[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Argue the evidence.
typoisThe evidence, to a person with proper credentials to eval;uate it, looks like p[aint chips.

There is no indication that the chips were ever anything other than a paint-thin layer of somethinmg.

The authorities you cite are know clowns.

Buh-bye.
 
Last edited:
Mods:

Please move this to the mental pygmies section.

The people here have no interest in rational or scientific discussion.

I am very disappointed in the quality of the James Randi forum.

Mods I agree with the reincarnation of Galileo who excuses Al Quada and accuses innocent people of mass murder with zero evidence, let’s move this nonsense to a more suitable place.
 
Last edited:
Dubya is so evil that not only does he pull off 9/11, he eats kittens alive.

President-Bush-Eats-Kitten-1259.jpg
 
Let's head off some of the potshots that have been fired off in this thread already.

1) It's not a vanity press. Here's the peer review process:

REVIEWING AND PROMPTNESS OF PUBLICATION: All manuscripts submitted for publication will be immediately subjected to peer-reviewing, usually in consultation with the members of the Editorial Advisory Board and a number of external referees. Authors may, however, provide in their Covering Letter the contact details (including e-mail addresses) of four potential peer reviewers for their paper. Any peer reviewers suggested should not have recently published with any of the authors of the submitted manuscript and should not be members of the same research institution.
All peer-reviewing will be conducted via the Internet to facilitate rapid reviewing of the submitted manuscripts. Every possible effort will be made to assess the manuscripts quickly with the decision being conveyed to the authors in due course.

2) Check the advisory board. It's not a bunch of kooks, but credentialed, international scientists.

3) The second author is Dr. Jeffrey Farrer, current BYU faculty. And although Jones has been smeared pretty good here, it's a solid list of scientists with him.

4) Read the paper. I'm going through it now and it's quite interesting and thoroughly sourced. It's certainly worthy of productive discussion.
 
It depends on the conclusions. SO they found Iron Oxide, and Aluminum.

Thermite could be one example, but the lack of other evidence to support it diminishes the claim.

The proper process is, for ANY good scientist is: What ELSE could that evidence conclude?
 
Is Jones pussyfooting the claim of finding barium in the red chips?

In the sections on the spectometry research, there is not a whiff about barium. I checked all the figures and the text, nothing about Ba. Now, if they DID find barium in those red chips, wouldn't that be mentioned? In fact, wouldn't that constitute key evidence in support of the hypothesis (well, at least insofar as thermate is concerned)?

Then in the penultimate section about avenues for further research, Jones et al. says this in passing:

Jones et al. said:
We have observed that some chips have additional elements such as potassium, lead, barium and copper. Are these significant, and why do such elements appear in some red chips and not others? An example is shown in Fig. (31) which shows significant Pb along with C, O, Fe, and Al and displays multiple red and gray layers. (p. 28)


This is the first mention of barium in the paper. And then in the conclusions, the authors again say: "The red material is most interesting and has the following characteristics: 1. It is composed of aluminum, iron, oxygen, silicon and carbon. Lesser amounts of other potentially reactive elements are sometimes present, such as potassium, sulfur, lead, barium and copper" (p. 29). There it is again, barium, although nothing about it was mentioned in the body of the paper. Has Jones elsewhere made more definite claims about barium?
 
Last edited:
It depends on the conclusions. SO they found Iron Oxide, and Aluminum.

Thermite could be one example, but the lack of other evidence to support it diminishes the claim.

The proper process is, for ANY good scientist is: What ELSE could that evidence conclude?

They address that on pg 27:

"7. Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?"
 
RedIbis:

1) It's not a vanity press. Here's the peer review process:

Are you freaking kidding me? Did you read this very freaking thread?? It has been established that Bentham is not a legitimate journal, is pay for publish and worse, their peer review process is a joke.

Also a joke is Jones and these other nitwits. Hey Red, quick question: how does gravity work? And in light of how gravity works, how does "super thermite" work horizontally?

Man, truthers are freaking morons.
 
Wow, they found red paint. This has already been discussed at JREF - use the search function and you'll find the thread and then you'll find my post where I prove that it's red paint.
 
The entire premise is ridiculous. The WTC towers collapsed because of an unspecified amount of an unspecified explosive plus thermite used with an unspecified technology to cut the columns horizontally, and the only way to uncover the mighty plot is to put some paint chips under a microscope. :wackyrolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Wow, they found red paint. This has already been discussed at JREF - use the search function and you'll find the thread and then you'll find my post where I prove that it's red paint.

Sunstealer, I'm not positive this is paint. Then again, I'm not sure if there are classes of silicon based paints that are not soluble in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK).

There are other classes of anticorrosive coatings. I wonder if that's what this could be that. I simply don't know enough about the composition of the towers to know if any were applied to the steel.

BTW, while I have you here: On p. 13 of this new paper, there's some X-EDS spectroscopy that Jones et. al. is claming demonstrates that the FE to O ratio is 2 to 3, therefore validating the notion that this is indeed Fe2O3. I haven't gone back to look at your posts regarding interpreting EDX, so I'm not sure how solid this identification is (my undergrad work had me do CGs and NMRs, and that was years ago, so I don't even remember much of that). Does that specific point seem solid to you?

Thanks.
 
Also (sorry to keep picking your brain, Sunstealer): Am I missing something, or is there indeed no work establishing that there are stochiometrically correct ratios of Aluminum to Fe2O3? (*Sigh*...) I'll go back and reread it, but I don't think I see that. I'm of course subject to correction if I'm mistaken.
 
That is a stupid question. I am not going to call you stupid, but your question is stupid.

Which authority shall I bring it to, the JREF police?

You obviously have a plan to bring it to SOMEBODY, otherwise you would not be saying that our "days are numbered".

So who are you planning to show this evidence to?
 
Sunstealer, I'm not positive this is paint. Then again, I'm not sure if there are classes of silicon based paints that are not soluble in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK).

There are other classes of anticorrosive coatings. I wonder if that's what this could be that. I simply don't know enough about the composition of the towers to know if any were applied to the steel.

BTW, while I have you here: On p. 13 of this new paper, there's some X-EDS spectroscopy that Jones et. al. is claming demonstrates that the FE to O ratio is 2 to 3, therefore validating the notion that this is indeed Fe2O3. I haven't gone back to look at your posts regarding interpreting EDX, so I'm not sure how solid this identification is (my undergrad work had me do CGs and NMRs, and that was years ago, so I don't even remember much of that). Does that specific point seem solid to you?

Thanks.
They haven't provided any figures or calculations nor said what the software package is for converting their qualitative data (the spectra) to a quantitative one which will then give you actual compounds present. So no they can't just say that the ratio is 3:2 but I'll check when I've got more time to digest the paper because they are clearly looking at proving aluminium powder iron III oxide. TBH if it's unreactive thermite then with the SEM they should be able to pickout individual particles of Aluminium and iron III oxide, instead we see some form of iron oxide and a spectra with Aluminium, Silicon and Oxygen in with distinct crystollographic shapes and they claim the Oxygen is on the surface of the aluminium (how they tell this I don't know).

I was expecting some proper analysis using XRD (x-ray diffraction) because this would then definitely give the compounds present and their amounts and prove once and for all what the chips are actually made of. They keep using EDS and whilst the graphs look pretty and fool those who don't have any experience they simply cannot be used for a quantitative analysis so their claims are pretty poor.

I'm actually interested in Figs 24-27 and Fig 8. On first looking at fig 8 along with the spectra the dark crystals and platelets looks like Kaolin/Kaolinite. Whilst the smaller brighter crystals look a bit like SiO2 but they have EDS data showing predominantly Fe and O in those regions.

Note how in fig 25 they pick up Titanium which will almost certainly be TiO2 which is a whitener and used in paint.

I'm sure that what gives the game away with regard to this material being red paint or potentially an anti-corrosion coating is the fact it's clearly dual layer. Could even be a primer with paint.

Themite is just a mix of fine iron oxide and aluminium powder (and sometimes Sulphur, Potassium Permanganate, Barium Nitrate). It won't form a dual layer because you require the mixture to be as well mixed as possible for it to work, it's effectively homogeneous.

It's late for me now, but I'll go over that paper a bit more closely to actually see what their claims are. You never know they could be right.
 
It's certainly worthy of productive discussion.

If this is true, how likely are you to get that, here? I would suggest taking the paper to your friendly, neighborhood university that has a Materials Science department (or two - you might find one group in the physics department, and another Materials Science department in the college of engineering.).

I haven't read any of the paper, but have seen photos of the chips. They struck me as far, far too regular to be paint chips. In any event, materials science is hardly my area of expertise.

Please direct any scientists you talk to, to the911forum.freeforums.org. The moderator there will not tolerate much abuse. Also, the comments tend to be substantive. Just like I don't think many scientists like to be insulted, I also don't think that they have a lot of time to waste.

Then, if you're so inclined, you can distill whatever pearls of wisdom qualified individuals have to say, and post the main points, here.
 
So... just curious... suppose it actually was thermite, instead of red (iron-pigmented) paint chips. A layer of thermite the thickness of a thick coat of paint--given something as massive as a steel beam, is the paint-thickness thermite likely to heat the beam up enough to make it too warm to pick up without gloves? Weaken steel? Liquify?

I have no expertise whatsoever on this, but every thermite video I have seen has used substantial amounts of thermite to attack a fairly small amount of metal. A paint-chip thickness seems... insignificant. Obviously, though, I could be wrong. Does anybody here know?
 
If this is true, how likely are you to get that, here? I would suggest taking the paper to your friendly, neighborhood university that has a Materials Science department (or two - you might find one group in the physics department, and another Materials Science department in the college of engineering.).

I haven't read any of the paper, but have seen photos of the chips. They struck me as far, far too regular to be paint chips. In any event, materials science is hardly my area of expertise.

Please direct any scientists you talk to, to the911forum.freeforums.org. The moderator there will not tolerate much abuse. Also, the comments tend to be substantive. Just like I don't think many scientists like to be insulted, I also don't think that they have a lot of time to waste.

Then, if you're so inclined, you can distill whatever pearls of wisdom qualified individuals have to say, and post the main points, here.

Oh Hai Metamars. Ask the serious scientists over by your web site just how the Thermite cuts STEEL BEAMS horizontally.

So you are about half way through the beam and in complete defiance of the laws of gravity, instead of burning the metal it is laying right the hell on top of, it keeps going sideways to sever the beam.

THAT is some SUPER Thermite!

Can a brother get a laughing dog?
 
When cornered, deny gravity exists

Oh Hai Metamars. Ask the serious scientists over by your web site just how the Thermite cuts STEEL BEAMS horizontally.

So you are about half way through the beam and in complete defiance of the laws of gravity, instead of burning the metal it is laying right the hell on top of, it keeps going sideways to sever the beam.

THAT is some SUPER Thermite!

Can a brother get a laughing dog?

Oh thats an easy one,

Just ignore the effects of Gravity in every situation. Just like Heiwa does.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom