[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Something is rotten in the state of Denmark.

Hi all

I have great concern for the credibility and reputation of the University of Copenhagen and Niels Bohr's old institute.

Harrit and 911 truthsites have attempted to gain credibility for they work and Bentham by pointing out that the dean of the natural science faculty of the university of Copenhagen is a member of The open chemical physical journal's editorial board.

This appears to no longer be the case. Dean Niels O. Andersen has been removed from the list of editors.

List of editors:
URL: ---.bentham.org/open/tocpj/EBM.htm

I hope this is a step towards repairing some of the damage done.

I'm currently considering translating a recent interview with Harrit from Danish national TV, where he claims:

- They have found nanothermite in WTC dust.
- The nanothermite is an explosive, apparently capable of hurling 30 tons steel beams in parabolic trajectories up to 100m.
- Nanothermite is super high technological front line military research

My poor language skills are holding me back, but if there is interest, i will try.

Interview with Niels Harrit:
URL: ---.youtube.com/watch?v=nP810ssxyo4

Regards
Scientiae Confidimus
 
Last edited:
Professor Jones has replied. He wants to know for which purpose the paint you are asking about is supposed to be for. (AFAIR, there was a test for resistance, and some burn tests).

Can you please formulate the paint question more precisely. As in "The paint you referred to on page X, paragraph y, for which z was claimed, is which exact paint?"
Sure - I'm surprised he hasn't had more queries.

The following is from the bottom of page 16 and the top of page 17 of the paper.

2. Test Using Methyl Ethyl Ketone Solvent

By employing some means to separate the different components of the material, the chemical compositions of the different particles in the red layer were more accurately determined. The initial objective was to compare the behavior of the red layer with paint when soaked in a strong organic solvent known to soften and dissolve paint. Red/gray chips were soaked in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) for 55 hours with frequent agitation and subsequently dried in air over several days. The chips showed significant swelling of the red layer, but with no apparent dissolution. In marked contrast, paint chips softened and partly dissolved when similarly soaked in MEK.

Those are the paint specimens I and everyone is interested in - what are they (that requires detail). I presume that this same paint was used for all of the testing comparisons.

I'd also ask why that particular type of paint was chosen as opposed to any other.

I'll leave it there for the moment - thanks.
 
Last edited:
Kreel, I don't want to distract you from your calculations, but I'd like to point out some additional things to consider:

1) you're proposing a hypothetical mechanism with an unknown compound! That's all very well, but don't act as if it's something real. It is just unproven speculation.
2) Since these grey/red chips are omnipresent in WTC dust, and have differing molecular characteristics, it MUST be assumed that [a] they were placed deliberately in the dust samples or they are extremely common materials.
If they would be present in fairly large quantities at GZ, and if (as Jones et all propose) originally bonded to structural steel, SOME SUBSTANTIAL quantity would have to still be attached to the steel.

There's just NO way around it. Now, we assume that FEMA and NIST would recognize primer paint on the structural steel. That's a no-brainer. We also assume they DIDN'T see anything suspicious attached to the steel. Again pretty much a no-brainer. Therefore nanothermite paint is virtually guaranteed NOT to be the source of materials such as those seen in the dust.

It can be eliminated fairly confidently without years of tedious confirmation. I wager that NO amount of testing will produce nanothermite from GZ materials, unless by fraud or by misrepresentation (that still amounts to nothing, btw)

The odds are looking very poor indeed (again that word) for Dr. Jones et al, and their loyal followers.

ps if Drs Judy Wood and James Fetzer are reading this thread (LOL) don't get your hopes up kiddies. You're not even in Dr. Jones' league. At least he's still on the planet.
 
Last edited:
Scientiae Confidimus - thank you. Very interesting.

'Something is rotten in the state of Denmark.' and also
'Something is rotten in the state of Utah'

Which hamlet in Utah is the good Dr. from anyway?
 
Well then why didn't they just simply use piximite. I mean the equivalent amount of piximite to produce the needed heat would be only 1-2 mm thick...that would only be a couple of coats of pixiprimer.

TAM:)

Well how about you research a bit for yourself? Have you even read the paper presented?

If the business down the street from you burns down, and in the following investigation it is shown that accelerants were found indicating arson, would you doubt that simply because you don't understand it?:eek:
 
Kreel, I don't want to distract you from your calculations, but I'd like to point out some additional things to consider:

1) you're proposing a hypothetical mechanism with an unknown compound! That's all very well, but don't act as if it's something real. It is just unproven speculation.
2) Since these grey/red chips are omnipresent in WTC dust, and have differing molecular characteristics, it MUST be assumed that [a] they were placed deliberately in the dust samples or they are extremely common materials.
If they would be present in fairly large quantities at GZ, and if (as Jones et all propose) originally bonded to structural steel, SOME SUBSTANTIAL quantity would have to still be attached to the steel.

There's just NO way around it. Now, we assume that FEMA and NIST would recognize primer paint on the structural steel. That's a no-brainer. We also assume they DIDN'T see anything suspicious attached to the steel. Again pretty much a no-brainer. Therefore nanothermite paint is virtually guaranteed NOT to be the source of materials such as those seen in the dust.

It can be eliminated fairly confidently without years of tedious confirmation. I wager that NO amount of testing will produce nanothermite from GZ materials, unless by fraud or by misrepresentation (that still amounts to nothing, btw)

The odds are looking very poor indeed (again that word) for Dr. Jones et al, and their loyal followers.

ps if Drs Judy Wood and James Fetzer are reading this thread (LOL) don't get your hopes up kiddies. You're not even in Dr. Jones' league. At least he's still on the planet.


Thermitic evidence was indeed found. I assume you read the paper? How deep can your head be buried in the sand? Somehow being a NIST apologist doesn't suit you well, my friend.
 
'Harrit and 911 truthsite have attempted to gain credibility for they work and Bentham by pointing out that the dean of the natural science faculty of the university of Copenhagen is a member of The open chemical physical journal's editorial board.

This appears to no longer be the case. Dean Niels O. Andersen has been removed from the list of editors.

List of editors:
URL: ---.bentham.org/open/tocpj/EBM.htm
Scientiae Confidimus

Anyone wanna bet that Niels O. Andersen's name won't stay connected with Bentham's in the truthersphere? Truthers to error correction are like Dracula to garlic necklaces.:eye-poppi
 
Hi all

I have great concern for the credibility and reputation of the University of Copenhagen and Niels Bohr's old institute.

Harrit and 911 truthsites have attempted to gain credibility for they work and Bentham by pointing out that the dean of the natural science faculty of the university of Copenhagen is a member of The open chemical physical journal's editorial board.

This appears to no longer be the case. Dean Niels O. Andersen has been removed from the list of editors.

List of editors:
URL: ---.bentham.org/open/tocpj/EBM.htm

I hope this is a step towards repairing some of the damage done.

I'm currently considering translating a recent interview with Harrit from Danish national TV, where he claims:

- They have found nanothermite in WTC dust.
- The nanothermite is an explosive, apparently capable of hurling 30 tons steel beams in parabolic trajectories up to 100m.
- Nanothermite is super high technological front line military research

My poor language skills are holding me back, but if there is interest, i will try.

Interview with Niels Harrit:
URL: ---.youtube.com/watch?v=nP810ssxyo4

Regards
Scientiae Confidimus

Welcome. enjoy.
 
I would bet that it would leave the same kind of coating on metal that the military thermite I worked with, or the improvised thermite that I made for arson investigations classes left behind.

Insolulable chalky white and baked onto the metal.
I make no comments or admissions as to my possible involvement in experiments in blowing things up....

....however I did hear some vague rumours about...... :D :o

:blush:
 
Well how about you research a bit for yourself? Have you even read the paper presented?

If the business down the street from you burns down, and in the following investigation it is shown that accelerants were found indicating arson, would you doubt that simply because you don't understand it?:eek:

If a plane full of fuel ran into it I wouldn't think arson.
 
Thermitic evidence was indeed found. I assume you read the paper? How deep can your head be buried in the sand? Somehow being a NIST apologist doesn't suit you well, my friend.

I'm an apologist for the truth and facts, my friend, not NIST. If you read my post carefully you will understand that the thermite claims ultimately must fit with reality - they cannot remain purely hypothetical. At some point the material would need to be applied in large quantities - you can't get around this. There WOULD be evidence on the leftover steel itself. This isn't a bad TV movie, y'know - stuff just doesn't disappear like magic because you say so. (ie appear in all the dust but NONE on the steel - not possible)

Just because the Jones paper describes this material as thermitic doesn't mean that it could actually do anything to structural steel. You do understand that, don't you?

Do you guys have any idea how far past the evidence you're leaping? Slow down and think, man.
 
Last edited:
Well how about you research a bit for yourself? Have you even read the paper presented?

If the business down the street from you burns down, and in the following investigation it is shown that accelerants were found indicating arson, would you doubt that simply because you don't understand it?:eek:

That is crazy funny. Because your're the one ignoring the investigation because you don't understand it. And because you really, really, really, really, want 9/11 to be an inside jobby job. Instead you listen to some quacks who wrote some crappy paper they had to pay to get published.

Hey twoofer, explain how magic super duper mega nano therm*te managed to destroy a skyscraper. Produces the calculations proving it can cut through vertical columns, calculate how much was needed, explain where it was applied and how it all got there, explain how it survived the plane crashes and fires , ect. I dare you, twoofer.
 
Hey twoofer, explain how magic super duper mega nano therm*te managed to destroy a skyscraper. Produces the calculations proving it can cut through vertical columns, calculate how much was needed, explain where it was applied and how it all got there, explain how it survived the plane crashes and fires , ect. I dare you, twoofer.

And how it magically vanished off all the structural steel after collapse, but reappeared in Dr. Jones' samples.
 
READ POST 1299 - That SEM Photo clarifies once and for all that Jones' samples a-d are paint attached to hematite. No mistakes, no ifs, no buts, it clearly shows a crystalline metallic substrate called steel with an oxidised layer and then paint attached.

Stop with the BS, the spamming the insinuation etc - that photo sinks Jones et al.

Sunstealer, could the steel crystals explain why the chips were attracted to a magnet?
 
I'm an apologist for the truth and facts, my friend, not NIST. If you read my post carefully you will understand that the thermite claims ultimately must fit with reality - they cannot remain purely hypothetical. At some point the material would need to be applied in large quantities - you can't get around this. There WOULD be evidence on the leftover steel itself. This isn't a bad TV movie, y'know - stuff just doesn't disappear like magic because you say so. (ie appear in all the dust but NONE on the steel - not possible)

Just because the Jones paper describes this material as thermitic doesn't mean that it could actually do anything to structural steel. You do understand that, don't you?

Do you guys have any idea how far past the evidence you're leaping? Slow down and think, man.

So you don't believe that a thermite reaction can do as much to structural steel than an office fire? Amazing - :jaw-dropp
 
Would the steel crystals explain why the chips were attracted to a magnet?
Firstly sorry for the large text font - it's not my style, but sometimes you have to shout above the noise.

Yes they would - but that is not quite the entire story.

The chip that has been sent to the French "truther" (I hate using that label, but there aren't any better) shows a number of different layers; namely 3.

The first - bottom layer, page 11 and page 13 left hand pic http://darksideofgravity.com/marseille.pdf is a fibrous, crystalline metallic layer, which with EDS spectra highly indicates steel. On top of that is an oxide layer, because all stable metals form a stable oxide on the surface, it stops them from burning, (middle - it's brittle - note the cracks) which can only come from the steel (and on top of that paint which is the only explanation for the material given in EDS analysis - it ain't thermite because there are far too many other elements present).

So we can safely say that the chip given to the Frenchman would indeed be attracted by a magnet.

I've alluded to the magnetism of different oxide layers or products before, so search hematite, maghemite and my name and you'll get the post in this thread.

With Jones' chips it's slightly more difficult, because we can't see the underside of the "gray layer".

Another problem is paramagnetism. On researching further, both Al, Fe2O3 in the form of hematite have these properties. In conclusion with other information I think it's wise to say that the chips would be attracted to a magnet either through paramagnetism or through magnetism. As far as I'm aware (and please anyone correct me if I'm wrong) the intention to use magnets was to separate iron-rich micro-spheres from the dust and not any other material.
 
....
- The nanothermite is an explosive, apparently capable of hurling 30 tons steel beams in parabolic trajectories up to 100m.....

Welcome from another "Newbie" Scientiae Confidimus.

If that claim is true we are seeing some fundamental revolution in basic physics.


Seriously ask the base question(s) "How does an explosive apply pressure to a mass to make a force which accelerates that mass over a time interval to a velocity which then results in a parabolic trajectory 100m long?"

An explosive works by producing rapidly expanding gas. The particle size for most changes the rate of gas emmission.

For any given quantity of explosive/firearm propellant grinding to smaller particles produces the gas faster but for a short time frame compared with larger particles producing gas more slowly with lower pressures but over a longer period of time. However, to first order accuracy, the quantity of gas is the same for both OR any intermediate sizes of particles.

And, to accelerate a mass the gas has to be constrained - hence most guns have breeches , chambers and barrels - those constrain the expanding gas to pushing the bullet/shell by its arse up the barrel and it accelerates all the way. Remove the constraints of barrel, chamber etc and you can set the cartidge off with a match without serious risk. (For rifle calibre stuff anyway - not Big Mo's 16 inch pop guns or similar.)

So don't hold your breath waiting for some big break through.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom