Child bride beaten in Yemen

She would scoff at you because it's ridiculous to expect a woman to never speak to non-relative men. She listens to heavy metal and chats with men on secular forums and chatrooms all the time
Even though she doesn't cover her hair, but does the rest, she can be considered a Muslim.

I seriously doubt that she is married?
 
You say that she is devout.

Does she cover her hair with a scarf? Fast on Ramadan? Pray 5 times a day? Doesn't eat pork?

If she observes these things, than she is a truely devout Muslim.

Otherwise, she is Muslim in name only.

What is your opinion on takfir?
 
What is your opinion on takfir?
I subscribe to the orthodox Sunni position is that sins do not in general prove that someone is not a Muslim, but that denials of fundamental religious principles do; thus a murderer, for instance, may still be a Muslim, but someone who denies that murder is a sin must be a kafir
 
She is still single. Why does that matter?


I don't know. Why is that significant?
If she was married. Talking to a men who was not her husband would be a serious matter.

Many Muslim women don't wear the head scarf in public.

But when praying or attending services at the Mosque, it is mandatory.
 
I subscribe to the orthodox Sunni position is that sins do not in general prove that someone is not a Muslim, but that denials of fundamental religious principles do; thus a murderer, for instance, may still be a Muslim, but someone who denies that murder is a sin must be a kafir

Strangely similar to what wiki has to say, made more suspicious by an "is that" error of pasting/grammar.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takfir

The orthodox Sunni position is that sins do not in general prove that someone is not a Muslim, but that denials of fundamental religious principles do; thus a murderer, for instance, may still be a Muslim, but someone who denies that murder is a sin must be a kafir, as long as he is aware that murder is a sin in Islam.
 
Strangely similar to what wiki has to say, made more suspicious by an "is that" error of pasting/grammar]
What's the problem?

Their answer was exactly how I believe. Plus the example was better than anything I could come up with.
 
Nothing, it's just that people find it suspect when, instead of phrasing something about one's beliefs in one's own words from one's own memory, a self-proclaimed believer instead copy-pastes it from wikipedia. If it was copied from wiki, then a citation would have been in order. There is nothing wrong with referring people to wiki as a source, as long as you provide the link (and admit to using it).

Also, you haven't answered my question regarding your belief that this forum is inappropriate for Muslim women to visit just because you say so.
 
Also, you haven't answered my question regarding your belief that this forum is inappropriate for Muslim women to visit just because you say so.
It would be highly inapproriate for any Muslim woman to visit any internet forum where there are men responding.

The only exception would be an Islamic forum that was frequented by other Muslims. And the topics were Islamic related.
 
What's the problem?

Their answer was exactly how I believe. Plus the example was better than anything I could come up with.

Well, you could have tried refering to the topic which provoked my question: Morrigan's friend. You seemed to be giving a judgement on her 'Muslimicity' -- so I brought up the topic of takfir.

Your comments:

Does she cover her hair with a scarf? Fast on Ramadan? Pray 5 times a day? Doesn't eat pork?

If she observes these things, than she is a truely devout Muslim.

Otherwise, she is Muslim in name only.

You don't mention her beliefs.
Suppose she doesn't fast, but believes that Muslims should if they are able. Then she doesn't fall into the category of the orthodox Sunni position you quoted:

The orthodox Sunni position is that sins do not in general prove that someone is not a Muslim, but that denials of fundamental religious principles do; thus a murderer, for instance, may still be a Muslim, but someone who denies that murder is a sin must be a kafir, as long as he is aware that murder is a sin in Islam.

ie: You didn't ask if she denied a fundamental religious principle. You asked about her actions.
 
Last edited:
You didn't ask if she denied a fundamental religious principle. You asked about her actions.
That's correct. There are a few basic fundamentals that all Muslims MUST observe.

Praying 5 times per day and fasting at Ramadan, are two of the Five Pillars of Islam.

Not eating pork and No sexual relations outside of marriage are two non negotable aspects of the religion.

Yes, actions such as those I have mentioned are mandatory to be a Muslim.

Only after a person has adhered to these actions, does the theology of the religion come into play.
 
It would be highly inapproriate for any Muslim woman to visit any internet forum where there are men responding.

The only exception would be an Islamic forum that was frequented by other Muslims. And the topics were Islamic related.

You still haven't explained why this would be inappropriate, or how this is consistent with your previous claims of gender equality. After all, it's not like people come here to solicit sex, so you can't analogize it to extramarital sex. Besides, why is it okay for a Muslim man to come here and speak to non-Muslims, half of whom are the opposite gender? Many of the topics around here are not Islamic related, and some are even downright heretical by your standards.

"Because I said so," doesn't count as an explanation by the way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom