Child bride beaten in Yemen

Basically, this is a mixed forum. Meaning there are both men and women posting here. She would never dialogue on a mixed forum.

An Islamic woman doesn't talk or dialogue with non relative men.

I don't have tell her No, because she knows what is proper and improper within the religion.

Also, because of the rules against sock-puppets and the strictness with which they are enforced, he'd be banned for giving a figment of his imagination an account.
 
An Islamic woman doesn't talk or dialogue with non relative men.
My devoutly Muslim Algerian friend would scoff at you, but then she'd be smart enough to know you're trolling, too. I mean first you say your wife is an MD, and then that she doesn't talk with non-relatives? So all her patients are women? :newlol

You are mediocre at this trolling thing, too.
 
Mediocre, perhaps, but high marks for persistence.
As for the patients all being women: it ain't necessarily so.
She examines the men without actually speaking to them.
I have been known to do that, and believe me, it can be a lot of fun!
 
My devoutly Muslim Algerian friend would scoff at you, but then she'd be smart enough to know you're trolling, too. I mean first you say your wife is an MD, and then that she doesn't talk with non-relatives? So all her patients are women?
Of course she talks with patients spouces and co-workers.

But my statement was about talking to strangers on the internet.

What makes you think your Muslim friend would scoff at me?

My wife and I observe "purdah" in our social lives and worship.

Ask your friend about it and what it means.


btw She is an obstetrician. So yes her patients are women.
 
Last edited:
Am I the only one astounded that someone with the intelligence to qualify as a doctor (if in fact this is true) can be attracted to someone professing sunni man's views?
 
Am I the only one astounded that someone with the intelligence to qualify as a doctor (if in fact this is true) can be attracted to someone professing sunni man's views?


To be fair, compartmentalizing and denial are a fairly well-known phenomena. I have seen many otherwise intelligent people act foolishly in one or more aspects of their lives, so it isn't all that unlikely. It is probably the same type of response a married woman would have when discovering her partner has an obsession with discussing anal intercourse.
 
Last edited:
Why is extra marital sex immoral?

You don't have to tell her no?
If she decided to do it anyway, what would you do?
How do you reconcile saying that your wife is your equal, with claiming the right to control her actions?

But my statement was about talking to strangers on the internet
No it wasn't. This was your statement:
An Islamic woman doesn't talk or dialogue with non relative men.
 
Am I the only one astounded that someone with the intelligence to qualify as a doctor (if in fact this is true) can be attracted to someone professing sunni man's views?
Why?

There are Muslim women all over the world who are both M.D.'s , lawyers, bankers, etc. And are also highly religious and follow the teachings of Islam.
 
My devoutly Muslim Algerian friend
You say that she is devout.

Does she cover her hair with a scarf? Fast on Ramadan? Pray 5 times a day? Doesn't eat pork?

If she observes these things, than she is a truely devout Muslim.

Otherwise, she is Muslim in name only.
 
Does she cover her hair with a scarf? Fast on Ramadan? Pray 5 times a day? Doesn't eat pork?

You know, if religion didn't have this made-up aura of respect to it that makes it "wrong" to criticize it, the description you just made would fit the symptoms of a mental disorder in any other context.
 
Last edited:
She would scoff at you because it's ridiculous to expect a woman to never speak to non-relative men. She listens to heavy metal and chats with men on secular forums and chatrooms all the time and she's no less a Muslim because you say so.
You say that she is devout.

Does she cover her hair with a scarf?
No.
Fast on Ramadan? Pray 5 times a day? Doesn't eat pork?
Yes, yes, yes.

If she observes these things, than she is a truely devout Muslim.

Otherwise, she is Muslim in name only.
No True Scotsman fallacy.

Say, why is pre-marital sex immoral again? Other than "because I say so", that is.
 
Basically, this is a mixed forum. Meaning there are both men and women posting here. She would never dialogue on a mixed forum.

An Islamic woman doesn't talk or dialogue with non relative men.

I don't have tell her No, because she knows what is proper and improper within the religion.
Please cite the specific law you are referring to, and explain why it should still apply today. If it's okay for you, an Islamic man, to speak with strangers online, but it's not okay for your wife just because she's a woman, then your previous claims about gender equality were lies. Besides, I'm sure you're aware that this forum is part of an educational foundation, and it's regulated with the intent of being suitable for children to read if they so choose. Are you admitting to keeping your wife on a tighter rein than one would keep a child? Is that how you truly regard her?
You say that she is devout.

Does she cover her hair with a scarf? Fast on Ramadan? Pray 5 times a day? Doesn't eat pork?

If she observes these things, than she is a truely devout Muslim.

Otherwise, she is Muslim in name only.
Yeah, I'll bet putting sugar on her porridge would disqualify her from being a devout Muslim too. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom