Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

I don't see how your graph proves that.
So it seems. Have you actually watched any of the descent videos ? The extreme southward motion of your stick figure simply does not occur.

The animated GIF I provided shows the southward motion from very early on. Not quite back to T0, but not far off, as can be confirmed by the displacement graph shape.

I'd be more interested in the SW one.
Which I'll no doubt produce, though it will be very short from that viewpoint, and almost totally vertical of course.

A better metric to determine would be angular change of the West roofline over time.

No, I don't see that. Your graph kind of proves that for the latter movement, not for the earlier one which is the focus of my interpretation.
Watch the videos is my best advice. Your stick diagram is not useful. If you are exaggerating motion, then show me the actual motion you are referring to. Again, we are NOT talking about CoG.

The well-behaved movement is expectable after the façade arrested the horizontal component.
The horizontal component is accelerating.

Near zero, there's an anomaly that supports my view.
Show me. I disagree. The wobbles in the graph are primarily stabilisation error, as I have already told you.
 
these accelerations are outside the range of known demolitions
AND
(measured) demolitions do not come close to g accelerations
do NOT IMPLY
the collapse of WTC7 was not a demolition
If it would make you happier, I'll admit that the logical conclusion to be drawn from those premises is that the collapse of WTC 7 was not a demolition unless you're crazy enough to expand the meaning of the word "demolition" to include events that do not resemble any known or measured demolition.

If you are saying that you and/or Major_Tom are crazy enough to adopt the italicized redefinition above and to assume that everybody else is so stupid that they'll accept your redefinition, then you might have a point.
 
Excuse the post editing...
I'll admit that the logical conclusion to be drawn from those premises is that
...
you might have a point.
Modus tollens is not subject to your emotive crazy and stupid terms. They are premises of your subjective belief, not the logical consequence of the statements.

I imagine you will suggest that emphasising the point infers a personal belief stance. You'd be wrong about that too.
 
You are making an indirect note of W.D.Clinger's logic error ? (with omission of measured in the second operator)

Why ? T'was a misapplication of modus tollensWP, though that was bolted on by Oystein if I recall.
He claimed that the collapse was outside the known range for a CD. It's like saying a burger was from McDonald's and simultaneously admitting it's outside the known range of their menu.

"This burger is a Whopper, which McDonald's does not, and never has, offered. I think it's from McDonald's."

Unless, of course, knowledge of some sort of unknown range is being implied, which would be a contradiction in terms.

It's fun to watch you shuck and jive to avoid admitting the point, such as attacking the fact that people believe something instead of the belief itself. MT made a self-contradictory statement. Either the statement was wrong, or his entire claim is.

Such leafing is not going to be on-topic at any point. I suggest simply making a browser bookmark instead.
Considering that I use almost a half-dozen different computers regularly, and two browsers, it'd be rather impractical. Please stop being condescending.

Excuse the post editing...
No.
 
Last edited:
Modus tollens is not subject to your emotive crazy and stupid terms. They are premises of your subjective belief, not the logical consequence of the statements.
And so, omitting the emotive terms, your point is that
the logical conclusion to be drawn from those premises is that the collapse of WTC 7 was not a demolition unless you expand the meaning of the word "demolition" to include events that do not resemble any known or measured demolition and assume that everybody else accepts your redefinition.​

To summarize:
In the post quoted above, femr2 objected to my emotive words but indicated that he otherwise agreed with my suggestion that he "might have a point." Indeed, he emphasized his agreement by editing my phrase to strike out the word "might". femr2's point, therefore, is that
femr2 and Major_Tom are redefining the word "demolition" to include events that resemble no known or measured demolition, and they expect the rest of us to accept their redefinition.​
 
He claimed that the collapse [maximum acceleration] was outside the known range for a CD.
He did indeed, which does not mean that in future a demolition will not extend that range, nor does it mean that prior demolitions have not, simply that there is no data, thus W.D.Clinger's comical application of modus tollens being highlighted.

Considering that I use almost a half-dozen different computers regularly, and two browsers, it'd be rather impractical.
Your personal terminal usage is of no relevance to your posting of off-topic bookmark spam.

Please stop being condescending.
The is nothing about the statement *Such leafing is not going to be on-topic at any point. I suggest simply making a browser bookmark instead* that is condescending.
 
<time consuming grasping at straws to attempt to change the rules of logic snipped>
See prior response to 000063...

...does not mean that in future a demolition will not extend that range, nor does it mean that prior demolitions have not, simply that there is no data, thus W.D.Clinger's comical application of modus tollens being highlighted.

Have a nice day.
 
...does not mean that in future a demolition will not extend that range, nor does it mean that prior demolitions have not, simply that there is no data, thus W.D.Clinger's comical application of modus tollens being highlighted.

Have a nice day.
:p

Major_Tom seemed to think there was plenty of data. Following the links in my previous post, everyone can verify that Major_Tom was aghast that we weren't drawing the conclusions he wanted us to draw from that alleged data.

Now femr2 comes along and tells us that Major_Tom was really drawing our attention to the fact "that there is no data" on accelerations in prior demolitions.

Which means it would have been illogical for us to draw whatever conclusions Major_Tom was berating us for not drawing.

Perhaps femr2 is just congratulating me on the wisdom of my original observation that, far from being based upon a wealth of data, Major_Tom's statements about prior demolitions were "bare assertions by a source that's known to be unreliable."
 
He did indeed, which does not mean that in future a demolition will not extend that range, nor does it mean that prior demolitions have not, simply that there is no data, thus W.D.Clinger's comical application of modus tollens being highlighted.
Is there such a fallacy as appeal to hypothetical?

If someone says they got a Whopper from McDonald's, I will not accept it unless I see an ad saying that McD's now serves Whoppers, or I walk into my local franchise and see it on the menu. Y'know, actual evidence. Claiming that it might be on the menu in the future is two qualifiers away from actual evidence. Claiming that it might've been in the past is not actual evidence. At the very least, it cannot be used to support his claim of CD, and should be withdrawn.

But feel free to keep shoving that square peg.

Your personal terminal usage is of no relevance to your posting of off-topic bookmark spam.
That's nice. I was indirectly expressing my approval of the entire post.

The is nothing about the statement *Such leafing is not going to be on-topic at any point. I suggest simply making a browser bookmark instead* that is condescending.
My mistake, I meant your entire post. If the subject it is off topic, as you claim, I will ignore any further comments referring to it.
 
Last edited:
Really ? Don't you mean... :blush:

I suggest you read through from this point.

Ouch.

Major_Tom seemed to think there was plenty of data.
Really ?

Now femr2 comes along and tells us that Major_Tom was really drawing our attention to the fact "that there is no data" on accelerations in prior demolitions.
Incorrect.

Perhaps femr2 is just congratulating me on the wisdom of my original observation
Far from it. I suggest you stop digging the hole even deeper.
 
Back up. You just admitted that the evidence either a)never measured, meaning it doesn't exist, or b)might exist in the future, which means that it doesn't exist. You cannot draw a conclusion from evidence which doesn't exist. Now you're relying on bald assertions and snideness to try and get people to forget.

I'm not arguing that the conclusion is necessarily wrong, just that the claim MT made--which you yourself admitted means that the evidence doesn't exist--cannot be used to support it.
 
My claims were simple. If you think that the measured acceleration profile is something you can dismiss as normal, you are not thinking very clearly.

That doesn't mean there is a signature of demo in the profile or that very tall buildings may not experience something like it with many columns removed if put to the test.


But if you think you know squat when you casually brush off the extreme acceleration changes as "normal", you are living in a dream.



I linked to some research by Frank Greening which is worth reading. If anyone reads it carefully instead of stroking their own egos, they may learn something.
 
...
But if you think you know squat when you casually brush off the extreme acceleration changes as "normal", you are living in a dream. ...

The accelerations changes on WTC 7 are normal for a collapsing building. You will not be able to back in CD without evidence, and femr2's work shows a gravity collapse, smoothed out hiding the actual acceleration, it look like music, a model of the acceleration, which is surprising you seem to like this model.
 
Please point me to position/time data for a number of collapsing buildings.
You mean you have no clue what is normal for a gravity collapse? How can you compare this gravity collapse to other ones? What do you expect the normal acceleration changes to be? Poor Major Tom is not an engineer, are you? You both seem void of experience, or the ability to understand a chaotic collapse would have changing acceleration. I understand this, you don't. It is your problem, your failure, your Fictional Official Theory claim.

Point me to why this is not normal, point to to the proof of Major Tom's claim. You are making the claims, you prove it.

They are normal accelerations for gravity collapse - you can try to prove different, it will be a trip.
 
Point me to why this is not normal.
You claimed it was normal. I've not said either normal or not. Point me to data showing that it is normal...aka common...

You are making the claims, you prove it.
Incorrect. You have claimed...
The accelerations changes on WTC 7 are normal for a collapsing building.
...so come on beachnut, don't be shy. Out with the data to support your assertion.

They are normal accelerations for gravity collapse
Awesome, so post me an example or two with their corresponding acceleration profiles.

you can try to prove different, it will be a trip.
This is your trip beachnut. Support your claim, or retract it.

Have a nice day.
 
You claimed it was normal. I've not said either normal or not. Point me to data showing that it is normal...aka common...


Incorrect. You have claimed...

...so come on beachnut, don't be shy. Out with the data to support your assertion.


Awesome, so post me an example or two with their corresponding acceleration profiles.


This is your trip beachnut. Support your claim, or retract it.

Have a nice day.
It is normal, and all your inside job beliefs will not change reality for your fantasy. Good luck proving it is not normal, you lack the engineering skills to do it now, but in 7 to 10 years I suspect you will understand if you try.

It is normal, Major Tom is wrong. If you support Major Tom's false claim, go ahead prove it. Otherwise I sugest you take some engineering courses and catch up.

My claims were simple. If you think that the measured acceleration profile is something you can dismiss as normal, you are not thinking very clearly.

That doesn't mean there is a signature of demo in the profile or that very tall buildings may not experience something like it with many columns removed if put to the test.


But if you think you know squat when you casually brush off the extreme acceleration changes as "normal", you are living in a dream. ...
Make my decade, prove Major Tom's claim is correct. If you read carefully you will see Major Tom states the "extreme" (which are normal) accelerations change are not normal.

WTC 7 collapse is a gravity collapse, any accelerations measured are normal. If you don't understand this, you are not an engineer, or you lack the skills, knowledge and experience to comprehend it is normal. No big deal, with education and time you will understand. Hang in there.

If you want to support Major Tom's delusion, please prove he is right, otherwise I suggest you pick reality over nonsense, and try to get out of the inside job business.
 
Awesome. I note that you have not actually provided me with any data from building collapse events to support your assertion :rolleyes:
You and Major Tom are expert engineers, prove your point that the acceleration is not normal for a gravity collapse. Make my decade, 911 truth actually doing original work based on reality with a goal. Prove Major Tom's claim the acceleration is not right.

The acceleration of WTC 7 is normal, it is proved. If you like to say it is not normal or not a gravity collapse you have to prove it. You can't, it is over, Major Tom was making up nonsense. If you support Major Tom, try and save his nonsensical claim.

You know the post, support it! You can't, you will now ask me to show a normal gravity collapse, and it is already done. End of story.

... But if you think you know squat when you casually brush off the extreme acceleration changes as "normal", you are living in a dream. ...
Prove Major Tom is right, prove you inside job. Good luck. Need some help understanding why this is nonsense?

If you like to prove WTC 7 is not a gravity collapse, do it.
Major Tom thinks the gravity collapse is an illusion, what say you? Not a darn thing, you avoid all questions, you can't do more than move on to the next imagined nonsensical anomaly fantasy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom