Contest: How Many Sylvia Browne Lies Can You Count?

It sounds like Sylvia had once read The Da Vinci Code.

You'd think that being able to see the future and the past and do things like tell people what their past lives were like, she'd know more about history than you and me. Not less.
 
So much for correcting history. :rolleyes:

The fascinating thing about Sylvia Browne is that she doesn't seem to be even the least bit concerned about contradicting herself on the air or in print.

I think everyone has done a pretty good job of catching the lies in this particular article. I'm just relieved it was limited to just this one article. Imagine if you'd been asking about all past interviews, trances, lectures, books. Mind boggling.

As I said in a different thread, I'm away from my books right at the moment, but Sylvia told the story of her 9/11 prediction in her book on dreams. It might be interesting to see how that story has changed from then to now. I recall it a bit differently from what she says here.
 
Last edited:
So much for correcting history. :rolleyes:
I think everyone has done a pretty good job of catching the lies in this particular article. I'm just relieved it was limited to just this one article. Imagine if you'd been asking about all past interviews, trances, lectures, books. Mind boggling.

And this was a short article! Like you said if everything was taken into account, or even just a little more the results would be jaw-dropping. :jaw-dropp
 
It sounds like Sylvia had once read The Da Vinci Code.

You'd think that being able to see the future and the past and do things like tell people what their past lives were like, she'd know more about history than you and me. Not less.

She did and this was her inspiration for the Secret Societies book. She often gets her ideas from movies, tv shows, and trashy magazines (how do you think she gets fodder for her New Years predictions?)

That is my thought too Eeney. If she can see so much about the past, she should be a historic genius.

So much for correcting history. :rolleyes:

The fascinating thing about Sylvia Browne is that she doesn't seem to be even the least bit concerned about contradicting herself on the air or in print.

I think everyone has done a pretty good job of catching the lies in this particular article. I'm just relieved it was limited to just this one article. Imagine if you'd been asking about all past interviews, trances, lectures, books. Mind boggling.

As I said in a different thread, I'm away from my books right at the moment, but Sylvia told the story of her 9/11 prediction in her book on dreams. It might be interesting to see how that story has changed from then to now. I recall it a bit differently from what she says here.

Thank you ExM, I look forward to that information when you return home. Her contradictions are unbelievable.


RSL- I'm with you there and your excellent beard.
 
Francine,

Speaking of ideas from books, 20 years ago Holy Blood, Holy Grail really seemed to impress her. Then, amazingly, the same type of information began to come through in trances! I mean exactly the same - Jesus was married to Mary Magdalene, they had kids, he didn't die on the cross, they relocated to France.

Talk about contradictions on tapes! Those tapes are full of them. Francine, you must be such a kidder! I bet you were just bored that month and wondering if any of us would notice, eh?

Now as for 9/11. Here is the quote from the article:

You are said to have predicted the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

I kept seeing fire everywhere in New York. I called Montel -- everyone. I saw fire everywhere. I kept seeing it a week before and it wouldn't leave me. Fire shooting up in the air. I couldn't pinpoint it and it kept driving me crazy.

And here is what she wrote in Sylvia Browne's Book of Dreams:

As psychic as I am, not for one moment did I see the terrorist attacks of September 11 coming. In the week before, I kept dreaming about fire, but I kept thinking maybe it was at one of my sons' houses and just warned them both to be extra careful.

Sheesh.

ExM
 
So when she says that not for one moment did she see the terrorist attack, it reminds me of something else she said on a very famous radio show - "I hate people (psychics) who say things AFTER THE FACT). Isn't that what she did in her book? Say AFTER THE FACT that she saw fires, so she can come off as having a "partial" hit?:footinmou
 
So when she says that not for one moment did she see the terrorist attack, it reminds me of something else she said on a very famous radio show - "I hate people (psychics) who say things AFTER THE FACT). Isn't that what she did in her book? Say AFTER THE FACT that she saw fires, so she can come off as having a "partial" hit?:footinmou

True.

And what I notice most of all is how when the interviewer says, "You are said to have predicted the 9/11 terrorist attacks," she doesn't say, "No, not for one moment did I see that coming. No, I just kept having these dreams about fire, though." Which an honest, sincere person would have done.

No, she just goes with what the interviewer says and elaborates on it - oh yeah, lots of fire, flames shooting up in New York - called Montel, blah blah.

So it seems to me she might have actually had a dream about fire in the week before 9/11 or she wouldn't even remember it this long. But otherwise it's all just exagerration and... lies.
 
Why couldn't Sylvia have been around during the Reformation? Sigh...

If Sylvia had been around during the Reformation, she would sure as hell not have styled herself a "psychic medium" (or is that John Edward - anywhichway, wtf other kind of medium would there be?) - she would have been a Witchfinder General and pointed her crooked fingers at innocent people. Or a local hausfrau whipping up hysteria and throwing around allegations.

And reprehensible as the witchhunts were, A: as many have pointed out - they didn't take place during the middle ages. B: as many have also pointed out - there were no millions of women.
The witch trials were actually well notarized - that is why we have such good knowledge of them. Something Browne would have known had she bothered to do some research.

Many European countries were not affected at all by witch hysteria, or they were affected for a very short time until someone put their foot down. Several affected countries did not even reach hundred executed - most accused were freed of suspicion.

And C: Who stopped the witch trials? Skeptics did. Such as Urban Hjärne in Sweden. (sorry, no link in English)

So - in a witch hysteria Europe, pre-incarnated Sylvia Browne would most likely have been identifying witches for cash, while R. Lancaster would have been Urban Hjärne.
 
If Sylvia had been around during the Reformation, she would sure as hell not have styled herself a "psychic medium" (or is that John Edward - anywhichway, wtf other kind of medium would there be?) - she would have been a Witchfinder General and pointed her crooked fingers at innocent people. Or a local hausfrau whipping up hysteria and throwing around allegations.

And reprehensible as the witchhunts were, A: as many have pointed out - they didn't take place during the middle ages. B: as many have also pointed out - there were no millions of women.
The witch trials were actually well notarized - that is why we have such good knowledge of them. Something Browne would have known had she bothered to do some research.

Many European countries were not affected at all by witch hysteria, or they were affected for a very short time until someone put their foot down. Several affected countries did not even reach hundred executed - most accused were freed of suspicion.

And C: Who stopped the witch trials? Skeptics did. Such as Urban Hjärne in Sweden. (sorry, no link in English)

So - in a witch hysteria Europe, pre-incarnated Sylvia Browne would most likely have been identifying witches for cash, while R. Lancaster would have been Urban Hjärne.

In England, Reginald Scot's The Discoverie of Witchcraft was an important work, although it was burned, and he blamed the Catholics. Still, he argued that there was no such thing as witchcraft, that some were deluded and that a lot of "magic" was trickery.

See also:
http://www.conjuror.com/archives/discoverie/discoverie.html
http://history.wisc.edu/sommerville/367/scot%20discovery.htm
Complete version of the Discoverie here: http://www.esotericarchives.com/solomon/scot16.htm
 
Why couldn't Sylvia have been around during the Reformation? Sigh...

Are you suggesting Sylvia Browne be burned alive Mr. Lancaster?
What happened to the level headed skeptical approach you are so famous for?
Have you ever had a whiff of burning human flesh? Not very pleasant I can tell you.

Now obviously Sylvia Browne should not be making money off the fools for a living.
But just as obvious is the fact that what she does for a living is not a crime.
If it were she would have been in jail a long time ago.

So now you are posting about someone who is not breaking the law being tied to a stake and burned alive because you don't agree with how she makes a living.

I have sensed a change in you Mr. Lancaster.
A change that your faithful follows on here would never dream of bringing up.
You have a real talent no doubt.
But you have bought into your own press clippings on this forum.
Also you have made Sylvia Browne your personal enemy.

Before, your site was not personal it was just the facts to let people make up their own minds.
But I can see a very real slant in your posting on here and no doubt that will make it's way on to your site.


Your friend,
Francine

Hey here is a lie I'll bet no one counted.
 
Last edited:
Are you suggesting Sylvia Browne be burned alive Mr. Lancaster?
What happened to the level headed skeptical approach you are so famous for?
Have you ever had a whiff of burning human flesh? Not very pleasant I can tell you.
Brattus, I have never smelled anything. I am congenitally anosmic.

I'm sorry, but - to use your tactic - I didn't think anyone would be so stupid as to think that I was actually advocating violence against Browne, or I would have added ample smilies.

Now obviously Sylvia Browne should not be making money off the fools for a living.
But just as obvious is the fact that what she does for a living is not a crime.
If it were she would have been in jail a long time ago.

So now you are posting about someone who is not breaking the law being tied to a stake and burned alive because you don't agree with how she makes a living.
Sorry that my little attempt at humor was evidently over your foolish head.

Do you intend to interpret all my posts literally from this point on?

I have sensed a change in you Mr. Lancaster.
A change that your faithful follows on here would never dream of bringing up.
Perhaps the stroke has robbed me of some of my ability to make my meaning clear.

Brattus, my "followers" on this forum have been critical of me many times. When I would post links here to new SSB articles, there were many instances when people were very critical of the article. So much so one time that I pulled an article off of the site in response to the chorus of criticism.

It seems to me that you have decided to be The Rebel here, but end up being the Rebel Without a Clue. Not because I disagree with you, but because you are intentionally misinterpreting my posts

you have a real talent no doubt.
But you have bought into your own press clippings on this forum.
Also you have made Sylvia Browne your personal enemy.

Before, your site was not personal it was just the facts to let people make up their own minds.
But I can see a very real slant in your posting on here and no doubt that will make it's way on to your site.
so, now you're psychic?




Hey here is a lie I'll bet no one counted.[/QUOTE]
 
1) Brill's Content stated after examining your claims of helping solve many criminal cases that in most the details were too vague to be clarified, and that in others law-enforcement officers said you played no useful role. Other critics contend that psychics never speak in specifics, only generalities. That makes it difficult for skeptics to find fault.
That's not true. I have 250 [criminal] cases that have come out, but they won't report it because police don't want people to know they work with psychics. There won't be need for me to have my name in the paper if I broke up a big drug ring -- which I did. But I'm not going to say which ring it was. That would be dangerous.

...

No, Sylvia, they haven't "come out". And they would report it. How could a journalist ever pass up a story like that? You could report it, if it were true. I would report it, if I had found even one case where you were correct, let alone 250. Unlike you, I can admit when I've been wrong- but I've been 100 percent right on you. I've gone through more than a hundred and you were incorrect and useless if not downright harmful on every single one. If you found that article to be "not true", how do you explain my work? And the reason the police might not want people to know they work with psychics is cause a) they actually don't, b) psychics are very dangerous frauds.

Actually, there would be need. You can't point at someone and accuse them of a crime they may or may not have committed and have legal action taken against them based on the word of an alleged psychic. Which didn't happen, anyway, cause you didn't break up a "drug ring".

Which brings me to another thing. If psychic powers were in the smallest way real, the legalities of it in court and on police forces would open another branch of study in law. All case law everywhere would be rewritten from top to bottom. The American legal system- systems of law all over the world- wouldn't even know where to begin. At the very least, you'd be subpoenaed to testify as an eyewitness in crimes for the rest of your life.

....


2) How often do you use your psychic powers on a day-to-day basis, as opposed to simple reliance on evidence provided by the material world?
It's always with me, I just don't always tune it up. You can dull the light. When I was younger, I couldn't. Now, if someone asks me a question as a psychic, my lights go on. But I'm not a mind reader or mentalist. I don't want to go around reading people's minds. That would be terrible. You'd be walking around smacking everyone in the face or something.


...


On that we are agreed; you most certainly are not a mind reader or a mentalist. And you are not a psychic, either.

...


3) You've famously predicted what heaven is like, and said that it is 78 degrees Fahrenheit there all the time. How hot is hell?
This [life on Earth] is hell. There's no pit with a fire in it. That's another way of making our Lord human. I believe we come down to this hell-hole to learn. Then we learn our lessons and come back home. Belief in hell's certainly made a lot of people wealthy.

...


No comment on this one.


...


4) Have you ever used your powers for stock tips?
I just won't. I won't use it for lottery or any of that. I've never been tempted. Never.

...


You just can't. You can't use it for lottery or "any of that". You've never been tempted- to do something you know you can't do. You can never do it.

...


5) Did Jesus have psychic powers? Joseph Smith?
Jesus? Absolutely. Look at what he said when he spoke to God in the Garden of Gethsemane. He knew he was going to be executed. How did he know what illnesses he was supposed to cast out? Joseph Smith also had powers. He saw the angel Moroni. Look how persecuted he was for that. What bothers me most about a lot of psychics is that they don't talk about God.


...


As a Baptized, Communion- ized and Confirmed follower of Jesus Christ, a lifelong member and all-eternity-till-Judgement-Day-long-would-they-be-correct-member of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church (at least on paper), as a graduate of C.C.D at Our Lady of Consolation Church in Brooklyn, New York City (and with good grades, too), as a former regular member of Corpus Christi Church in Woodside, Queens, as a former C.C.D student at Corpus Christi, as a former member of St. Anthony's in Soho and as a former member of another parish I now don't remember the name of, I can tell you that this is absolutely not what Christians believe. The very idea of this would be hilarious to them, as a matter of fact. Jesus knew he'd be executed cause God told him. He was able to cast out illnesses cause he was the son of God. That you'd claim the same powers as Jesus is rather funny, though.

Joseph Smith did not see an angel. He did not have psychic powers. He was a convicted con man and possibly mentally unbalanced...but he was indeed persecuted for that.

...

6) Some critics like to point to your past legal problems, noting you and your husband pled no contest to securities fraud in 1992.
My husband was. I paid off the IRS. It's all in my book, Real Adventures of a Psychic . My husband opened up a gold mine, and of course my name was on everything. He didn't have a securities license and they came down on him. I was never booked. I was never indicted. But I paid all the fines because I was the only one working.



...


No. Just no. Robert has some mighty interesting documents on his site that say otherwise. You were booked. You were indicted. You did plead no contest. You also don't seem to know what "paying off the IRS" means, in addition to everything else you don't know. Like the meaning of the words "You are under arrest" and "Sylvia Celeste Browne, you have been charged with eight counts of securities fraud, how do you plead?". Like the most basic shame, the most basic compassion for people who've tragically lost loved ones, what the most basic human decency is, what a Master's degree is, how to speak intelligible English, how to spell, how to not get caught in obvious lies on TV, what a matching outfit constitutes, what appropriate nail length is, what lecithin can and can't do and that Nero did not have "an address", let alone "666".


...


7) Some psychologists explain "seers" and "psychics" as people with "eidetic" abilities that allow them to project into the outer world what they see in their minds.
What difference would that make, whether it comes inward or outward? That's such a stupid theory. What's the difference between it being infused through me, rather than it just being there?
Well, some might say the difference is that you see it, but others don't.
That's true. It doesn't mean we're [psychics] any better. We just happened to be at the right place at the right time. It's not a pleasant place to be because then you've set yourself up for everything.



...


It makes no difference because neither exist. You do not "see" anything. If you don't think it would be "pleasant" to be psychic, you should be pretty glad because you are not one.
 
Last edited:
Brattus, my "followers" on this forum have been critical of me many times. When I would post links here to new SSB articles, there were many instances when people were very critical of the article. So much so one time that I pulled an article off of the site in response to the chorus of criticism.

Yeah, but I was critical of you when I thought you weren't harsh enough towards Browne :D. And when you didn't include information that would have damned her even more or added more to the story because you were too fair and even handed.

And I was critical of you when you didn't naturally assume she was a fraud and work from there (a very reasonable assumption) and, instead, chose to only make articles based on only the very solid evidence against her and the strongest evidence against her powers (when anyone else would have been much less charitable).

Whoa, when?! And what?! It must have been quite quickly because I followed the site religiously from the week it was born and I apparently missed this.

It seems to me that you have decided to be The Rebel here, but end up being the Rebel Without a Clue. Not because I disagree with you, but because you are intentionally misinterpreting my posts

Word. Excellent response, sir.
 
Last edited:
Brattus, I apologize for my previous post. You are neither stupid nor foolish. I used those terms to "tweak" you for referring to Browne's followers in similar ways. But two wrongs don't make a right, so I apologize. And my joke about Browne and the reformation was ill-advised, but I truly don't think it indicates any change in my approach to skepticism. It was an attempt at humor in a casual post in a forum, not a formal article on my site. I know there are those who would use such a post to try and discredit my formal writings, so you are right - I need to be more careful. But a couple more intentional misinterpretations of my posts, and I will put you on Ignore here. that is something I do not do lightly, but I need to watch my blood pressure.
 
Whoa, when?! And what?! It must have been quite quickly because I followed the site religiously from the week it was born and I apparently missed this.

I can't recall what the article was, but many (especially CFLarsen) were jhighly criitical of it, saying that it was not to the site's usual standards. I pulled it down immediately, but may have rewritten and reposted it.



Word. Excellent response, sir
 
Are you suggesting Sylvia Browne be burned alive Mr. Lancaster?
What happened to the level headed skeptical approach you are so famous for?
Have you ever had a whiff of burning human flesh? Not very pleasant I can tell you.

Now obviously Sylvia Browne should not be making money off the fools for a living.
But just as obvious is the fact that what she does for a living is not a crime.
If it were she would have been in jail a long time ago.

So now you are posting about someone who is not breaking the law being tied to a stake and burned alive because you don't agree with how she makes a living.

I have sensed a change in you Mr. Lancaster.
A change that your faithful follows on here would never dream of bringing up.
You have a real talent no doubt.
But you have bought into your own press clippings on this forum.
Also you have made Sylvia Browne your personal enemy.

Before, your site was not personal it was just the facts to let people make up their own minds.
But I can see a very real slant in your posting on here and no doubt that will make it's way on to your site.




Hey here is a lie I'll bet no one counted.

Dear Brattus,

You stated in another thread that the only thing you needed to know about Sylvia Browne is when she is dead. Well she isn't dead yet.

Your friend,
Francine
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom