Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

The Fraudulent Fraud Squad


The Nation in an article actually defending Fund against a charge of beating a girlfriend had this reference,

John Fund's book on voter fraud is a fraudThe article elaborates on each "fact" to support their case.

And from someone who knows Fund quite well, it appears:

Yes, there are political axes to grind in these citations. Yes, the authors are left of the right wing Fund. But there are clear facts which are supported, and some that can certainly be verified, like Fund's public fraud claiming to be running for the school board when he wasn't.

Fund's book on election fraud is sourced with anecdotes, a common ploy which can be used knowing the average person (and pomey, apparently)is not going to notice how weak such evidence really is.

So let's not be claiming here this guy has a reputation of truthfulness and reliability when not a shred of evidence has been posted supporting that claim. And, pomey, this is the last word on Fund from me unless you have more than those anecdotes in his book to share with us. I have presented a case and my opinion, you have presented only an opinion.
Very good stuff, SG. I learned a few things here.

Another piece of the puzzle falls into place. Fund is a libertarian, or is still very close to that ideology, apparently. As is pomey. So, it's really just partisan support, and rather blind support at that.
 
Look, I'm not interested in taking your money. Bets that I can't possibly lose don't appeal much to my competitive nature (naturally if the price is right...). But, if the subject interests you, why not read the book? Of course Fund presents detailed coverage of some of the Dems' most brazen and infamous heists. If you don't know what happened in St. Louis in 2000, you owe it to yourself to find out.

Have you read the links Skeptigirl posted? It looks like a substantial number of Fund's claims have been proven to be mendacious, and that he's fabricated at least one news story in the past.

Under the circumstances your second-hand claim that Fund proves there was substantial zombie voter fraud somewhere, some time has to be approached with considerable skepticism.

But please, regale us with the tale of St. Louis in 2000 and link us to his sources. We're mostly good skeptics here, if you have a compelling case we'll acknowledge it.
 
...

But please, regale us with the tale of St. Louis in 2000 and link us to his sources. We're mostly good skeptics here, if you have a compelling case we'll acknowledge it.
Including me. I'm always being accused by those who don't hold my political conclusions of only having those conclusions because I am some blind ideologist. I think by now it should be clear, I have drawn the conclusions I have because I am a fanatical seeker of information. And I look to validate that information and the sources. I don't just suck up what I already agree with.

Provide convincing evidence. I have the usual human fault of needing a bit more to counter what I have already been exposed to, but I am, over everything else, a skeptic. If the evidence is there, it's time to shift one's position. But if someone doesn't have anything to counter what I have, they shouldn't expect to convince me with insults to my skeptic nature and critical thinking skills.
 
Is it me or have you repeated your post within your post?
It was a bizarre event, I cannot explain other than to say it had something to do with something I unknowingly must have done in the copy and paste mode. ;)

So what about those emails?
 
...CLAIM: The Palm Beach Post found "no more than 108 'law-abiding' citizens of all races who 'were purged from the voter rolls as suspected criminals, only to be cleared after the election." (p. 32)

FACT: The Palm Bach Post reported that "at least 1,100 eligible voters [were] wrongly purged from the rolls before last year's election."...
How does this refute Fund's claim? The PBP is clearly talking about voters purged for all reasons (death, no longer live in county, etc) while Fund specifically was talking about criminal purges.
 
...CLAIM: Democratic campaign workers in Wisconsin were caught on film in 2002 "handing out food and small sums of money to residents of a home for the mentally ill in Kenosha, after which the patients were shepherded into a separate room and given absentee ballots." (p. 47)

FACT: News reports directly contradict Fund's account....
Fact: I personally know a Kerry supporter who, along with other Kerry supporters, drove up to Wisconsin to "help" residents of a senior citizens home too frail to do it themselves fill out their absentee ballots. Guess who those seniors all voted for? :rolleyes:

Call me a liar if you want, but I know it to be true.
 
How does this refute Fund's claim? The PBP is clearly talking about voters purged for all reasons (death, no longer live in county, etc) while Fund specifically was talking about criminal purges.

