Debunking a meme: clock vs suitcase bomb.

HeyLeroy

Vegan Cannibal
Joined
Oct 14, 2005
Messages
5,567
This meme has been circulating in online discussions re the Ahmed Mohamed business, purporting to show how much the kid's invention resembles a real actual bomb.

I've never seen a real, actual bomb, but that device on the right seems a bit overly Rube Goldbergian to be a simple explosive device.

Can anyone help identify that?

Thanks.

11221945_892939474123476_6605102287863798730_n.jpg
 
Well, where are the explosives on the right? Or on the left?

Are they attempting to make a point that time bombs have timers/clocks? Duh.

In fact, not all have electronic timers or electronic clocks, but use mechanical clocks or chemical fuses. If one wants to create a threatening looking "bomb":

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/IncrediblyObviousBomb
 
Last edited:
Hard to tell from the tiny image but it looks like a salesman's demo unit for an industrial controller board.

There is far too much electronic circuitry, especially user inputs, built in there for it to be a normal suitcase bomb.
 
If I were to make a suitcase device, it would be almost entirely payload, with a small controller box on it with a switch to arm it and a single LED that lit up to indicate it was armed.

The controller box might have a time-delay clock inside, that determines how long after arming the thing actually... does it's thing. But as a device maker, I'd be ashamed of my craft if I needed visible clock display.
 
Why would a suitcase bomb need a power cord? They both have it. You have to plug it in? That sort of defeats the purpose doesn't it?
 
Not many people can expect to know what a bomb looks like. I have no problem people may have thought it was a bomb. It was how they went about the situation. Maybe take the kid aside and as casual as you can, try and figure out what it is. Shouldn't take long.
 
As others have pointed out, current bomb makers favor cell phones as detonators. I suppose one might want something a bit fancier if one were going for something set off my pressure, magnetism, or something like that. But a basic bomb does not need much

Also, the school non-hoax bomb is much smaller than a briefcase - 5 inches by 8 inches by two inches. It can be hard to tell in the stock photo of it.
 
According to a post on this other site, "It's a Honeywell security sales demo kit".
Hmm. The picture is clearly the same but has much better resolution.

The tag on the suitcase says Novell. One can make out the words 'Charge Demolition M112' on the circuit board near the handle.
The picture doesn't make sense to me. I have no idea what it shows but it certainly does not look like a bomb: Where's the explosive? Instead you have a huge circuit board with an electrial plug?
 
Good job everyone involved in debunking this. Now I gotta remember which of my dumb facebook friends shared this dumb meme.
 
In the 80s one of the European radical groups exclusively used a particular brand of very reliable cheap alarm clock for their bombs. (Source: classified intelligence reports I handled at the time)

The briefcase upthread reminded me of a device I bought years ago at an auction. It was an 8088 based microprocessor training device, with breadboard and some I/O stuff on board. Would have made a convincing prop with about 10 lines of machine language code to drive a number display.
 
I have absolutely zero expertise in bomb making, but I will go out on a limb and say that any bomb that has to be plugged in so that it can work has a critical design flaw.
 
He never claimed it was a bomb. The school/police didn't think it was a bomb either, which is why they didn't evacuate the school. No one ever thought it was an actual bomb. This is a story that originally started with "wow, that could be confused with a bomb" by ignorant ignoramuses.
 
He never claimed it was a bomb. The school/police didn't think it was a bomb either, which is why they didn't evacuate the school. No one ever thought it was an actual bomb. This is a story that originally started with "wow, that could be confused with a bomb" by ignorant ignoramuses.

The teacher seems to have thought it could have been a bomb. So there was no certainty but there was a suspicion on one person's part.
 
I have absolutely zero expertise in bomb making, but I will go out on a limb and say that any bomb that has to be plugged in so that it can work has a critical design flaw.

Note to self: add useless power cord to get through security.
 
The teacher seems to have thought it could have been a bomb. So there was no certainty but there was a suspicion on one person's part.

The teacher seems to have thought it looked like a Hollywood depiction of a bomb. There's little to no indication that the teacher thought it could have been a real bomb that required a real bomb threat response.

Ultimately, the kid got in trouble for allegedly making a bomb hoax, not for making a bomb.
 
Not many people can expect to know what a bomb looks like. I have no problem people may have thought it was a bomb. It was how they went about the situation. Maybe take the kid aside and as casual as you can, try and figure out what it is. Shouldn't take long.

True dat. And, there really isn't a "thing that a bomb looks like." The Uni-bomber made at least one that looked like a piece of lumber. I don't think it would be uncommon to disguise a real device - meaning even bombs don't look like bombs.

Unless... maybe that black, cannon ball thing with the fuse sticking out? The one popular with Boris Badenov and Wile E. Coyote?
 
The teacher seems to have thought it looked like a Hollywood depiction of a bomb. There's little to no indication that the teacher thought it could have been a real bomb that required a real bomb threat response.

Ultimately, the kid got in trouble for allegedly making a bomb hoax, not for making a bomb.

Except he wasn't making a bomb hoax: he was making a clock. And the clock looked like a clock, not a bomb fake or otherwise. And he said so when asked.

If one teacher thought it looked like a fake bomb (out of ignorance and IMHO bigotry) then okay- ask the student what it is and ask others what they think. Ask him to open it up. But apparently people in authority at the school assumed it was intended as a bomb threat for no reason other than not understanding what the inside of an alarm clock looks like. And the police failed to supply any rationality to this craziness: they arrested the kid in handcuffs and violated his rights by refusing him his request to call his parents.

I am pained by this effort among conservatives to minimize or distort this event to suggest "Well it looked like a bomb." In fact it did not look like anything a bomb, it looked like a clock. It looked less like a bomb than does a regular umbrella looks like a epee. "Well, it was fair to investigate a potential threat." In fact, it was never presented nor looked like a potential threat, only the ignorant or bigoted would have seen it in this way. Even so, everything after the English teacher asking the boy what it was, and confiscating it until the end of the day, was not a legitimate investigation but was a crazy, over-the-top, dreadful abuse of a 14 year old boy highly interested in technology and education, both emotionally and in terms of his legal rights.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom