Continuation The Electric Comet Theory Boogaloo (Part 2)

[tusenfem]

Sol88, just curious, why did you rotate that image 180 degrees?

Hi phunk, go 2 pages back, there you can find that the EC is the concave/convex illusion, thus the rotation of the image.

 

[Reality Check]

I happen to live in what appears to be EDM scars on Earth, ...

Sorry, Sol88, but ignorance about basic geology just emphasizes that you are wrong about astronomical images.

Arguments from ignorance/incredulity are not science, Sol88.

In the real world the MUPUS results make sense. They were expecting ices and dust in comets. So they designed MUPUS for the types of ices and duct they expected in comets. We had a wonderful surprise - 67P has a layer of ices and dust that was not expected. This will lead to actual science to determine why that layer is tougher than expected.

In the real world it is delusional to think that comets are solid rock that MUPUS should have been designed for.

In the real world " discharge etching here in the Kimberleys" is a delusion.

 

[Reality Check]

And to boot the local Aboriginal population....

would recognize the stupidity of comparing what looks like an artists impression of imaginary stuff in the sky to their rock art, Sol88 !

 

[Reality Check]

... we only have images to speculate over, what aleCcowaN, would you speculate in this image...

aleCcowaN does not have to speculate on an unattributed image, Sol88.
It as if you are not brave enough to show us what scientists who have the knowledge to analyze the image have said about the image

Anyone with eyes will know that the "white spots" are relatively bright areas in the image. Anyone who knows anything about 67P and is not in total denial of science will say that this is reflection from the dusty surface of 67P. So what would make dust vary in brightness? The obvious answer is more ices in the dust particles. This is supported by the spots looking to be mostly within pits or otherwise sheltered - less sublimation of ices from the surface.

 

[Sol88]

The obvious answer is more ices in the dust particles.

Obviously!!! It can be nothing else


Thanks for a least having a crack at it RC!

I think Capatain Swoop was on the correct track with

Over exposed pixels.

What caused the over exposure I wonder?

 

[tusenfem]

What caused the over exposure I wonder?

Most likely a long shutter time of the camera.

 

[Jrrarglblarg]

Obviously!!! It can be nothing else


Thanks for a least having a crack at it RC!

I think Capatain Swoop was on the correct track with

What caused the over exposure I wonder?

Albedo in small areas of the image exceed the exposure contrast ratio latitude of the image system at the camera settings used and/or exceed the contrast ratio latitude of image compression algorithms and/or exceed the contrast ratio latitude of your image display system.

 

[Jrrarglblarg]

I would be hesitant to speculate on what specific chemical or physical effects or processes are present in those localized high albedo areas based exclusively on one image which you present in an altered form from the source (and without telling us).

 

[Andy_Ross]

Obviously!!! It can be nothing else


Thanks for a least having a crack at it RC!

I think Capatain Swoop was on the correct track with

What caused the over exposure I wonder?

Exactly the same thing that causes over exposure on any photograph.

 

[tusenfem]

Exactly the same thing that causes over exposure on any photograph.

but maybe if you rotate it by 180 degrees it will be under-exposed!!!!

 

[Reality Check]

Obviously!!! It can be nothing else

That is correct, Sol88 - to anyone with the brains enough to understand basic physics the answer is obvious!!!! An image of a comet made up of ices and dust can only be of ices and dust !

 

[grmcdorman]

That is correct, Sol88 - to anyone with the brains enough to understand basic physics the answer is obvious!!!! An image of a comet made up of ices and dust can only be of ices and dust !

That must be some interesting image.

 

[LSSBB]

That must be some interesting image.

Ice sculptures.

 

[Sol88]

Looks a little like you'd expect EDM too look like! Etching away at the rock in circular scalloped depressions

 

[Lukraak_Sisser]

Looks a little like you'd expect EDM too look like! Etching away at the rock in circular scalloped depressions

Tell us, what exact experiments has the EC / EU group done to actually show that electrical discharges would etch rock at all? And what Amperage/Voltage/Time is needed to achieve this? Because everything known by mainstream science about electricity, backed up by a LOT of experimental evidence, would suggest this would not happen.

 

[Tolls]

Tell us, what exact experiments has the EC / EU group done to actually show that electrical discharges would etch rock at all? And what Amperage/Voltage/Time is needed to achieve this? Because everything known by mainstream science about electricity, backed up by a LOT of experimental evidence, would suggest this would not happen.

Experiments?
Pah!

EU people can imagine it working the way they want!
What more does anyone need?

 

[Andy_Ross]

To me it looks a lot like it was nibbled by a giant Space Goat.

 

[aleCcowaN]

Looks a little like you'd expect EDM too look like! Etching away at the rock in circular scalloped depressions

You'd expect? would? could? should? Where does that expectation come from, other than fantasy?

C'mon! Even Velikovsky tried much harder!

 

[Jrrarglblarg]

Looks a little like you'd expect EDM too look like! Etching away at the rock in circular scalloped depressions

Congrats. Now it's your turn to ignore the direct questions I asked haig: what specific features are specifically and exclusively characteristic of electrical activity.

What specific characteristic features of sublimation erosion would be present that are not?

And the special bonus question just for sol8&:
How do we know If a terrain feature is a protuberance of depression?

 

[Andy_Ross]

How do we know If a terrain feature is a protuberance of depression?

This thread gives me depression!