Thanz said:
It was in the massive thread The "Process" of John Edward
Thank you for wasting my time pointing to the wrong page. I would prefer it if I did not have to wade through 28 pages to find
your examples.
I see Hoyt explain statistics. Not necessarily the clearest explanation I have ever seen. But he does try.
I see Lurker try to understand. Not the easiest task. But he does try.
I see T'ai Chi try to counter Hoyt, but is rebutted by Jeff Corey.
I see you do a Google and think you can participate in a discussion on statistics.
If I have missed something
relevant (I frankly don't have time to read closely through 28 pages), you are most welcome to point it out.
Now, to your post in this thread:
Thanz said:
Let's take Mr. Hoyt as an example. Some time ago there was a thread in which the letter J was analyzed for frequency against the general population. Mr. Hoyt chose a Poisson distribution test, but never explained why it was appropriate for the analysis. But let's just take his test as appropriate.
Fine with me.
Thanz said:
He then embarked on a counting method of J's that defied logic and came up with a statistically significant result, using the Poisson test. When anybody else used the same raw data and went through counting guesses and letter J's, the results were not statistically significant.
Really? Where do people show this? (and, please be
precise!)
Thanz said:
So, did Mr. Hoyt consciously choose a method to skew the results in his favour? If he did, he is intellectually dishonest and a fraudster.
Did he unconsciously choose a method that would skew the results in his favour? If that is what happened, then you have a great example of bias on the statisticians part altering the results.
First, I have not seen your evidence that Hoyt consciously chose a method that skewed the results in his favor.
Second, this example is not comparable to T'ai Chi's: T'ai Chi is (presumably!) talking about two sets of data, where the same method is being applied, and the result favors the "paranormal" dataset.
That's what I am trying to get T'ai Chi to explain. I try to keep focused here.
So, whatever your beef with Hoyt is, take it up with him.