[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think that value is in the ballpark. How much do you think would be needed then?

Here's some help if you really care about the truth:

Dr. Greenings calc max boundary for 100 micron thickness:

http://the911forum.freeforums.org/active-thermitic-material-in-wtc-dust-t150-15.html#p2605

A more realistic value:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4599163&postcount=951

Regarding a practical application:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4599832&postcount=1067

We're talking about a 1 in thick coating for 1 in thick steel. The materials are roughly the same weight. Even if it was 1/10th of what I am saying (i.e. 10,000 tons), it would be a ridiculous plan because there are much better alternatives where the perpetrators could avoid that telltale bright white light emanating from the entire building on all sides.

Here again, gregory, you are assuming 1" thickness. You must remember that military grade nano-thermite remains out of the public domain. Quite simply we can't guess how much, or what thickness, would be required to produce the results witnessed. Your argument fails.:cool:
 
No evidence? Would NIST scientists that knew of this delivery system of nano-thermite be so utterly clueless?:jaw-dropp

What on gods earth are you getting on with? Are you intentionally acting so stupid? That is an honest question?

TAM:)
 
Here again, gregory, you are assuming 1" thickness. You must remember that military grade nano-thermite remains out of the public domain. Quite simply we can't guess how much, or what thickness, would be required to produce the results witnessed. Your argument fails.:cool:

Well then why didn't they just simply use piximite. I mean the equivalent amount of piximite to produce the needed heat would be only 1-2 mm thick...that would only be a couple of coats of pixiprimer.

TAM:)
 
Done. I wrote:

Professor Jones has asked for more details. I know there was a link posted in this, by now, very long thread. Can somebody provide the link to the video (or audio), and the quotes, and, if handy, the point in the video or audio where Professor Jones spoke about lab tests. The date and place of the talk would be nice.
 
I read somewhere else a few days ago that one of the persons that collected substantial amounts of dust was going to use it in some sort of remembrance sculpture or art exhibit. ill have to go look for the source to cite and edit this post later.

Yes, this was what Jones implied strongly when he first showed off some pieces of molten metal; IIRC this was at the Los Angeles conference in 2006 that was broadcast on CSPAN. He said that somebody had seen this slag had fallen off one of the memorial sculptures and picked it up and put it in a bucket, and moved out to California a few years later (which MacKinlay did) and left it in her garage for years. I could never quite get a read on whether MacKinlay's boyfriend had been the sculptor or not.

ETA: See this video at about 24:10. It is not clear to me that Jones is referring to MacKinlay here.

ETA 2. MacKinlay's dust has also been used to confirm the use of mini-nukes:

In a collaborative effort between Author/Artist/Survivor/Patriot Janette MacKinlay, Physicist Dr. Bill Deagle, MD, and Dr. Ed Ward, MD, MT, WTC debris has been received by a Certified Laboratory for key tests which may show definitive origination for the massive Tritium Levels in the WTC buildings.
 
Last edited:
You can also ask him why he failed to put that crucial information in his paper and whilst you're at it slap his wrist for such a basic error, it's unforgivable for someone of a post graduate level.

Professor Jones has replied. He wants to know for which purpose the paint you are asking about is supposed to be for. (AFAIR, there was a test for resistance, and some burn tests).

Can you please formulate the paint question more precisely. As in "The paint you referred to on page X, paragraph y, for which z was claimed, is which exact paint?"
 
What is the exact name, and composition of the paint they tested to rule out "paint" as a source of the chips?

If he used more than one, then give the names and compositions of all of the ones he used.

Seems simple enough!!!

TAM:)
 
...Regarding a practical application:
{Part only}...If I thought this work was convincing I would support it. My impression of Sunstealer, Mackey and Dr. Greening is that they are good scientists. They are bringing up important issues that should be resolved before getting to far along with acting on any perceived implications....
We're talking about a 1 in thick coating for 1 in thick steel. The materials are roughly the same weight. Even if it was 1/10th of what I am saying (i.e. 10,000 tons), it would be a ridiculous plan because there are much better alternatives where the perpetrators could avoid that telltale bright white light emanating from the entire building on all sides.
Whilst I respect the wishes of persons who want to pursue the scientific aspects of these excursion topics I personally prefer the direct approach to the implicit primary question of "demolition or not?".

Since direct consideration of the "no demolition" evidence legitimately takes us straight to the negative answer of "NO DEMOLITION" I prefer not to give "truthers" or pro demolition conspirisists the ego satisfaction of even responding to nonsense claims.

Hence my advocacy, to those who are interested in the science, of clearly identifying that their interest is in the science of something that cannot affect the primary question of "Demolition or not?"

For example the issue of molten steel in the basements, usually presented with the inference that it had something to do with demolition. Plus the second innuendo in the form of a statement "was still present weeks after" implying it had been there from 9/11 and had remained hot/molten. In reality the only way the metal flow from level 8n could have been molten steel caused by thermxte requires a fire suited suicide team to enter the impact zone after the plane crash and conduct a specific set of logistic operations. So near enough to "impossible" in lay person speak and "veryN improbable" in scientific speak where "N" is a big number.

AND the molten metal at ground level weeks later needs a "multiple quantum leap" into improbabilites to tie it to the material flowing from the 8nth floor.

So your comment
...My impression of Sunstealer, Mackey and Dr. Greening is that they are good scientists. They are bringing up important issues that should be resolved before getting to far along with acting on any perceived implications....
I agree that they are raising interesting issues BUT there is no need to resolve them "...before getting to far along with acting on any perceived implications...." - the implications perceived or intended are far easier dealt with by direct attack and rebuttal of more relevant points.

For example the only location and stage of the collapse where use of thermate may have assisted the actual collapse is in the impact zone in the interval of time between aircraft crash and the "initial collapse" which triggered the inevitable "Global Collapse". (Note my careful structure of "assisted the actual collapse" - there are "logic gaps to cover" but I take the simple track for this illustration). There are two other "possibilities" of time and location but both can be eliminated by simple analysis/logic.

I routinely refer to the "collapse that actually happened" because most demolition techniques are not valid causes of that "collapse that actually happened". So coating low level columns with therm*te OR explosively cutting core columns in the basement OR (many others) are not and cannot be components of a scheme of demolition actually employed on 9/11. They can easily be shown to be inconsistent with the "collapse that actually happened".

Your reference to the absence of a tell tale white hot glow showing no use of Therm*te is one such case. I say "since it couldn't be so" why stroke the egos of the "truther charlatans" by debating it - other than as a matter of interest only.
 
metamars: Any paints Jones used for the purposes of writing this paper, he should divulge.

For our CD advocate friends out there, please read through this report:

http://www.nyenvirolaw.org/WTC/130 ...ignature.Composition and Morphology.Final.pdf

It's a PDF made by the RJ LeeGroup explaining the composition and morphology of the WTC dust. Their elaborate collection procedure is detailed within. Please compare it to Jones' "some people put dust in baggies and mailed it to us" methodology.

Please remember this - the report quoted in this post shows that paint chips were found in the dust. Did Jones find any paint chips in his dust samples? Wouldn't that have been something worthwhile to have compared to his red/gray chips? Why didn't he?
 
Here again, gregory, you are assuming 1" thickness. You must remember that military grade nano-thermite remains out of the public domain.

So you do not even know whether or not such a thing exists, but state that it is ther best explanation for the collapse.

If you cannot descxribe it in full detail, stop expecting rational adults who have reason to believe otherwise that your garbage exists.

You're making less sense than some of those idiots from WeAreChange.
 
Not in my day in the Army but that is now 20 years past. :( (gee - I am that old..... :mad: :rolleyes: )

...and that is only one point wrong with all this nano thermite nonsense. :boggled:

I would bet that it would leave the same kind of coating on metal that the military thermite I worked with, or the improvised thermite that I made for arson investigations classes left behind.

Insolulable chalky white and baked onto the metal.
 
READ POST 1299 - That SEM Photo clarifies once and for all that Jones' samples a-d are paint attached to hematite. No mistakes, no ifs, no buts, it clearly shows a crystalline metallic substrate called steel with an oxidised layer and then paint attached.

Stop with the BS, the spamming the insinuation etc - that photo sinks Jones et al.

Would the steel crystals explain why the chips were attracted to a magnet?
 
See "Obtaining the first dust sample" at http://911guide.googlepages.com/jones
Just had a look at that and opened some links - I listened to the first 3 minutes or so of the video and she ticked all the boxes in my head that I would prejudicially associate with someone who was a bit more flamboyant, artsy fartsy type etc. Then I looked at the Fortunate Diary and it's well put together with some striking images and I revised my view a little. She's obviously had a traumatic experience. I feel for her (although that won't get in the way of a good objective examination).

The only mention that I can see about her boyfriend and welding along with other info is

This dust was exposed to all surrounding conditions for a minimum of nine days before being collected.

It is also important to note, that her boyfriend, Jim Lecce, was a sculptor who possibly worked with metals and welding equipment

"I (Jannette MacKinlay) moved to New York in September of 1997 with sculptor Jim Lecce to curate art shows featuring both New York and California artists. What was initially going to be a three-month stay turned into four years. Our art loft was directly across the street from the World Trade Center complex."

The dust sample is taken from a household of a man, who was possibly using welding gear to make sculptures. Welding gear can create the iron spheres Jones is talking about. Even the possibility of contamination of the dust samples with dust from his clothing hasn't been ruled out, or even addressed. And this sample was the main piece of evidence he built his theory on

Whilst I can fully appreciate the above statements, there isn't any evidence that he actually did any welding work in the apartment, nor whether he came home in the same overalls or that the overalls ever entered the apartment. However, I take on board the possibility of cross-contamination, whether that be with regard to iron-microspheres, paint or any other material.

This only highlights, again, the problems with such a sample, but also that there is a problem with the method of paint chip extraction from the dust in that it will only pick up certain things and that if you concentrate on them and disregard the rest then you start to get tunnel vision. Why are iron micro-spheres important? Why concentrate on them? Why are subsequent materials removed by the same extraction process important? You get the idea.

I've seen some characterisation under microscope and SEM of the dust and it would be impossible and unreasonable to examine every particle as well as those recovered from magnetic separation, however, it is reasonable to ask for a characterization of the individual chips that Jones has recovered with this method.

It is not unreasonable to want to see a full visual characterization (and therefore labelling) of these chips, especially in light of the view that they are not all the same - as evidence by Jones et al and their paper. A visual characterization would group the specimens accordingly and help the individual in the task of choosing which chips should be used for each testing method. What is clear is that duplication has occurred and we have 3 specimens a,b,d (with "c" coming close - see red layer spectra Fig 7) that are identical, being used with the suggestion that this is typical of each sample. It clearly isn't due to chips such as that found in Fig 31, which have multiple layers - which has significantly different elements observed in the "gray layer" aswell as this layer being considerably thicker than samples a-d.

Is this chip an anomaly? If so how has that been determined? (especially bearing in mind the difference in "gray layer" spectra). Why was it not included for further examination or given greater prominence in a paper that had room taken up by duplication of information from samples a-d?

Now I admit I maybe being a bit harsh here. There is only so much room in a paper and decisions must be made what to publish (in terms of pretty pictures and space) and what to file. Some may think I'm nit picking and that's fair enough, but I'd have preferred to have seen a more measured approach.

Characterize the specimens from each sample - this allows one to observe patterns and determine what is needed for examination. By all means examine samples a-d as has been done, but at least keep one of these for the MEK test rather than do DSC on all of them then select a new sample and not subject it to the same examination as specimens a-d - that way you keep consistency with the experiments and therefore the paper.

OK - I've waffled on and it's probably tl;dr for a few, but I hope that those who do read get the gist of what I'm saying.
 
Professor Jones has asked for more details. I know there was a link posted in this, by now, very long thread. Can somebody provide the link to the video (or audio), and the quotes, and, if handy, the point in the video or audio where Professor Jones spoke about lab tests. The date and place of the talk would be nice.

In the Boston lecture in december 2007 he introduced the unreacted thermite for the first time I believe. I think he said something about independent testing at that lecture.Keep us informed of the email exchange if you would.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1957490867030316250&ei Boston lecture
 
Last edited:
...and that is the crux of your problem, alien. You are assuming that the material was not universally applied.

Once you crack the means with which the towers were demolished, the evidence discovered by Jones becomes insurmountable.

Government hacks - like the majority of posters in this thread - simply lack the power to deduce how the towers were demolished.

You lack the knowledge to understand why the WTC collapse. Lack of knowledge you seem proud of, as you support the idiotic ideas of Jones and 911Truth due to your ignorance on the topics related to 911. You are gullible and have no clue on the mechanisms of failure. At least you wasted no money or time on education in the past 7 years. You are a welcome member of 911Truth, no clue what happen and happy to repeat the lies, hearsay, and failed delusions at will.
 
Here again, gregory, you are assuming 1" thickness. You must remember that military grade nano-thermite remains out of the public domain. Quite simply we can't guess how much, or what thickness, would be required to produce the results witnessed. Your argument fails.:cool:
Actually we can, because we know the energy required to heat a mol of steel up to it's melting point and then the energy required to transform it from a solid phase to a liquid phase - call it A. We know the thickness of steel and it's density.

Once you know this then you know what is required. Then you look at what is proposed, it's constituents and it's volume and calculate the energy generated - call it B.

if A>B for a given volume or weight then A doesn't melt.

You get the idea.

As an aside.

KreeL - Would you be a damn good fellow and help me with a calculation? I've been struggling some what. Come on be a sport, there's a good chap.

I have a material that is 20µm thick (gawd knows what that means) and I cannot work out how many millimetres that is. I also have a piece of steel that's 5 of these blasted metric millimetres thick too! I don't know what happened to good old feet and inches (or chains for that matter), but I need some help old bean.

What I really need to know is the ratio of the thickness (that's a bit like me guffaw) of the steel to the thin 20µm layer thingy. I'm getting all fouled up with this new-fandangled slide-rule what-dya-ma-call-it and I'm in somewhat of a pickle.

I tell you what, why don't you come over and we'll have a spot of afternoon tea, a piece of mother's frightfully good fruit cake, a quick go on the tennis lawn and then you can tell me your answer over a gin and tonic.

Toodle pip.
 
I'm still at a loss to explain why NIST didn't check for thermitic material in the debris during the course of their investigation.... Talk about turning a blind eye.:covereyes

Kreel, if I may reply to that question; the initial investigation was carried out be FEMA, not NIST. Large numbers of experienced engineers and other specialists were at GZ fairly shortly after 9/11.
Indeed (I like that word too) there were some notable demolition specialists onsite.

From what I've read there just was no evidence to lead them down that path (CD). The steel was inspected and sorted; if there was no evidence of cutter charges, melting (thermite?) or unexploded devices, det cord, blasting caps or any other physical evidence then why would you expect them to pursue that theory?

I think you should seriously consider that the reason the mainstream, established scientific community has not embraced CD theory is that there isn't the evidence to support it - instead of assuming that they're all either incompetent or part of an unimaginably huge conspiracy.

ie if they didn't find anything, perhaps that's because there was nothing to find. If you can't accept that as a distinct possibility, you're being far too unobjective about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom