Based on simulations that showed little deflection of the engine sections by the office contents the relatively straight path of the engine through the building was used to decide between the impact angles that best fit the observed damage to the exterior of the building.
Which comment restates the NIST position including its inbuilt source of probable error - the reliance on the assumption of a linear transit through the building. However don't overlook the main point which femr was making and which I have also made - the exit trajectory shows additional deflection which is significant.
Put simply the NIST assumed impact trajectory is derived by backwards extrapolation of a presumed transit path through the building AND the assumption that the transit path was linear - no significant deflections.
However the point which NIST overlooked, and which much discussion here is overlooking, is the
significance of the accepted fact that there was a total deflection of 20
o shown by the exit and fall to ground trajectory.
As Reactor Drone correctly points out:
...If the NIST trajectory is right you need a 6-7 ° deflection, if you go with Femr2's trajectory you need double that deflection.
Now let's get a proper focus on that true statement. The key issue IMO is not that the NIST and femr findings differ. The key point is that BOTH of them show a deflection. So we can, at least briefly, get away from the NIST v femr comparisons. They both say there was an additional deflection. And AFAICS no one here is denying that fact of additional; deflection.
So what caused that deflection? More importantly, what impact does it have on the NIST assumptions about the linear transit path and the extrapolated impact trajectory which NIST based on it?
I suggest that it is fatal to the NIST hypothesis and here is why.
If NIST is correct that the transit through tower path was linear it inevitably follows that the extra deflection MUST have resulted from the penetration of the perimeter at the exit point. And that is true whether we take the 6-7° needed by NIST OR the double that needed by femr. So the NIST v femr differences are irrelevant to what follows.
Now members may agree or disagree that the extra deflection occurred at the exit point but it doesn't matter. There are two options and NIST was wrong whichever option we follow. Here's why for both:
1) If members hold the view that that such a step deflection could not occur at the exit point then it must have originated inside the building during transit - and that kills the NIST assumption of "linear transit".
Alternatively;
2) If members claim that such a step deflection could occur on exit then a similar step deflection would equally plausibly have occurred on initial impact entry. And that kills the legitimacy of the NIST "backwards projecting" the transit path to become impact trajectory.
So that puts the NIST position out of consideration and the discussion is simplified to comparisons of femr's measurements versus other members measurements.