Debunking a meme: clock vs suitcase bomb.

True dat. And, there really isn't a "thing that a bomb looks like." The Uni-bomber made at least one that looked like a piece of lumber. I don't think it would be uncommon to disguise a real device - meaning even bombs don't look like bombs.

Fake bombs, on the other hand, are intentionally designed to "look like" the public perception of a "bomb"; that's the entire point. Fake bombs are meant to be seen, not hidden, because they aren't meant to destroy anything, but to cause a reaction.

And the "random wires and electrical components" motif is actually quite prolific in hoax bombs. Last year in New York, a disturbed man entered a military recruiting station and threw a fake bomb at personnel before quickly leaving; he was apprehended later. The "bomb" was a briefcase that contained a cobbled-together set of wires and PCBs. In 2011 at LaGuardia airport, a homeless man came into the terminal with a bag, pulled a wired trigger-looking mechanism out of it, and started pressing it, causing wide panic. Police later found the wires to lead to a similar nest of random electrical components inside the bag. That same year a young boy in Wisconsin threatened to blow up his elementary school bus with a fake bomb, a device made up of some kind of game controller and duct-taped batteries, and again a number of random wires. In 2007 a couple of tabloid journalists were arrested for trying to smuggle a fake bomb again consisting of the favorite wires and parts onto the London subway hoping to be able to write an article about lax security (they later complained that they should not have been subject to the decidedly un-lax security response the stunt caused because they were journalists doing an investigation, not real terrorists). And on it goes.
 
Last edited:
Fake bombs, on the other hand, are intentionally designed to "look like" the public perception of a "bomb"; that's the entire point. Fake bombs are meant to be seen, not hidden, because they aren't meant to destroy anything, but to cause a reaction.

And the "random wires and electrical components" motif is actually quite prolific in hoax bombs. Last year in New York, a disturbed man entered a military recruiting station and threw a fake bomb at personnel before quickly leaving; he was apprehended later. The "bomb" was a briefcase that contained a cobbled-together set of wires and PCBs. In 2011 at LaGuardia airport, a homeless man came into the terminal with a bag, pulled a wired trigger-looking mechanism out of it, and started pressing it, causing wide panic. Police later found the wires to lead to a similar nest of random electrical components inside the bag. That same year a young boy in Wisconsin threatened to blow up his elementary school bus with a fake bomb, a device made up of some kind of game controller and duct-taped batteries, and again a number of random wires. In 2007 a couple of tabloid journalists were arrested for trying to smuggle a fake bomb again consisting of the favorite wires and parts onto the London subway hoping to be able to write an article about lax security (they later complained that they should not have been subject to the decidedly un-lax security response the stunt caused because they were journalists doing an investigation, not real terrorists). And on it goes.
Agreed: fake bombs are intended to look like bombs: wires, switches, possible timers, and things that look like explosives. It really helps if you also, at the time, yell "Duck- it's a bomb!"

Things that just look like clocks: not so effective. In fact, clocks sort of often look like clocks. And if you yell "Clock!" it tales a lot away from the effect.
 
I have absolutely zero expertise in bomb making, but I will go out on a limb and say that any bomb that has to be plugged in so that it can work has a critical design flaw.

But it can save you a fortune in batteries. Come on- what is your priority? "Excuse me- can I use your outlet? I need it to blow up your house."
 
Hmm. The picture is clearly the same but has much better resolution.

The tag on the suitcase says Novell. One can make out the words 'Charge Demolition M112' on the circuit board near the handle.
The picture doesn't make sense to me. I have no idea what it shows but it certainly does not look like a bomb: Where's the explosive? Instead you have a huge circuit board with an electrial plug?

The suitcase tag I assume is a promotional luggage tag with a Novel logo like the ones shown at the MicroFocus Wiki Novell Museum Luggage Tags page.

I hadn't thought of downloading the picture to see a larger version but now that I have it does show Charge Demolition M112 LOT 19 DATE 2006 which I believe is a label for C4 explosive.

It appears to have been formed to fit in the front magnetic latch area and under the circuit boards with a strip of the C4 running up on to the electronics. So I'm now thinking that is a picture of a salesman's demo unit for an industrial controller board that is a booby trap. It could also be a training device to show a suitcase booby trap or a movie prop.
 
Last edited:
I feel that I should make my position on this topic absolutely clear:

If you try to board an airplane and you set off the metal detector, security should have to right to stop you and ask you what is in your pocket. If you pull out a cell phone and state it is a cell phone, typically security will re-test you with a metal detector and at that point let you through. If they have a specific reason to be extra suspicious, they might ask you to show them that the cell phone actually works as a cell phone.

Okay by me if a teacher hears a beep coming from a kid's back pack and asks the kid to show them and tell them what was making the beep. Probably okay even to hold on to some items until the end of the day even if they aren't dangerous, but if they are likely to disrupt the kid's classes: fancy pens, pictures of the last big party, unusual jewelry, uncontrollable noise makers, etc., although I would want real evidence that the kid will use the items in a way that might be disruptive.

Although it can yield stupid responses if extended too far, I even am okay with confiscating a device expressly made to look like a weapon ("Yeah, it's a real gun! Well okay, it only shoots blanks..., but it looks real doesn't it?").

But to detain and suspend the student, have him arrested and questioned by the police, etc. when the beep is revealed to have been caused by a clock? Just stupid. It should have stopped with "Hey what's that beeping in your backpack? A clock? Neat. But please don't plug it in, take the battery out, and wait until after school to show your friends!"
 
The suitcase tag I assume is a promotional luggage tag with a Novel logo like the ones shown at the MicroFocus Wiki Novell Museum Luggage Tags page.

I hadn't thought of downloading the picture to see a larger version but now that I have it does show Charge Demolition M112 LOT 19 DATE 2006 which I believe is a label for C4 explosive.

It appears to have been formed to fit in the front magnetic latch area and under the circuit boards with a strip of the C4 running up on to the electronics. So I'm now thinking that is a picture of a salesman's demo unit for an industrial controller board that is a booby trap. It could also be a training device to show a suitcase booby trap or a movie prop.
It really leaves me confused. Novell appears to be mostly a computer/data security firm and I haven't found any evidence that it operates against physical threats. Plus getting on board a plane with real or dummy plastique explosive sounds like a stupid risk of long jail time or being shot simply to demo a controller board or a suitcase prop to a client. And whatever "secrets" might be in the electronics, I find it hard to believe that a salerep would willingly put themselves at a personal risk of blowing themselves up if they forget how to avoid a real booby-trap. If I were the sales rep I would wonder if the company was trying to "down-size."

Any more information?
 
As I pointed out in the other thread, a timer is a nice (but unnecessary) item on a bomb, but a quantity of explosive is absolutely necessary. And to do any amount of damage, a pretty fair bit of explosive.
 
Agreed: fake bombs are intended to look like bombs: wires, switches, possible timers, and things that look like explosives.

The italicized doesn't seem to have featured in any of the examples I gave of fake bombs. It appears to be the consensus of most fake-bomb makers that the mere appearance of a homemade electronic "device" with exposed components and wires is sufficient enough to evoke the desired effect, and that creating and including fake "explosives" is not a necessary part of the hoax object.
 
It really leaves me confused. Novell appears to be mostly a computer/data security firm and I haven't found any evidence that it operates against physical threats. Plus getting on board a plane with real or dummy plastique explosive sounds like a stupid risk of long jail time or being shot simply to demo a controller board or a suitcase prop to a client. And whatever "secrets" might be in the electronics, I find it hard to believe that a salerep would willingly put themselves at a personal risk of blowing themselves up if they forget how to avoid a real booby-trap. If I were the sales rep I would wonder if the company was trying to "down-size."

Any more information?

My thought is that is a promotional luggage tag and is not meant to show that the case is owned by Novell, only that the guy who owns the case met with a Novell sales person at some point and was given the luggage tag. I've gotten all kinds of logo branded merchandise from salesman over the years.

Poking around the site abaddon linked above, I found it is definitely a reduced size version of the same photo. If you check the EXIF data it has the same make, model and and creation date as the larger pics on other sites. I also found that the guy writing about the trip to Malta is ex-army and was working for Honeywell in their security division. So it seems most likely the suitcase is a Honeywell salesman's demo unit that has been modified to be an instructional prop suitcase bomb (almost certainly it's simulated C4).

The site abaddon found: Malta "Honeywell EMEA Partner of Choice Meeting."
Other pages from that site:
Security Systems and Business Logic
Honeywell Global Kick Off
El Salvadoran Army Training
Anti-Armor Ambush

So while it almost certainly isn't an actual bomb, considering it was likely made by an ex-Army security professional as a training device, it is most likely a good representation of what a booby trapped salesman's demo suitcase could look like.
 
Last edited:
If I were to make a suitcase device, it would be almost entirely payload, with a small controller box on it with a switch to arm it and a single LED that lit up to indicate it was armed.

The controller box might have a time-delay clock inside, that determines how long after arming the thing actually... does it's thing. But as a device maker, I'd be ashamed of my craft if I needed visible clock display.
Then how do you expect James Bond to defuse your bomb exactly 7 seconds before it would go off?
 
The italicized doesn't seem to have featured in any of the examples I gave of fake bombs. It appears to be the consensus of most fake-bomb makers that the mere appearance of a homemade electronic "device" with exposed components and wires is sufficient enough to evoke the desired effect, and that creating and including fake "explosives" is not a necessary part of the hoax object.

In your examples wasn't a crucial part that the bomb thrower claimed it was a bomb when they threw it? Or wouldn't the reaction have been to think oh he is throwing an alarm clock? And weren't the reporters testing security, and in fact claim it was not meant to look like a bomb? But I would nonetheless appreciate a citation where these fake bombs didn't have fake explosives or were at least claimed to have explosives in them.

Actually I don't disagree with you that anything with a timer and lose wires might generate suspicion and questions. I've flown r/c airplanes and received some suspicion after 9/11. But if I explained it people were reassured. If it is clearly a clock project on inspection, and the owner says so as well, it strikes me that arresting the owner is a bit over the top. Especially if they are a 14 year old boy.

Further, I think we are agreed that it wasn't a real bomb and that the school and police quickly came to the same conclusion that it was not a real bomb. So the question isn't did it look like a bomb, because it didn't, but was it intended to look like a fake bomb? Given that the boy repeatedly told people it was not a bomb, and anyone with any sense could quickly confirm that by just looking at it, then what could justify any punishment?
 
My older brother works in a retail store that sells, among other things, alarm clocks and pencil boxes like the one the kid used. I suggested that he should put them on sale, have them together in a display labeled "Crafting Supplies" and see if anyone calls the police.:)
 
I have absolutely zero expertise in bomb making, but I will go out on a limb and say that any bomb that has to be plugged in so that it can work has a critical design flaw.

Power on arms. power off detonates. Didn't you see Speed?
 
According to a post on this other site, "It's a Honeywell security sales demo kit".

I took something like that on a plane a couple of times. It was a case that just barely fit in an overhead compartment. It had a power supply, with power cord, and a group of circuit boards in it. It was the control system for an arc welding machine - minus the welding power supply. It was just the computers that made the thing work. I took it with me to factories because I could rig it to do testing of newly written software in my hotel room.

The most amusing incident with it came at the airport in Monterrey, Mexico. I was changing planes, and had to go through security again. I spoke no Spanish. They spoke no English. I knew miscellaneous words of Spanish, can communicate poorly in French, and just barely a little bit in German, so my attempted explanation was a bizarre mix of English, Spanish, French and German words. After a minute or so, a guard motioned that he would fetch someone, and looked at me with an inquisitive look, started wagging a hand back and forth and said, "Tick, tick, tick?"

Fortunately, everyone involved had a sense of humor, they fetched someone who spoke English, they swabbed the case for explosives (just like they would most laptops these days) and I was on my way.
 
This meme has been circulating in online discussions re the Ahmed Mohamed business, purporting to show how much the kid's invention resembles a real actual bomb.

I've never seen a real, actual bomb, but that device on the right seems a bit overly Rube Goldbergian to be a simple explosive device.

Can anyone help identify that?

Thanks.

View attachment 33805

It's dumb because it shows an analogue clock face, as if that's only what a clock can look like.
 
Then how do you expect James Bond to defuse your bomb exactly 7 seconds before it would go off?

I'm no explosives expert, but can't you just isolate the detonator (blasting cap) and cut it's wires? Look for a wired gismo stuck into the powder/plastique.

Hmm, I wonder if the bomb squad has non-conductive ceramic nippers?
 
Last edited:
As I pointed out in the other thread, a timer is a nice (but unnecessary) item on a bomb, but a quantity of explosive is absolutely necessary. And to do any amount of damage, a pretty fair bit of explosive.

Isn't it possible to have a remote detonator device that would set off the explosives which had been placed at a different location? I suspect that what the teacher thought it was was not the explosives part of the 'bomb', but the control unit, or fake control unit.
 
I somehow doubt the English teacher was considering the situation in such depth. The cell phone is a far handier and more effective device for such purposes anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom