Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

Which argument do you not buy, that the Dems are not currently as corrupt as the Republicans?

I am not advocating excusing any financial shenanigans. Sweetheart deals on real estate are not right. And they should be exposed. I refer to the $100,000 profit on the Whitewater real estate by Ms Clinton, not the rest of the accusations of which I find the evidence equivocal. Could she have advised McDougal how to get past regulators? Sure. Did she? Who knows? Was there obstruction of justice trying to cover up the crime? You tell me. Eight years of Republican hack, Ken Starr, trying to find any dirt he could possibly get the Clinton's on and all he ended up with was Bill's entrapped perjury about a blow job.

Frontline on the billing records incident.
Of particular interest to investigators has been Ms. Clinton's work on an option agreement drafted to provide Seth Ward with some $300,000 in commissions on the re-sale of his holdings at Castle Grande. Regulators determined that the option agreement was principally designed to further obfuscate and hide the fraudulent nature of the underlying Castle Grande transactions....According to their conversation, Denton believes that Ms.Clinton was familiar with the nature of the transaction -- again, a transaction that investigators believe was intended to deceive financial regulators....failure to divulge or turn over the records could be the basis for criminal charges -- the obstruction of justice.

The billing records found in Hillary Clinton's book room were a copy of an original version printed out from the Rose Firm computer in 1992, when the computer file itself was deleted. Webb Hubbell has testified that he recalls reviewing a copy of the billing records in response to press inquiries during the 1992 Presidential campaign. Hubbell says that he then passed the records on to Vince Foster who was, as far as Hubbell knows, the last person to have the records.

Investigators believe the book room copy was indeed Vince Foster's. The copy contains notations, in red ink, that are Vince Foster's handwriting. These notations appear to be directed toward Hillary Clinton, including questions about some of the individual billings. Investigators believe this suggests that, at some point, this copy was passed from Vince Foster to Hillary Clinton for her review.

In addition, investigators had the FBI conduct fingerprint analysis of the billing records. Of significance, the prints of Vince Foster and Hillary Clinton were found. ... The Independent Counsel continues to investigate Ms. Clinton's involvement in handling the records.

For her part, Hillary Clinton has said that she has no idea how the billing records came to be in her book room....Shortly after Vince Foster's death on July 20, 1993, a group of files were moved from his office to a closet near Hillary's office in the Clintons' personal quarters on the third floor of the White House.

One item which may have been among those files were the billing records from the Rose Law Firm which documented Hillary Clinton's legal work on Jim McDougal's Castle Grande real estate deal. These records had been the subject of various investigative subpoenas but had been missing for over two years. They mysteriously resurfaced in January 1996 when Carolyn Huber, a White House aide, came upon them in her office and recognized them as the missing files. She later testified that she had moved them to her office from Hillary's book room six months earlier while straightening up, but had not realized their significance at the time....

Nightline on the incident.
CHRIS BURY: The first lady has conceded her answers have often been too lawyerly, but Mrs Clinton has not acknowledged how her own instinct for evasiveness may have contributed to a pattern of stonewalling and possible perjury among her loyal allies at the White House.

...CHRIS BURY (VO): The suicide of Vince Foster - White House lawyer, long time Clinton friend, Rose Law Firm partner - is a pivotal event. The Travel Office and Whitewater paths intersect in his office, in his files, on his mind. A note written the week before he died has a confessional quality. 'I made mistakes from ignorance, inexperience and overwork. I did not knowingly violate any law or standard of conduct.'

Another entry in a personal notebook says, 'Defend Hillary Clinton role, whatever is, was, in fact, or might have been misperceived to be.' We don't know exactly what that means, but we do know Foster served as Hillary Clinton's confidante and protector, going back to the 1992 presidential campaign.

In March of '92, a potentially damaging story breaks about Hillary Clinton's legal work for a failing savings and loan.

...CHRIS BURY (VO): We know, from the dates stamped on them, that the billing records were printed out February 12, 1992. They are covered with Foster's handwriting in red ink. Most are bookkeeping notations. Hillary Clinton's work is circled. The messages are cryptic, such as 'HRC - this suggests 1st matter.' We also know that Webb Hubbell, the former associate attorney general and Rose partner imprisoned for cheating his clients, talked about the billing records February 24th with Susan Thomases, another Hillary Clinton friend and campaign adviser. (December 18, 1995)

...CHRIS BURY: What ever happened to those records is a mystery investigators have been trying to unravel for more than two years. They were not among the documents Hubbell took to Washington and later turned over to investigators. The only other person known to have the billing records is Vince Foster, and that gives rise to a Republican theory that Foster had custody of the records until his suicide.

...CHRIS BURY (VO): Senator D'Amato has asked the independent counsel to take another look at the harried actions of Hillary Clinton's aides following Foster's suicide, including Margaret Williams, Hillary Clinton's chief of staff.

...CHRIS BURY: Nightline has learned that a preliminary check of the Secret Service and White House usher logs has turned up as many as 100 names of people admitted to the White House residence in a 20 day period last August. On that list are visiting dignitaries and insiders, including Hillary Clinton's top aides, and perhaps the very name of the person who can solve Washington's biggest mystery.

...CHRIS BURY: Absolutely. I mean, it's hard to believe that 116 pages of documents, five or six inches thick, is going to fall out of a construction worker's pocket up there. And I think it's interesting to note whom Kenneth Starr, the independent counsel, has called in to investigate these records. He's called in the head usher, who might know. He's called in Mrs Clinton's personal attorney. He's called in the White House lawyer in charge of producing these documents. So those indications are that Kenneth Starr is already narrowing the search, and I doubt if he's going to be calling many of the visiting dignitaries who showed up at the White House in August

TED KOPPEL: We should make the point, I guess, Chris, that- that there is no suggestion at this point that Mrs Clinton herself is facing any criminal investigation.

CHRIS BURY: Absolutely. She was called before the grand jury for about three and a half hours. She has not been notified that she's the target. But we do know that she testified during that time primarily about what happened to these mysterious, you know, missing and reappearing records.

TED KOPPEL: And when all is said and done now, we're not really talking about Whitewater anymore, we're not really talking about Travelgate anymore, now it's something that has happened within a very discrete period of time, within the past two years.

CHRIS BURY: This is a tangible thing that- that people can get. This is about a coverup inside the White House in one select room populated by the first family, their immediate staffs, perhaps some close friends. It's a very select circle.

TED KOPPEL: Chris Bury, thank you.

Another view
This pattern of never apologizing for innuendo that is never proven has been one consistency throughout the Whitewater affair. The dark clouds of guilt never lift. One ominous rumble of suspicions follows the next, with no one noticing that the expected storm never breaks.

The Whitewater storm clouds looked especially threatening during the 1996 presidential race. Then, the press anticipated the unprecedented moment when the first lady would be indicted, possibly for obstruction of justice. Many of these stories appeared to be leaks from Starr's office. But no indictment of Mrs. Clinton followed.

The reason was simple: the case against Hillary Clinton never held water.

Item One -- often cited against the first lady -- is the mystery of the Rose billing records whose discovery touched off the speculation about her impending indictment.

The billing records were discovered in the White House living quarters in January 1996, two years after they were among documents that had been subpoenaed. With great fanfare, Starr hauled Mrs. Clinton before the federal grand jury in Washington.

Most famously, New York Times columnist William Safire seized on the occasion to denounce Mrs. Clinton as a "congenital liar." Safire asserted that “the records show Hillary Clinton was lying when she denied actively representing a criminal enterprise known as the Madison S&L.” [NYT, Jan. 9, 1996]

Largely ignored by the media, however, was the fact that the billing records substantiated Mrs. Clinton's public and sworn statements about her limited work on the Madison Guaranty account. The records showed that Mrs. Clinton billed Madison Guaranty for 60 hours of work over a 15-month period.

There wasn't much to the mystery of the reappearing records either. After their discovery, White House special counsel Jane Sherburne interviewed Carolyn Huber, the White House secretary who discovered them, and pieced together the likely story.

The records were removed from the Rose files in March 1992 to answer questions from New York Times reporter Jeff Gerth. After the election, Huber, a former Rose Law Firm secretary, apparently "packed them up in the governor's mansion in Little Rock before the Clintons moved to Washington," Sherburne said.

All the Clintons' boxes were stored elsewhere, said Sherburne, and then brought, a few at a time, to the "book room" in the East Wing of the White House. There, Huber unpacked them and determined what should be done with the contents.

"But in the rush to clear out the book room in 1995 to make office space for the people who were going to help Mrs. Clinton write her book [It Takes a Village], Carolyn probably threw the billing records she had unpacked into a box along with the old shoes and empty hangers that were also in the box, and moved it to her office to deal with later," Sherburne explained.

Starr has developed no known evidence to contradict this innocent explanation.

...On June 30, the air finally went out of the seven-year-old Whitewater balloon. In announcing the conclusion of the Whitewater phase of his investigation, Starr acknowledged that he had no prosecutable case against Mrs. Clinton.

Despite the stunning development, no major media outlet offered a self-critical assessment of the breathless -- and often mindless -- handling of the story. The major news outlets, often led by The New York Times and The Washington Post, had dug themselves so deeply into trying to prove the Whitewater case that they saw no way out.

Instead, the newspapers and networks quickly moved on. What commentary there was focused on the nation's "scandal fatigue" and Starr's political clumsiness. Somehow, those clever Clintons -- like a political Bonnie-and-Clyde team -- had slipped away from the authorities one more time.

Attention turned, too, to Starr’s expected scathing final report, its likely effect on the New York Senate race and what it finally would show about Hillary Clinton's presumption of guilt.

Mollie Dickenson is a specialist on the savings-and-loan scandal.

My district Congressman has his elderly mother on his payroll. It doesn't matter what his party is, he is a Republican, but I have no doubt this is a common practice and a way to get bribes, pad pockets and and the whole lot of them should be swept out of office.

On the other side we have reality and we have a Republican Party leadership that is working just a little too hard to make their position on top permanent. There is a concerted effort, in addition to the financial shenanigans to manipulate the democratic process.

What is it I see as different? It is the concerted effort to manipulate the democratic process. Bush has used his position to use the D o J to further the power of the Republican Party. The actions discussed in this thread that are beyond the financial corruption activities which have become the norm are those by top Republican Party officials to cheat in the elections. Financial corruption should be exposed and we really need to quit re-electing those people. And we need to decrease the influence money has on the electoral process. But when you start getting actual election fraud, that threatens our democracy. That is just not on the same level as financial corruption.
 
I don't think Pomeroo does specific cites. He just tells you to read his little book, or makes totally unverifiable claims about fraud.


ETA regarding the Byron York article: It's an oddity significant enough to merit some investigation, but there's no evidence of wrongdoing and if it turns out that there is a reasonable explanation for those polling stations reporting in last then there's not much meat to the story. It should not be too hard to establish whether the systems in use and the presence of bipartisan observers made it possible or impossible to generate a few hundred extra votes at the last minute. It shouldn't be possible of course, but nothing would surprise me about US electoral systems.


It is tiresome to keep presenting evidence that is waved away. I am no expert in Tasmanian politics, so I shouldn't expect you to follow American politics too closely.
 
It is tiresome to keep presenting evidence that is waved away. I am no expert in Tasmanian politics, so I shouldn't expect you to follow American politics too closely.

There are plenty of US posters in the thread who I'm sure would be interested in any actual evidence you have.

Why not pick what you think is the best case study from Fund's book, in terms of evidence, seriousness and relevance to the current discussion? We can talk about that. Just show us the evidence, if you have any.
 
There are plenty of US posters in the thread who I'm sure would be interested in any actual evidence you have.

Why not pick what you think is the best case study from Fund's book, in terms of evidence, seriousness and relevance to the current discussion? We can talk about that. Just show us the evidence, if you have any.


Should I copy two twenty-page chapters from Fund's book? Skeptigirl will dismiss them with a childish insult. We can't debate a book that only I have taken the trouble to read.
 
It is tiresome to keep presenting evidence that is waved away. I am no expert in Tasmanian politics, so I shouldn't expect you to follow American politics too closely.
Are you really in that much denial that you look at my detailed posts discrediting your unsupported claims and you believe I waved away your evidence with childish insults?

Excuse me pomey, but it is you who is waving away the evidence with childish excuses.

I posted citations and detailed analyses of the evidence you offered. Your claim I had nothing to say boggles the mind.

Copy the 22 pages if you are unable to sift through them for the supportable facts and citations supporting them. I'm game.
 
Fact: I personally know a Kerry supporter who, along with other Kerry supporters, drove up to Wisconsin to "help" residents of a senior citizens home too frail to do it themselves fill out their absentee ballots. Guess who those seniors all voted for? :rolleyes:

Call me a liar if you want, but I know it to be true.
Taking this at face value, first, it is an individual. The reason I put this thread in the CT forum was to look at party leadership involvement or at least involvement on the top levels.

Second, there is an issue here of what constitutes ethical campaigning and what constitutes unethical campaigning and what amounts to outright voter fraud.

I assume you are claiming your friend voted for incompetent people. You cannot be sure, however, that some of those "frail" people didn't exert their own desires on those ballots. What irks me the most about the accusations here is that all of those people for whom votes were cast had a right to vote. The implication is because they were influenced in a way one person doesn't think is right, that something fraudulent occurred.

Is it any less fraudulent to put out false Swift Boat attack ads? Is it any less fraudulent to help a relative send in an absentee ballot if that person is not legally incompetent? Is it fraudulent to grant a couple million dollars of taxpayer's money to a large Evangelical congregation via the Faith Based initiative fund and have that church pastor recommend the congregation vote for certain candidates?

Ky. representative uses 'faith-based' funding to win votes, critics say

2004: Bush Campaign Seeks "Friendly Congregations" To Aid Re-election Campaign.

The point is, "feeble" is not a legal definition. There are laws prohibiting legally incompetent persons from voting. If any of those "feeble" voters had legal guardians assigned due to court declared incompetence, then your friend could be prosecuted for breaking the law. Otherwise, you are bringing up an issue that is very gray.

I have no problem discussing the ethical issues involved in influencing voters as long as you want to discuss all the ways voters are unethically influenced rather than just this particular type of influence.

In any case, voter ID wouldn't impact this. Voter disenfranchisement isn't the issue. Voter fraud in this case is a matter of opinion where to draw the line. The court draws it at legally being declared incompetent. And this isn't a widespread practice being directed from the highest ranks in the Democratic Party.
 
Last edited:
How does this refute Fund's claim? The PBP is clearly talking about voters purged for all reasons (death, no longer live in county, etc) while Fund specifically was talking about criminal purges.

In making this claim [in the book, Stealing Elections], Fund selectively quoted from a May 27, 2001, article in the Palm Beach Post. While the article did state that "[a]t least 108 law-abiding people were purged from the voter rolls as suspected criminals, only to be cleared after the election," it also stated that an additional 996 people who had been convicted of crimes in other states but were now eligible to vote were also cut from the rolls.

Fund then compared what he called the "trivial number" of 108 voters with the 1,420 military ballots that were rejected statewide, ignoring the other 996 who were eligible but were denied the right to vote.


From the May 27, 2001, article in the Palm Beach Post:

But a Palm Beach Post computer analysis has found at least 1,100 eligible voters wrongly purged from the rolls before last year's election -- the collateral damage from an aggressive and ill-conceived state plan to prevent felons from voting.

[...]

At least 108 law-abiding people were purged from the voter rolls as suspected criminals, only to be cleared after the election. DBT's computers had matched these people with felons, though in dozens of cases they did not share the same name, birthdate, gender or race. One Naples man was told he couldn't vote because he was linked with a felon still serving time in a Moore Haven prison.

Florida officials cut from the rolls 996 people convicted of crimes in other states, though they should have been allowed to vote. Before the election, state officials said felons could vote only if they had written clemency orders, although most other states automatically restore voting rights to felons when they complete their sentences. This policy conflicted with a 1998 court ruling that said Florida had "no authority" to deny civil rights to those who had them restored in other states. After the election, the state changed its policy.
See bolded text.
 
Taking this at face value, first, it is an individual. The reason I put this thread in the CT forum was to look at party leadership involvement or at least involvement on the top levels.

Second, there is an issue here of what constitutes ethical campaigning and what constitutes unethical campaigning and what amounts to outright voter fraud.

I assume you are claiming your friend voted for incompetent people. You cannot be sure, however, that some of those "frail" people didn't exert their own desires on those ballots. What irks me the most about the accusations here is that all of those people for whom votes were cast had a right to vote. The implication is because they were influenced in a way one person doesn't think is right, that something fraudulent occurred.

Is it any less fraudulent to put out false Swift Boat attack ads?


If you can tell us what was fraudulent about them, you'll be doing far more than John Kerry was able to do. Bear in mind that on the single bone of contention between Kerry and the Swift Boat vets that is NOT a matter of opinion, it has been established that Long John lied and the Swiftees told the truth: Kerry was not in Cambodia over the 1968 Christmas holiday and Richard Nixon was not President at the time. Those falsehoods were "seared" into his memory.

Is it any less fraudulent to help a relative send in an absentee ballot if that person is not legally incompetent? Is it fraudulent to grant a couple million dollars of taxpayer's money to a large Evangelical congregation via the Faith Based initiative fund and have that church pastor recommend the congregation vote for certain candidates?

Ky. representative uses 'faith-based' funding to win votes, critics say

2004: Bush Campaign Seeks "Friendly Congregations" To Aid Re-election Campaign.



You can't be serious. If any Republican dared to campaign in churches as though they belonged there, the way Democrats routinely commandeer the pulpits of black churches, the media would go berserk.



The point is, "feeble" is not a legal definition. There are laws prohibiting legally incompetent persons from voting. If any of those "feeble" voters had legal guardians assigned due to court declared incompetence, then your friend could be prosecuted for breaking the law. Otherwise, you are bringing up an issue that is very gray.

I have no problem discussing the ethical issues involved in influencing voters as long as you want to discuss all the ways voters are unethically influenced rather than just this particular type of influence.

In any case, voter ID wouldn't impact this. Voter disenfranchisement isn't the issue. Voter fraud in this case is a matter of opinion where to draw the line. The court draws it at legally being declared incompetent. And this isn't a widespread practice being directed from the highest ranks in the Democratic Party.


You have no idea what the Democrats have pulled in Milwaukee in the last two presidential elections.
 
Are you really in that much denial that you look at my detailed posts discrediting your unsupported claims and you believe I waved away your evidence with childish insults?

Excuse me pomey, but it is you who is waving away the evidence with childish excuses.

I posted citations and detailed analyses of the evidence you offered. Your claim I had nothing to say boggles the mind.

Copy the 22 pages if you are unable to sift through them for the supportable facts and citations supporting them. I'm game.


Your "detailed analyses" were not very impressive. Fund devotes most of chapter on the Democrats' vote fraud in Palm Beach County. He makes a convincing statistical case that Bush lost roughly 15,000 votes there. He outlines the methodology of the fraud: Democratic poll workers were creating overvotes. You present a Washington Post piece that points to the huge number of overvotes containing a mark for Kerry--exactly what we'd expect if Fund is correct--and claims, either disingenuously or obtusely, that they hurt Kerry!
 
Your "detailed analyses" were not very impressive. Fund devotes most of chapter on the Democrats' vote fraud in Palm Beach County. He makes a convincing statistical case that Bush lost roughly 15,000 votes there. He outlines the methodology of the fraud: Democratic poll workers were creating overvotes. You present a Washington Post piece that points to the huge number of overvotes containing a mark for Kerry--exactly what we'd expect if Fund is correct--and claims, either disingenuously or obtusely, that they hurt Kerry!

There are two problems here.

Firstly you haven't given us any actual evidence, or even a convincing statistical case, you have just claimed they exist in Fund's book and ignored repeated requests to share that information. I'm open to any actual evidence you do have, but the longer you evade requests for specifics the more likely it seems that the specifics aren't up to scratch.

Secondly, while the hypothesis that Democratic party workers created overvotes in Palm Beach County by punching Kerry-holes in non-Kerry ballots (and I thought we were talking about Gore in 2000, so one of us is muddled) covers the known facts, so does the hypothesis that Republican party workers created overvotes by punching non-Democratic holes in Democratic ballots. So the fact that your favoured hypothesis covers the facts is not conclusive given other hypotheses do too.

My last point is only relevant if you are the one who is muddled and not me. If we are talking about 2000, it occurs to me that since the subsequent media-sponsored recount claimed to clearly show that Gore would have won if the voters who wanted to vote for Gore had punched their cards correctly, that would seem to indicate that many of the overvotes with a Gore hole punched had scribbled "Gore" on their ballot or otherwise made it obvious that Gore was their intended choice. In such cases, the hypothesis that Democrats spoiled those votes would make little sense.
 
There are two problems here.

Firstly you haven't given us any actual evidence, or even a convincing statistical case, you have just claimed they exist in Fund's book and ignored repeated requests to share that information. I'm open to any actual evidence you do have, but the longer you evade requests for specifics the more likely it seems that the specifics aren't up to scratch.


Why do you pretend that I've "ignored" your requests when I have explained that I have no intention of copying a twenty-page chapter.



Secondly, while the hypothesis that Democratic party workers created overvotes in Palm Beach County by punching Kerry-holes in non-Kerry ballots (and I thought we were talking about Gore in 2000, so one of us is muddled) covers the known facts, so does the hypothesis that Republican party workers created overvotes by punching non-Democratic holes in Democratic ballots.

My mistake. I have been posting about Kerry in another thread and he was on my mind. Obviously, we're talking about Gore. Your other comment makes absolutely no sense. There is an inexplicable shortfall in Bush's total for Palm Beach County of 15,000 votes. There is a huge spike in overvotes, roughly ten times the percentage recorded in other counties. Fund makes the statistical case in detail.





So the fact that your favoured hypothesis covers the facts is not conclusive given other hypotheses do too.


Wrong.


My last point is only relevant if you are the one who is muddled and not me. If we are talking about 2000, it occurs to me that since the subsequent media-sponsored recount claimed to clearly show that Gore would have won if the voters who wanted to vote for Gore had punched their cards correctly,


Claims about the infamous "butterfly ballot," designed by a Democrat and published, as required by law, weeks before the election have nothing to do with the specific vote fraud described by Fund.




that would seem to indicate that many of the overvotes with a Gore hole punched had scribbled "Gore" on their ballot or otherwise made it obvious that Gore was their intended choice. In such cases, the hypothesis that Democrats spoiled those votes would make little sense.

The overvotes in Palm Beach County are indicative of fraud. A former Democratic Congressman conceded as much.
 
Why do you pretend that I've "ignored" your requests when I have explained that I have no intention of copying a twenty-page chapter.

Because presumably Fund cites primary sources which you could share with us in much less than twenty pages.

My mistake. I have been posting about Kerry in another thread and he was on my mind. Obviously, we're talking about Gore. Your other comment makes absolutely no sense. There is an inexplicable shortfall in Bush's total for Palm Beach County of 15,000 votes. There is a huge spike in overvotes, roughly ten times the percentage recorded in other counties. Fund makes the statistical case in detail.

Link to somewhere that has specifics? You make it sound like there may be a case to be made, but at this stage nobody is going to take your word for it.

The overvotes in Palm Beach County are indicative of fraud. A former Democratic Congressman conceded as much.

Who? When? Where?
 
Pomey, I am not going to hijack my own thread providing the evidence to you about the Swift Boat lies, go look them up for yourself and post about it in another thread.

Nor am I going to play ever shifting goalposts with you. I do believe I have made my case, and I do believe you have yet to make yours.

The Defense rests until such time as actual evidence worth investigating is presented showing massive voter fraud perpetrated by the top members of the Democratic Party that is at least equal to the numbers of voters disenfranchised by actions directed by top members of the Republican Party.
 
Pomey, I am not going to hijack my own thread providing the evidence to you about the Swift Boat lies, go look them up for yourself and post about it in another thread.


Not interested. The pompous blowhard was beaten. The Swiftees didn't tell any lies, and do you know why I can state this so baldly? Because Kerry was unable to show any of those lies. He huffed and puffed, brayed about his unmatched valor, but on the single issue that was resolved definitively, it turned out that he was the liar and the Swiftees were telling the truth.


Nor am I going to play ever shifting goalposts with you. I do believe I have made my case, and I do believe you have yet to make yours.


Of course you think you've made a case. In the loony-left blogosphere, making a case means citing raving lunatics like Brad Friedman and never ever reading a serious book.



The Defense rests until such time as actual evidence worth investigating is presented showing massive voter fraud perpetrated by the top members of the Democratic Party that is at least equal to the numbers of voters disenfranchised by actions directed by top members of the Republican Party.


The disenfranchisement scam has served the Democrats well. If they never have to produce an actual living person who was "disenfranchised," they will have demonstrated--redundantly--that crime pays.

Incidentally, I suspect that most of us noticed that nobody ever said anything about Democratic vote fraud being perpetrated by "top members" of the Democratic Party. The fraudsters in Hawaii, New Mexico, South Dakota, Washington, Wisconsin, Louisiana, Florida, Missouri, etc. are locals.
 
Incidentally, I suspect that most of us noticed that nobody ever said anything about Democratic vote fraud being perpetrated by "top members" of the Democratic Party. The fraudsters in Hawaii, New Mexico, South Dakota, Washington, Wisconsin, Louisiana, Florida, Missouri, etc. are locals.

Evidence of this fraud please. Just a few links to non-partisan primary sources will do, we're not demanding a twenty page chapter.
 
Evidence of this fraud please. Just a few links to non-partisan primary sources will do, we're not demanding a twenty page chapter.


Completely cognizant that posting this brief excerpt from Fund's chapter on fraud in St. Louis will accomplish nothing, I can't resist giving a sample of the book's abundant riches:

"Secretary Blunt's investigation of the 2000 election also detailed how the federal Motor Voter Law was facilitating fraud. He calculated that a total of 247,135 St. Louis residents, dead or alive, were registered to vote, as compared with the city's voting-age population of 258,532. That translated to a whopping 96 percent registration rate, the envy even of places like Pyongyang, where not voting is a capital offense.

"The secretary of state also made the following findings:
Sixty-two (62) federal felons voted in that election along with fifty-two (52) state felons; Sixty-eight (68) people voted twice; Fourteen (14) dead people cast votes; Seventy-nine (79) registered to vacant lots in the city of St. Louis voted in the election; 45 of the city's election judges were not registered to vote, as they are required to do in order to lawfully hold the position of election judge. 250 addresses [were discovered] that are not identified as apartments from which eight or more individuals are registered to vote. A random sampling of 54 of these locations indicates that 14 might have been used as drop-sites for multiple false voter registrations.

"Democrats responded to the report by insisting that their only interest had been to ensure that as many people voted as possible."
 
rying to find any dirt he could possibly get the Clinton's on and all he ended up with was Bill's entrapped perjury about a blow job.

Asking a question of someone under oath and getting them to answer is 'entrapment'? That's an interesting legal theory. I wonder if you'd apply that kind of thinking to Libby's conviction for perjury?
 
Completely cognizant that posting this brief excerpt from Fund's chapter on fraud in St. Louis will accomplish nothing, I can't resist giving a sample of the book's abundant riches:

"Secretary Blunt's investigation of the 2000 election also detailed how the federal Motor Voter Law was facilitating fraud. He calculated that a total of 247,135 St. Louis residents, dead or alive, were registered to vote, as compared with the city's voting-age population of 258,532. That translated to a whopping 96 percent registration rate, the envy even of places like Pyongyang, where not voting is a capital offense.

Primary source? Also, how many of those people actually voted?

"The secretary of state also made the following findings:
Sixty-two (62) federal felons voted in that election along with fifty-two (52) state felons; Sixty-eight (68) people voted twice; Fourteen (14) dead people cast votes; Seventy-nine (79) registered to vacant lots in the city of St. Louis voted in the election; 45 of the city's election judges were not registered to vote, as they are required to do in order to lawfully hold the position of election judge. 250 addresses [were discovered] that are not identified as apartments from which eight or more individuals are registered to vote. A random sampling of 54 of these locations indicates that 14 might have been used as drop-sites for multiple false voter registrations.

Primary source? You do understand why a primary source is important, right? Without primary sources your book is a source of fertiliser, not a source of riches.

If I recall correctly, in some places in the USA homeless people have been known to register as living in vacant lots, since they have to put some location down. Homeless people are still entitled to vote of course so this is not so much fraud as the system not keeping up with the times. For that matter eight people of voting age living in one house is unusual but far from inconceivable, even if some similar "address of convenience" business is not going on in those cases.

I'd also like to know how they established the number of people who voted twice or voted while dead, just to rule out the possibility of accidental error. If a legitimate voter has a name and address similar to that of a dead person or someone else who has already voted elsewhere, then human error at the polling booth could lead to the discrepancy claimed without any actual malice or any actual effect on the outcome.

How many of the naughty election judges were Democratic representatives and how many were Republican?

I'm not ruling out voter fraud, just trying to nail down the details of the case study in question. Please link us to Fund's primary sources.

"Democrats responded to the report by insisting that their only interest had been to ensure that as many people voted as possible."

Ah, Fund, you are a comic genius, and completely non-partisan too.
 
There is a lot of material here. I've posted a lot of the text from the links below so people don't have to read through every link but it makes for an overly lengthy post. It's even almost too long for me to re-read to edit it.

Here is the summary:

No one has said voter fraud doesn't occur. Blunt found a small number of confirmed cases and a larger number of potential cases because the registration roles were cluttered with errors and deceased voters. Subsequent investigations from a couple different reporters found there were more registration errors than illegal votes.

Exaggerating the problem, Blunt got state voter ID legislation passed by a very small margin. It was overturned by the state supreme court who found the amount of fraud was small and the ID reqs amounted to a poll tax. There was one dissenting judge and I posted his opinion as well as the majority's below.

This is the same thing that is turning up in all these cases. There are a small number of illegal votes. (No surprise) The Republicans are using those to go around campaigning for voter ID reqs. The allegations continue to be found to be greatly exaggerated and there is a considerable number of people who are convinced the voter ID amounts to a move to disenfranchise a large number of voters, especially in key states.

But oh what a tangled web they weave...

Turns out Blunt was helped in his Secretary of State campaign by the RNC just before he made the public cries about voter fraud and pushing for voter ID laws. And the firing of Attorney Cummins in the same state to make way for Griffin ties in nicely if one is looking at Karl Rove's advance planning to disenfranchise a large number of voters in key states in the 2008 election. Not only is Missouri evenly divided between Republicans and Democrats, there is a key Senate race coming up in Missouri that is likely to be a close call.

This just adds a ton to the credence to my conspiracy claim. The attorney scandal includes firing Bud Cummins from Missouri and replacing him with Griffin, from Rove's inner circle who had no qualms directing the well documented Fl. caging incident. (Reminder: the caging list existed, the RNC admitted so with an absurd excuse for its existence, Goodling testified under oath the caging incident occurred and Griffin was involved, and Griffin resigned because of it.) Clearly Rove has a hand in elections and attorneys in Missouri for a reason.

Looking at the Wiki entry on Blunt and this article which outlines the claims Blunt made about voter fraud and the subsequent events surrounding state legislation enacting voter ID, we have a microcosm of things to come.

There is a curious connection to the voter disenfranchisement plot. Blunt went investigating voter fraud in Missouri shortly after being elected to Sec. of State.

From Wiki:
Election as Secretary of State

Blunt received considerable fundraising support from his father's supporters and from out-of-state Republicans in his 2000 Secretary of State bid. Senior political strategist Karl Rove appeared at an April 21, 2000 fundraiser in Springfield.[2] The state Republican Party contributed $160,000 to Blunt's campaign, having received $100,000 in donations from Rep. Roy Blunt's PAC[3], and the 7th District Congressional Republican Committee - a fundraising group affiliated with the senior Blunt - donated $40,000.[4]. Contributions from 84 of Rep. Blunt's colleagues in the U.S. House of Representatives totalled over $65,000.[5][6] Matt Blunt defeated his Democrat opponent Steve Gaw with 51.4% of the vote, to Gaw's 45.1%.[7]

Seems Blunt then went on to run for governor and won. Again we have evidence he is close with the big guys in the RNC and not above taking advantages in a race when the opportunity arises.

It seems some of his campaign money for the governor's race was tainted with the Tom DeLay/Jack Abramoff illegal dealings via Blunt Sr's manipulations. After all, ethics are taught at home.
When it all ended, DeLay's private charity, along with the consulting firm that employed DeLay's wife and the Missouri campaign of Blunt's son, Matt, who now is the state's governor, all ended up with a piece of the pie, according to campaign documents reviewed by The Associated Press.

Jack Abramoff, the Washington lobbyist recently charged in an ongoing federal corruption and fraud investigation, and Jim Ellis, the DeLay fundraiser indicted with his boss last week in Texas, also appeared in the picture.

The complicated transactions are drawing scrutiny in legal and political circles after a grand jury indicted DeLay on charges of violating Texas law with a scheme to launder illegal corporate donations to state political candidates.

The government's former chief election enforcement lawyer said the Blunt and DeLay transactions are similar to the Texas case and raise questions that should be investigated regarding whether donors were deceived or the true destination of their money was concealed.
And we have this little jewel:For someone concerned about voting practices as Blunt claims to be, this was a bit hipocritical. Voting Rights: Missouri Compromised
John Hickey is the executive director of the Missouri Progressive Vote Coalition. He said today: ... As we witnessed in 2000, the secretary of state plays a very crucial role in the electoral process. It's essential that this person runs fair and impartial elections and does not misuse the office for partisan gain. Unfortunately, recent events in Missouri show serious problems can arise from partisan use of this key public office. Missouri Secretary of State Matt Blunt has spent almost $48,000 in public money on statewide newspaper advertising that included his name and picture, urging voters to turn out for the August 3 primary -- where he was running on that same ballot as a Republican gubernatorial candidate! Adding to the irony is the fact that the funds Blunt used for what amounted to a publicly-paid campaign ad were from federal appropriations to Missouri from the Help America Vote Act (HAVA), which was enacted in 2002 as a response to the events in Florida. That money is supposed to be used for purposes such as recruiting and training election judges, buying voting machines that disabled people can use, and improving maintenance of voter lists. It's outrageous that a secretary of state used HAVA money as a personal political slush fund."

Hickey added: "Matt Blunt is the son of Roy Blunt, the current Republican Majority Whip in the U.S. House of Representatives, a very powerful position. Roy Blunt has already raised money for his son's previous campaigns, and the Matt Blunt bid is a priority for the Republican National Committee."
No wonder! Missouri's race for governor was neck and neck (Blunt won 51 to 49%) as was the 2000 election where the Blunt's claims of voter fraud surfaced. And voter ID law was passed by a slim margin. If you were Karl Rove planning your 2008 strategy of voter disenfranchisement in key states, Missouri would clearly be a candidate. Send in one of the 'team', Griffin, and make sure to disenfranchise as many Democratic voters as the opportunity allows. And you have already helped get your man, Blunt, in as governor after he did your bidding looking for voter fraud. Not to mention there will be a close race for a Senate seat in 2008 as well as the vote for President which could change the power in the House.

Also from Wiki:
United States Attorney Controversy -
In April 2006 it was reported that United States Attorney Bud Cummins "is handling an investigation into how the license fee offices were awarded to political supporters of the Blunt administration."[26] On October 4, 2006, Cummins announced "that he has concluded an inquiry into alleged wrongdoings involving the awarding of contracts for Missouri fee offices with no indictments sought or returned." Cummins elaborated: "First, the matter has been closed with no indictments sought or returned. Second, at no time was Governor Blunt a target, subject, or witness in the investigation, nor was he implicated in any allegation being investigated. Any allegations or inferences to the contrary are uninformed and erroneous." [27] Cummins has since become embroiled in the Dismissal of U.S. attorneys controversy: in December 2006, Cummins resigned from his post in favor of Tim Griffin, a former aide to Karl Rove. Cummins acknowledges that he "served at the pleasure of the president," and that Attorney General Gonzales "doesn't owe me an apology." [28] Cummins concluded his investigation of the Blunt Administration two months before he resigned.


Here is the account of the events from 2000 on. It is long, but this whole affair has that much crap in it.
Now, six months after freshman Missouri Sen. Jim Talent's defeat handed Democrats control of the U.S. Senate, disclosures in the wake of the firings of eight U.S. attorneys show that that Republican campaign to protect the balloting was not as it appeared. No significant voter fraud was ever proved. Before last fall's election:

-Schlozman, while he was acting civil rights chief, authorized a suit accusing the state of failing to eliminate legions of ineligible people from lists of registered voters. A federal judge tossed out the suit this April 13, saying Democratic Missouri Secretary of State Robin Carnahan couldn't police local registration rolls and noting that the government had produced no evidence of fraud.

-The Missouri General Assembly - with the White House's help - narrowly passed a law requiring voters to show photo identification cards, which Carnahan estimated would disenfranchise 200,000 voters. The state Supreme Court voided the law as unconstitutional before the election.

-Two weeks before the election, the St. Louis Board of Elections sent letters threatening to disqualify 5,000 newly registered minority voters if they failed to verify their identities promptly, a move - instigated by a Republican appointee - that may have violated federal law. After an outcry, the board rescinded the threat.

-Five days before the election, Schlozman, then interim U.S. attorney in Kansas City, announced indictments of four voter-registration workers for a Democratic-leaning group on charges of submitting phony applications, despite a Justice Department policy discouraging such action close to an election.

-In an interview with conservative talk-show host Hugh Hewitt a couple of days before the election, Rove said he'd just visited Missouri and had met with Republican strategists who "are well aware of" the threat of voter fraud. He said the party had "a large number of lawyers that are standing by, trained and ready to intervene" to keep the election clean.


Missouri Republicans have railed about alleged voter fraud ever since President Bush narrowly won the White House in the chaotic 2000 election and Missouri Republican Sen. John Ashcroft lost to a dead man, the late Democratic Gov. Mel Carnahan, whose name stayed on the ballot weeks after he died in a plane crash.

Joining the push to contain "voter fraud" were Sen. Christopher Bond, R-Mo., who charged that votes by dogs and dead people had defeated Ashcroft, Missouri Republican Gov. Matt Blunt, whose stinging allegations of fraud were later debunked, and St. Louis lawyer Mark "Thor" Hearne, national counsel to Bush's 2004 re-election campaign, who set up a nonprofit group to publicize allegations of voter fraud.

Many Democrats contend that the efforts amount to a voter-suppression campaign.

"The real problem has never been vote fraud," said Rep. William Lacy Clay, D-Mo. "It's access to the polls. In the last 50 years, no one in Missouri has been prosecuted for impersonating someone else at the polls. But thousands of eligible voters have been denied their constitutional rights. . . . It's sickening."

However, Jessica Robinson, a spokeswoman for Blunt, said a report he'd authored in 2001 as secretary of state "documented credible instances of fraud." She said Blunt wanted the legislature to take another shot at passing a photo ID bill as "a reasonable step . . . to help stamp out" such abuse.

The Republican-dominated legislature is considering the bill again this year, along with a resolution asking voters to pass a constitutional amendment so the measure can withstand court challenges.

In a separate assessment of alleged voter fraud in Missouri, Lorraine Minnite, a Barnard College professor, found scant evidence of it. The study was undertaken for the nonpartisan policy-research group Demos, which despite its name isn't affiliated with the Democratic Party.

Minnite, who's writing a book on the issue of voter fraud, said successful drives to register poor people and minorities in recent years had threatened to "tip the balance of power" to Democrats, so it was understandable that the Republican Party would seek restrictions that "disproportionately hinder the opposition."

It's difficult to capture the emotional debate over the issue of voter fraud in Missouri without considering the Election Day tumult in St. Louis on Nov. 7, 2000. Hundreds, perhaps thousands, of voters were turned away because their names weren't on official lists, and many of them converged on the city's election board seeking assistance.

Responding to the bedlam, Democrats won an emergency court order that kept some polls open beyond their scheduled 7 p.m. closings. That outraged Republicans, and Hearne, the Bush campaign lawyer, in turn won an emergency appeals-court ruling that shut the polls within an hour.

In the ensuing days, Bond blamed Ashcroft's defeat on "a criminal enterprise."

The following summer, then-Secretary of State Blunt alleged in a 47-page investigative report that the use of affidavits to allow more than 1,000 "improper ballots . . . compels the conclusion that there was in St. Louis an organized and successful effort to generate improper votes in large numbers."

But an investigation by the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, launched before Ashcroft settled in as U.S. attorney general in 2001, found the reverse. In a 2002 court settlement with the department's Voting Rights Section, St. Louis election officials acknowledged that they'd improperly purged some 50,000 names from voter lists before the 2000 elections and had failed as required by federal law to notify those people properly that they'd been placed on inactive status. No one knows how many eligible voters were denied their right to cast ballots.


Missouri's Rep. Clay charged in a recent interview that Blunt's report was an attempt "to violate the voting rights of certain Missourians."

Things didn't heat up again until 2005, when Schlozman authorized a Justice Department suit naming the newly elected Missouri secretary of state - the daughter of the late governor - as the defendant. It alleged that her office had failed to make a "reasonable effort" to remove ineligible people from local voter-registration rolls.

A federal judge dismissed the suit last month, saying the government had provided no evidence of fraud.

Speaking on behalf of Schlozman, who's now with the Justice Department's Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, agency spokesman Dean Boyd said: "We are disappointed with the court ruling." [Surprise, more ties to the US Attorneys scandal]

Separately, Hearne helped establish the nonprofit American Center for Voting Rights in February 2005, which issued lengthy reports alleging voter fraud in states across the country, including Missouri. One director of the supposedly nonpartisan group was Brian Lunde, a former executive director of the Democratic National Committee who switched his allegiance in 2000 and headed Democrats for Bush in 2004.

Barnard's Minnite said the center's summary on Missouri consisted of "a litany of overblown allegations of fraud appearing in newspapers, most of which turn out to be minor problems or no problem at all."

Republican state Sen. Delbert Scott of Lowry, Mo., chief sponsor of the photo-ID bill last year, said Hearne had helped draft it and served as a key adviser.

Hearne didn't respond to several requests for comment. His organization closed down its Internet site in March and has disappeared from view.


Last fall, with Missouri's new voter-ID law thrown out by the court, allegations of fraud arose over registration drives among Democratic-leaning minorities in St. Louis and Kansas City by the Democratic-leaning Association of Community Organizations for Reform (ACORN).

Brian Mellor, a Boston lawyer for ACORN, said many of the accusations surrounded the submission of duplicate or multiple registration forms for the same voters. Such duplication would be caught by election officials and wouldn't enable anyone to vote twice, he said.

But officials at St. Louis' Board of Elections took the unusual step of alerting the FBI to those and other irregularities, Mellor said, and he wound up turning over copies of 40,000 St. Louis-area registration forms to bureau agents.

Facing the FBI scrutiny, Mellor said, ACORN reviewed its forms in Kansas City and found several with similar handwriting, suggesting that they were bogus. He said the group turned over evidence involving four workers to a county prosecutor in mid-October.

That same month, at the initiative of a Republican appointee, the St. Louis Board of Elections sent letters warning 5,000 people who'd registered through ACORN that their voting status was in question. They were given one week to return signed copies of the letter and confirm personal identifying information or they'd lose their registration status.

ACORN attorneys charged that the notice "appears to be an unlawful attempt to suppress and intimidate voters of color." The board sent another mailing withdrawing the threat.

Meanwhile, the evidence against the four ACORN workers ended up with the FBI.

Five days before the election, U.S. Attorney Schlozman got another voter-fraud headline, announcing the indictments of the four workers. The indictments charged that six applications that ACORN had submitted were fraudulent.

"ACORN abhors fraud," Mellor said. He said the timing of the indictments seemed to be aimed at hurting Democrats.


Justice Department spokesman Boyd said the policy that prosecutors "refrain from any conduct which has the possibility of affecting the election" didn't bar pre-election indictments and was intended to ensure that investigators didn't intimidate voters during an election. Boyd said officials in the department’s Public Integrity Section approved the indictments.

But Joseph Rich, who headed the department's Voting Rights Section from 1999 to 2005, said the timing of the indictments "flies in the face of long-standing policy. . . . There was no need to bring cases on the eve of the election."

Reporters from the Kansas City Star investigated the voter fraud supposedly found by Blunt.
The Star's investigation uncovered more double voters, and records suggest there could be more than 300 statewide. The exact number is impossible to determine because many counties have shredded their poll books, as allowed under state law, and state computer files are rife with data errors.

Of the more than 300 potential cases of vote fraud in 2000 and 2002, The Star found about 150 in St. Louis or St. Louis County, 60 in the Kansas City area — including three dozen in Kansas City itself — and the rest scattered across the state.

The total number of cases could be even higher.

Anyone registered under a slightly different name or date of birth in two places would escape detection in the newspaper's analysis of voter registration databases in Missouri and Kansas. The study only flagged people registered in two places under exactly the same names and dates of birth.

The figure may be smaller, on the other hand, because the state computer files contain many errors that show people voting who did not actually vote.

Information for the St. Louis area in the state computer file, however, is especially corrupt. For example, nearly 15,000 voter names appear with no date of birth or dates before 1880. With so many errors, many of the voters listed as having voted in two places in the St. Louis area may actually have voted in only one.

A state audit in May found 24,063 persons registered in St. Louis who were dead, registered somewhere else, convicted of a felony or listed as living at a vacant lot.

Local election officials said they don't think the problem of double-voting is widespread. Dan Seligson, editor of Electionline.org, which provides nonpartisan information about election reform, said fraudulent absentee ballots seem much more common.

The State Supreme Court ruling on the voter ID law:
October 17, 2006; Missouri State Supreme Court Affirms Order Barring Implementation of State Voter ID System
The court's opinion is here. Though this is decided on state constitutional grounds (which insulates it to a great extent from U.S. Supreme Court review), the court's decision has the same structure of those other court decisions that have struck down similar laws in other jurisdictions. (1) These laws impose too great a burden on the right to vote, and indeed can constitute a poll tax to the extent that the state does not pay the expenses associated with obtaining the documentation necessary to get the i.d. and (2) the state has not shown a sufficient interest in the law as a means of fraud prevention, given the paucity of evidence that such laws would meaningfully prevent "impersonation" voter fraud.

One state court justice dissented, and pointed to this evidence of impersonation voter fraud in the record:

According to the majority, there has been no fraud in the polling places; thus no need to prevent it. But the evidence, in part, is this: In an investigative report issued after the 2000 presidential election by outgoing Secretary of State Rebecca McDowell Cook, and introduced in evidence in this case, "135 people who were not registered to vote were permitted to vote at a polling place without a court order and without apparent authorization from [an election] Board Official." A subsequent report from then Secretary of State Matt Blunt noted, as even the plaintiffs have acknowledged here, that 79 voters registered from vacant lots, 45 people voted twice, and 14 votes were cast by the "dead." Further, as part of a federal investigation in the aftermath of the 2000 election, the United States Department of Justice found a stunningly large number of duplicate and ineligible voter registrations throughout the state. According to that report,...

And if, as in the DOJ report, there are more voters registered to vote than persons eligible to vote, the requirement to present a photo ID will at least eliminate those who attempt to vote in the place of others and those who attempt to vote more than once. It must be said, too, that even if there were no substantial evidence of existing voter impersonation fraud, legislatures are permitted to respond to the potential for such fraud, and they may do so "with foresight" rather than "reactively." Munro v. Socialist Workers Party, 479 U.S. 189 (1986). In any event, as the Carter-Baker Commission recently concluded, "there is no doubt that [in-person voter fraud] occurs" and that such fraud "could offset the outcome of close elections"

[Article commentary]Why else would registration fraud occur? Because there is sometimes a bounty paid for each registration turned into election officials. The more important question is whether these number, assuming they are accurate (they may not be) would justify an onerous voter identification law. Spencer Overton's recent book [Stealing Democracy, the New Politics of Voter Suppression] and forthcoming article [Voter Identification; SPENCER A. OVERTON; George Washington University - Law School] explore this question very nicely.
More commentary from Bob Bauer [Voter ID: The Missouri Supreme Court Evaluates Legislative "Foresight"].

October 18, 2006; More on Fraud Allegations in Missouri Supreme Court Voter ID Dissent
Judge Limbaugh's characterization was itself inaccurate, and incorrectly bolsters a report often cited as proof that fraud occurs.

In the snippet that was disseminated, the dissent claims that "A subsequent report from then Secretary of State Matt Blunt noted, as even the plaintiffs have acknowledged here, that 79 voters registered from vacant lots, 45 people voted twice, and 14 votes were cast by the 'dead.'"

On page 9 of the report itself (http://bond.senate.gov/mandate.pdf), Secretary Blunt was more precise:
"Based on information provided by the City and County Boards of Election Commissioners (the "City Board" and "County Board", respectively), it is highly probable that twenty-three (23) people voted more than once in the November 7 election, and it is likely that an additional forty-five (45) persons voted twice.

"Based on information provided by the Missouri Department of Health, fourteen (14) persons in St. Louis City and County who were reported as deceased before the November 7 election nevertheless are recorded as having voted in the election.

"Based on information provided by the City Board, it appears that seventy-nine (79) voters who were registered from vacant lots in St. Louis City voted in the November 7 election."
(emphasis added).

Later in the report, Secretary Blunt revealed the basis for these three assessments. The first two do not necessarily reveal fraud. And the last has been conclusively disproved.

For the double-voters, investigators used voting history entries in St. Louis City and County computer databases to determine whether individuals were listed as voting twice. 23 voters who were apparently listed in both databases as voting in the same election matched name, date of birth, and social security number; 45 voters matched names and date of birth. Although I do not have ready access to the actual list of compared names, if the names are even relatively common, it would not be surprising to find 45 pairs of distinct voters whose name and date of birth match, out of more than 613,000 votes cast in St. Louis City and County in 2000. And though it is, of course, possible that the voters whose name, date of birth, and social security number were actually double voters, before determining that such a conclusion is "highly probable," I'd want some rough approximation of the rate of clerical errors -- which have been mistaken for double votes before. (See, e.g., http://www.jsonline.com/story/?id=350183)

For the deceased voters, investigators compared a list of individuals who died in St. Louis City and County from 1990-2000 against the same voter databases, and found 14 voters with the same names, dates of birth, and social security numbers. Again, it is possible that these votes were fraudulent. But before so concluding, in addition to examining the clerical error rate, it would be useful to double-check to see whether any of the voters on the deceased list actually died after the election. (See, e.g., Marcia Myers, Election Theft Ruled Out, Baltimore Sun, Aug. 24, 1995, at 1A.)

Finally, for the 79 voters apparently registered from vacant lots, the St. Louis City Board of Election Commissioners provided a report of addresses "verified to be vacant by the Board" and the names and voting history of individuals registered to vote at those addresses. Exemplary follow-up investigation by the St. Louis Post-Dispatch found that the supposedly vacant lots were, in fact, not vacant; indeed, some apparently contained buildings more than 50 years old. As a Demos report by Lori Minnite and David Callahan reported, "Errors in the city's property records and methods for classifying vacant a multi-parcel address if only one of the parcels at the address is vacant" apparently accounted for the errors. (See, e.g., http://www.demos.org/pubs/EDR_-_Securing_the_Vote.pdf at 49 & n.88).

Finally, this abstract from voter ID article above sums up the reason for not implementing the voter ID regs:
In the wake of closely contested elections, calls for laws that require voters to present photo identification as a condition to cast a ballot have become pervasive. Advocates tend to rely on two rhetorical devices: (1) anecdotes about a couple of elections tainted by voter fraud; and (2) common sense arguments that voters should produce photo identification because the cards are required to board airplanes, buy alcohol, and engage in other activities. This Article explains the analytical shortcomings of anecdote, analogy, and intuition, and applies a cost-benefit approach generally overlooked in election law scholarship. Rather than rushing to impose a photo identification requirement for voting, policymakers should instead examine empirical data to weigh the costs and benefits of such a requirement. Existing data suggests that the number of legitimate voters who would fail to bring photo identification to the polls is several times higher than the number of fraudulent voters, and that a photo identification requirement would produce political outcomes that are less reflective of the electorate as a whole. Policymakers should await better empirical studies before imposing potentially antidemocratic measures. Judges, in turn, should demand statistical data to ensure that voter identification procedures are appropriately tailored to deter fraudulent voters rather than legitimate ones and do not disproportionately exclude protected classes of voters.
That leaves the question about why are the Republicans pushing so hard for this action? Very little evidence the ID reqs would do anything except cost money. Hmmm, now why would they want to spend money on something to prevent a few illegal votes that very little evidence suggest matter? Could it be they hope it will prevent a lot of legal votes that will matter?
 
Last edited:
Asking a question of someone under oath and getting them to answer is 'entrapment'? That's an interesting legal theory. I wonder if you'd apply that kind of thinking to Libby's conviction for perjury?
Oh come on, Bob. Asking a guy to admit he cheated on his wife when she obviously didn't know about it at the time...yes, unless there was a good reason the testimony was needed, it was entrapment.

The whole 54 million taxpayer Grand Jury Ken Star investigation was supposedly looking into the financial dealings. How was Monica's BJ and semen on a dress in any way related to that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom