Constructing a new age "energy" test, suggestions and help appreciated.

It just came to my mind that we'd also have to monitor the healers in case they try to use static electricity to signal the CLAIMANT by rubbing their shirt in a specific way before entering the room. If anyone still comes up with precautions or possible cheating mechanism, please let us know.
 
Last edited:
We don't think THE CLAIMANT is going to cheat, but we will do our best to eliminate any kind of cheating (conscious or unconscious) nevertheless.
<snip>
I'm quite confident that we can block cheating from this test.

I think what you're doing is great, and I'm not casting aspersions on anyone involved. I will suggest that people can cheat with good intentions. For example, one might say, "I know this works, but they don't understand that science can't explain it. If I can pass this little test of theirs, then maybe it will open their minds. So what if I 'cheat' a little bit? They're not being fair either. They will be better off because of it."

I'm glad you're confident you can detect cheating, but if it were me, I'd be nervous. You have two people who know each other and know the protocol in advance. They will be in *very* close physical proximity. The *only* message that needs to be transmitted and received is "Hello, it's me."

I'd say that maybe I'm paranoid, but that's not something I want The Watchers see me write in a public forum.
 
I hear you UncaYimmy, good point regarding cheating w/ good intentions. We want to be as fair as possible, while still being very careful not to leave any holes in the protocol that would allow cheating of any kind. Please, let us know if you come up with any possible problems regarding the protocol. We are doing our best to eliminate any signalling.

We are making it very clear that this is still just a home test, although one that we are going to do "by the book" and as well as we can. If she passes the test, my first thought would be that we have a hole in the protocol. If we can't find any holes we will take the case further. We will also make it clear that the real tests (Finnish Skeptics and the MDC pre-test) are going to be much more official, tight and scientific in their nature. Maybe this will also lessen their possible eagerness to cheat w/ good intentions, or maybe it will only increase it, who knows? The bottom line is that they understand that it takes proper and repeated tests to "open" our minds. The good thing is that they are willing to participate, THE CLAIMANT is at the top of the food chain when it comes to alternative healers in our town.
 
Last edited:
I understand that being a home test you're not going to go with the same standards you would on an official test. And since you're dealing with someone who seems to genuinely believe in her powers, you're not going to have the same concerns you might going up against a known con artist. Even if she wanted to "cheat" for the greater good of mankind, it probably wouldn't be that sophisticated.

As I read through the suggestions it would seem pretty difficult to create a signal. The mask over the healer's face alleviates my concern about using air as a signal, though having her face down would also make it harder for her to see.

Has she ever done anything like this before? In other words what gives here cause to believe that she could pass this test in the first place? I know I don't have someone's hands near my face all that often.

Has she seen this thread? I wonder how it compares with the steps she has taken to ensure that her healing powers are genuine and not due to some other factor.
 
Has she ever done anything like this before? In other words what gives here cause to believe that she could pass this test in the first place? I know I don't have someone's hands near my face all that often.

Has she seen this thread? I wonder how it compares with the steps she has taken to ensure that her healing powers are genuine and not due to some other factor.

She's never done anything like this before. I don't think she would understand a whole lot from this thread, because she doesn't speak english so well.

What gives her cause to believe? Simply put, each and every aspect of her life, I think. For this kind of person every emotion, every feeling, phenomenon and incident gives her affirmation in the reality she's living in. To her it's all part of the same oneness, which manifests itself in various forms and blaah blaah...if you've been around the people of woo, you know what I mean. Concerning the ability she claims to have, I think it's even more simple. She has it because she feels it to be true.

I don't think she'll go through any special preparations before the test. To her it's relatively mundane, and she constantly keeps reminding us (or herself?) that no matter what the result, it won't affect her beliefs in the claimed ability or the existence of chi.
 
I don't think she'll go through any special preparations before the test. To her it's relatively mundane, and she constantly keeps reminding us (or herself?) that no matter what the result, it won't affect her beliefs in the claimed ability or the existence of chi.


This is where we need to step in, I think. Last time we had a meeting I asked her: "..why not, is there something wrong with the protocol?", I think that got her thinking for just a little while. If she doesn't pass the test, I'm hoping that we can get something inside her "click" just a little bit towards other explanations than healing "energy", etc., or at the very least, make her actually think about the issue.
 
Alright, people!

Everything is in order and we're going to perform the test tomorrow, starting at nine. We're pretty stoked here with Kuko, and are truly hoping that after the open test (before the actual one) the claimant will still feel certain of her ability, so we can get down to business.

The protocol's fairly tight for a hometest like ours, but there's still one addition we decided to propose to the claimant and the healer. It's turning the test from mere 50/50 chance (coin tossing) to a notably more difficult task by adding also a third option of "no one present" (a roll of dice defining who, or nobody, gives the "healing").

We haven't done the math to see what the odds are if the claimant scores 8/10 twice in a row with three options to choose from. But I think it's safe to say that a result like that would be worthy of some rekognition.

That's it for now. We'll be back with some results!
 
Last edited:
The odds of correctly guessing a 1 in 3 chance event at least 8 times out of 10 in two consecutive 10 test trials is nearly 1 in 90,000.

That said, if no one is now a possible answer, how will you rule out clues form body heat or the lack thereof? Depending upon how close a persons hands are to your face you may be able to sense them by their temperature. This wouldn't help her to differentiate between the healer and the placebo but it could help her to distinguish between someone and no one thus skewing your results.

Best of luck with the test.

'beeees
 
That said, if no one is now a possible answer, how will you rule out clues form body heat or the lack thereof? Depending upon how close a persons hands are to your face you may be able to sense them by their temperature. This wouldn't help her to differentiate between the healer and the placebo but it could help her to distinguish between someone and no one thus skewing your results.

We thought about this today and decided to test it out by ourselves first. With the kind of ear-protection we're going to use, and if the hands are kept at the agreed distance (which they better be, or else the test is going to be interrupted), it seems highly unlikely (if not utterly impossible) to sense any difference in temperature near the skin. The ears are the most sensitive part of the side of the head, and the ear-protectors cover them (as well as a few cm around the ears) completely. Also, wearing the protectors heats you up after a while, so we came to the conclusion that heat radiation wouldn't be a risk. Not unless the hands are put just above the surface of the skin. We've agreed to keep them at least 10 cm away and stable.

Oh yeah, out of 10 attempts (defined by coin toss) I got 5/10 right when attempting to feel if Kuko's hands were 10 cm away from my head or completely absent (we didn't try it out with three options).

I'm really looking forward to seeing the healers expression after she hears the results of the actual test, if we get that far...we'll catch it on video!
 
Also, wearing the protectors heats you up after a while, so we came to the conclusion that heat radiation wouldn't be a risk. Not unless the hands are put just above the surface of the skin. We've agreed to keep them at least 10 cm away and stable.

Oh yeah, out of 10 attempts (defined by coin toss) I got 5/10 right when attempting to feel if Kuko's hands were 10 cm away from my head or completely absent (we didn't try it out with three options).

It's good to know that you already had that issue covered :)
 
THE CONCLUSION:

Thanks everyone for your invaluable help, the test went pretty smoothly, although we had to cut some corners due to a very tight schedule. As far as I am concerned the test was a very good learning experience, and we are sure to continue testing her and other people like her as soon as possible. The person we tested yesterday was one of the most prominent new age / alternative medicine advocates in our town.

We ended up using only two options. Her goal was to successfully differentiate between the fake healer and the real healer. We set the single trial pass mark at 8 correct hits out of 10. She would have to pass two trials in a row to pass the test.

Unfortunately for her, she got only 5 hits out of 10 in her first trial, result: fail.

We concluded in good spirit that, under these circumstances she did not have the ability that she was sure of having before the test. In the near future we are planning to loosen up the protocol bit by bit up to the point that she can perform 100% or at least closer to our pass mark. This will hopefully make her understand better what her ability is really about. Once again thanks for the help, it was an interesting ride!

I will get back later with a summary of what we learned from the experience and what kind of reasoning the claimant showed after the test, she still believes she has a special ability like this.
 
Last edited:
Congratulations!

I'm glad everything came together for this one. I think that going with the two option test was probably for the best. It is always good to make a test as simple as possible.

Her score or better could have been achieved 62% of the time simply by guessing.

I am interested to hear how she felt about the non-blind trial and her rationalisation of her poor performance in the test proper.

In subsequent tests where you relax the protocol, you should consider running at least two full trials with each protocol variation since the odds of a high score in a single trial are non-trivial.

Well done again,

'beeees
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom