Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

T'ai Chi said:

One [dataset].

" The entire dataset we want information about is called the population. A sample is a part of population that we actually examine to draw conclusions. A good sample should be a true representation of data."
Sampling

"In another case, suppose you want to compare two populations to find out whether there is a real difference between them. Instances that might be included here may be the impact of different medical treatments for a particular disease, the difference between men and women's performance in specific workplaces and the effectiveness of different training methods for developing skills in sport. To deal with such questions, you will need to take a sample of each population and then compare the results.

From your analysis of each sample and the conclusions you reach about the populations the samples come from, you should be able to say whether the difference between the populations is real, within certain confidence levels."
Inference Testing

In statistics, sir, the "dataset" is the "population." In "inference testing" sir, the aim is to determine whether or not two datasets (populations) are the same. The moment you had two groups with two different treatments, you had two datasets.
 
T'ai Chi said:
What in the world are you talking about?? Are you reading the same thread? Where do you get all of this 'before taking a measurement, before seeing the data' nonsense?
You need to pay attention, T'ai:

"If, instead, you claim this person first does the calculations and then doesn't like the outcome and tortures the data or test to force an outcome, you are no longer speaking of bias, but of fraud."

There are only two alternatives. The first is to adhere to the basic rule of inference testing: establish the model and the test before you collect the data. The second is to wait until after the data are in. Either way, if you claim a bias during the selection that favors an outcome you are claiming psychic pap. If, on the other hand, you are claiming this person doesn't like the outcome of the first analysis and reselects a model to force the outcome he wants, you are talking fraud.
 
CFLarsen said:


Can't do it, huh?

Ignore, then taunt. Seems promising in theory, but in reality it is utterly ineffective eh Claus?

You'll have to address the actual issues.
 
Jeff Corey said:

A minor error? The p value was twice what you represented. The point is that your huge error was made to prove your point that stat rats could be biased.
Don't you get it?

Pathetic. The minor error was in reading the wrong line from output. The large error is people not addressing the updated corrected example and latching on to a minor error that is irrelevant to the actual issues the example demonstrated.

You will address it, won't you?
 
BillHoyt said:

In statistics, sir, the "dataset" is the "population." In "inference testing" sir, the aim is to determine whether or not two datasets (populations) are the same. The moment you had two groups with two different treatments, you had two datasets.

No.

One dataset.

Again, however, irrelevant to the actual issues presented (no surprise there!)
 
BillHoyt said:

You need to pay attention, T'ai:


You need to address some relevant issues.


Either way, if you claim a bias during the selection that favors an outcome you are claiming psychic pap.


Nope. Unconscious bias is natural, not supernatural.

Why do you think triple blinding is being done at all in real life?
 
T'ai Chi said:
Ignore, then taunt. Seems promising in theory, but in reality it is utterly ineffective eh Claus?

Not really. I think this thread speaks for itself.

T'ai Chi said:
You'll have to address the actual issues.

Oh, I am, T'ai Chi. I am:

You are not able to analyze the data, using a method that will show bias towards the "coffee" group.

Ergo, your claim is unfounded.

Ergo, your description of how "triple-blinding" works is based on an unfounded claim.

So, we are back to square 1: "Triple-blinding"....how does that work, T'ai Chi?
 
T'ai Chi said:


No.

One dataset.

Again, however, irrelevant to the actual issues presented (no surprise there!)

Let's see. I give you evidence from two sources. You repeat your bald assertion. Somehow, rational people need more.
 
T'ai Chi said:


You need to address some relevant issues.

[/b]

Nope. Unconscious bias is natural, not supernatural.

Why do you think triple blinding is being done at all in real life? [/B]
I am addressing the relevant issues, sir. You continue to deflect at every juncture. You have been asked repeatedly and by multiple parties here to substantiate your unconscious bias claim vis-a-vis model and test choice. Your first response was to compare a two-tailed test with a one-tailed test. You then corrected yourself with a Fisher's Exact of.0237, compared to a Chi-Square of .0179. You may think that it went unnoted that the test results are the same, sir, but it did not. The cut-offs chosen a priori are typically .01, or .05 or .001. Not .02. These two tests do not result in different decisions, do they sir?

And you continue to fail to address the point that has been raised repeatedly about your paranormal claim that a statistician can, without calculating the results, choose a test to give him a predetermined outcome. That is prognostication, sir. Perhaps even backward causation since the data themselves would usually have to be altered to realize a particular outcome. If you don't like these conclusions, I'm afraid your claim degenerates to one of your stat brat committing scientific fraud.
 
CFLarsen said:

Not really. I think this thread speaks for itself.


Oh this thread illustrates a whole lot of things about bias.

[]b
You are not able to analyze the data, using a method that will show bias towards the "coffee" group.
[/b]

Moot. You simply ignored what I said in response.


Ergo, your claim is unfounded.


Um what claim specifically? What I said, or how you are erroneously interpreting what I said?


Ergo, your description of how "triple-blinding" works is based on an unfounded claim.


Nope. Triple blinding is well known and employeed in experiments.


So, we are back to square 1: "Triple-blinding"....how does that work, T'ai Chi?

You might be back to square one, that's great.

Triple blinding? How does it work? As I said in a post long long ago, in a thread far far away, by blinding the evaluator to the group membership..
 
BillHoyt said:

Let's see. I give you evidence from two sources. You repeat your bald assertion. Somehow, rational people need more.

My example used one dataset. Just what do you think is meant by saying the evaluator has one spreadsheet with all the data from the experiment in it?
 
BillHoyt said:

I am addressing the relevant issues, sir.


Ok, fair enough. :)


You continue to deflect at every juncture.


You caught me! And, well, since I'm already deflecting at junctures, I'll take the time to deflect extra at this juncture:

  • Do you think your choice of analyzing the J counts (and counting them multiple times for the same instance), and your choice of analysis and interpretation of the analysis, for the JE transcripts is completely free of all types of bias?
  • Do you claim that it is not possible for you to impart your unconscious bias into it anywhere?
  • Do you claim to not have unconscious bias?
  • Do you think if you were presented with say 4 transcripts, 2 each from a well-known medium, say 'Margey Madeline' (made up name) and 2 each from a person, say 'Skeeter Jones' (made up name) who doesn't claim to be a medium, but their names were changed from Margey Madeline and Skeeter Jones to 'Person 1' and 'Person 2', and you analyzed the transcripts, and commented on them, do you think your analysis and interpretation would be improved from what you were doing before being blinded?


You have been asked repeatedly and by multiple parties here to substantiate your unconscious bias claim vis-a-vis model and test choice.


Multiple parties, ie. you and Claus. ;)

Moreover, I did present the Fisher's Exact vs Chi Square test as an example, as well as talked about how an evaluator can impart his/her bias in general, and presented sites with information on unconscious bias as well as online tests to detect/measure it.


Your first response was to compare a two-tailed test with a one-tailed test. You then corrected yourself with a Fisher's Exact of.0237, compared to a Chi-Square of .0179.

You may think that it went unnoted that the test results are the same, sir, but it did not.


I don't understand your last sentence above. The test results are most certainly not the same if alpha = .02 as I stated. In one case you reject the null hypothesis (because the p-value is less than .02), and in the other you fail to reject the null hypothesis (because the p-value is greater than .02).

How is that "the same"? It is only the same conclusion (of rejecting the null hypopthesis) if alpha is greater than .02, which it wasn't because I set it to be .02.


The cut-offs chosen a priori are typically .01, or .05 or .001. Not .02. These two tests do not result in different decisions, do they sir?


Alpha can be set to anything in real life. Find me any mathematical theory that says that alpha is always .05 or .01 (or any value for that matter).

While it is true that the commonly used alphas are .05, .01, etc., alpha can be set to anything in practice, depending on what past studies used, the nature of the phenomena at hand, the experimenters' judgement, and the severity of making a Type 1 Error, for example.

Non .05 or .01 alphas are extremely common in practice. In many instances in the area of 'multiple comparisons', for example, alpha is calculated to be some truly bizarre non-typical number like .00833, etc. Again, it just depends on the situation.

I repeat: I can create the exact same scenario with alpha = .05 if you'd like. Just lemme know. :) The main idea with the test still stands though, not to mention all the ways unconscious bias can creep in elsewhere, like in the presentation of the data and in the interpretation of the analysis, etc., hence the need for triple blinding when feasible.


And you continue to fail to address the point that has been raised repeatedly about your paranormal claim ...


It's not paranormal despite your belief that it is or that I am claiming it is. Unconscious bias is normal.


...that a statistician can, without calculating the results, choose a test to give him a predetermined outcome.


Not predetermined, just an outcome that reflects his bias(es). For example, the evaluator might know the p-value would be lower (because one test is an approximation of another), but he wouldn't know that the p-value would be exactly .013736, for example. :) If I was claiming the latter (I'm not) I'd agree that it was paranormal and prognosthewordIcantsay.


That is prognostication, sir.


No, it is being influenced by bias.


If you don't like these conclusions, I'm afraid your claim degenerates to one of your stat brat committing scientific fraud.

Nope, because we are talking about unconscious bias here, not conscious bias.
 
Clancie said:

He's got the lingo down so well that there have been some posters who responded to him here as a fellow skeptic, lol.)



Hmmm. Well, I've only been here a few months, and I immediately recognized what he was doing and found it funny the first, oh, 10 threads I read. Then I found it annoying, and after 30, I was just pissed.

At some point of my annoyance phase, I responded to him that his chronic parodying was a disservice to the important role skeptics play in some lives, including mine. I would delete that if I could (you can do that here, I think?, but I did not know this at the time), since it reflected more my pique at finding him freakin' constantly posting ◊◊◊◊ when I was trying to read a thread for substantive exchange. But that isn't what I said, and I regret having unleashed a peevish diatribe.

One trick ponies are just that. I wish he'd move on to either other points/gimmicks, or another board.

[edited for coherence]


<table cellspacing=1 cellpadding=4 bgcolor=#660066 border=0><tr><td bgcolor=#660066><font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" color=#ffffff size=1>Posted by Pyrrho:</font></td></tr><tr><td bgcolor=white><font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" color=black size=2>Edited for language.

As always, this decision may be appealed to Hal Bidlack[/i]</font></td></tr></table>
 
CFLarsen said:


You know, something funny happened just after this. I read the news, and came across this piece:

A Danish IT-company has actually just hired 6 autistic people to help with software testing, e.g. for the biggest telecom in Denmark, TDC. They are specifically hired, because they are brilliant with computers.

I've been reading this looooong thread, and had sorta decided not to much jump in. But this is the second time issues pertaining to my "sacred motherhood" have arisen, so here I go.

My youngest is autistic -- he is 19 but has a "mental age" of 12. While his IQ is sub-par at 75, damn, that kid can tell you in 5 seconds what day of the week Xmas was on in 1982, and what Aunt Janice wore to the family get-together. Or, what day of the week I was born on, and on what weekday my b'day will fall on in 2015. Now, ask him to stay on task getting the carts back in the store at Lowe's, where he works, and you will have problems cuz he finds navigating the parking lot pretty confusing. He cannot divide fractions, and does not really even know what a fraction is.

His oldest brother died 6 yrs ago, and that brings me to the points that have been raised about mediums preying on parents of dead children. Until I became one of those parents, I did not particularly find this so offensive. I now do. But I will also admit that a part of me wishes I was one of the ignorant who could believe JE or whomever could put me in touch with my son. That I am so envious of the gullible fuels my outrage. They ought not do that, tho; it is immoral, even if comfort is had there.
 
T'ai Chi said:
Oh this thread illustrates a whole lot of things about bias.

And your knowledge of it.

T'ai Chi said:
Moot. You simply ignored what I said in response.

It is far from "moot". You flat-out refused it, although it should be easy for someone with your education in the field of statistics.

T'ai Chi said:
Um what claim specifically? What I said, or how you are erroneously interpreting what I said?

Stop playing word games.

T'ai Chi said:
Nope. Triple blinding is well known and employeed in experiments.

And I have asked you to tell us how that works.

T'ai Chi said:
You might be back to square one, that's great.

You are, T'ai Chi.

T'ai Chi said:
Triple blinding? How does it work? As I said in a post long long ago, in a thread far far away, by blinding the evaluator to the group membership..

For what benefit? No bias, right? So, how does the bias influence the results?

That's what you cannot explain.
 
T'ai Chi said:
My example used one dataset. Just what do you think is meant by saying the evaluator has one spreadsheet with all the data from the experiment in it?

As with many of your responses, Tr'olldini, this hardly warrants a response. But for those who don't get just how stupendously stupid, incredibly ignorant and massively moronic you are being here, lets run this one up the tr'oll poll and see how many woos ooh and ahh.

We have a dataset of temperature measurements from dogs and a different one from cats. We put them on a spreadsheet for a side-by-side comparison and *poof* they are instantly one dataset!

We have a dataset of skeptic IQs and a dataset of woo Qs. We put them on a spreadsheet for a side-by-side comparison and *poof* all the woos start scratching their heads, jaws agape, and search the office looking for that other dataset they used to have.

Ah, the power of Bill Gates. The eX files! Excel has the god-like power of merging datasets into one simply by putting them together on a spreadsheet.

I better lodge a complaint with the mods that you just violated the JREF conjuror's rule by revealing yet another magician's trick.

Let this be an object lesson to you all that you should remember to always keep a backup so you don't lose datasets to the eX files.
 
T'ai Chi said:

Alpha can be set to anything in real life. Find me any mathematical theory that says that alpha is always .05 or .01 (or any value for that matter).
... prognosthewordIcantsay.
We're not talking about mathematcal theory, tr'oll. Find me one research paper from a peer-reviewed journal with an alpha set at .0213.
 
Posted by Mona

His oldest brother died 6 yrs ago,
Mona, I'm so sorry about your son. Please accept my condolensces.. I have always felt that no loss would be worse to than the loss of a child. I am so sorry that you have been through that.
Posted by Mona

...and that brings me to the points that have been raised about mediums preying on parents of dead children.
Since you've read through this thread, you know that I often argue on behalf of mediums and mediumship here. So (true to form) I take some issue with the word "prey" (which many others here agree with you about).

Whether or not psychic ability is real, there is no doubt in my mind that some psychics are convinced that they -do- have mediumistic abilities. I do not think these kinds of psychics mean to "prey" on grieving people when they come to offer their services (for example, with missing children). I think they are trying to be helpful. (That said, I don't think they should do it. But, in my experience, it is often not about money...or even publicity for the psychic...it is simply someone who feels he/she has a gift and is trying to be helpful).

As for situations where parents seek out a medium, I don't think that qualifies as "preying" on someone either, unless a medium is knowingly fraudulent. And, there is no question that some parents -do- get comfort from their readings with mediums.
Posted by Mona

But I will also admit that a part of me wishes I was one of the ignorant who could believe JE or whomever could put me in touch with my son.
Just curious. Have you seen a medium yourself? And, what has lead you to the apparent conviction that people who do are "ignorant"? :confused:
Posted by Mona

That I am so envious of the gullible fuels my outrage. They ought not do that, tho; it is immoral, even if comfort is had there.
People get comfort from many things that aren't affective for everyone (religion, mediumship, psychotherapy, work...whatever). Personally, I admire people who seem to have worked through their grief very well in whatever way they can, but we all know the pain of a deep loss never completely goes away, regardless. Have you seen the HBO documentary "Life after Life"? There is a couple in it who receives a good reading from George Anderson. They believe he has actually put them in touch with their son, and yet afterwards, they are still grieving because the son is just not here with them anymore in their daily life and not even mediumship can change that. At best, it can give a little hope, a little comfort, help people move on a little bit, (sometimes prevent them from ending their own lives due to grief), but ultimately I don't there's any real panacea, even with mediums.
 
Clancie said:
But, in my experience, it is often not about money...or even publicity for the psychic...it is simply someone who feels he/she has a gift and is trying to be helpful).
Anybody out there got the annual income figures for all the medium clowns running around today? It should be interesting to see how not about the money it all is. One also needs to speculate here as to how all these sincere but deluded ones manage to converge on the same conjuror tricks? Is there a conjuror's gene out there responsible for this cluster of behavioral patterns? Some toxin in the water?

:dl:
 
So...Bill....you're saying that you're convinced that all psychics are definitely fraudulent? Is that what you think? :confused:

P.S. Ever planning to address Thanz's question about your "J" analysis? Or mine about bias in general? :confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom