Debunking a meme: clock vs suitcase bomb.

In your examples wasn't a crucial part that the bomb thrower claimed it was a bomb when they threw it?

Only in one case, the little boy on the bus actually claimed he was carrying a bomb. In the other three cases, it was an implication - an "improvised electronic device" was all that people saw, but it provoked the reaction. The man in the terminal for instance pulled out a "trigger like device" whose wires trailed into his bag and began pushing it, but none of the articles I saw mention that he actually verbally said anything about it being a bomb. People are conditioned, mostly by entertainment media, to look at a hand-held trigger connected to wires leading underneath a person's clothing or to some other concealed place and think "bomb", specifically "suicide bomb", and so that's how they reacted.
 
Only in one case, the little boy on the bus actually claimed he was carrying a bomb. In the other three cases, it was an implication - an "improvised electronic device" was all that people saw, but it provoked the reaction. The man in the terminal for instance pulled out a "trigger like device" whose wires trailed into his bag and began pushing it, but none of the articles I saw mention that he actually verbally said anything about it being a bomb. People are conditioned, mostly by entertainment media, to look at a hand-held trigger connected to wires leading underneath a person's clothing or to some other concealed place and think "bomb", specifically "suicide bomb", and so that's how they reacted.

Fair enough. pulling out a trigger-lie device with wires leading to a bag and pushing it toward other people would be likely to inspire a feeling that it was a bomb for use as a weapon. So would someone in a cafeteria yelling that they had a steak knife in their pocket and approaching a fellow diner while holding their hand in their pocket and mumbling curses under his breadth. I have no illusion that in a confrontation it is possible to create concern in a reasonable person that someone intends to use a bomb or a knife as a weapon, even if the bomb or knife isn't real.

However, the OP the authorities had a very calm situation and lots of time to examine the "device" which clearly was a clock on examination, and to ask the 14 year old what it was, which he said was...a clock. As I and others have stated, the initial concern/curiosity in the high school as to the identity of the object was reasonable. Clearly immediate inspection revealed it was not a bomb or even a fake bomb (nothing that looked like explosives was revealed during this inspection). The boy readily confirmed this. There was no attempt by the boy to present it as a weapon. There was no way for the boy to use it either as a weapon and no evidence that he would ever use it even as a fake weapon (it would have made a poor one indeed given how no one at the school took it seriously as a real bomb). If the incident had stopped there we would never have learned about it or discussed it.

I also have stated that I would have not been disturbed if a teacher confiscated the clock for the day, or told the kid to not play with it during classes. I received the same reaction when I was in school if I brought in a fancy pen and began to show it around- it is distracting to the teaching environment. But then, just give the kid back his project to take home after class. Or better still, ask the kid if it could be left in the engineering teacher's classroom as an example of a student's "project." This sort of thing happens every day (do you think high school art work needs to be that of a genius to be displayed?). But here the school went ballistic: they confined the student, suspended him, and called the police, who in turn arrested him in handcuffs and refused his requests to call his parents. That is what was stupid, justifiably made the news, and what angers me.

A comparable example: someone has their hand in their pocket without making a claim that he has a knife; he acts perfectly calm and normal and goes about his school reading. A teacher asks "What's in your pocket?" The student answers that is it just his house key and pulls it out, emptying his pocket to show there is only a key. The school principal pulls the kid into his/her office and accuses the kid of making a knife threat and has him arrested. Sure, a pocket might have a knife. A person with their hand in an empty pocket may even be suspected to maybe have a knife in it, particularly if they are threatening someone in a confrontation and intentionally making it look as if there is a knife in there. But if the person is making no threat, not acting funny (other than being dark skinned and Muslim that is), and shows that it is only a key in his pocket when asked, making a big deal and arresting them is just stupid (and IMHO bigoted).
 
The teacher seems to have thought it looked like a Hollywood depiction of a bomb. There's little to no indication that the teacher thought it could have been a real bomb that required a real bomb threat response.

Ultimately, the kid got in trouble for allegedly making a bomb hoax, not for making a bomb.

All true. But the hoax was generated in the mind of the teacher.
 
A few general notes on explosives.

Electric blasting caps can be detonated by very low electric currents. When working with electric blasting caps the army does not allow radios to be anywhere near them. The caps come with the wires shunted together so that they cannot act as an antennae. If the wires are separated and a radio in close proximity transmits there is a chance the nearby radio could induce a current that triggers the cap.

My knowledge about that dates back to the 80s before cell phones. Although cell phones emit very little power compared to the military radios used back then, I doubt they would let anyone have their phones on when working with demolitions. Probably best to collect them up and keep them a 100 meters or so away.

What that also means is that if you did find a bomb and there were only two wires leading into the explosive, cutting them might stop the bomb from detonating when intended but lead to you accidentally triggering the explosion by using some sort of radio device such as a cell phone in very close proximity. Although the odds of that are rather low. A two way radio like those used by the police would be more dangerous. If you cut the wires you should immediately shunt them together assuming that there are no other wires leading into the explosive.

That said, if you were dealing with a bomb put together by somebody with an electronics background you might have other worries in various combinations:

1.) There could be more wires that might be a second detonator.
2.) The ones you cut could just be a decoy with the real wires hidden somewhere.
3.) Adding to item 2, the wires could in fact be set up so that if you cut them the bomb detonates because you broke a circuit that must be maintained to prevent detonation.
4.) If there is a capacitor of reasonable size anywhere in the circuit the device could have been built to detonate when the power source is removed.
5.) Non-electric booby trapping could have been done to set off the bomb if you start moving things around to look for additional wires. This could take the form of a "mouse trap" type devices and a non-electric blasting cap. (Note that this does not require an actual mouse trap. Look up the M5 pressure-release firing device for a military grade example.)

That said, the bomber would need a fair amount of knowledge to make the above work. Most notably if he is building a complex circuit with a transistor as a switch he has to worry about killing himself if there is serious leakage current through that transistor. That can be accounted for but might take a bit of experimentation.

Means of detonation could be a timer using existing digital watches is or was quite common. One specific model of Casio digital watch was often used in the middle east at one time and apparently did not produce leakage current problems I described above. I do not recall what model that was. Cell phones have been used for command detonation more recently. Not sure how well they do with the leakage current problem since those were not around when I was learning about this sort of thing.

What all of that means for the average person is that if you saw something that looked like a bomb the only safe thing to do is get everybody away from it.
 
Last edited:
In the 80s one of the European radical groups exclusively used a particular brand of very reliable cheap alarm clock for their bombs. (Source: classified intelligence reports I handled at the time)

The briefcase upthread reminded me of a device I bought years ago at an auction. It was an 8088 based microprocessor training device, with breadboard and some I/O stuff on board. Would have made a convincing prop with about 10 lines of machine language code to drive a number display.

According to countless news stories, the cheap and ubiquitous Casio F91W is often used as a timer.

According to Wiki, this is what a bomb timer looks like:

220px-Al_Qaida_watch_timer_on_perf_board_84071_-abc.jpg
 
According to countless news stories, the cheap and ubiquitous Casio F91W is often used as a timer.

According to Wiki, this is what a bomb timer looks like:

[qimg]https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/ca/Al_Qaida_watch_timer_on_perf_board_84071_-abc.jpg/220px-Al_Qaida_watch_timer_on_perf_board_84071_-abc.jpg[/qimg]

Even simpler than what I would have expected. Components include one voltage regulator integrated circuit, one transistor, one capacitor, 5 resistors, one or two diodes (cannot tell for sure from the image), one LED (although it looks a little fuzzy in the picture), one battery, one battery connector, one watch, one proto board, a small amount of wire and some solder.
 
Last edited:
According to countless news stories, the cheap and ubiquitous Casio F91W is often used as a timer.

According to Wiki, this is what a bomb timer looks like:

[qimg]https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/ca/Al_Qaida_watch_timer_on_perf_board_84071_-abc.jpg/220px-Al_Qaida_watch_timer_on_perf_board_84071_-abc.jpg[/qimg]

The specific bombs I was reading about used a wind up mechanical clock with screws through the clear plastic to contact the hands. It sounds crude but the end product was apparently very reliable. Also, this was in the days when terrorist groups had competition in the marketplace and felt the need to self identify, as well as announce attacks and issue press releases afterward taking credit for them. The specific clock had limited geographic distribution and served as a trademark of sorts.
 
Was talking about this over the weekend with the Mrs. As a parent of an 8-yr old, my biggest problem with this whole thing is the alleged "interrogation" where they denied his request to talk to his parents. In which case I don't blame the parents for finding a different school for their son.

It hits close to home as this high school is not too far from where I live. Fortunately my child does not go to school in this district.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom