Mojo
Mostly harmless
T'ai Chi said:I'm more interested in what the claimant can do, rather than what they believe they can do. What if they are incorrect about their own assesment. For example, they state their expected success rate of 80%, but they can really perform at 60%.
Then if they get 70%, they are really performing acceptably, but you would say they'd fail.
Yes, it's entirely possible that they are mistaken about their abilities.T'ai Chi said:See my example why. The person could be mistaken about their beliefs (in fact, it is known that people are regularly mistaken, so this seems an obvious point).
If you've followed threads in the Challenge forum, you will no doubt be aware that applicants and potential applicants are routinely advised to perform tests of their own, under similar conditions to an actual challenge test, so that they can figure out for themselves whether they really have the ability they claim, and what success rate they can expect. If they carry out the tests as they are recommended to do, and they actually do have an ability, they should be able to figure out what their success rate is likely to be and to negotiate an appropriate success rate for the challenge.
If they don't bother to test themselves properly before negotiating a target success rate for the challenge, then that's their problem, isn't it?