If you read the article, the PBP is talking about people who had committed crimes but who were nonetheless legally eligible to vote, who were purged on the false basis that they had committed crimes that rendered them ineligible.
 
There is no doubt hawking books is motivating Palast. That or basking in the limelight.
True enough.
I'm not clear given the published caging lists, Goodling's testimony, and the fact Griffin has resigned that you are making the assertion, Palast's claims are not substantiated. From this source, the Republicans claimed the lists were for campaign fund raising purposes.
Given that your links are often to partisan blogs, it is difficult to take your protestations of objectivity seriously. The Brad Blog is yet another emotionally charged foaming at the mouth, for all that Griffin surely deserves a basket of overripe fruit tossed at him. I am trying to discern what felony Griffin has been convicted of, for example.
From what I gather, "caging" is standard practice in building mailing lists. But I'll be a monkey's uncle if the Florida GOP didn't already know EXACTLY who lives in the 32209 zip code, and wasn't planning on mailing them campaign literature
That's not evidence of much more than Sven's bias, however, his root cynicism regarding motive of mailing for contributions I'll share.
Apparently Griffin has explained himself now that he has resigned.
Brad blog, 6/14; Tim Griffin Cries, Denies 'Vote Caging' Charges, in Arkansas Speech

The audio link didn't load, blah.

The Arkansas Business link was semi neutral, and raised a point that goes in my next letter to DC (Rep and Sens).
Attorney General Alberto Gonzales dismissed Bud Cummins in December to make way for Griffin. The appointment was made under a provision of the U.S. Patriot Act, which permitted Griffin to serve without Senate confirmation.
That crap needs to get corrected. :mad: Advise and consent was put into the Constitution for a good reason.

Maybe I'll just wait for Palast's book to come out. Without the support for his conclusions in front of me, wading through the dross of partisan blogs is not worth my time.

Sven may be right, where there is smoke there may be fire.

I'll reserve judgment.

DR
 
Have you read the links Skeptigirl posted? It looks like a substantial number of Fund's claims have been proven to be mendacious, and that he's fabricated at least one news story in the past.


Looks can be deceiving. The biggest whopper was the Washington Post's "debunking" of the claim that overvotes hurt Bush. Let's examine this particularly disingenuous argument made by Gore apologists.

Fund documents instances of Democratic vote fraud in Palm Beach County. Specifically, Democratic poll workers were observed inserting a metal device through stacks of paper ballots. Now, when you punch the hole next to Gore's name, you do no damage to a ballot already marked for Gore. When you punch Gore's hole on a ballot cast for another candidate, you invalidate the ballot and create an overvote. Get it? Of course, there were more overvotes with Gore's hole punched--that was the nature of the fraud being committed.

Byron York published an eight-page analysis of Democratic vote fraud on Indian reservations in South Dakota in the 2002 Senatorial election. John Thune decided not to contest the result because the fraud, although blatant, would probably have survived the court's extremely rigid standards of proof that allowed, for example, the Democrats to steal a governor's race in the state of Washington in 2004.


Under the circumstances your second-hand claim that Fund proves there was substantial zombie voter fraud somewhere, some time has to be approached with considerable skepticism.


Your "skepticism" is very far from being real skepticism. It is agenda-driven willful blindness.


But please, regale us with the tale of St. Louis in 2000 and link us to his sources. We're mostly good skeptics here, if you have a compelling case we'll acknowledge it.

Read the book.
 
Very good stuff, SG. I learned a few things here.

Another piece of the puzzle falls into place. Fund is a libertarian, or is still very close to that ideology, apparently. As is pomey. So, it's really just partisan support, and rather blind support at that.


I think you meant to write, the puzzle becomes more puzzling. Libertarians--here's a newsflash--really dislike George Bush. I'm not a true libertarian: I'm a conservative with libertarian views on several issues. Fund is no fan of the current administration.
 
True enough.

Given that your links are often to partisan blogs, it is difficult to take your protestations of objectivity seriously. The Brad Blog is yet another emotionally charged foaming at the mouth, for all that Griffin surely deserves a basket of overripe fruit tossed at him. I am trying to discern what felony Griffin has been convicted of, for example.
I don't believe I asserted everything posted in the blogs was relevant, nor factual. I don't write off everything in a right wing blogs on that basis alone. It is reason to be a tad more skeptical, as I am of information in some left wing blogs. There are, however, sources which are very partisan yet have a high degree of reliability and information in a radical blog can still be looked into.

The Arkansas Business link was semi neutral, and raised a point that goes in my next letter to DC (Rep and Sens).

That crap needs to get corrected. :mad: Advise and consent was put into the Constitution for a good reason.
I appreciate your position here.

That's not evidence of much more than Sven's bias, however, his root cynicism regarding motive of mailing for contributions I'll share.

Brad blog, 6/14; Tim Griffin Cries, Denies 'Vote Caging' Charges, in Arkansas Speech

The audio link didn't load, blah.

Maybe I'll just wait for Palast's book to come out. Without the support for his conclusions in front of me, wading through the dross of partisan blogs is not worth my time.

Sven may be right, where there is smoke there may be fire.

I'll reserve judgment.

DR
While I share your skepticism principles, there is still plenty of material here which is irrefutable. No need to slog through the blogs, I'll summarize it for you. Taken in its entirety there is evidence that Republicans, with direct involvement at the top levels, using the power of state and local positions in the polling system, took specific actions intended to eliminate large numbers of voters in heavily Democratic precincts.

Here are the 'facts' which I don't think are deniable:
  • Goodling testified under oath that the Griffin caging incident was true.
  • Griffin resigned.
  • The list existed, the RNC's reply confirmed it.
  • The RNC put out an explanation for the list which, given the circumstances, was not credible.*
  • The list is of addresses in areas which the demographics show to be heavily Democratic.
  • The Dead Letter office web page exists, as well as a credible explanation of how mis-addressed emails could have indeed been collected.

*You'd have to be an idiot to believe the RNC official explanation for the list, so I think concluding they had something to hide is reasonable regardless of partisan blog discussions.

Then you have the evidence which is reasonable to expect corroborating evidence before concluding it is valid:
  • Some of the emails are posted on the net, in which incriminating statements are made, some by top Republican Party officials and party members.
  • Some of the emails were sent to addresses which only differed by .org and .com providing a credible story about Palast getting the emails.
  • Other addresses on the emails' headers included a mix of .orgs and .coms, also adding to the credibility of emails being easily mis-addressed.
  • Some of the sources discuss the existence of the people to whom the emails were intended. You don't have the RNC claiming those people do not exist and/or that those are not their correct email addresses.

Perhaps it is time to take that 'reservation' out and make a judgment.
 
Pomey, can't you posts some links for those claims of yours? Why should we even believe what you are claiming happened?

Your story about the witnessing of after the fact ballot punching is not sourced for anyone to verify your version, and on its face it isn't credible. Ballot counting in Florida in particular was done in full view of witnesses. So provide a link that can be looked at first hand. Same with the Indian Reservation incident.

Those of us following the Federal Attorney firing scandal are well aware of the handful of incidents of voter fraud, and, of the insignificance of those incidents. Except for the van tire slashing, you got nothin'. And that did not involve a single top Democratic Party official as opposed to the Griffin caging affair which clearly involved not just people at the top, but Bush appointees within the Department of Justice. That's worse than Nixon using the FBI to spy on his political enemies.

I think I posted enough about Fund's book to discredit it. What have you specifically cited from the evidence in the book refuting what I've posted?
 
Last edited:
Your story about the witnessing of after the fact ballot punching is not sourced for anyone to verify your version, and on its face it isn't credible. Ballot counting in Florida in particular was done in full view of witnesses. So provide a link that can be looked at first hand. Same with the Indian Reservation incident.

Indian Reservation incident from Byron York.
 
I think I posted enough about Fund's book to discredit it. What have you specifically cited from the evidence in the book refuting what I've posted?

I don't think Pomeroo does specific cites. He just tells you to read his little book, or makes totally unverifiable claims about fraud.

ETA regarding the Byron York article: It's an oddity significant enough to merit some investigation, but there's no evidence of wrongdoing and if it turns out that there is a reasonable explanation for those polling stations reporting in last then there's not much meat to the story. It should not be too hard to establish whether the systems in use and the presence of bipartisan observers made it possible or impossible to generate a few hundred extra votes at the last minute. It shouldn't be possible of course, but nothing would surprise me about US electoral systems.
 
Last edited:
I don't think Pomeroo does specific cites. He just tells you to read his little book, or makes totally unverifiable claims about fraud.

ETA regarding the Byron York article: It's an oddity significant enough to merit some investigation, but there's no evidence of wrongdoing and if it turns out that there is a reasonable explanation for those polling stations reporting in last then there's not much meat to the story. It should not be too hard to establish whether the systems in use and the presence of bipartisan observers made it possible or impossible to generate a few hundred extra votes at the last minute. It shouldn't be possible of course, but nothing would surprise me about US electoral systems.

In a lot of ways this stuff doesn't really bother me. Why? Because it only matters when the election is a tossup anyway, and the American people (or the local voters) have not really made up their minds either way. And Thune ended up coming back the next election and edging Tom Daschle, a huge win for the Republicans in 2004, so it's hard to say the will of the people of South Dakota was really thwarted; they ended up with a Senate delegation split evenly between Tim Johnson and John Thune, just as that 2002 vote was split evenly.
 
Indian Reservation incident from Byron York.

Well let's see. There was an active successful drive to register more voters by the Democrats......

1 in 10 of the registrations had some irregularities, but we don't know what those consisted of. They could have been as simple as signing an X by an illiterate voter to voters with no birth certificates or SSNs. Pine Ridge is a poverty stricken Indian reservation which did have one of the highest rates of alcoholism and suicide in the country not too long ago. But poverty, depression and alcoholism doesn't mean you lose your right to vote, if that is the case.

79% voted Democratic in the previous election. 92% voted Democratic the year of the incident. Well, d'uh! Democrats recruited the new voters.

The counts came in late. Again, d'uh. They had a substantially greater number of voters.
The county has been the target of intensive get-out-the-vote efforts by Democrats and has reported the largest gain in registrations, 17 percent, of any county in the state. In recent weeks, federal and local authorities have been investigating allegations of fraudulent voting practices related to some of those new voters (along with some in other counties around the state).

In mid-October, the Shannon County auditor said one in ten of the county's new registrations was under investigation for possible irregularities. On October 20, the Sioux Falls Argus Leader reported that, "Auditors in 10 counties, all but one adjoining a reservation, have forwarded questionable registration forms or absentee ballot requests to the sheriff or state's attorney for investigation. Of the nearly 400 questionable documents discovered by the auditors, 338 came from Shannon and Pennington counties, where the two investigations into possible voter fraud are under way."

Shannon County went heavily for Johnson — out of 3,118 votes cast, 2,856, or about 92 percent, went to Johnson,

Daschle, who won in a landslide statewide, won just 79 percent of the votes in Shannon County and newly registered voters this year raised the % voting Democratic.

The situation might be completely attributable to get-out-the-vote efforts; 17,000 new voters were signed up statewide in recent months, and Democrats were particularly aggressive in Shannon County and on the state's other Indian reservations. But Republicans signed up new voters, too, and now they want to have a look at the county's voting patterns.

That was 2002, surely the case has gotten further along since then....hmmmm, let's see.

CNN Reports:
Saturday, November 2, 2002, Pierre, South Dakota (CNN) — A South Dakota election worker will be arrested on charges of forging absentee ballot applications, the state's attorney general announced Friday.

Many voters will continue with older voting technology, while newer methods are being tested around the country. CNN's Kate Snow reports.

Becky Red Earth-Villeda, also known as Maka Duta, is expected to be charged on multiple counts of forgery in Minnehaha County, where Sioux Falls is located, according to a statement from Attorney General Mark Barnett.

"Maka Duta will be arrested in the ordinary course of events," said Barnett. "No evidence has been obtained that shows she has cast or made an attempt to cast actual ballots."

A local Sioux Falls newspaper, the Argus Leader, reported that the woman apparently tried to burn the original applications, but then decided to retrieve them, according to Barnett.

The woman told the attorney general she copied the applicants' names from the original documents because they had been filled out wrong, then she apparently tried to replicate the voter's signature on the corrected form, the newspaper reported.

County auditors alerted the state's Division of Criminal Investigation about allegations of bogus ballot applications, according to Barnett's office. At least 30 DCI agents are working on the case and have interviewed over 400 people in 25 South Dakota counties.

DCI agents also conducted a lengthy interview with Maka Duta Tuesday.

The information obtained is still being processed.

"Voters should proceed as normal and go to the polls on the 5th," said Barnett.

It is not clear how many absentee ballot applications are believed to have been forged, but Barnett told the Argus Leader between 80 and 100 are suspected in one county alone.

Could be bad, the right wing blog, Free Republic, seems to be chiming in to repeat the CNN story and confab add to it.

Arrest Expected in Voter Fraud Investigation (South Dakota)
(Pierre) – Attorney General Mark Barnett announced today that Becky Red Earth-Villeda, also known as Maka Duta, will be arrested in the ordinary course of events for alleged forgery of absentee ballot applications. “Maka Duta will be arrested in the ordinary course of events,” said Barnett. “No evidence has been obtained that shows she has cast or made an attempt to cast actual ballots.”

Maka Duta will be charged in Minnehaha County on multiple counts of forgery.

The Division of Criminal Investigation has interviewed over 400 people in 25 counties. DCI agents also conducted a lengthy interview with Maka Duta on Tuesday. The information obtained is still being processed.

“Voters should proceed as normal and go to the polls on the 5th,” said Barnett.

The Division of Criminal Investigation began investigating allegations of bogus absentee ballot applications after being alerted by county auditors. There are currently 30 DCI agents working on the case.

BUT WAIT, LATE BREAKING NEWS!!! ;)

(It's archived so I had to use the cached, text only, link from the Google search.)
Voter fraud charges in South Dakota prove fraudulent
PIERRE, S.D. - What started out as an attempt to catch the Democrats at voter fraud on South Dakota Indian reservations has backfired on the Republican National Committee.

Republican attorneys fanned out across the state on Election Day Nov. 6 to gather affidavits to show voting irregularities. Now the most serious of those affidavits have been found to be fraudulent themselves.

State Attorney General Mark Barnett, himself a Republican, said of the 50 affidavits the Republican operatives collected, only three alleged criminal activity, and two of those proved to be false. One person is still being sought for questioning.

He said some of the rest of the affidavits were signed with false signatures and others were based on routine questions that come up every election cycle.

Barnett said two of the affidavits were either forgery or perjury because they contained the same wording. "They are just flat false," he said.

In the latest development, David Norcross, a former general counsel for the Republican National Committee and director of the Republican effort, admitted that his group had drawn up stock affidavits with blanks for the signature and then went looking for people to sign them.

According to a Dec. 23 Sioux Falls (S.D.) Argus-Leader story, "Kim Vanneman, the chairwoman of the Tripp County Republicans and a notary public, went door to door in Mission and secured the three signatures of people who said they were offered money in that situation."

The trouble is that two of those three now deny the story, and the third cannot be located.

The revelation is highly embarrassing, both for the Republican National Committee and the "old-right" opinion magazine National Review, which devoted its Dec. 23 cover story to an expose based entirely on the Republican collection of affidavits.

Barnett denounced the National Review story by Byron York as "shoddy, irresponsible, sensationalistic and garbage."
....

:dl:
 
Sorry, couldn't help myself. :dl:

There's no way I would ever claim the Democrats haven't done anything bad. And I already pointed out the pendulum swings both ways. It just so happens the corruption is at the top of the Republican Party currently.

Time to weed it out. Democracies don't last without diligence.
 
Sorry, couldn't help myself. :dl:

There's no way I would ever claim the Democrats haven't done anything bad. And I already pointed out the pendulum swings both ways. It just so happens the corruption is at the top of the Republican Party currently.

I don't buy the argument, but may I point out that the top of the Republican party is going to be completely replaced in 2008? Whereas the Democrats appear set to nominate that noted reformist candidate, "What are these billing records doing in my sewing room?" Hillary Clinton.

Yes, yes, tu quoque and all that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom