Hellbound
Merchant of Doom
Good god (pardon the expression)! One person's "understanding" differs from another person's "understanding" by three orders of magnitude!
I find it ironic that such uncertainty and lack of precision rears its ugly head on a site which ostensibly goes out of its way to be perfectly clear about the rules of the game in the Million Dollar Challenge. Once again, why in the blue blazes doesn't Randi simply state what the expected odds are going to be, in any test of a statistical nature? It's not like it's necessarily carved into stone tablets or anything...he could include a disclaimer to the effect that the odds _may_ be adjusted in certain cases, but they normally will be set to 1-in-a-million (or 1-in-a-billion, or whatever).
The more I hear about this apparent uncertainty, the more it leaves a rather bad taste in my mouth. If I personally wanted to submit myself for testing, I'd sure as heck want to know what was expected of me right up front, before going through even the early rounds of paperwork, negotiations, etc.
Bryan
Why are you even bothering to post? It's apparent you've made up your mind to dismiss the challenge anyway, so why are you here?
Three orders of magnitude, yes. It's a misunderstanding of a single aspect. I knew 1 in 1000 and 1 in 1000000; it was my mistake in assuming 1 in 1000000 was a cumulative rather than independent probability. A mistake akin to "forgetting to carry the one", and due to my ignorance. As I stated multiple times, I am not an authority on the challenege, and was going from memory. The fact that I am wrong is no reflection on the challenge, rather on myself.
Frankly, NO ONE in the forum is involved, in any official way, with the challenge itself. If you actually wanted answers to these questions you should have emailed randi himself, or the challenge email listed on the main page.
Your assertion that my poor understandign somehow means the challenge is dodgy is, frankly, ridiculous and smacks of your underlying bias. It's the same as declaring a doctor as incompetent because one of his patients mis-remembers the dosage on his last prescription.
I'm calling troll (not that this will suprise many).