I wouldn't use the word assumption since it was a conclusion based on modelled behaviour.
Sure - I'm not fussed about terminology on this matter. If we want to be pedantic it was an
interim conclusion adopted as a premise on which NIST's
conclusion of 13
o is based.
However, terminological niceties aside, the key point is "if the straight line assumption is wrong then NIST's work based on that assumption is wrong".
Now thanks for your second point which goes to the reasoning of my explanation:
...It shows that your reasoning is wrong. Deflection behaviour of a complete engine assembly doing over 500mph is going to be different to an engine fragment doing 100mph. To say that if an engine part could deflect on exit it must be able to deflect similarly on entry is faulty reasoning...
There are two aspects why I disagree with your claim that my "reasoning is wrong". One is technical the other is the requirements for standard of proof/burden of proof. Set the proof issues aside at this stage - let's look at the technical.
My argument essentially rests on a premise that impact at entry and exit walls would follow similar mechanisms. You dispute this premise with "Deflection behaviour of a complete engine assembly doing over 500mph is going to be
different to an engine fragment doing 100mph." (My emphasis.)
That statement is true BUT it depends on what you mean by "different". The results will be
quantitatively different but not
qualitatively different. The mechanisms of physics will be the same mechanisms. Despite all the detailed differences other than velocity the actual mechanisms for deflection will be the same.. Take any aspect you choose - lets say impact of a moving body on an inclined plane - deflection will still occur conforming to the same equations of motion.
Qualitatively the same. The difference will be in the magnitude of the effects.
Quantitatively different. If there is deflection at low speed the same mechanism acting at high speed may well cause less deflection for whatever reason of the maths BUT it will not be zero.
Your reasoning presumes that faster impacts will have zero deflection whilst slower impacts will have some deflection. So "zero" at high speed, "some" at low speed. That is not how the physics works. You could well be correct that it will be "more at low speed" BUT it will be "less at high speed" not "zero" And my reasoning only requires "some" whether it be more or less.
So, without attempting to identify every component of the impact interactions, some may be more at high speed, some may be less. The ones that are less may be very small BUT still not zero. And my argument only requires "not zero".
So that is the technical overview - the logical requirements for "proof" are more complex so I'll leave them for now.
And:
...As Femr2 shows in the simulation in post #3235 the engine shows little initial deflection from the walls and floor until it has lost enough momentum to enable it to be deflected by the floor.
That may well be true but it is not part of the reasoning I used and you are disputing.