See "Obtaining the first dust sample" at
http://911guide.googlepages.com/jones
Just had a look at that and opened some links - I listened to the first 3 minutes or so of the video and she ticked all the boxes in my head that I would prejudicially associate with someone who was a bit more flamboyant, artsy fartsy type etc. Then I looked at the Fortunate Diary and it's well put together with some striking images and I revised my view a little. She's obviously had a traumatic experience. I feel for her (although that won't get in the way of a good objective examination).
The only mention that I can see about her boyfriend and welding along with other info is
This dust was exposed to all surrounding conditions for a minimum of nine days before being collected.
It is also important to note, that her boyfriend, Jim Lecce, was a sculptor who possibly worked with metals and welding equipment
"I (Jannette MacKinlay) moved to New York in September of 1997 with sculptor Jim Lecce to curate art shows featuring both New York and California artists. What was initially going to be a three-month stay turned into four years. Our art loft was directly across the street from the World Trade Center complex."
The dust sample is taken from a household of a man, who was possibly using welding gear to make sculptures. Welding gear can create the iron spheres Jones is talking about. Even the possibility of contamination of the dust samples with dust from his clothing hasn't been ruled out, or even addressed. And this sample was the main piece of evidence he built his theory on
Whilst I can fully appreciate the above statements, there isn't any evidence that he actually did any welding work in the apartment, nor whether he came home in the same overalls or that the overalls ever entered the apartment. However, I take on board the possibility of cross-contamination, whether that be with regard to iron-microspheres, paint or any other material.
This only highlights, again, the problems with such a sample, but also that there is a problem with the method of paint chip extraction from the dust in that it will only pick up certain things and that if you concentrate on them and disregard the rest then you start to get tunnel vision. Why are iron micro-spheres important? Why concentrate on them? Why are subsequent materials removed by the same extraction process important? You get the idea.
I've seen some characterisation under microscope and SEM of the dust and it would be impossible and unreasonable to examine every particle as well as those recovered from magnetic separation, however, it
is reasonable to ask for a characterization of the individual chips that Jones has recovered with this method.
It is not unreasonable to want to see a full visual characterization (and therefore labelling) of these chips, especially in light of the view that they are not all the same - as evidence by Jones et al and their paper. A visual characterization would group the specimens accordingly and help the individual in the task of choosing which chips should be used for each testing method. What is clear is that duplication has occurred and we have 3 specimens a,b,d (with "c" coming close - see red layer spectra Fig 7) that are identical, being used with the suggestion that this is typical of each sample. It clearly isn't due to chips such as that found in Fig 31, which have multiple layers - which has significantly different elements observed in the "gray layer" aswell as this layer being considerably thicker than samples a-d.
Is this chip an anomaly? If so how has that been determined? (especially bearing in mind the difference in "gray layer" spectra). Why was it not included for further examination or given greater prominence in a paper that had room taken up by duplication of information from samples a-d?
Now I admit I maybe being a bit harsh here. There is only so much room in a paper and decisions must be made what to publish (in terms of pretty pictures and space) and what to file. Some may think I'm nit picking and that's fair enough, but I'd have preferred to have seen a more measured approach.
Characterize the specimens from each sample - this allows one to observe patterns and determine what is needed for examination. By all means examine samples a-d as has been done, but at least keep one of these for the MEK test rather than do DSC on all of them then select a new sample and not subject it to the same examination as specimens a-d -
that way you keep consistency with the experiments and therefore the paper.
OK - I've waffled on and it's probably tl;dr for a few, but I hope that those who do read get the gist of what I'm saying.