Constructing a new age "energy" test, suggestions and help appreciated.

There shouldn't be much sound. All communication should be by prearranged signals. You can gesture wildly at the healer and lay person. You could signal her that a new round is starting by tapping her ankle. She could then signal you by raising her right hand with closed fist or 1 finger raised (to let you know if she is guessing the healer or non-healer). An ankle tap tells her you got the message and another tap tells her it's time to start the next round.

It should be very, very easy to do without talking.


I agree, we can manage it all by different signals.

I think we will stick with the 2 persons in the room at a same time technique, though. We wouldn't want to distract the healers concentration in any additional way.
 
This is not exactly her claim, so she might not go for it, but try this on for size....

Only use one person, the healer. Based on a coin flip, the healer is either to "really" heal, or just hold her hands without emitting energy. At end of 2 minutes, testee states whether energy was emitted or not.

This removes issues of identification. Still leave testee blindfolded, so she can't tell by facial expressions or the such whether the healer is 'trying' or not.
 
Thanks for the correction, it looked wrong when I typed it but my spell checker doesn't catch when I correctly spell the wrong word.

"I'm an American Sergeant, not an English Major."

Robert


The smiley was actually there because of the pun :boxedin: I don't worry about stuff like that too much on forums. At least not if the poster is making good sense and being helpful.
 
Interesting idea, roger, we'll think about it and ask what she thinks about it too. To me, the current one seems more robust / conclusive, so I think we'll stick with that for now.
 
Don't know what she thinks about the cardboard or glass between the hands and the head, something to think about more for sure.

I'm pretty sure she won't accept it. After all, what she's expecting "to feel" is from her point of view a real force, easily interrupted by material objects. I think if we raise the room temperature just a bit and keep the healer's / lay person's hands far enough, heat radiation won't be a problem.

But we're gonna have to ask her about this one anyway. She's really helpfull and seems to be as excited (and genuinely interested in the result) about this test as we are.

Very good advice ya'll, thanks!
 
She agreed on these, what people use on the construction areas, etc.:

http://images.google.fi/images?hl=fi&q=ear+protectors&gbv=2

I don't know the correct word, so I just used ear protectors, we can use normal professional ear plugs under these as well. We will also try them first to make sure how much noise gets through (this is a home test so I guess that will have to do). We agreed that we can also play music to cover potential light noises. Maybe we should put somekind of a carpet on the solid floor and ask the lay person and the healer to take off their shoes and also decide how they walk, stop, turn and walk back.

That ought to cover it. With that type of hearing protection I believe you typically get 20-30 dB of reduction, which is an apparent division of 4-8. If they're walking on carpet w/o shoes I'd be satesfied.
 
Interesting idea, roger, we'll think about it and ask what she thinks about it too. To me, the current one seems more robust / conclusive, so I think we'll stick with that for now.
I suggest mine is far more robust and conclusive, as there is much less possibly for external factors to sway the outcome. Nor can she claim after the fact that as it turns out the lay person must have untapped talent.
 
I suggest mine is far more robust and conclusive, as there is much less possibly for external factors to sway the outcome. Nor can she claim after the fact that as it turns out the lay person must have untapped talent.


I agree that there is less external factors, but I think we need to be extra careful with the "energies". She or they could feel afterwards that she still felt a "presence" in the room, or something like that. I think the solid floor, carpet and very good ear protection is good enough. But I will definitely ask her about this, after all, the simpler, the better.
 
Last edited:
That ought to cover it. With that type of hearing protection I believe you typically get 20-30 dB of reduction, which is an apparent division of 4-8. If they're walking on carpet w/o shoes I'd be satesfied.
I'd be careful. I have ear protection like this, as well as bud type earplugs. As an experiment for this thread, I am currently wearing both at once. I can still hear my own typing, and my dogs walking around. Not running around, just walking. Pretty quiet. These pretty much attenuate sound, but don't block it completely.

With just the single set of over the ears, I can hear the gentle rain falling on my roof, the quiet hum of my computer, the breathing of my dogs, etc.

I am using MSA Apex 30, which provide 30dB attenuation. I don't have a rating for my in ear buds, but would guess they are running around 25dB based on their performance.
 
Thanks for the additional info roger, we will definitely test it well beforehand, don't forget we also have the opportunity to play music in the room.
 
Who qualifies as a "healer"? A doctor?

And is your friend likely to declare someone a "healer" if she "senses" that the person is one, even if the person isn't? I mean, would she claim that the person is a "healer" and doesn't realize it?


M.
 
Who qualifies as a "healer"? A doctor?

And is your friend likely to declare someone a "healer" if she "senses" that the person is one, even if the person isn't? I mean, would she claim that the person is a "healer" and doesn't realize it?


M.


She knows many new age "energy" healers, after all, she is one of the most prominent ones in our city. Real medical background does not come into play here I assume, it's all about the new age "energy". The healer is an acquaintance of her who she trusts to be an excellent "energy" healer.

We talked about the "hidden healer" aspect earlier today in our first meeting, and that's one of the reasons I volunteered as the placebo healer as we both agree I'm not one, at least for now..
 
This is not exactly her claim, so she might not go for it, but try this on for size....

Only use one person, the healer. Based on a coin flip, the healer is either to "really" heal, or just hold her hands without emitting energy. At end of 2 minutes, testee states whether energy was emitted or not.

This removes issues of identification. Still leave testee blindfolded, so she can't tell by facial expressions or the such whether the healer is 'trying' or not.
But the healer would have to know if he is healing or not healing during a trial. Maybe the healer unconsciously squeezes a bit harder when he believes he is healing. For a set-up trick you could do anything: For "HEAL" squeeze hard, or tap finger twice, or move finger slightly left to right instead of in a circle, or brush wrist lightly before grabbing hands, or grab left hand before right hand, or just about anything.
 
The test could easily work if the healer doesn’t touch her.

She lays down with a blindfold and headphones playing loud music or static or whatever. Healer, wearing mask to prevent breathing, enters the room and stands behind her. Tester in front flips a coin and displays a sign for “heal” or “don’t heal”. Healer raises his hands near her head and either heals or doesn’t heal. Tester signals when 2 minutes is up. Healer leaves room. Tester turns off music/static in headphones to signal trial is done. She records whether it was a “heal” or “don’t heal”. Repeat this procedure for the predetermined number of trials.

It might be helpful to have some oscillating fans blowing to reduce the possibility of waving hand as a signal, but you would have check that the hand positions of the healer could not control the wind from the fans to create some signal. Several oscillating fans at a distance could do the trick. Or better yet, she could wear cloth over her head as an additional blindfold and as something to prevent wind interfering with her head. It could be something simple: a towel, a hoodie sweatshirt with the face tied all the way up, a parka coat where the face is almost completely enclosed, etc.

If I were doing an investigation instead of a contest, I would also add two types of control trials where there is a non-healer standing behind her, where the is a mannequin standing behind her, and where there is nobody standing behind her. But that is not really necessary if she doesn’t pass the test.

It seems to me the only condition you would need is that the healer "can" hold his hands near someone's head without healing. If that is the case, there should not be many roadblocks.
 
Last edited:
I'd be careful. I have ear protection like this, as well as bud type earplugs. As an experiment for this thread, I am currently wearing both at once. I can still hear my own typing, and my dogs walking around. Not running around, just walking. Pretty quiet. These pretty much attenuate sound, but don't block it completely.

With just the single set of over the ears, I can hear the gentle rain falling on my roof, the quiet hum of my computer, the breathing of my dogs, etc.

I am using MSA Apex 30, which provide 30dB attenuation. I don't have a rating for my in ear buds, but would guess they are running around 25dB based on their performance.
If I had $1 million on the line, I would require that she wear large headphones playing loud static or music intermixed with finger-snaps at varying frequency and loudness, with maybe some random hand-claps and shuffling noises.
 
Thanks for the ideas, all of you. Keep 'em coming!

I've got a set of combined earplugs and phones which I use as a drummer. I think those with white noise at volume as loud as possible plus heavy duty protection will be enough to rule out any hearing-based guesses. Of course we've got to test it ourselves first.

The idea about occasionally leaving no one standing behind her is also excellent. Actually, if she even once signals "healer" when there's nobody, the case is pretty much settled, ain't it?

If we have a videorecorder zoomed in on her head and the hands of whoever's behind her, shouldn't that be enough to bust anybody trying to signal her, even with the slightest of motion?
 
You should set pre-set terminating rules, like. The persons involved on the test must no wear any kind of fragrance, must not wear any kind of bracelet, necklace or noisy free object.

There should be a third observer that does not interact directly whit the subjects to check for any kind of cheating attempt, if a cheating method is suspected to be involved, the observer can give a signal to the referee and test his hypothesis without the person taking the test noticing.

The person taking the test must be made aware to take a sample (indicate which person it correspond) by a remote vibrating device, hear click directly input on their head phones or a mechanical device that taps the test subject that is not influenced by more then its activation.
 
Maybe I've completely misunderstood you, but the whole point of this test is that the healer does NOT touch her.

If the "healer" touches her inevitably pre combined pressure signals can be transmitted trough the skull.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom