Daniel Tammett - Savant Without the Disadvantages

Just so you know, over a year ago I PMed Linda and Jeff and a couple of influential TAMers urging them desperately to contact Temple Grandin to invite her to be a speaker at TAM. I gave them links and really talked her up, including her books. I mentioned her achievements and that she is a scientist with unique insights into the human brain, as well as what she believes must be what it's like to think like a horse or a cow.

One TAMer was like, "Hell, yeah! I've heard her speak and she would be great!" The other was all, "Temple who?"

You know what the JREF officials' response was? "Hmmm...interesting. How do we fit her into a "skeptical" meeting?"

I had to suppress the urge to ...whatever. Some people just don't get it. I was thinking, hmmm, a female astronomer (former TAM speaker) is obviously skeptical to them, but an autistic female with a PhD who is a college professor, inventor with a patent or two related to treatments for autistism, best selling author, and a highly influential guru in the beef industry known for her wide-sweeping innovations due to thinking outside the box isn't skeptical? OK, whatever, TAM people. So much for my benign suggestions.

AS

That is rather sad, skepticism is more than just debunking idiotic theories and famous frauds. I'm a bit disappointed to hear about this. I'll have to think about this but I think I know the reason why she wasn't important enough. I know little about TAM, but I believe that it is more of an entertainment event than an academic level event. It has Pen and Teller, and such so I suppose there's little room for a non-entertainer. Even though in my opinion it is FAR more important for a skeptical audience to hear voices such as her's than mere magicians or men like Dawkins. Perhaps it's all just the bottom line in the end. That's one thing I've learned; If you're unsure about why something happened look at where the money is.

That's my guess for it anyway. All due respect to magicians and the like. Let's think of Carl Sagan though and there is no comparison.

AS, what's your opinion on why the TAM committee, (or whoever decides) thought she wasn't even worth considering being included?

Truly very disappointing to hear.
 
So suggest her again for TAM6, Solus. There is talk of relaxing the topic-heaviness of the next TAM, so all sorts of speakers should fit in.

~~ Paul
 
I saw the pbs show on Daniel TammetWP. There are some drawbacks to his condition. He told the interviewer later he might forget the guys name (me too) but he would remember how many buttons he had on his suit.

One of the problems is the incessant habit of counting things. Daniel can't walk on sand. He has to try and count the grains but who can. It drives him crazy.

Gene

He sure won't come to Vegas, then!!
 
I saw the pbs show on Daniel TammetWP. There are some drawbacks to his condition. He told the interviewer later he might forget the guys name (me too) but he would remember how many buttons he had on his suit.

One of the problems is the incessant habit of counting things. Daniel can't walk on sand. He has to try and count the grains but who can. It drives him crazy.

Gene

Just think if those drawbacks could be eliminated though...

We humans are just too feeble but at least I can conceive of a greater level of awareness. I can imagine beings that would consider the most intelligent humans the same way: we as humans view the intellectual ability of a worm.
 
That is rather sad, skepticism is more than just debunking idiotic theories and famous frauds. I'm a bit disappointed to hear about this. I'll have to think about this but I think I know the reason why she wasn't important enough. I know little about TAM, but I believe that it is more of an entertainment event than an academic level event. It has Pen and Teller, and such so I suppose there's little room for a non-entertainer. Even though in my opinion it is FAR more important for a skeptical audience to hear voices such as her's than mere magicians or men like Dawkins. Perhaps it's all just the bottom line in the end. That's one thing I've learned; If you're unsure about why something happened look at where the money is.

Personally, I'm interested in science and reason. I don't give a flip about homeopathy or dowsing or self-proclaimed psychics. I'm all for hearing from persons like Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens and the like, whom I understand can be intellectually stimulating and entertaining all the same.

I understand that at the previous year's TAM one of the featured speakers was a prominent female astronomer. That's fine. I have no problem with that. What I have difficulty understanding is that if she is fine and sufficiently "skeptical" (using the brand name sense in the way the term is often used on the JREF forum), then why would Dr. Temple Grandin, another prominent woman scientist and pioneer of sorts, be dismissed as insufficiently "skeptical" out of hand? The immediate reaction from Linda was, "She sounds interesting, but how does she fit into a skeptical meeting?"

I slapped my forehead and thought that her response was pretty unimaginative, frankly. I had done my homework and had done a pretty thorough job of selling her and her ideas in my e-mails to Linda. I even included links to her homepage, to her best-selling books at Amazon, and mentioned that she had been featured on 60 Minutes and other television specials, and had been featured in major newsmagazine stories as well.

That's my guess for it anyway. All due respect to magicians and the like. Let's think of Carl Sagan though and there is no comparison.

I agree. Although I'm not a TAM attendee, based on my understanding of the JREF's educational mission, I would think that the JREF would want to focus more on science and less on magic. Then again, Randi himself is a magician, and not a scientist by trade.

AS, what's your opinion on why the TAM committee, (or whoever decides) thought she wasn't even worth considering being included?

To be fair, this was within a few weeks of Randi's heart problems, and Linda's and the JREF's attentions were understandably and rightly more focused on his health and recovery at the time, and not so much on future TAM speakers. I don't blame her or anyone else, but I was disappointed in their seeming dismissal of Grandin out of hand with what amounted to a "what's she got to do with skepticism?" response.

I suppose my idea of what is topical or not is different from theirs. That's fine. They run TAM and I don't. I don't even attend, so I lack any kind of standing whatsoever to object or raise a stink. I was merely trying to be helpful in an observer and admirer sort of way. It's no big deal.

AS
 
So suggest her again for TAM6, Solus. There is talk of relaxing the topic-heaviness of the next TAM, so all sorts of speakers should fit in.

~~ Paul

I sometimes let my reactions go over the top a little bit... I was just disappointed in the official response. A knee jerk reaction, my post was a bit silly (the money part) but at least I can admit to it. You don't see many (any) CTers or even regular JREF forum members do that very often.

I’ll make the suggestion if I plan on attending. Although I’d perfer to hear Tammet, well actually both would be very interesting.
 
Last edited:
He sure won't come to Vegas, then!!

He went to Vegas as part of his trip to the U.S. for the Discovery Channel documentary entitled "Brainman." Although he had never played blackjack before, he learned the rules and tried his hand at a table for a while. He played intuitively, without actively counting cards as they were dealt. He was apparently counting on some subconscious level, however. For a while he sustained some sizeable losses, but came back with a spectacular finish on one huge deal in which he made several splits and double downs. He used his intuitive numerical sense in determining how to play the hand and how to bet accordingly. He went against what would be "correct" play according to Basic Strategy, if one were not counting cards. He ended up being correct on every single hand he had in play for that deal.

AS
 
I think that's the point. He doesn't make mistakes of memory any more than you would make a mistake reading the digits off a page.
Ha. I routinely screw that up. But it doesn't seem that surprising to me, a man quite obsessed by pi who uses a variant on the loci system to memorise it.

Does he do anything else or is he 'just' a memory guy?
 
Ha. I routinely screw that up. But it doesn't seem that surprising to me, a man quite obsessed by pi who uses a variant on the loci system to memorise it.

Does he do anything else or is he 'just' a memory guy?

He is a mathematics whiz in a superhuman way. He doesn't just memorize. Tammet has an extraordinary ability, the likes of which has only been seen in a handful of other humans throughout history (and his surpasses everyone else's) to perform complex calculations in his head very quickly. For instance at Cal Tech, a neurologist and psychologist designed several tests for him (and included controls to check for his using some system or mneumonic device, and he wasn't). One was to list several large numbers with more than 5 or 6 digits and ask him if they are prime or not. He would close his eyes and answer correctly within a couple of seconds each time. He doesn't know how he does it exactly, but says that he sees the "shape" of the number in his head, and then he can tell if it's prime or not. Prime numbers look different in his head from non-primes. They also got Tammet to take two and three digit numbers and multiply them to their power of four or five (e.g., 89 x 89 x 89 x 89 x 89 x 89). He could do this in his head, correctly and consistently, in a matter of seconds, before the other researcher assisting the primary doctor could complete the calculations on a calculator.

Furthermore, that Tammet was able to learn Icelandic, a language that is much different from his own native tongue English, in a week so that he was conversant enough to appear on a live television show in Iceland and carry on a decent two-way conversation for several minutes, is indicative of his doing much more than simply memorizing. He was thinking in Icelandic and getting it grammatically correct. That's more than sheer rote memorization.

In his autobiography, Tammet explains that he speaks six (I think it's six, but I don't have the book handy at the moment) different languages with near fluency. That itself is not extraordinary, as there are lots of ordinary humans who are multi-lingual, but I believe that kind of talent for languages is unusual for autistic persons, even savants. Tammet is a savant's savant.

AS
 
Last edited:
Similar number and language memorisation feats are reasonably feasible for dedicated normal people using mnemonic techniques. It is by making associations you find interesting that mnemonic techiques become powerful and Tammett is apparently quite naturally doing his equivalent of that.

Calculating ability is much, much more interesting as mnemonic techniques can be used to hold a lot of information mid-calculation but not at any real speed. However, whenever someone says they can't describe how they are doing what they're doing, I raise an eyebrow at that.

As an aside, perhaps a way to help some autistic people remember details about other people is to reverse the usual way to create mnenomics of converting, say, numbers into an imaginary journey with people and activities and to instead teach them convert whatever they need to remember about people into whatever it is they find most interesting.
 
Personally, I'm interested in science and reason. I don't give a flip about homeopathy or dowsing or self-proclaimed psychics. I'm all for hearing from persons like Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens and the like, whom I understand can be intellectually stimulating and entertaining all the same.

I understand that at the previous year's TAM one of the featured speakers was a prominent female astronomer. That's fine. I have no problem with that. What I have difficulty understanding is that if she is fine and sufficiently "skeptical" (using the brand name sense in the way the term is often used on the JREF forum), then why would Dr. Temple Grandin, another prominent woman scientist and pioneer of sorts, be dismissed as insufficiently "skeptical" out of hand? The immediate reaction from Linda was, "She sounds interesting, but how does she fit into a skeptical meeting?"

I slapped my forehead and thought that her response was pretty unimaginative, frankly. I had done my homework and had done a pretty thorough job of selling her and her ideas in my e-mails to Linda. I even included links to her homepage, to her best-selling books at Amazon, and mentioned that she had been featured on 60 Minutes and other television specials, and had been featured in major newsmagazine stories as well.

I agree. Although I'm not a TAM attendee, based on my understanding of the JREF's educational mission, I would think that the JREF would want to focus more on science and less on magic. Then again, Randi himself is a magician, and not a scientist by trade.

To be fair, this was within a few weeks of Randi's heart problems, and Linda's and the JREF's attentions were understandably and rightly more focused on his health and recovery at the time, and not so much on future TAM speakers. I don't blame her or anyone else, but I was disappointed in their seeming dismissal of Grandin out of hand with what amounted to a "what's she got to do with skepticism?" response.

I suppose my idea of what is topical or not is different from theirs. That's fine. They run TAM and I don't. I don't even attend, so I lack any kind of standing whatsoever to object or raise a stink. I was merely trying to be helpful in an observer and admirer sort of way. It's no big deal.

AS

Seems your thinking is in line with my own about this. I never cared much about the psychic and paranormal nonsense, this a good place for people to find out who were unaware though. To me I know it's nonsense so from that I don't really care to hear about it. Tell someone who doesn't already know.
As I got older I figured out for myself basically but without a proper education I have no idea what I'd be thinking today. Education isn't just going to school it also pertains to seeking knowledge and going through the effort of learning by one's own volition.

I was just recently thinking of education in China. A friend’s grandson lives their and is teaching. I was thinking how I might help. My answer was to somehow provide books or information to the children so that they could learn some basic critical thinking skills and not fall into the same rut and as the parents likely have. Of course the grandson would likely get in a great deal of trouble so in that case it's not simple by any means.

I won’t admit I’m anywhere close to prefect at this but teaching people critical thinking skills would a greater goal to me. The credulity so bemoaned here comes from people who don’t know "how to think” which sounds strange but isn’t off from the truth. A serious teaching of the basic scientific method is.. anyway enough of that.

The part about money is why I backpedeled in my other post. That was going a bit too far, as I have no clue what the reason is in this case. In most events if you are unsure about something. Find out who gets what, as in the benefits to each party and you can understand the real motives. In this case the event isn’t on a large enough scale for that to apply. Works well (in miost cases) if you study history.

I always was think of the E in JREF when I think of the foundation.

Anyway that’s just a long way of saying I agree with your post. :p
 
Last edited:
Similar number and language memorisation feats are reasonably feasible for dedicated normal people using mnemonic techniques. It is by making associations you find interesting that mnemonic techiques become powerful and Tammett is apparently quite naturally doing his equivalent of that.

Calculating ability is much, much more interesting as mnemonic techniques can be used to hold a lot of information mid-calculation but not at any real speed. However, whenever someone says they can't describe how they are doing what they're doing, I raise an eyebrow at that.

As an aside, perhaps a way to help some autistic people remember details about other people is to reverse the usual way to create mnenomics of converting, say, numbers into an imaginary journey with people and activities and to instead teach them convert whatever they need to remember about people into whatever it is they find most interesting.

You seem to dismiss Tammet's ability as I see this.

It goes beyond dedication, no normal human can do what this man can do period. There is no method or trick to copy him and reach anywhere even remotely close to his ability. If there was I would be doing it RIGHT NOW! :D

One thing to remember you are not autistic (I'll take a risk assuming that) :p
How you think doesn't matter. His method is deferent obviously and it's worthless to compare your standard of thought process with an autistic. It seems to me like your saying anyone can do what this man can do.:confused:
 
You seem to dismiss Tammet's ability as I see this.

It goes beyond dedication, no normal human can do what this man can do period. There is no method or trick to copy him and reach anywhere even remotely close to his ability. If there was I would be doing it RIGHT NOW! :D

One thing to remember you are not autistic (I'll take a risk assuming that) :p
How you think doesn't matter. His method is deferent obviously and it's worthless to compare your standard of thought process with an autistic. It seems to me like your saying anyone can do what this man can do.:confused:

I'm saying that artificial mnemonic strategies allow people with normal memories to do some of what Tammet can do if they're dedicated to it. I know this to be true as I have various books written by people holding memory world records and I know what they do and how they do it. 22,511 digits of pi would take quite a bit of work but it's not out of the question for anyone crazy enough who wants to do it enough.

I also know a little about people with synaesthesia and impressive memories like the famous case of Solomon Shereshevsky. People like him and Tammet make natural associations that make numbers and words memorable but artificial associations can certainly be created and used by normal people to match some of what they can do.

Doing multiplication and division calculations like Tammet presents a different challenge. I'm not sure how fast someone with a normal memory using mnemonics strategies could be. They could do it but how fast? I don't know.

Also, how to copy the prime number test Tammet can do is a bit of a mystery to me right now if it doesn't involved the insane feat of memorising tens of thousands of prime numbers.
 
Last edited:
Found this excerpt from Oliver Sack's book here, concerning the autistic twins ~

http://www.secamlocal.ex.ac.uk/people/staff/mrwatkin/isoc/twins.htm

<SNIP> I returned to the ward the next day, carrying the precious book of primes with me. I again found them closeted in their numerical communion, but this time, without saying anything, I quietly joined them. They were taken aback at first, but when I made no interruption, they resumed their 'game' of six-figure primes. After a few minutes I decided to join in, and ventured a number, an eight-figure prime. They both turned towards me, then suddenly became still, with a look of intense concentration and perhaps wonder on their faces. There was a long pause - the longest I had ever known them to make, it must have lasted a half-minute or more - and then suddenly, simultaneously, they both broke into smiles.

They had, after some unimaginable internal process of testing, suddenly seen my own eight-digit number as a prime - and this was manifestly a great joy, a double joy, to them: first because I had introduced a new plaything, a prime of an order they had never previously encountered; and secondly, because it was evident that I had seen what they were doing, that I liked it, that I admired it, and that I could join in myself.

They drew apart slightly, making room for me, a new number playmate, a third in their world. Then John, who always took the lead, thought for a very long time - it must have been at least five minutes, though I dared not move, and scarcely breathed - and brought out a nine-figure number; and after a similar time his twin Michael responded with a similar one. And then I, in my turn, after a surreptitious look in my book, added my own rather dishonest contribution, a ten-figure prime I found in my book.

There was again, and for even longer, a wondering, still silence; and then John, after a prodigious internal contemplation brought out a twelve-figure number. I had no way of checking this, and could not respond, because my own book - which as far as I knew, was unique of its kind - did not go beyond ten-figure primes. But Michael was up to it, though it took him five minutes - and an hour later the twins were swapping twenty-figure primes, at least I assume this was so, for I had no way of checking it. Nor was there any easy way, in 1966, unless one had the use of a sophisticated computer. And even then, it would have been difficult, for whether one uses Eratosthenes' sieve, or any other algorithm, there is no simple method of calculating primes. There is no simple method, for primes of this order - and yet the twins were doing it.<SNIP>

It's worth adding that the twins' primes were later validated.
 
I'm saying that artificial mnemonic strategies allow people with normal memories to do some of what Tammet can do if they're dedicated to it. I know this to be true as I have various books written by people holding memory world records and I know what they do and how they do it. 22,511 digits of pi would take quite a bit of work but it's not out of the question for anyone crazy enough who wants to do it enough.
Most of the record holders of pi memorisation are not autistics or savants. I know Simon Plouffe who held the record at 4096 in 1975 and he is a regular person not autistic.

http://www.recordholders.org/en/list/memory.html

The actual record is 83,431.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/4644103.stm

nimzo
 
Found this excerpt from Oliver Sack's book here, concerning the autistic twins ~

http://www.secamlocal.ex.ac.uk/people/staff/mrwatkin/isoc/twins.htm

It's worth adding that the twins' primes were later validated.

I knew of this story but had forgotten it. Now that you have reminded me, I went looking to find what could be wrong with Dr. Sacks' story and Google sent me back to the same website as you linked to:

http://secamlocal.ex.ac.uk/people/staff/mrwatkin/isoc/sacks-yamaguchi.htm

Interesting that Dr. Sacks seems to have misplaced what should be an implausibly vast book of 10 digit prime numbers, a feat in itself with a book that massive. :D
 
Most of the record holders of pi memorisation are not autistics or savants. I know Simon Plouffe who held the record at 4096 in 1975 and he is a regular person not autistic.

http://www.recordholders.org/en/list/memory.html

Cool. I see at Amazon he's one of the authors of the "Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences". I guess that's the 1 3 6 10 15 21 ... kind of sequences.


I can't remember if it was this person or the person before who held the record but I remember the mnemonic system was surprisingly inefficient when described. Visualization strategies like Dominic O'Brien's are better but I have a vague suspicion some kind of verbal system would work best.

A related point I wonder is just how good are "photographic" memories really since so many of the memory world records and championships seem to be held by people with normal memories using mnemonic strategies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom