Dec. 7th, 2014, 73 years later.

They fought the Chinese and won. They fought the Germans and won. Victory disease was a problem they never got a grip on.
During that period they developed some weird ideas. This is from an account of the siege of Port Arthur written by a Japanese veteran.
... the aiming and the pulling of the trigger must be done deliberately, however noisy the place may be, however bloody the scene. This is the secret determining who shall be the victor.
“Pull the trigger as carefully and gently
As the frost falls in the cold night,”
is the poem teaching the secret. Such a cool, deliberate shot is sure to hit the mark. The enemy fall one after another. Then follows the final assault (tokkwan), then the triumphal tune is sung, the Kimi ga yo is played, and Banzai to the Emperor is shouted. This is the natural order of events.
http://www.gutenberg.org/files/47548/47548-h/47548-h.htm
So anything less than victory is a sort of violation of the universal cosmic order.
 
During that period they developed some weird ideas. This is from an account of the siege of Port Arthur written by a Japanese veteran. http://www.gutenberg.org/files/47548/47548-h/47548-h.htm
So anything less than victory is a sort of violation of the universal cosmic order.

Yep. I'm currently re-reading Japan's Longest Day. It was written in the '70s and the authors interviewed those still living who were involved in ending the war, plus copious other sources. The people that accepted the reality of defeat were opposed by those who would rather die (and take the entire country with them) than surrender. It was a near run thing. Attempts were made to "protect" the Emperor from the "traitors" who wanted to announce Hirohito's desire to end the fighting. They weren't willing to admit that the "the war had progressed in a fashion not necessarily favorable to Japan." :rolleyes:
 
There are those that say our invasion of Europe was mainly to keep the Russians from occupying all of Europe. Not to beat the Germans, which was being done rather well by the Russians in 1944.
 
There are those that say our invasion of Europe was mainly to keep the Russians from occupying all of Europe. Not to beat the Germans, which was being done rather well by the Russians in 1944.
I don't think that was the main motive. When did the preparations for D-Day start? Months before.
 
I don't think that was the main motive. When did the preparations for D-Day start? Months before.

The urgency became apparent after the crushing defeat of the Germans at Kursk in July-Aug. 1943. The Quebec Conference occurred the 3rd week in August of 1943. This is the conference where the invasion of Europe was put into motion, and where the joint efforts to build a nuke were talked about.

The Russians destroyed the German Eastern Front at Kursk. The war was over for the Germans after that battle for certain.

Is it a coincidence that the New Allied command set up for the invasion was called COSSAC? Chief of Staff to the Supreme Allied Commander

Cossacks weren't just a peaceful lot were they? They were the ones who fought the Bolsheviks in the Russian Civil War.
 
Last edited:
Is it a coincidence that the New Allied command set up for the invasion was called COSSAC? Chief of Staff to the Supreme Allied Commander

Cossacks weren't just a peaceful lot were they? They were the ones who fought the Bolsheviks in the Russian Civil War.
I think that's a bit fanciful. Anyway, some fought on the Red side.

In other titles and combinations were the expressions "chief of staff" and "Supreme Allied Commander" abbreviated in that way?
 
Um.
COSSAC was assigned months before either Quebec or Kursk.
The base planning for invasion began in late '42, with Morgan made COSSAC in early '43.

And lets not forget that Stalin kept pushing for a second front.
 
The urgency must have been pressing in Early 1944 to get onto the Mainland for both reasons.
 
The urgency must have been pressing in Early 1944 to get onto the Mainland for both reasons.
But they were already committed to the invasion. And Stalin continually berated them for any delay.

Even after Kursk, the Soviet Union was faced with a colossal task. Millions more casualties were incurred.
 
+Cossacks weren't just a peaceful lot were they? They were the ones who fought the Bolsheviks in the Russian Civil War.

MacArthur requested that the US do all it could to make sure the USSR invade Hokkaido to draw troops away from Kyushu. I haven't found much that supports the notion that we were worried about a divided Japan. Mission One was to end the war.
 
The Russians destroyed the German Eastern Front at Kursk.
No, that happened in consequence of Operation Bagration.
The operation resulted in the almost complete destruction of an entire German army group, with the loss of Army Group Centre's Fourth Army, Third Panzer Army and Ninth Army. It is considered the most calamitous defeat experienced by the German armed forces during the Second World War.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Bagration
It was launched on 22 June 1944, subsequent to D-Day. The initial phase ended only on 14 August. German Army Group Centre was more or less eliminated as an effective fighting force.
 
Last edited:
The Army and Navy weren't very responsive to government control. The constitution was modified in ... 1932 IIRC, to allow only active duty officers to be War Minister and Navy Minister. If the military didn't like what a government was doing they'd order the Minister to resign, killing the government. The "Big Six"* dominated the government to the point where nobody else was able to get anything done if the top dogs didn't like it.

On Dec. 7th, 1941, Tojo Hidecki was Prime Minister and War Minister. This give you a feel for how much military domination there was at the time.

*Prime Minister, Secretary of State, War Minister, Navy Minister, Army Chief of Staff, and Navy Chief of Staff,

The old joke about Prussia not being a nation with an army,but an army with a nation,applies even more to Japan from 1932 to 1945.
 
During that period they developed some weird ideas. This is from an account of the siege of Port Arthur written by a Japanese veteran. http://www.gutenberg.org/files/47548/47548-h/47548-h.htm
So anything less than victory is a sort of violation of the universal cosmic order.

Pretty bizarre.
The advice of how to shoot a rifle...a slow even squeeze on the trigger rather then a pull...is the first thing you learn when learnng how to use a rifle (In the US Army "don't pull it ,squeeze it" is a main theme of the marksmenship intructors, and I suspect that is true in every military on earth) but then it goes into that truly wack rant about the Natural Order of the Universe.
 
Yep. I'm currently re-reading Japan's Longest Day. It was written in the '70s and the authors interviewed those still living who were involved in ending the war, plus copious other sources. The people that accepted the reality of defeat were opposed by those who would rather die (and take the entire country with them) than surrender. It was a near run thing. Attempts were made to "protect" the Emperor from the "traitors" who wanted to announce Hirohito's desire to end the fighting. They weren't willing to admit that the "the war had progressed in a fashion not necessarily favorable to Japan." :rolleyes:

People forget that even after the Nagasaki bomb, many high up in the Military wanted to fight to the bitter end, attempted a palace coup,and nearly suceeded.
 
There are those that say our invasion of Europe was mainly to keep the Russians from occupying all of Europe. Not to beat the Germans, which was being done rather well by the Russians in 1944.

You have been misinformed.
 
People forget that even after the Nagasaki bomb, many high up in the Military wanted to fight to the bitter end, attempted a palace coup,and nearly suceeded.

Well there thinking had reached such a despicable level they simply saw it as just another destroyed city. The real motivator for the surrender was the Soviets opening their offensive against Japan. The Japanese might have feared and hated Americans, but the thought of Soviet soldiers in Yokohama almost produced involuntary bowel motions.
 
Well there thinking had reached such a despicable level they simply saw it as just another destroyed city. The real motivator for the surrender was the Soviets opening their offensive against Japan. The Japanese might have feared and hated Americans, but the thought of Soviet soldiers in Yokohama almost produced involuntary bowel motions.

I have to disagree with you, then hide the body. ;) The Soviet entry into the Pacific War was a complete non-surprise. The Japanese had large forces on Hokkaido specifically to handle this threat. The combination of the bombs and the Soviets was the last straw for the Emperor and most of his advisors, but the bombs were the shocker, they had no idea how many we had. And they were very worried we'd use one on Tokyo, thus threatening the august person.
 
I don't think that was the main motive. When did the preparations for D-Day start? Months before.

Just to remind everyone that the British invaded the mainland of Europe on 3 September 1943 in Operation Baytown :rolleyes: D-Day in Normandy does tend to get all the press.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom