Contest: How Many Sylvia Browne Lies Can You Count?

I can't recall what the article was, but many (especially CFLarsen) were jhighly criitical of it, saying that it was not to the site's usual standards. I pulled it down immediately, but may have rewritten and reposted it.

Does anyone remember which article this was? Or where the original thread is? I'm very curious what this was all about.
 
Eeney, I still don't recall what the article was. Susan recalls the incident, but not what the article was about. I have PMed Claus to see if he recalls. If he does, I will post more here. -RSL
 
Montel knows of a lot of BS and still backs her up, still appears with her!

Montel Williams is both Sylvia Brown's friend and in the entertainment business. You can take Mz. Brown's...stuff...as a form of 'entertainment' if your so inclined. Were I to seek such 'advise', I would seek it from someone not seeking any sort of financial gain. That person is more likely to give accurate data if possible. (shrugs)
 
What is the difference between a "psychic" and a "mentalist" and does a "mentalist" hold more credibility to skeptics?
 
Mentalism is just a branch of performance magic. There are stage illusionists, close-up magicians, parlour magicians. Any one of them might perform something that would qualify as mentalism now and then, but not exclusively. Mentalists tend to deliberately NOT do much "straight" magic -- making things float or disappear or transpose, etc. -- and stick with effects that mimic those things that a "psychic" might do -- read minds, predict or influence future events, move objects by unseen force, etc. The confusion -- and ethical dilemma -- is when mentalists make no disclaimer about the nature of their powers, allowing audiences to presume they really are "psychic" or in possession of supernatural powers. Some mentalists, like Randi's friend, Banachek draw a very clear distinction, claiming up front that they are NOT claiming supernatural abilities. Some mentalists find this to be going too far. Is a stage illusionist obligated to stop after every mind-blowing illusion and remind the audience it's "not real"? Absent any overt disclaimers, the line between a "psychic" and a mentalist can get blurred pretty easily for a layperson. The subject of disclaimers -- how much or how little -- is quite vigorously debated within magic circles, a profession that has traditionally attracted (or created) a lot of the most hard-core skeptics.
 
#8 when millions of women were burned to death.

- Evidence?

W.J. Bethancourt has done an actual count of the number of people killed as "witches", from the twelfth century CE to modern times. He's listed all those he could find by name, and as well included the "unknowns" ("100 burned in Como, Italy, in 1523; 1000 + in Como, Italy, in 1524 ... 368 persons killed for witchcraft between 18 January, 1587, and 18 November, 1593, in the diocese of Treves; 1 burned at Riom, France, in 1588; 133 persons burned in one day at Quedlinburg, in Germany, in 1589; 48 burned in Wurttemberg, Germany, in 1589 ... 77 burned in Vaud, Switzerland, in 1599; 10 -daily- were burned (average) in the Duchy of Brunswick between 1590-1600").

He admits that an accurate number is hard to arrive at, but his estimate is a minimum of twenty thousand and a maximum of "perhaps as many as one-half million" -- again, that's continuing through to modern times ("2, a mother and daughter, killed in Benin, West Africa, January, 2002; 2 men hacked to death, Rajmai tea garden in Sivasagar district, about 370 km east of Assam's main city of Guwahati, in India, 20 Nov. 2005; 15 women burned to death by a mob, Kenya, Africa. May 2008").

One-half million maximum. Not a small number, but not "millions".

(He also mentions, in an aside possibly directed to neo-Pagans, that "of all the trials, only one set (in 1390 Milan) involved women tried for practicing rites led by the pagan Goddess Diana".)
 
What is the difference between a "psychic" and a "mentalist" and does a "mentalist" hold more credibility to skeptics?

If the mentalist makes no claims to paranormal abilities, then yes - heor she has more credibility to me than does a "psychic."
 
Eeney, Claus recalls the incident, but not the article itself. Perhaps the article is best left unremembered... but if I remember it, I'll let you know.
 
I have to say, you've never had a weak article. Not one. There isn't one I'd remove from the site, for any reason (though there are some I'd add important details to and add more information to. And there are a few I'd personally have written a little differently. So there are several I'd somewhat revise, myself.)

Do you remember what the issue with it was? Did Claus and the others tell you that you were being unfair or too biased or something like that? Or that your information was too incomplete and the conclusions you were drawing were too tenuous?
 
Last edited:
It wasn't just Claus, but the consensus was either that the topic of the article wasn't appropriate for the site (as some say of the "smoking" article), or that the tone of the article wasn't up to my usual standards. I really don't recall.
 
It takes a lot before I can come to dislike someone on a personal level, but after seeing Sylvia's total lack of empathy and dignity when Mark Edward had a fall (Sylvia Browne Punked) at her appearance at the Gibson Amphitheatre at Universal Studios recently, I will have to answer to the question of this thread with, it converges to infinity.

Be sure not to miss Mark's captivating blogs about the event at the Sceptic Blog at,
Sylvia Shakedown Pt. 1
Sylvia Shakedown Pt. 2

Mark attended my IIG paranormal demonstration, and was one of the friendliest people to me there. He was always at hand for me to share my thoughts with, and it was only after the test I found out that he was not just some member of the IIG, he is a skilled mentalist turned skeptic. So I take very badly if anyone is unfriendly toward someone like Mark.

Plus, Mark offered me a peanutbutter cup.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6HLKxrOaI4
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom