty prior examples.

So, again, please direct me to acceleration data for building collpases which exhibit similar behaviour to WTC7.
 
Last edited:
Could you point me to where I have said such is unexplainable ? Unexpected ? Even unusual ?

I can point you to numerous instances of me suggesting what the cause is...

I'm simply asking for examples from beachnut given his repeated claims that it is normal...

...from ONE singular, isolated post :jaw-dropp


Great. Normal will mean plenty prior examples.

So, again, please direct me to acceleration data for building collpases which exhibit similar behaviour to WTC7.


Oh good, I was a bit worried that readers wouldn't understand what I meant by a "festival of equivocation" but you've demonstrated exactly what I was talking about. Thanks.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Any example of a building collapsing with near-at-over g acceleration profile of a significant portion of the whole will do just fine and dandy. (Yes, one wall and no roof does not a building make. Excuse the Tolkien reference. ;) )
All right ... all right ... but apart from better sanitation and medicine and education and irrigation and public health and roads and a freshwater system and baths and public order ... what have the Romans done for us?

Excuse the Monty Python reference :p
 
Last edited:
Here's a response to the fellow who's started to accuse others of making semantic arguments...

You forgot the number of times I've specifically suggested the reason for the over-g period ?
It's more likely that you've forgotten the number of times I quoted or linked to Myriad's response to your suggestion.

What is being questioned is the silly assertion that such behaviour is normal. Normal ? :eye-poppi Yikes !
Oh, I doubt very much whether 1g lies within the normal range of accelerations anticipated by the architects of WTC 7. If some reliable source were to inform me that the north wall of WTC 7 had experienced few sustained accelerations of that magnitude before 11 September 2011, it wouldn't surprise me at all.

That may be why, instead of using the word "normal", I wrote:
As Myriad explained nearly two years ago, but I figured out only last year, there's nothing at all odd about accelerations of a little over 1g for portions of a structure whose center of gravity is falling at close to 1g.


But if you honestly believe that beachnut was using the word "normal" to say near-1g acceleration was an everyday phenomenon at WTC 7, then you should most certainly carry on as you have been doing.

After all, you and Major_Tom can't possibly proceed to Major_Tom's third stage (honest debate) until all such illusions have been eradicated from JREF.
 
But if you honestly believe that beachnut was using the word "normal" to say near-1g acceleration was an everyday phenomenon at WTC 7, then you should most certainly carry on as you have been doing.
Splendid. By his subsequent action he shall be judged :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom