determining what constitutes a success

Oh, it's not really that I see it as being all that "urgent". In the grand scheme of things, it's obviously not something to lose any sleep over!;)

I guess it's mainly just that I find it a little incongruous that despite the fact that they take such great care to spell out all the other rules of the challenge (sometimes in exquisite detail), they leave completely unspecified the odds required to pass the test(s), until they are hashed-out in an arduous process that can take many months.

Why is it incongruous? It's not like it would make a flaming difference to anyone who can really do what they claim they can do. And that much is clear from the rules and the entire setup of the challenge, too.

It is simple to win the challenge if you can do somethoing paranormal. You can predict coin flips? Great! What does it matter to you, if you have to do 5, 10 or even 100 predictions?

Also, it's not like the process of designing a protocol would take many months because the odds have to be determined. It takes many months because other things have to be taken care of.

And then combine that with the criticisms that come from the JREF people when an applicant overlooks one of the rules himself, or supposedly doesn't tow-the-line precisely enough on one of them for their taste, and that leaves a situation which in my opinion has a slight odor about it.

Bryan

Then why add further rules?
 
Why is it incongruous? It's not like it would make a flaming difference to anyone who can really do what they claim they can do. And that much is clear from the rules and the entire setup of the challenge, too.

It is simple to win the challenge if you can do somethoing paranormal. You can predict coin flips? Great! What does it matter to you, if you have to do 5, 10 or even 100 predictions?

OH REALLY?? What if my paranormal ability were to be able to correctly predict the outcome of coin flips with an accuracy of 50.1%? Would THAT be provable with 5, 10, or even 100 trials?:D

There are obvious examples like that where the exact odds required by the JREF could make a HUGE difference in the amount of work required to meet a challenge.

Bryan
 
OH REALLY?? What if my paranormal ability were to be able to correctly predict the outcome of coin flips with an accuracy of 50.1%? Would THAT be provable with 5, 10, or even 100 trials?:D

There are obvious examples like that where the exact odds required by the JREF could make a HUGE difference in the amount of work required to meet a challenge.

Bryan

Absolutely. Should you chance to run into such an applicant, or happen to be one yourself, I advise you to contact JREF staff to discuss the matter. Thank you for your concern.
 
OH REALLY?? What if my paranormal ability were to be able to correctly predict the outcome of coin flips with an accuracy of 50.1%? Would THAT be provable with 5, 10, or even 100 trials?:D

There are obvious examples like that where the exact odds required by the JREF could make a HUGE difference in the amount of work required to meet a challenge.

Bryan

And how many people are likely to have tossed enough coins to be able to say they can do that? People can only claim on what they believe themselves able to do. Someone could easily claim to do this, but unless they can offer proof that they have actually done a trial large enough to detect it they will simply be ignored.

In addition, who cares? If someone is willing to spend their time tossing millions of coins, why would they care if they have to do a few million more? Since they would agree the number beforehand anyway it's not like they'd waste their time or the JREF's time.
Edit : At least not any more than the usual applicants.;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom