determining what constitutes a success

T'ai Chi said:
I'm more interested in what the claimant can do, rather than what they believe they can do. What if they are incorrect about their own assesment. For example, they state their expected success rate of 80%, but they can really perform at 60%.

Then if they get 70%, they are really performing acceptably, but you would say they'd fail.

T'ai Chi said:
See my example why. The person could be mistaken about their beliefs (in fact, it is known that people are regularly mistaken, so this seems an obvious point).
Yes, it's entirely possible that they are mistaken about their abilities.

If you've followed threads in the Challenge forum, you will no doubt be aware that applicants and potential applicants are routinely advised to perform tests of their own, under similar conditions to an actual challenge test, so that they can figure out for themselves whether they really have the ability they claim, and what success rate they can expect. If they carry out the tests as they are recommended to do, and they actually do have an ability, they should be able to figure out what their success rate is likely to be and to negotiate an appropriate success rate for the challenge.

If they don't bother to test themselves properly before negotiating a target success rate for the challenge, then that's their problem, isn't it?
 
I am new here
Welcome, Jehanne!
If I claimed that I could predict the exact outcome (that is, the exact sequence of Heads & Tails) of 100 tosses of a "fair coin" of your choosing, would you accept that as evidence of the existence of the paranormal and/or supernatural? The following protocol would apply:
(snip)
I can't speak for JREF, but it looks OK to me. You'd have to fill out an challenge application though. Your 'donate to charity' and 'never reapply' might be better kept as private promises to yourself, and you shouldn't try to change the challenge rules for even such terms.

1) I will pray to my deity and let him know that we are going to conduct an experiment to prove his existence.
As with any claim, claimants may want to conduct an experiment themselves to see if they might be deceiving themselves about the power. This claim is very easy to test like that.
 
Aye! Ye canna gae ordering thon wee jock aboot.
Tae fick with he.

Oh [Expletive Deleted], I pissed off an Aussie again. :)

Please, please forgive a celtic caveman, oh honourable superhero from the continent that blessed us with the great Virgil Donati but also spat out Columcille Gerard Gibson so you probably made just up for that screw-up I mean I liked Lethal Weapon II III also but that passion stuff and the alleged antisemitc rant pfui can you believe how bad this guy acts and what about all the violence does he get off on it does he get paid by the government to desensitize the population for present and future wars I mean the bringing of peace and democracy did he go weewee in his bed and his mommy beat the living piss out of him or some other quasi-psychodiddlyological ramalamadingdong I mean can you believe this nonsense you know Danny Glover really carried him the whole time and Pesci and Russo well at least the Simpsons parlayed his sorry tuchus into a great episode you know he's just a dummy I know but he sells tickets yeah mad max schmad schmax lethal weapon schmethal schmeapon Air America Schmair Schmamerica Maverick yeah Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks ruleDallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Dallas Mavericks rule Maverick Schmaverick Braveheart Schmaveschmart Pocahontas Pukahontas Schmukaschmonschmas Ransom Schmanschmom Payback Schmayback Million Dollar Hotel Dime Brothel Chicken Run Schmicken Schmun Patriot Oh say can you see What Women Want well who knows when they mostly do not even know themselves what they frickin want am I right am I right tough crowd Schmat Schmomen Schmant brrrzzzzz brrrrRRRRR RRzzzzZZZZZ and the weather forecast for Monday: Buy waffles tasty waffles with plenty of maple sirup and schmmmmm brrrzzzzrrrrrbrprrzz ZZZZschmschm schmzzzzz how does this promote the JREF Mission I guess you will have to answer that for yourself what I have learned is that this Forum has a great wingspan tremendous upside potential and freakish atleticism it will have enough chances to prove its abilities in the future as it will face beaucoup challenges every single day every single day every single day bbbrrrmmmschm zzzZZZp pffsssSSSSSss [insert noise of my cat snoring (!) on her pillow, breathing very audible. probably chasing a big fat mouse in her mind, oh how cute, oh my, if this is love it feels great, oh.]
And that's the Wørd.
We'll be right back.
(Fade in music.)
 
...For example if someone claims to be able to predict outcomes of coin flips obviously it wouldn't be considered a success if they successfully predicted 5 coin flips, but how many flips would have to be accumulated and what would the final probablity of the guesses/outcomes have to be (after all the flips) to be considered a success?
From what I understand Randi does a card trick. Although he's merely normal he can do that trick with 100% accuracy. I think Randi would expect that anyone who claims to have a paranormal ability to at least be able to demonstrate it to the extent a normal person can do something. Anything less than 100% accuracy is less than what a normal person can do. It shouldn't be considered paranormal.

Gene
 
If they don't bother to test themselves properly before negotiating a target success rate for the challenge, then that's their problem, isn't it?

If they are suspected of not having critical thinking skills, they how can they be expected to carry out their own tests and have a good notion of their own skill assessment?
 
If they are suspected of not having critical thinking skills, they how can they be expected to carry out their own tests and have a good notion of their own skill assessment?

"They" can inquire in this very Forum and "they" will most likely find step-by-step help and guidance. The only requirements for "them" are basic social and communication skillz.
 
Seems true. From reading the FAQ page, - .../research/faq.html#4.2

... you need to have your health checked, you need to discuss your ability/power/whatever with your Doctor, demonstrate it to them and other observers before you even apply. Seems simple to me. Then, if you have already demonstrated something to rational, healthy, scientific minds, you could apply for the challenge.

To quote from the FAQ, -"If you can convince a brutally honest friend that you can do something paranormal, then keep going. Otherwise, stop; you will have no chance convincing the JREF's investigators."

Forgive me if I missed this in some other thread here. While I have not read everything, I have studied the challenge since it was only $10,000 years ago, and I love it!

Not just the big money aspect, but the entire idea of it.

And hello, my first commentary here. I'm a short tempered, crusty old skeptic, so don't worry about hurting my feelings.
 
T'ai Chi said:
I'm more interested in what the claimant can do, rather than what they believe they can do. What if they are incorrect about their own assesment. For example, they state their expected success rate of 80%, but they can really perform at 60%.

Then if they get 70%, they are really performing acceptably, but you would say they'd fail.

1) The successes needed is mutually agreed upon. If the applicant doesn't believe they can meet that standard they shouldn't agree to it.

2) This is a challenge. Its up to the applicant to meet the specified goals.

3) What you're proposing is a variant of texas sharpshooter's fallacy (fire your shots, then draw the bullseye). The reason the challenge uses very specific pass criteria is to avoid complaints by applicant's that they "performed acceptably."
 
I could win the MDC if they changed the rules.



Or if I had some powers science couldn't explain.


Or an ultra cool super secret mind ray hidden on my person.
 
...I believe it's been stated that the odds of winiing by chance are adjusted to be less than 1 in 1000 for the preliminary and 1 in 1,000,000 for the final test.

I'm new here, and I've been looking around trying to find out what the required odds are for that Million Dollar Challenge. I've read the official rules for the challenge and I've read a few threads in the forums having to do with it, but I haven't seen anything yet stating that the required odds that the results are from chance alone must be 1 in a million, or worse. Can you point me to any official statement of that?

Bryan
 
I'm new here, and I've been looking around trying to find out what the required odds are for that Million Dollar Challenge. I've read the official rules for the challenge and I've read a few threads in the forums having to do with it, but I haven't seen anything yet stating that the required odds that the results are from chance alone must be 1 in a million, or worse. Can you point me to any official statement of that?

Bryan

Nope, no idea :)

I'll look through a bit, see what I can find though. I recall reading it somewhere here, but that's just my recollection. And we all know how reliable memory is...
 
Nope, no idea :)

I'll look through a bit, see what I can find though. I recall reading it somewhere here, but that's just my recollection. And we all know how reliable memory is...

I don't think it's explicitly part of the challenge. It may well be a guideline Randi et al. use in determining if a test is acceptable, but I doubt they'd put it down on the challenge FAQ, there's far to much room for misinterpretation. Can you imagine the woo's? "There's no point entering; Randi won't let anyone compete unless they have less than a 1 in a million chance of winning!"
 
I'm new here, and I've been looking around trying to find out what the required odds are for that Million Dollar Challenge. I've read the official rules for the challenge and I've read a few threads in the forums having to do with it, but I haven't seen anything yet stating that the required odds that the results are from chance alone must be 1 in a million, or worse. Can you point me to any official statement of that?

There's no official statement of that nature, partly because for many of the proposed abilities/challenges, calculating probabilities in such a manner is problematic. (For example, one person claimed to be able to make UFOs -- flying saucers -- appear on command. Another person claimed to be able to make it snow in july in Oakland, CA. Can you give me a meaningful odds assessment for that?)

Also, Randi has from time-to-time bent his own rules regarding the strictness of the test criteria in order to make specific offers to specific high-profile charlatans (such as Sylvia Browne).
 
Probability isn't always relevant anyway. If someone claims to be able to levitate all they need to do is show that they can levitate in an environment where they can't be cheating. There is no possibility of this happening by chance, so this criteria (criterion?) wouldn't apply. I assume that since every claim is different Randi feels there is no point trying to fix the odds, as long as the possibility of a chance win is so small that it can be ignored.
 
I find it very odd that they wouldn't explicitly state something as important as that right up front for everyone to see. If the average "woo" (I can guess what that means, from the context) doesn't understand the nuances, that's HIS problem, not JREF's.

Bryan
 
Ithere's far to much room for misinterpretation. Can you imagine the woo's? "There's no point entering; Randi won't let anyone compete unless they have less than a 1 in a million chance of winning!"
And it's so easy to mis-interpret. Most people wouldn't catch the distinction between "winning" and "winning by chance".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom