Daniel Tammett - Savant Without the Disadvantages

I'm talking about actual biological mutations. I wonder if there are any significant ones in the portion of his genome related to his brain function?

~~ Paul
Wish you had said so originally. Until now you've just talked about mutations in brain function.

But, yes, that also is a very interesting question!

Have you considered the question of how his "functional" outlook affects deeper things, such as the concept of "objectivity"?
 
Uh..yes. His brain function is one giant mutation compared to the norm.

Perhaps you were asking something else?
It could be an unlikely combination of quite numerous small genetic variations. There certainly seems to be a trade-off between between different types of brain-function, but both normally co-exist. That suggests, to me, a tipping-point rather than a single dominant influence.
 
It could be an unlikely combination of quite numerous small genetic variations. There certainly seems to be a trade-off between between different types of brain-function, but both normally co-exist. That suggests, to me, a tipping-point rather than a single dominant influence.
Quite possible. The specific mechanism which lets this person perform feats of memory and learning way, way beyond the norm, is certainly of great interest.

I was just trying to think more generally about the consequences of the fact that a human brain can do these things.
 
Mr. Tammett was on NPR last week and does identify himself as being Autistic. He spent quite a bit of time discussing how he interprets the world around him through numbers, colors and textures. In describing the concept of lonliness or sadness he associated it with the number 6. He stated that while the emotion is not one he understands the feeling is one of very small, cold and cramped which is how he visualizes 6. To understand it he imagines being inside that number.


Another striking this he spoke of was not being 'aware' of other people or desiring their companionship until he was 9 years of age. Only then did he begin to feel apart and want companionship of his peers. Learning eye contact and the social skills required to make friends took him many years.

His voice, along with Ms Grandin and Toby, the poopie commie bastage, give me hope that someday my son will be able to tell me about the world he lives in. For now, it's through their voices my son speaks and I can see into his world.



Boo
 
Thanks, AS.

I learned about "Born on a Blue Day" from the link and will probably buy it soon.

Regarding Temple Grandin, I think I heard a radio interview with her some months ago, possibly on NPR. If not her, then someone remarkably like the person you describe. Female PhD, highly accomplished, etc.

From that interview I most remember her description of following social niceties and conversational nuance. She said she still does not actually "get" conversational nuance (either vocal or via body language) and does not naturally engage in it, but over the years she has learned it academically. She looks for such nuance, and when she sees it she consciously processes it (i.e., "Oh, they mean such and such because they twitched an eyebrow") and responds appropriately with a likewise processed nuance.
Grandin was chronicled in Oliver Sachs' book An Anthropologist on Mars [wikipedia.org], which is how Grandin describes herself. She understands human interaction only by studying it the same way that Jane Goodall studies chimps to learn about their behaviour.
 
Grandin was chronicled in Oliver Sachs' book An Anthropologist on Mars [wikipedia.org], which is how Grandin describes herself. She understands human interaction only by studying it the same way that Jane Goodall studies chimps to learn about their behaviour.
I suspect most people never even considered it a "talent" to understand human interactions. It was just something built-in, like the ability to see or hear.

It is wonderful that high-functioning autistics like these people exist. In the sense that it gives enormous insight into so many things, not least the world which less well functioning autistics inhabit.
 
His voice, along with Ms Grandin and Toby, the poopie commie bastage, give me hope that someday my son will be able to tell me about the world he lives in. For now, it's through their voices my son speaks and I can see into his world.


Boo

Just so you know, over a year ago I PMed Linda and Jeff and a couple of influential TAMers urging them desperately to contact Temple Grandin to invite her to be a speaker at TAM. I gave them links and really talked her up, including her books. I mentioned her achievements and that she is a scientist with unique insights into the human brain, as well as what she believes must be what it's like to think like a horse or a cow.

One TAMer was like, "Hell, yeah! I've heard her speak and she would be great!" The other was all, "Temple who?"

You know what the JREF officials' response was? "Hmmm...interesting. How do we fit her into a "skeptical" meeting?"

I had to suppress the urge to ...whatever. Some people just don't get it. I was thinking, hmmm, a female astronomer (former TAM speaker) is obviously skeptical to them, but an autistic female with a PhD who is a college professor, inventor with a patent or two related to treatments for autistism, best selling author, and a highly influential guru in the beef industry known for her wide-sweeping innovations due to thinking outside the box isn't skeptical? OK, whatever, TAM people. So much for my benign suggestions.

AS
 
I've always been fascinated by cases like Tammet, ever since reading about the twins in Oliver Sack's "The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat" and their almost instant "calculations" of huge prime numbers. I find it almost fundamentally puzzling how Tammet performs calculations without the use of accepted symbols or methodology. A more intelligent person than me might ponder on how his ability could relate to an independent reality of mathematics.

I wasn't that impressed by Temple Grandin, to be honest. I'm not doubting her empathetic abilities, or her tremendous achievements in the face of autism, rather that much of her "intuition" could be duplicated by simple common sense. For example, I saw a documentary in which she was called to an abbotoire to figure out why cattle refused to pass through a gate. She discovered that the cattle were spooked by small stones and objects on the concrete floor beyond the gates. She got the floor cleaned up and the problem was solved. Effective, yes, but extraordinary? I don't know, maybe.
 
Last edited:
These are also all things that can be learned by a person with ordinary aptitude who does lots and lots of practice (and also makes use of some techniques, which he mentions he does in fact us for memorizing numbers).
As a bit of a magician/mentalist, I am aware of many of these, though I rarely use them.

The difference is that Tammet did not need to research, learn, and practice any method.

If I don't continually use Harry Lorayne's "walking tour" memory aid, I lose it.

If I don't continually use Si Stebbins in card magic, I lose it.
 
Danish said:
Wish you had said so originally. Until now you've just talked about mutations in brain function.
You took "mutations in brain function" to mean something other than "mutations in the genes that govern brain function"? Why, and what did you take it to mean? :eye-poppi

~~ Paul
 
Say, does anyone else have some sort of funny feeling about this whole story? Something is bothering me, but I'm not sure what.

~~ Paul
 
You took "mutations in brain function" to mean something other than "mutations in the genes that govern brain function"? Why, and what did you take it to mean? :eye-poppi

~~ Paul
Yes I did. I misunderstood as the word "mutation" is not exclusive to the world of genes. I wasn't sure what you meant but assumed you meant "a substantial change" in brain function.

Look up the definition of mutation sometime.

Glad we cleared things up. :)
 
Danish said:
Yes I did. I misunderstood as the word "mutation" is not exclusive to the world of genes. I wasn't sure what you meant but assumed you meant "a substantial change" in brain function.
Which would be brought about by ... mutations in the genes that control brain function.

Actually, I suppose it could be brought about by something in the environment, so point taken.

Nope. Sorry.
22,000 digits of pi and not a single mistake? Hmm. Okay.

~~ Paul
 
Yes, not all savants are autistic. The word savant does not come from this woman's name but should be noted : Marilyn vos Savant

I am familiar with Marilyn but had not realized she is considered a savant. Are you sure of this? I was under the impression she is considered (at least near) genius level, but not a savant. If high IQ is the only criterian to be a savant, then do we include Planck and Bohr?

If she is, I know of nothing indicating that she has been studied along the lines that Tammett has. The invaluable thing about Tammett is that he can communicate his autistic characteristics in a way most autists cannot.

I'm unsure if Marilyn Savant has that kind of ability, I'd have to research it a bit. I doubt it though, the autistic type abilities are something special onto themselves. The woman is a genius that much is true however.
 
I'm living in the wrong time period. Where is the special nanosurgery that could give me an "IQ" of "whatever the highest number possible", and all the abilities that autistic savants possess. :mad: Tiger Woods ability + (all other great golfers that would bore people to death to even mention) would be a necessary part of the surgery as well.

Honestly though, be thankful for what ability you have.
 
I saw the pbs show on Daniel TammetWP. There are some drawbacks to his condition. He told the interviewer later he might forget the guys name (me too) but he would remember how many buttons he had on his suit.

One of the problems is the incessant habit of counting things. Daniel can't walk on sand. He has to try and count the grains but who can. It drives him crazy.

Gene
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom