Constructing a new age "energy" test, suggestions and help appreciated.

If the "healer" touches her inevitably pre combined pressure signals can be transmitted trough the skull.


I'm so sorry, I just don't get it. The "healer" does not touch her at any point. I must be losing my mind, I cannot understand what you guys mean :o


ETA: I think I got it now, I think DevilsAdvocate interpreted this:

roger said:
..or just hold her hands without emitting energy.


..as touching the hands of our friend the claimant who claims she can sense healing "energies". And I think that roger mistook (or mistyped) that the healer is a "she" when in fact the healer is a "he". And that roger meant what we mean in the OP with that quote, maybe :) Who knows, anyways, at this point we are not going to deviate from the original plan - this means that there will be no touching at all, only sending of the "energies".
 
Last edited:
CLAIM:

She lays on her back and the healer places his hands about 10 cm away from both sides of her head, no moving of the hands, no touching, nor anything similar to message her. In two minutes time she can differentiate between a lay person and a healer only through the "energy" the healer sends to her. The healer is someone she knows and trusts to be a genuine "energy" healer.

There it is. In the OP. NO touching involved.

How about some math on chances? How many people do we need to use and how many times does she have to make the guess?
 
How about some math on chances? How many people do we need to use and how many times does she have to make the guess?


I think 1 lay person and 1 healer is enough, Loss Leader put it nicely. I'd also like to know more about the chances, what is the equivalent of chance and what is the success rate that you guys would consider impressive? Our friend claimed a success rate of 100%.

I think we are good with 1 healer and 1 lay person, we flip a coin to decide the "healer", repeat this 10 times, and run it twice.

ETA: I agree that it would be interesting to test her with three subjects: healer, lay person, no-one.
 
Last edited:
You should set pre-set terminating rules, like. The persons involved on the test must no wear any kind of fragrance, must not wear any kind of bracelet, necklace or noisy free object.

There should be a third observer that does not interact directly whit the subjects to check for any kind of cheating attempt, if a cheating method is suspected to be involved, the observer can give a signal to the referee and test his hypothesis without the person taking the test noticing.

The person taking the test must be made aware to take a sample (indicate which person it correspond) by a remote vibrating device, hear click directly input on their head phones or a mechanical device that taps the test subject that is not influenced by more then its activation.
The signal can be a light that is plainly visible to the person being tested, but operated by the observer, preferably out of sight of the one being tested. The observer sets up a test round by flipping a coin or rolliing a die and positioning healer, non-healer, or no-one. He (or she) then turns on the light to indicate the test round has started, and also starts a timer. The light is turned off when the one being tested indicates her choice of who she thinks is behind her, or the two minute time frame expires with no indication.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, to make things clearer, here are the persons taking part in this test so far:

JANE, and she is: THE CLAIMANT

JOHN, and he is: THE HEALER

KUKO, and he is: THE PLACEBO HEALER

TAPIO, and he is: THE OBSERVER

NO-ONE, who is: THE NO-ONE
 
Last edited:
There should be a third observer that does not interact directly whit the subjects to check for any kind of cheating attempt, if a cheating method is suspected to be involved, the observer can give a signal to the referee and test his hypothesis without the person taking the test noticing.


Yes, this is a good point, we need to discuss this more with THE CLAIMANT and THE HEALER, especially the possible pausing of the test. If they think a 3rd person might cause "mixed energies" in the room, we're just going to have to find another way to do it. Maybe through a window. Or maybe even through the two videocameras. I don't think this will be a problem, but we will definitely need to agree that the test can be paused if the OBSERVER or someone else notices anything suspicious or not belonging to the protocol.
 
I'm so sorry, I just don't get it. The "healer" does not touch her at any point. I must be losing my mind, I cannot understand what you guys mean :o
I'm supporting your point that the healer can not touch her at any time.
 
Last edited:
The signal can be a light that is plainly visible to the person being tested, but operated by the observer, preferably out of sight of the one being tested. The observer sets up a test round by flipping a coin or rolliing a die and positioning healer, non-healer, or no-one. He (or she) then turns on the light to indicate the test round has started, and also starts a timer. The light is turned off when the one being tested indicates her choice of who she thinks is behind her, or the two minute time frame expires with no indication.

Light is not a good idea because that would implicate that the test subject is not blindfolded. If we can’t restrain the subject from being blindfolded, you must be extra careful in order to not place objects that might give any reflection, lights must be put in such a fashion that shadows are not visible by the test subject, also you must be extra careful whit the test subject objects or actions.
 
Light is not a good idea because that would implicate that the test subject is not blindfolded. If we can’t restrain the subject from being blindfolded, you must be extra careful in order to not place objects that might give any reflection, lights must be put in such a fashion that shadows are not visible by the test subject, also you must be extra careful whit the test subject objects or actions.
Duh! Oh, well, back to the drawing board ...
 
To recap, this is what he have so far:

The key:

THE CLAIMANT (JANE)

THE HEALER (JOHN)

THE PLACEBO HEALER (KUKO)

THE OBSERVER (TAPIO)




THE CLAIM:

THE CLAIMANT (JANE) lies on her back on a bed, all normal ways to sense a presence of anyone else in the same room blocked. THE HEALER (JOHN) places his hands about 10 cm away from both sides of her head and sends healing "energy" to THE CLAIMANT. In two minutes time THE CLAIMANT claims to be able to differentiate between THE HEALER and THE PLACEBO HEALER (KUKO) only through the healing "energy". Moving of the hands, any kind of touching, or anything similar used to signal or message THE CLAIMANT in a known physical way is not allowed. THE CLAIMANT claims a 100% success rate.



So far, these are the details we have already agreed that THE CLAIMANT is 100% comfortable with:

* THE HEALER is someone THE CLAIMANT knows and trusts to be a genuine "energy" healer.

* THE CLAIMANT will have her eyes blinfolded at all times during the test.

* THE CLAIMANT will be wearing sufficient ear plugs + ear protectors + allows music in the room to block any noise and sounds that might occur during the test.

* THE CLAIMANT will be wearing nose plugs and allows different incenses in the room to block any smells that might connect THE CLAIMANT with THE HEALER or to THE PLACEBO HEALER.

* There will be 2 video cameras, 1 for overall picture and 1 for close up of the action.

* THE PLACEBO HEALER and THE HEALER must approach THE CLAIMANT in the same way, no extra or sudden movements allowed.

* The hands of THE PLACEBO HEALER and THE HEALER have to remain at a certain maximum lenght from the head, no hand movements allowed.

* Only two persons are allowed in the room at a same time: THE CLAIMANT and THE HEALER / THE PLACEBO HEALER.



The following are the "pending" details, ideas and suggestions we haven't yet discussed with the CLAIMANT (JANE) nor the HEALER (JOHN):

* The test consists of two separate trials. A trial consists of 10 "guesses" from THE CLAIMANT where she is to say whether she feels the "energies" of THE HEALER, or not. The test is a success if THE CLAIMANT succeeds 10 times out of 10, in both separate trials. However, if THE CLAIMANT significantly beats the odds of random guesswork, I have promised to investigate her ability further and help her in contacting the MDC.

* Randomizing between the THE HEALER and THE PLACEBO HEALER will be accomplished by a coin flip or something similar.

* There will be an open test before the real test, to make sure THE CLAIMANT can feel the "energies" and is happy with the testing conditions and her own state of mind.

* The inclusion of NO-ONE to the protocol.

* A carpet will be placed on the solid floor + THE HEALER and THE PLACEBO HEALER must not wear shoes.

* To let THE CLAIMANT know when THE HEALER / PLACEBO HEALER is ready and in place, first idea: THE CLAIMANT has a phone in her pocket, set on vibration. THE OBSERVER calls THE CLAIMANT when THE HEALER or THE PLACEBO HEALER is ready and in place, THE CLAIMANT lifts her hand to let THE OBSERVER know she knows it's time. Further, THE CLAIMANT could also lift her hand whenever she is ready before the 2 minutes have passed.

It would be very good if there could be a small piece of cardboard, glass or plexiglass between the person's hand and her head. This will rule out many things (even skin heat) that might help her tell which person is which.


Make sure the room has a very solid floor and/or an isolated surface for the subject to lay on. Walking rhythm or slight shifts in weight could be communicated to the subject.


If you have an office char with wheels and a floor it rolls easily upon (or a wheelchair ideally) you could have the healer (real or placebo) sit in the chair and wheel them into position, eliminating clues from footsteps.


A bit of Vicks vapo rub applied to the hands of the healers (real and placebo) should eliminate any personal odour.

Depending upon the shape of the bridge of the subject's nose, you may have to tape down some parts of the blindfold to prevent her from actually seeing out. Watch to see if she tilts her head in any funny ways during the test.

Ask if she can perform the test while listening to music through headphones. This might be more effective at eliminating telltale sounds such as breathing or deep humming from the healers than ear plugs.

Have the healers chew on a breath mint prior to the test and wear a dust mask during the test. This eliminates clues from breath smell as well as subtle blowing on the forehead of the subject.


All communication should be by prearranged signals.


Why not have both the healer and the placebo sit on chairs behind her, and she has to tell which one has reached out to put his hand behind her head? That eliminates footsteps.


Only use one person, the healer. Based on a coin flip, the healer is either to "really" heal, or just hold her hands without emitting energy. At end of 2 minutes, testee states whether energy was emitted or not.


Playing white noise through headphones..


You should set pre-set terminating rules, like. The persons involved on the test must no wear any kind of fragrance, must not wear any kind of bracelet, necklace or noisy free object.


There should be a third observer that does not interact directly whit the subjects to check for any kind of cheating attempt, if a cheating method is suspected to be involved, the observer can give a signal to the referee and test his hypothesis without the person taking the test noticing.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for all the help so far, we are looking pretty much set to go. Any further comments, ideas, etc. are still very much appreciated. Especially in the odds department. What would be the equivalent of a guesswork in this case: 10 guesses, two separate trials?
 
Thanks for all the help so far, we are looking pretty much set to go. Any further comments, ideas, etc. are still very much appreciated. Especially in the odds department. What would be the equivalent of a guesswork in this case: 10 guesses, two separate trials?

I'm not quite sure what you mean by, "the equivalent of guesswork." The subject could, potentially, achieve any result by guesswork, some results are simply less likely than others.

Score >= | Probability 1 trial | Probability both trials
5 |0.6230 |0.3882
6 |0.3770 |0.1421
7 |0.1719 |0.0295
8 |0.0547 |0.0030
9 |0.0107 |0.0001
10 |0.000977|0.000000954

So the odds of the subject guessing correctly 10 times out of 10 in a given trial are about 1 in 1000

The odds of the subject scoring at least 9 out of 10 in both trails are about 1 in 10000.

The odds of the subject scoring at least 8 out of 10 in both trials are about 1 in 300.

I would suggest that you set the pass mark for the trail as being at least 8 out of 10 for both trials. This leaves some room for error and does not allow for an excuse along the lines of "I was under too much stress to be 100% accurate."

If she scores 8 out of 10 in one of the trails but fails the other you should be sure to point out that the odds of scoring at least 8 out of 10 in a single trial are about 1 in 20 and so, not particularly impressive.

I have a spreadsheet for calculating these odds but, if you google "binomial calculator" there are quite a few java apps on university websites which will allow you to double-check my calculations.
 
Last edited:
Anyone object to CB's suggestion that at least 8 out of 10 in both trials should be enough for us to take the case forward?

My math shows that to be a 1/65,536 chance. That's damn low.


My math might be wrong.
 
My math shows that to be a 1/65,536 chance. That's damn low.

My math might be wrong.

Your calculations and mine disagree so one of us is wrong. I'm pointing no fingers as I've been wrong before.

I find the odds of guessing 8 or more correct out of 10 to be 0.0547 or about 1 in 18 (I'm being a bit more precise here than I was above.)

This was calculated by applying the standard binomial formula with n=10, p=0.5 & q=0.5 and summing P(k) for k=8, 9 & 10.

The odds of achieving this in both tests would be (0.0547)^2 which is 0.00299 or about 1 in 334.

So the odds of scoring at least 8 out of 10 in both trails are about 1 in 300.

How did you calculate your figure LL?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom