Child bride beaten in Yemen

You still haven't explained why this would be inappropriate, or how this is consistent with your previous claims of gender equality. After all, it's not like people come here to solicit sex, so you can't analogize it to extramarital sex. Besides, why is it okay for a Muslim man to come here and speak to non-Muslims, half of whom are the opposite gender? Many of the topics around here are not Islamic related, and some are even downright heretical by your standards.

"Because I said so," doesn't count as an explanation by the way.
Gender equality in Islam is different than Western ideas of the concept.

In Islam men and women are equal in the eyes of God and the rewards after death are also equal.

But during our time in the earth. Women are under the protection of men.

In our country we have a President and a Vice President.

In an Islamic marriage the man is like the President and women are like the Vice President.

So all final decisions are in the domain of the man.
 
That's correct. There are a few basic fundamentals that all Muslims MUST observe.

Praying 5 times per day and fasting at Ramadan, are two of the Five Pillars of Islam.

Not eating pork and No sexual relations outside of marriage are two non negotable aspects of the religion.

You should be careful with absolute statements.

Here's a verse on food:
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Holy_Qur'an/An-Nahl

115 He has only forbidden you dead meat, and blood, and the flesh of swine, and any (food) over which the name of other than Allah has been invoked. But if one is forced by necessity, without willful disobedience, nor transgressing due limits, then Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.

On fasting,
What happens if you have a permanent medical condition and cannot fast? What if you are poor and ill? Do you have to stop being a Muslim?

Yes, actions such as those I have mentioned are mandatory to be a Muslim.

Only after a person has adhered to these actions, does the theology of the religion come into play.

That doesn't agree with the quote you gave, which says that sin is not a sign that someone has given up Islam.
 
In our country we have a President and a Vice President.

In an Islamic marriage the man is like the President and women are like the Vice President.

So all final decisions are in the domain of the man.

Speaking of leaders....
Not only have women been leaders of Islamic countries, but the Quran mentions two pagan leaders: Pharoah and the Queen of Sheba. Which of the two was the better leader?

http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Holy_Qur'an/An-Naml
 
Gender equality in Islam is different than Western ideas of the concept.

In Islam men and women are equal in the eyes of God and the rewards after death are also equal.

But during our time in the earth. Women are under the protection of men.

In our country we have a President and a Vice President.

In an Islamic marriage the man is like the President and women are like the Vice President.

So all final decisions are in the domain of the man.

If it's a matter of protection, then please explain why this forum would be 'dangerous' to a Muslim woman. For that matter, please explain what possible way it could cause harm to a Muslim woman if she were to visit any place on the Internet where there were men responding. As I explained before, this forum was intended to be suitable for people as young as children to be able to read (no swearing, no vulgarity, no adult pictures, etc.) Are you saying that Islam needs to keep women under tighter control than most parents would keep their children?

Again, "Because I said so," will not suffice as an explanation.
 
If she was married. Talking to a men who was not her husband would be a serious matter.

Yeah, serious business! :rolleyes: There is no way you can defend this statement without being a disgusting bigotted sexist pig. Period.
 
On fasting,
What happens if you have a permanent medical condition and cannot fast? What if you are poor and ill? Do you have to stop being a Muslim?
Naturally I was talking about a normal healthy person. There are allowances for the person who is ill.

In Islam a person who is sick doesn't have to fast on Ramadon.

Or a person who is physically unable to prostrate themselves for prayer. They can just sit in a chair and do the prayers sitting.
 
If it's a matter of protection, then please explain why this forum would be 'dangerous' to a Muslim woman. For that matter, please explain what possible way it could cause harm to a Muslim woman if she were to visit any place on the Internet where there were men responding. As I explained before, this forum was intended to be suitable for people as young as children to be able to read (no swearing, no vulgarity, no adult pictures, etc.) Are you saying that Islam needs to keep women under tighter control than most parents would keep their children?

Again, "Because I said so," will not suffice as an explanation.

Slientknight, did you miss the fire that just lit up under the bridge? Firegarden just caught Sunni Man copying and pasting his Islamic 'knowledge' from Wikipedia. He doesn't know, believe, or live any of this stuff. He's just making incediary statements and then doing c&p to keep the troll going.
 
If it's a matter of protection, then please explain why this forum would be 'dangerous' to a Muslim woman. For that matter, please explain what possible way it could cause harm to a Muslim woman if she were to visit any place on the Internet where there were men responding. As I explained before, this forum was intended to be suitable for people as young as children to be able to read (no swearing, no vulgarity, no adult pictures, etc.) Are you saying that Islam needs to keep women under tighter control than most parents would keep their children?
I never used the word "dangerous".

I said that a married woman talking to men on a non Islamic form would be inappropriate and unacceptible.

I am sure that this forum is safe, but a religious Muslim woman, married or not, has NO business on any secular forum.

An Islamic woman can talk to a man who is not a relative, at work, the clerk or sales person at a store, government employees at say drivers licsense place, tax accountant, etc.

But not for entertainment or socially.
 
Slientknight, did you miss the fire that just lit up under the bridge? Firegarden just caught Sunni Man copying and pasting his Islamic 'knowledge' from Wikipedia. He doesn't know, believe, or live any of this stuff. He's just making incediary statements and then doing c&p to keep the troll going.

Yeah, I saw it. But to be fair, without letting my personal animosity towards any particular troll get in the way, it could have been a simple matter of forgetting to cite sources. There's no rule against using a source to explain your point of view. (That and I'm rather jealous that FireGarden caught it, so I'm hoping he'll do another blatant C&P so I can call him out. :D )

I never used the word "dangerous".

I said that a married woman talking to men on a non Islamic form would be inappropriate and unacceptible.

I am sure that this forum is safe, but a religious Muslim woman, married or not, has NO business on any secular forum.

An Islamic woman can talk to a man who is not a relative, at work, the clerk or sales person at a store, government employees at say drivers licsense place, tax accountant, etc.

But not for entertainment or socially.

You did use the word "protection" before, when describing the male's role, and protection implies that there is some harm that could come to a woman if she socialized with non-relative men (and women, since this is a public forum). Are you admitting that this rule has nothing to do with protection at all? Why does a Muslim woman have no business on a secular forum? If it has to do with being exposed to secular ideas, then you'd have to shelter women from real life in its entirety, including television, newspapers, books, etc. If the concern is that any socialization will lead to extra-marital sex, then I think you're grasping at straws here. By that logic, there's a huge risk that Muslim women will pursue lesbian relationships if they socialize with non-relative women.

Also, I have yet to see you cite any specific laws. Show me where it states in Islamic laws that women can't socialize with strangers, male or otherwise.
 
....
Also, I have yet to see you cite any specific laws. Show me where it states in Islamic laws that women can't socialize with strangers, male or otherwise.

Following the thread, it seems to me that SMan (born American if I am not mistaken) is somehow trying to live out the culture of the Mid East, from inside the U.S., or sort of an Al 'awrence thing or something. I think he may be confusing Arab cultural practices with Islam.
 
Last edited:
Naturally I was talking about a normal healthy person. There are allowances for the person who is ill.

In Islam a person who is sick doesn't have to fast on Ramadon.

And what about the requirement to feed a poor person? Did that slip your mind?

Also,
You didn't answer my question regarding Pharoah, the Queen of Sheba and which of the two was the better leader.
 
Slientknight, did you miss the fire that just lit up under the bridge? Firegarden just caught Sunni Man copying and pasting his Islamic 'knowledge' from Wikipedia. He doesn't know, believe, or live any of this stuff. He's just making incediary statements and then doing c&p to keep the troll going.

He thinks he's wasting our time. But I can afford a minute here and there. I wonder if Sunni Man ever adds up the time he spends on this.
 
You did use the word "protection" before, when describing the male's role, and protection implies that there is some harm that could come to a woman if she socialized with non-relative men (and women, since this is a public forum). Are you admitting that this rule has nothing to do with protection at all? Why does a Muslim woman have no business on a secular forum? If it has to do with being exposed to secular ideas, then you'd have to shelter women from real life in its entirety, including television, newspapers, books, etc. If the concern is that any socialization will lead to extra-marital sex, then I think you're grasping at straws here.
As stated before, I observe "purdah" at my house and at the Mosque.

There is No mixing between men and women outside of the home or work.

We don't even shake the hand of members of the opposite sex when meeting for the first time.

At the Mosque there is a seperate entrance door and prayer room for men and women. If there is a special dinner. The men and women eat in seperate areas.
 
As stated before, I observe "purdah" at my house and at the Mosque.

There is No mixing between men and women outside of the home or work.

We don't even shake the hand of members of the opposite sex when meeting for the first time.

At the Mosque there is a seperate entrance door and prayer room for men and women. If there is a special dinner. The men and women eat in seperate areas.

You can tell folks. This man knows Islam. Well, once read a book about it. Well, the cliff notes. Abridged.
 
I don't understand why you guys are still entertaining this fake.

(Well except maybe Firegarden, since he owns him I guess he can play a little with him)
 
Last edited:
As stated before, I observe "purdah" at my house and at the Mosque.

There is No mixing between men and women outside of the home or work.

We don't even shake the hand of members of the opposite sex when meeting for the first time.

At the Mosque there is a seperate entrance door and prayer room for men and women. If there is a special dinner. The men and women eat in seperate areas.

Yes, I know about the separate entrances for "brothers and sisters" since I've been to a local mosque as part of an educational outreach program. But once inside, men and women worship together in the same room, to the same God. Both the men and women were happy to answer the questions I had about the religion and its culture (you could probably learn a lot) and they said that the separation, including dining arrangements, was more a formality than an absolute requirement under the law.

Of course, had you checked your Cliff's notes, you'd know that Purdah (unlike Hijab) is more of a regional cultural practice than an Islamic law, given that it also occurs in Hinduism. The Taliban were strict observers of this segregation of genders, and the practice has often been condemned, not by westerners, but from within the communities where it's observed.

So what can you tell me about Islamic rules regarding handshaking?
 
In sunniman's world they don't shake hands on the first meeting. That happens on the second meeting.
I personally don't shake the hand of a women. Some muslim men will, but I don't.

I used the phrase first meeting, because if you shake hands with someone it is usually when first meeting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom