determining what constitutes a success

Good god (pardon the expression)! One person's "understanding" differs from another person's "understanding" by three orders of magnitude! :-)

I find it ironic that such uncertainty and lack of precision rears its ugly head on a site which ostensibly goes out of its way to be perfectly clear about the rules of the game in the Million Dollar Challenge. Once again, why in the blue blazes doesn't Randi simply state what the expected odds are going to be, in any test of a statistical nature? It's not like it's necessarily carved into stone tablets or anything...he could include a disclaimer to the effect that the odds _may_ be adjusted in certain cases, but they normally will be set to 1-in-a-million (or 1-in-a-billion, or whatever).

The more I hear about this apparent uncertainty, the more it leaves a rather bad taste in my mouth. If I personally wanted to submit myself for testing, I'd sure as heck want to know what was expected of me right up front, before going through even the early rounds of paperwork, negotiations, etc.

Bryan

Why are you even bothering to post? It's apparent you've made up your mind to dismiss the challenge anyway, so why are you here?

Three orders of magnitude, yes. It's a misunderstanding of a single aspect. I knew 1 in 1000 and 1 in 1000000; it was my mistake in assuming 1 in 1000000 was a cumulative rather than independent probability. A mistake akin to "forgetting to carry the one", and due to my ignorance. As I stated multiple times, I am not an authority on the challenege, and was going from memory. The fact that I am wrong is no reflection on the challenge, rather on myself.

Frankly, NO ONE in the forum is involved, in any official way, with the challenge itself. If you actually wanted answers to these questions you should have emailed randi himself, or the challenge email listed on the main page.

Your assertion that my poor understandign somehow means the challenge is dodgy is, frankly, ridiculous and smacks of your underlying bias. It's the same as declaring a doctor as incompetent because one of his patients mis-remembers the dosage on his last prescription.

I'm calling troll (not that this will suprise many).
 
Why are you even bothering to post? It's apparent you've made up your mind to dismiss the challenge anyway, so why are you here?

DISMISSING a challenge? Who said anything about even ACCEPTING a challenge? Not me.

Three orders of magnitude, yes. It's a misunderstanding of a single aspect. I knew 1 in 1000 and 1 in 1000000; it was my mistake in assuming 1 in 1000000 was a cumulative rather than independent probability. A mistake akin to "forgetting to carry the one", and due to my ignorance. As I stated multiple times, I am not an authority on the challenege, and was going from memory. The fact that I am wrong is no reflection on the challenge, rather on myself.

Why do you assume that YOU are the one in error? Maybe you are correct, and "drkitten" is the one in error. The truth of this matter hasn't beeen determined, has it?

Frankly, NO ONE in the forum is involved, in any official way, with the challenge itself. If you actually wanted answers to these questions you should have emailed randi himself, or the challenge email listed on the main page.

I think I'll do that. But at the very least, I think everybody now sees that there's a lack of information in the stated rules.

Your assertion that my poor understandign somehow means the challenge is dodgy is, frankly, ridiculous and smacks of your underlying bias.

You're showing a bit of paranoia, friend. Nobody accused YOU specifically of being wrong.

I'm calling troll (not that this will suprise many).

There: do ya feel better? :-)

Bryan
 
Not that this will make any difference to this discussion (which I've just now stumbled upon), but isn't it something of a moot point? I mean, in view of the fact that 1) the challenge is Randi's; he decides how it's structured and is under no obligation to specify odds up-front, and 2) for each applicant, the specific rules/protocol and what constitutes a win - including odds - if appropriate to the type of claim - must be agreed on by both parties.
 
...
The more I hear about this apparent uncertainty, the more it leaves a rather bad taste in my mouth. If I personally wanted to submit myself for testing, I'd sure as heck want to know what was expected of me right up front, before going through even the early rounds of paperwork, negotiations, etc.

Bryan

As Gr8wight already said:

Bryan, If you state a claim and how you would like to prove it, a simple inquiry to [email protected] will most likely dispart any clouds of uncertainty concerning the odds. Quick and efficent. No mouthwash needed.
 
I understand what you're saying, but at the risk of beating a dead horse, isn't it a little odd that the standard (or typical) odds aren't already common knowledge? What's the Big Secret?

Bryan
 
Last edited:
Bryan Shelton said:
I've been looking around trying to find out what the required odds are for that Million Dollar Challenge.

Bryan Shelton said:
I find it very odd that they wouldn't explicitly state something as important as that right up front for everyone to see.

Bryan Shelton said:
But at the very least, I think everybody now sees that there's a lack of information in the stated rules.

Bryan,

I'm trying to understand what you're saying. You seem to think the JREF should post the "required odds" for a claim. Why? What is the point? It might be helpful for someone unfamiliar with the challenge coming to see it in "mid run". And if the claim were "statistically based" (i.e. predicting coin flips). Then this visitor would be told something like, "Psychic Fred's chances of succeeding by chance alone are X."

Also, the challenge rules are for the claimant; to guide him/her to putting together a proper statement of abilities, and move toward preliminary testing. And, as others have said, this is a challenge. It's for the claimant to show of his/her powers. Not for JREF to figure what the chances are of success.

Finally, since each claim is unique, having odds posted doesn't seem to make sense. And again, as others have pointed out, how does one determine the odds of levitation, or telekenisis?

Sorry if I am not understanding you. You seem to feel very strongly about this. I'm just trying to understand why.
 
I understand what you're saying, but at the risk of beating a dead horse, isn't it a little odd that the standard (or typical) odds aren't already common knowledge? What's the Big Secret?

Bryan

Bryan, since there are no "standard (or typical)" paranormal claims, odds of claims cannot be "common knowledge".

For claims which pop up from time like "telepathy" or "mind reading" the odds used in a JREF protocol (see the Achau Nguyen thread http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=28936) seem similar.

The very different nature of claims make it impossible to give standard odds up front. How for example, would you calculate the odds of "bending a key with your mind"? What would the standard odds be for UFO summoning?

The upcoming Carina Landin test http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=63753 and http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=32779 and http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=58612 and http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=47223 allows for a precise calculation of odds. Perhaps you find it interesting enough to follow.
 
I understand what you're saying, but at the risk of beating a dead horse, isn't it a little odd that the standard (or typical) odds aren't already common knowledge? What's the Big Secret?

Bryan

Why is it odd?

The only time these odds would even matter at all is if you planned on winning the challenge through chance.

If you actually have an ability, the chance odds never come into play.

What you're doing here would be like somone challenging you to throw a dart at a dartboard, and you complaining that something seems "fishy" because he doesn't tell you the odds of hitting the board if you were blindfolded, spun in place, and throw in whatever direction you end up facing.

THe chance odds are, really, inconsequential as long as they are low enough to rule out chance as a likely reason for a "win". Whether 1 in a million or 1 in a billion, I'm comfortable with either.

Agian, you're either ignorant or deceptive...and I am still fairly certain you aren't debating honestly. However, there are lurkers that might believe your argument has some bearing, so it needs to be responded to.
 
I understand what you're saying, but at the risk of beating a dead horse, isn't it a little odd that the standard (or typical) odds aren't already common knowledge? What's the Big Secret?

Bryan

Would you find it odd if a Casino didn't post the odds for winning a game? Would their failure to do so make you feel they're witholding a Big Secret?
 
Bryan,

I'm trying to understand what you're saying. You seem to think the JREF should post the "required odds" for a claim. Why? What is the point?

For maximum transparency, of course. Again I ask, what is the big secret? What is the point of obscuring information? Why not just be right up-front about it, from square-one? Does the JREF have anything to hide?

It might be helpful for someone unfamiliar with the challenge coming to see it in "mid run". And if the claim were "statistically based" (i.e. predicting coin flips). Then this visitor would be told something like, "Psychic Fred's chances of succeeding by chance alone are X."

Yes.

Also, the challenge rules are for the claimant; to guide him/her to putting together a proper statement of abilities, and move toward preliminary testing. And, as others have said, this is a challenge. It's for the claimant to show of his/her powers. Not for JREF to figure what the chances are of success.

HUH??

But OF COURSE it's for JREF to figure what the chances are of success!! If I told them that if they thought of a number between 1 and 10 and I could read their mind and tell them what that number was, do you think they'd let me get away with demonstrating it only one single time, and then making a million bucks if I get it right?? Of course not. They'd think about the challenge for about a nanosecond, and then make me do it successfully for several times in a row (probably at least 6-10 times)! :-)

You were obviously just talking off the top of your head when you said that it's not for JREF to figure the chances of success.

Finally, since each claim is unique, having odds posted doesn't seem to make sense. And again, as others have pointed out, how does one determine the odds of levitation, or telekenisis?

One DOESN'T determine the odds of levitation or telekinesis. As I've indicated before, I'm talking only about challenges which have an obvious statistical element involved.

Sorry if I am not understanding you. You seem to feel very strongly about this. I'm just trying to understand why.

I hope this clarifies things for you.

Bryan
 
Bryan, since there are no "standard (or typical)" paranormal claims, odds of claims cannot be "common knowledge".

For claims which pop up from time like "telepathy" or "mind reading" the odds used in a JREF protocol seem similar.

The very different nature of claims make it impossible to give standard odds up front. How for example, would you calculate the odds of "bending a key with your mind"? What would the standard odds be for UFO summoning?

I addressed that in my previous post. I was referring only to challenges that involve an obvious statistical element, of course. For those, the odds can certainly be calculated. At the very least, in principle.

The upcoming Carina Landin test allows for a precise calculation of odds. Perhaps you find it interesting enough to follow.

Thanks for citing that for me! I'll definitely follow that.

Bryan
 
Why is it odd?

The only time these odds would even matter at all is if you planned on winning the challenge through chance.

Yes. Or another possibility: you are sincere and well-meaning, but you don't really have the ability that you THINK you do.

If you actually have an ability, the chance odds never come into play.

What you're doing here would be like somone challenging you to throw a dart at a dartboard, and you complaining that something seems "fishy" because he doesn't tell you the odds of hitting the board if you were blindfolded, spun in place, and throw in whatever direction you end up facing.

I've already given you obvious examples where chance odds sure as hell DO come into play.

THe chance odds are, really, inconsequential as long as they are low enough to rule out chance as a likely reason for a "win". Whether 1 in a million or 1 in a billion, I'm comfortable with either.

Yes. And I'm curious to know exactly how stringent the JREF is when setting the requirements necessary to ensure that they don't lose their million bucks through chance alone. The fact that they seem rather cagey about that leaves a bad taste in my mouth, as I said before.

Agian, you're either ignorant or deceptive...and I am still fairly certain you aren't debating honestly.

Thanks for sharing that with me, but that's the very least of my concerns.

Bryan
 
For maximum transparency, of course. Again I ask, what is the big secret? What is the point of obscuring information? Why not just be right up-front about it, from square-one? Does the JREF have anything to hide?
...

And again the answer is: There is no "big secret". I also do not see where the JREF "obscures information".

At the risk of sounding redundant, hardly any Challenge resembles the other. As JREF hence treats claims on a case-by-case basis, right from square one, the need for odds up-front is irrelevant.
As soon as there is a clearly stated claim, the odds get determined in the protocol. I have not yet witnessed the JREF hiding anything concerning the odds of a successful Challenge.

Bryan, may I suggest you read as many of the past Challenge Applications as possible? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=43

Not only will it enlighten you as to the odds of claims of a statistical nature (e.g. Hans Peter Borer's claim + test http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=29864 ), it will also show you how hard it seems for applicants to even state the claim precisely.
 
And again the answer is: There is no "big secret". I also do not see where the JREF "obscures information".

It's obscure enough that at least two established posters here disagreed completely on what the odds are in these tests. One thought that there was a cumulative 1/1,000,000 chance through luck alone, whereas the other thought that it was 1/1,000,000,000. They both used the rather vague expression "my understanding is...", which sounds to me like people here aren't very clear about how the probabilities are adjusted in these tests that involve a statistical element. It sounds to me like the JREF doesn't take any great pains to make the odds clear and up-front.

At the risk of sounding redundant, hardly any Challenge resembles the other. As JREF hence treats claims on a case-by-case basis, right from square one, the need for odds up-front is irrelevant.

Why is it irrelevant? I don't see how that follows logically. Why aren't the odds of passing any test standardized, regardless of how disparate the claims themselves happen to be? For example, why wouldn't the required odds for success from sheer guesswork alone be adjusted to be 1-in-a-million (or whatever number JREF finds acceptable), regardless of whether I claim to be able to predict the results of coin-flipping trials, or whether I claim to be able to tell the sex of the author of a diary that I hold in my hands? Do you see what I'm saying? It's a matter of standardization.

As soon as there is a clearly stated claim, the odds get determined in the protocol.

Why on earth would the odds get determined in the protocol?? It's obvious that the protocol itself is going to change from one claim to another; however, I don't see why the actual ODDS would change (be re-adjusted) from one test to another, except for a special case which has been mentioned before (like if Randi wanted to relax the odds a bit just to entice a high-profile "psychic" like Sylvia to take the test).

Bryan, may I suggest you read as many of the past Challenge Applications as possible? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=43

I read through the first page of applications, but didn't see anything of relevance to what we've been discussing. In only a couple of the threads did I see anything much more than just a casual discussion of the odds, and those were from the applicants themselves. I believe there was only one very brief and insignificant reference to some "acceptable" odds from someone associated with JREF.

Not only will it enlighten you as to the odds of claims of a statistical nature (e.g. Hans Peter Borer's claim + test http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=29864 ), it will also show you how hard it seems for applicants to even state the claim precisely.

There's a brief section on the required odds for both the first and second parts of Borer's testing, but true-to-form, it's ambiguous and uncertain whether those are standardized requirements for all applicants, or just something negotiated between Borer and JREF.

Bryan
 
I think I see your point, Bryan. But I suppose I just don't see it as urgently needed as you do.

Also, that's not what I'd call "transparency". It's more like "additional info". My take on it is, yes the JREF doesn't take "great pains" to make the odds clear. So what? It would be nice, but if not, I don't see how it matters.
 
It's obscure enough that at least two established posters here disagreed completely on what the odds are in these tests. One thought that there was a cumulative 1/1,000,000 chance through luck alone, whereas the other thought that it was 1/1,000,000,000. They both used the rather vague expression "my understanding is...", which sounds to me like people here aren't very clear about how the probabilities are adjusted in these tests that involve a statistical element. It sounds to me like the JREF doesn't take any great pains to make the odds clear and up-front.
And they don't take any pains to hide it either, they just don't say. Have you tried actually asking anyone in the JREF?

Why is it irrelevant? I don't see how that follows logically. Why aren't the odds of passing any test standardized, regardless of how disparate the claims themselves happen to be? For example, why wouldn't the required odds for success from sheer guesswork alone be adjusted to be 1-in-a-million (or whatever number JREF finds acceptable), regardless of whether I claim to be able to predict the results of coin-flipping trials, or whether I claim to be able to tell the sex of the author of a diary that I hold in my hands? Do you see what I'm saying? It's a matter of standardization.

Why should it be standard? As long as the odds are low it doesn't matter if the odds are different each time. It's Randi's challenge and he can do what he likes with it.

Why on earth would the odds get determined in the protocol?? It's obvious that the protocol itself is going to change from one claim to another; however, I don't see why the actual ODDS would change (be re-adjusted) from one test to another, except for a special case which has been mentioned before (like if Randi wanted to relax the odds a bit just to entice a high-profile "psychic" like Sylvia to take the test).

I claim I can predict a coin toss with 60% accuracy, someone else claims they can dowse for water with 80% accuracy. To test the dowsing claim would require maybe 20 buckets to be checked and could be done in a couple of hours. The coin tossing one could be tested with maybe 100 tosses. The odds of success by chance are completely different, but there is no point attempting to make them equal since it is easier for all concerned just to make up a test that give low odds.

I read through the first page of applications, but didn't see anything of relevance to what we've been discussing. In only a couple of the threads did I see anything much more than just a casual discussion of the odds, and those were from the applicants themselves. I believe there was only one very brief and insignificant reference to some "acceptable" odds from someone associated with JREF.

Exactly. Even with people who are actually trying to apply the issue of the odds does not come up much. Why do you amke such an issue of it when clearly the JREF and the applicants really don't care, as long as the odds of winning by chance are low enough to be ignored.

There's a brief section on the required odds for both the first and second parts of Borer's testing, but true-to-form, it's ambiguous and uncertain whether those are standardized requirements for all applicants, or just something negotiated between Borer and JREF.

Bryan

It's not uncertain at all. The test was conducted in Switzerland by someone trusted by the JREF to run a proper test. It never says specifically, but is very clearly implied, that Kramer didn't even know what the test consisted of, let alone what the odds were, until the test was complete and he was given the results.
 
Bryan Shelton, I suggest you contact JREF directly, e.g.: [email protected]

Only JREF Officials can give a definitive answer which will satisfy you.

I do not see what you see. Your view seems to overly simplify. I'm afraid I can be of no more assistance to you in this matter.
 
The odds of winning the challenge by chance aren't clear and upfront. Why? It's isn't a lottery, it's a challenge. It's not intended that a challenger wins by chance. Informally, the odds in the past have tended to 1/1000 by chance. Perhaps if you were to apply, they would require performace of 1/1,000,000,000,000 by chance, that's their business. The only people that such a statistic is really important too are the people that intend to win by chance, and I doubt JREF really cares what such people think.
 
I think I see your point, Bryan. But I suppose I just don't see it as urgently needed as you do.

Oh, it's not really that I see it as being all that "urgent". In the grand scheme of things, it's obviously not something to lose any sleep over!;)

I guess it's mainly just that I find it a little incongruous that despite the fact that they take such great care to spell out all the other rules of the challenge (sometimes in exquisite detail), they leave completely unspecified the odds required to pass the test(s), until they are hashed-out in an arduous process that can take many months.

And then combine that with the criticisms that come from the JREF people when an applicant overlooks one of the rules himself, or supposedly doesn't tow-the-line precisely enough on one of them for their taste, and that leaves a situation which in my opinion has a slight odor about it.

Bryan
 
"There's a brief section on the required odds for both the first and second parts of Borer's testing, but true-to-form, it's ambiguous and uncertain whether those are standardized requirements for all applicants, or just something negotiated between Borer and JREF." --- Bryan

It's not uncertain at all. The test was conducted in Switzerland by someone trusted by the JREF to run a proper test. It never says specifically, but is very clearly implied, that Kramer didn't even know what the test consisted of, let alone what the odds were, until the test was complete and he was given the results.

So you're claiming that the odds WEREN'T standardized? The guy did say something about how he gave Borer "the usual test", if I remember the wording correctly. That seems ambiguous to me. That could conceivably also imply some "usual odds".

Bryan
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom