Daniel Tammett - Savant Without the Disadvantages

A related point I wonder is just how good are "photographic" memories really since so many of the memory world records and championships seem to be held by people with normal memories using mnemonic strategies.
Many years ago, I had a friend who could play blindfolded 10 simultaneous chess games. I ask him how he could do it. At the time I thought that he "reconstructed" mentally the games as he went from one game to the next. But no. He said that the position just "appeared" in his head as if he opened drawers with chessboards in them.

So I guess in his case it was photographic memory and not a mnemonic strategies.

nimzo
 
Baron said:
I think that's the point. He doesn't make mistakes of memory any more than you would make a mistake reading the digits off a page.
But I surely would make mistakes reading the digits. It's a pantload of digits! No human brain process is perfect.

Besides, he's nowhere near world record standard. This guy recited 100,000 digits without error.
Well, that's just plain sick.

~~ Paul
 
I saw the show on Tammet. Interesting. I understand he had some sort of seizure when he was young, and that they are hypothesizing that perhaps damage to a certain part of the brain allows more resources to be devoted to a different area.
 
I saw the show on Tammet. Interesting. I understand he had some sort of seizure when he was young, and that they are hypothesizing that perhaps damage to a certain part of the brain allows more resources to be devoted to a different area.

Well, yeah, what you mention about the hypothesis is precisely what is so fascinating about savants in general to me, including persons who grew up without developmental delays who were later sustained brain injuries and suddenly gained preternatural abilities they had never had previous, primarily in the arts (Oliver Sacks writes about some of them, and I have seen some profiled on Discovery or the Science Channel).

The suggestion is that the ordinary human brain is capable of far more than we used to think is is. It suggests that perhaps within each of us lies a potential for developing mental skills, or lie hidden, dormant talents, that are far beyond what we usually experience. That doesn't mean each of us is a potential Rembrandt. It means, rather, that we trade specialization for generalization.

Critical to understanding that is the concept of mental "filters," if you will. Consider the sheer volume of sensory input that comes at someone trying to cross a busy intersection on foot in New York City. If our brains had to analyze consciously all of that sensory input, sort it out and make sense of all of it, process it, and make decisions based upon it, we would be paralyzed into inaction. We would cower in fear and collapse in frustration and sensory overload.

That's not what happens to most of us, however. Most of us have well-functioning filters in place to discard most of the sensory input, and pay attention only to the relevant information that matters. We ignore the conversation between the two persons behind us about whether Guici or Louis Vitton handbags are better, and we focus instead on the signal in the crosswalk and the traffic approaching the intersection.

We have to do that constantly, in every situation. In other words, we allocate our brain's limited resources to a multitude of tasks. This is true whether we navigate the African savannah and avoid being eaten, but still find food for ourselves, or whether we navigate the urban jungle of streets and crowds and avoid being splatter on the pavement but still get our Starbucks.

Now, imagine if we could harvest all our brains' resources and devote them to more abstract tasks, like math. Imagine we don't have to go out on the streets and avoid hazards and also find food, but we live in an inner world devoted to and obsessed with prime numbers, for instance. It's not only our time that is devoted to thinking about prime numbers, but also a greater proportion of our brains' thinking capacity. When taken to its extremes, that leads to persons like Tammet (albeit he is quite the standout from the already exceedingly rare class of savants) being able to develop extraordinary talents with plain old human brains. Tammet is quite human, and he possesses a human brain. It is an extraordinary one, but it is a human one just like yours and mine are.

AS
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom