Contest: How Many Sylvia Browne Lies Can You Count?

Francine

Scholar
Joined
Jan 5, 2010
Messages
68
Dear JREF Pals,

She's done it again! Now that I have learned to use the internet and do a bit of research, I'm angrier than ever. She's spreading her poison now to the Mormons? This is just crossing the line. They are Latter Day Saints, people!! Would you lie to a Saint?

http://www.sltrib.com/entertainment/ci_13911076

I have many issues with this article. There's so many lies.

Here's a fun contest that I hope you will all participate in.

How many lies can you count?

I'll follow up with my analysis later.

Your friend,
Francine
 
You are said to have predicted the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

I kept seeing fire everywhere in New York. I called Montel -- everyone. I saw fire everywhere. I kept seeing it a week before and it wouldn't leave me. Fire shooting up in the air. I couldn't pinpoint it and it kept driving me crazy.

Do you think Montel would lie to back her up?

Steve S.
 
Last edited:
I saw that article last month and wasn't impressed with the journalist. The journalist could have, at any point, asked: "where's your proof?" Browne, on the other hand, was fairly typical for what she does.
 
#1: San Jose-based psychic Sylvia Browne doesn't care if you believe her predictions.

- Of course she cares. If people didn't believe her predictions, they wouldn't pay her for her "readings."

#2: She has, she said, passed muster with the Better Business Bureau.

- I don't think that the BBB has a "passed muster" rating. there are complaints against SBC with the BBB, but not as many as you would think. Possibly because people are too ashamed that they fell for Browne's crap to want to admit to it to the BBB, afraid the response would be "what did you expect?"

#3: She never solicits clients

- there are whole pages on her web site devoted to soliciting clients.

#4 and first knew of her powers at age 5 when she saw both her great-grandmothers' faces melt as they sat together on the family sofa.

- how many conflicting versions of this tall tale has she told? She was 5, she was 7. they were on the sofa, they were at the kitchen table... Sounds like a pretty memorable event - you'd think her memory of it would be clearer and more consistent - had it ever happened.

#5 I kept seeing fire everywhere in New York.

Oh, so now it was "in New York?" I never heard THAT particular version of that reprehensible lie before.

#6 and 7 "I told James Randi two months before the fact that he was going to have a heart attack"

- if she is talking about the september 3, 2001 Larry King Live show (and, by the way, she didn't complain of "seeing fire" then), she told him to "have his left ventricle checked." He did, and was given a clean bill of health. He had his bypass surgery more than four years later, not "two months later." And his heart problem was not related to his left ventricle.

#8 when millions of women were burned to death.

- Evidence?

#9 "I was never booked. I was never indicted."

- she was convicted and did public service.

I cannot be bothered to read the rest of this crap. Next time Francine, have a contest to count the number of true and accurate statements she makes. It would save timne.
 
Maybe :) But its a fair question...how far would he lie?

Well, since he has stated publicly that he does not believe in "psychic powers", yet continued to introduce Browne on his show as "world-famous psychic Sylvia Browne", it seems that he would lie pretty damned far.
 
Last edited:
Maybe :) But its a fair question...how far would he lie?

That is a good question. With her he's in too deep. He won't back out now. And he has his previous weasel phrase of "I don't believe in psychics but I do believe in Sylvia Browne." And "she has a great intuition that the rest of us don't."

And I'm surprised Randi even bothered to leave a comment.

I wish the reporter would do a follow up and expose her. But I'm sure that would never happen.
 
Last edited:
This may not be the most important lie; it may not even be a lie, exactly. Perhaps she's just ill-informed, but it irked me, nonetheless:

I always agree what people say about history. It's written by the victors.

The most comprehensive accounts of the Anglo-Saxon invasion of Britain were by Britons, not Anglo-Saxons (since the Anglo-Saxons has not yet been introduced to the Latin alphabet).

The Holocaust was absolutely horrifying, but we never talk about the burning times during the Middle Ages in Europe when millions of women were burned to death. Even if you were an herbalist and a woman, you were burned as a witch.

First of all, no good is ever going to come from a sentence that begins, "The Holocaust was absolutely horrifying, BUT..." And, what, historians have ignored the witch persecutions? Try searching for "witch persecutions" or "witch hunts" on Amazon. Oh, and the worst witch persecutions were AFTER the Middle Ages, during the Reformation. Read a book, Sylvia.
 
I think that Steve was being facetious.

Not entirely. I think he's just managed to avoid the question. I doubt that anyone has ever asked him directly "Did Sylvia call you in the week before 9-11 and tell you that she saw fires in New York?" I wonder how he'd respond if confronted with it.

Steve S.
 
Oh, and the worst witch persecutions were AFTER the Middle Ages, during the Reformation.

Really? Maybe you are confusing burning at the stake in Protestants vs. Catholics conflicts with witch persecutions? I'd think that way more witches would be burned from the 400s to the 1500s than in the 1500s to the 1600s.
 
Really? Maybe you are confusing burning at the stake in Protestants vs. Catholics conflicts with witch persecutions? I'd think that way more witches would be burned from the 400s to the 1500s than in the 1500s to the 1600s.

No. The main persecutions were in the Renaissance and later. People always associate the Middle Ages with witch hunts, but people always associate everything bad with the Middle Ages. Trust me, I'm a medievalist.

If you don't trust me (you skeptic, you), here are a few resources (just from a quick google search): Witch-hunt, Witch Trials in Early Modern Europe, Ten Common Errors and Myths about Witch Hunts.

I would also note that the Malleus Maleficarum (The Hammer of Witches) was published in 1486, toward the end of the medieval period and beginning of the early modern period.
 
The thing that gets me about that particular lie is that I seriously doubt "millions" of witches were burned. Come on, millions?! :boggled:
 
The thing that gets me about that particular lie is that I seriously doubt "millions" of witches were burned. Come on, millions?! :boggled:

From the 10 Common Errors page I cited above:

#6. Millions of people died because of the Witch Hunts.

FACT: While millions of people might have been affected, the best estimates of recent historians range from 50,000 to 200,000 dead.

COMMENTARY: The earlier estimates, too often the figure of 9 to 10 million dead is cited, were grossly exaggerated; no respectable historian supports them anymore. Modern figures concerning the number of executed witches are based on a much closer examination of the surviving historical records, combined with reasonable guesswork and statistical analysis for those areas and periods lacking clear sources. The hunts were anything but constant, systematic or frequent.

That some villages were wiped out by witch hunters is also an exaggeration. There is little evidence for such devastation. One extreme example is reported from 1589, where only two women were left in one village in the Trier diocese after a hunt (Wolfang Behringer, ed. Hexen und Hexenprozesse in Deutschland, 4th ed. (Munich: Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag, 2000), 205, #124). But that left the men. In any case, such thoroughness and ferocity were extremely rare. Further, any particular area had hunts irregularly, and many regions had no hunts at all.

Even the much lower figure of under 50,000 dead would have meant over a hundred thousand put on trial. Then, considering all the personnel involved in the justice system as court officials and witnesses, friends and family members, and those who even felt the "fear" caused by the hunts, millions of people’s lives changed, usually for the worse, because of the witch hunts.
 
Thank you Lucian.

To take Sylvia's lie one step further- what she said is that "millions of women were burned to death" and that "even if you were an herbalist and a woman, you were burned as a witch".

So you mean to tell me that millions of women were killed? Wouldn't this have greatly impacted the population back then? Sylvia specifically stated Europe. Even if it was over a large span of time, millions?!

It's also ridiculous to state that herbalist + woman = death. Perhaps some of the women who were persecuted were herbalists, but certainly not all instances, as Sylvia has implied.
 
Thank you Lucian.

To take Sylvia's lie one step further- what she said is that "millions of women were burned to death" and that "even if you were an herbalist and a woman, you were burned as a witch".

So you mean to tell me that millions of women were killed? Wouldn't this have greatly impacted the population back then? Sylvia specifically stated Europe. Even if it was over a large span of time, millions?!

It's also ridiculous to state that herbalist + woman = death. Perhaps some of the women who were persecuted were herbalists, but certainly not all instances, as Sylvia has implied.

There's no question that witch persecutions were awful, but to compare them to the holocaust....well.... Pretty much everything she said is wrong. The numbers are wrong; the time period is wrong, and although women may have been overrepresented among the persecuted, men were tried and killed, as well.

To be fair, she isn't by any means the only one to make these mistakes. I remember that in one of Michael Shermer's books, he talks about witch hunts, and he says "medieval" over and over, even though he also places the persecutions in the 16th and 17th centuries. I think he even manages to get "medieval" and "17th century" in the same sentence to refer to the same time period. Again, I don't think he's lying; people just have a knee-jerk response and want to modify "witch hunt" with "medieval." You'd think someone in the editorial process would have caught such an obvious error, however.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom