Dec. 7th, 2014, 73 years later.

Just to remind everyone that the British invaded the mainland of Europe on 3 September 1943 in Operation Baytown :rolleyes: D-Day in Normandy does tend to get all the press.

Yes.
It annoys me a little.
I could never figure quite why Italy didn't count.
 
It annoyed the troops fighting in Italy as well. See The D-Day Dodgers

Both my great uncles were in 2nd NZ Division for the whole duration of the war, from Greece, Crete, North Africa and Italy. When reminiscing in later years they would on occasion make some sniffy comments about "johnnies-come-lately" who only fought for less than a year after D-Day. I think they were annoyed that their biggest moment - capturing Rome - was overshadowed in the press by D-Day the next day. Apparently there existed at some point newsreel footage of one my uncles driving a jeep up the steps of St Peters.
 
Both my great uncles were in 2nd NZ Division for the whole duration of the war, from Greece, Crete, North Africa and Italy. When reminiscing in later years they would on occasion make some sniffy comments about "johnnies-come-lately" who only fought for less than a year after D-Day. I think they were annoyed that their biggest moment - capturing Rome - was overshadowed in the press by D-Day the next day. Apparently there existed at some point newsreel footage of one my uncles driving a jeep up the steps of St Peters.
.
I caught a glimpse of my dad in some D-day newsreel a while ago.
 
Did the Allies occupy the Vatican City?

I don't know, but I suspect that after 4 years of hard fighting at least some bolshie Kiwis weren't going to let a bunch of foreigners in tights and stupid hats tell where they couldn't go. :)

I know that when they occupied a large vineyard in Italy, with cellars stacked 30 feet high with enormous wine barrels, that portion of the Allies consisting of New Zealanders annexed as many fire engine water bowsers as they could find to transport vital military supplies with them as they advanced.

The two incidents may not be unrelated.


.
I caught a glimpse of my dad in some D-day newsreel a while ago.

That is seriously awesome.
 
Pretty bizarre.
The advice of how to shoot a rifle...a slow even squeeze on the trigger rather then a pull...is the first thing you learn when learnng how to use a rifle (In the US Army "don't pull it ,squeeze it" is a main theme of the marksmenship intructors, and I suspect that is true in every military on earth) but then it goes into that truly wack rant about the Natural Order of the Universe.
I'm working out a theory that might explain it, strange as it is.

Emperor worship was established as a state religion to serve as an ideological prop for the Meiji Restoration régime. That meant that certain state activities, which in other countries are normal mundane matters, took on the character in Japan of religious sacraments. And perfectly ordinary writings, like instructions on how to shoot a rifle, started to be treated like holy texts, the correct observation of which would induce divine favour. So that
The enemy fall one after another. Then follows the final assault (tokkwan), then the triumphal tune is sung, the Kimi ga yo is played, and Banzai to the Emperor is shouted. This is the natural order of events.
Evidently, in a régime of state worship, to proclaim a victorious Banzai to the Emperor is an obligatory ceremony, like a Catholic receiving Holy Communion.

This Banzai can't be consecrated unless the Victory has been won. The battle is therefore not a mundane military event leading to some desired political outcome: it is a means of achieving the obligatory ritual status necessary for the valid performance of a ceremony of state worship. That status is attained only through a victorious assault, followed by the triumphal tunes and songs.
 
I have to disagree with you, then hide the body. ;) The Soviet entry into the Pacific War was a complete non-surprise. The Japanese had large forces on Hokkaido specifically to handle this threat. The combination of the bombs and the Soviets was the last straw for the Emperor and most of his advisors, but the bombs were the shocker, they had no idea how many we had. And they were very worried we'd use one on Tokyo, thus threatening the august person.


There was also a large, 800+ aircraft bombing raid on Tokyo on or just before Aug. 14th which may have also provided additional impetus to finally give up fighting. (As the USSBS was to observe, any nation which has lost control over its own airspace has effectively lost the war. Sooner or later the conditions on the ground will catch up to the conditions in the air.)
 
There was also a large, 800+ aircraft bombing raid on Tokyo on or just before Aug. 14th which may have also provided additional impetus to finally give up fighting.
They mention that in Japan's Longest Day.
(As the USSBS was to observe, any nation which has lost control over its own airspace has effectively lost the war. Sooner or later the conditions on the ground will catch up to the conditions in the air.)
Be careful when using the USSBS, even when the information is true. "Hap" Arnold told the USSBS field teams that he would be using the data gathered to support a separate Air Force. This bias shows quite clearly in the material.
 
Be careful when using the USSBS, even when the information is true. "Hap" Arnold told the USSBS field teams that he would be using the data gathered to support a separate Air Force. This bias shows quite clearly in the material.


Noted. But the general observation is correct: if one cannot control one's own airspace, the enemy then has free reign to strike at whatever target they wish whenever they wish in whatever degree they wish. And it has the ability to do unimpeded observation work while denying that to the one's own side. Sooner or later that spells trouble for one's own forces on the ground.
 
Noted. But the general observation is correct: if one cannot control one's own airspace, the enemy then has free reign to strike at whatever target they wish whenever they wish in whatever degree they wish. And it has the ability to do unimpeded observation work while denying that to the one's own side. Sooner or later that spells trouble for one's own forces on the ground.

Very true. I was taking the opportunity to advise against taking the conclusions therein as being entirely accurate.
 
I'm working out a theory that might explain it, strange as it is.

Emperor worship was established as a state religion to serve as an ideological prop for the Meiji Restoration régime. That meant that certain state activities, which in other countries are normal mundane matters, took on the character in Japan of religious sacraments. And perfectly ordinary writings, like instructions on how to shoot a rifle, started to be treated like holy texts, the correct observation of which would induce divine favour. So that Evidently, in a régime of state worship, to proclaim a victorious Banzai to the Emperor is an obligatory ceremony, like a Catholic receiving Holy Communion.

This Banzai can't be consecrated unless the Victory has been won. The battle is therefore not a mundane military event leading to some desired political outcome: it is a means of achieving the obligatory ritual status necessary for the valid performance of a ceremony of state worship. That status is attained only through a victorious assault, followed by the triumphal tunes and songs.


So losing a battle is akin to not being able to find one's rosary beads?
 
Last edited:
So losing a battle is akin to not being able to find one's rosary beads?

"A glorious death excuses all." (Rational? No.) The Japanese believed that if you ended a battle with a splendid show of courage you were exonerated from any blame for previous failures. The Battle of the Ilyu (Tenaru) River is an example of this, I do believe.
 
It annoyed the troops fighting in Italy as well. See The D-Day Dodgers

One of my favorite World War 2 songs.

The Rapido and the Sangro, were taken in our stride,
We did'nt go to fight there, we just went for the ride,
Anzio and Cassino are just names, we just went there to look for dames,
We are the D Day Dodgers, in Sunny Italy.
 
One of my favorite World War 2 songs.

The Rapido and the Sangro, were taken in our stride,
We did'nt go to fight there, we just went for the ride,
Anzio and Cassino are just names, we just went there to look for dames,
We are the D Day Dodgers, in Sunny Italy.

My favourite WW2 song is the one about Dugout Doug.

Dugout Doug MacArthur lies ashaking on the Rock
Safe from all the bombers and from any sudden shock
Dugout Doug is eating of the best food on Bataan
And his troops go starving on.
Dugout Doug's not timid, he's just cautious, not afraid
He's protecting carefully the stars that Franklin made
Four-star generals are rare as good food on Bataan
And his troops go starving on.
Dugout Doug is ready in his Kris Craft for the flee
Over bounding billows and the wildly raging sea
For the Japs are pounding on the gates of Old Bataan
And his troops go starving on...
 
My favourite WW2 song is the one about Dugout Doug.

Dugout Doug MacArthur lies ashaking on the Rock
Safe from all the bombers and from any sudden shock
Dugout Doug is eating of the best food on Bataan
And his troops go starving on.
Dugout Doug's not timid, he's just cautious, not afraid
He's protecting carefully the stars that Franklin made
Four-star generals are rare as good food on Bataan
And his troops go starving on.
Dugout Doug is ready in his Kris Craft for the flee
Over bounding billows and the wildly raging sea
For the Japs are pounding on the gates of Old Bataan
And his troops go starving on...

The US Marines had this little ballad

(Tulagi was a Island a couple of miles off the coast of Guadalcanal which was the scene of savage fighting early in the Guadalcanal campaign)

They Sent for the Army to Come to Tulagi but Dugout Doug said no
He said there's a Reason, It Just Isn't the Season,
Beside there ain't no USO.




We sent for the Army to come to Tulagi
 
My favourite WW2 song is the one about Dugout Doug.

How could you ever forget this one:

DOUG’S COMMUNIQUÉ

For two long years, since blood and tears have been so very rife,
Confusion in our war news burdens more a soldier’s life;
But from this chaos, daily, like a hospice on the way,
Like a shining light to guide us, rises Doug’s Communiqué.

For should we fail to get the mail; if prisoners won’t talk;
If radios are indisposed and carrier pigeons walk,
We have no fear because we’ll hear tomorrow’s news today
And see our operation plan in Doug’s Communiqué.

Here, too, is told the saga bold of virile, deathless youth,
In stories seldom tarnshed with the plain, unvarnished truth.
It’s quite a rag, it waves the flag, its motif is the fray,
And modesty is plain to see, in Doug’s Communiqué.

“My battleships bombard the Nips from Maine to Singapore,
My subs have sunk a million tons; they’ll sink a billion more.
My aircraft bombed Berlin last night.” In Italy they say,
“Our turn’s tonight, because it’s right in Doug’s Communiqué.”

“My armoured tanks have mowed his ranks, so Rommel’s gone to hide.
“And the frozen Steppes of Russia see my wild Don Cossacks ride.
“My brave beleaguered Chetniks make the Axis sweat and pay.”
It’s got to be, it’s what we see in Doug’s Communiqué.

His area is quite cosmic, and capricious as a breeze;
Ninety times as big as Texas, bigger than Los Angeles.
It springs from lost Atlantis, up to where the Angels play,
And no sparrow falls unheeded; it’s in Doug’s Communiqué.

He used to say, “And with God’s help,” but lately it has seemed
That his patience is exhausted, and God’s on his second team.
And the cabots and the lodges, too, have long since ceased to pray
That they’ll ever squeeze a by-line into Doug’s Communiqué.

And while possibly a rumor now, someday ‘twill be a fact,
That the Lord will hear a deep voice say, “Move over God — it’s Mac.”
So bet your shoes that all the news that last great Judgment Day
Will go to press in nothing less than Doug’s Communiqué!​

:blackcat:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom