I think what this shows is the exact opposite of what the OP intends. While people who are highly versed in all the evidence would say this is an absurd position to have, they say that only because they are experts who have a full and complete understanding of all the evidence.
I see what you did there - a subtle form of the appeal to ignorance. Maybe you didn’t realize you were doing it.
It’s not at all true that only experts who know “all the evidence” can see the absurdity of the claim that Apollo was hoaxed. Plenty of laymen have taken a bit of time to learn a few basic facts, or a particular general principle at even a non-mathematical level, which is all it takes to refute the majority of Apollo hoax claims. Most of the time, it
doesn’t take an expert.
It’s also very rare to find someone who can be described as “knowing all the evidence”. The Apollo record - scientific, technological, and programmatic; text, imagery, data, and physical - is vast beyond your realization and virtually fractal in detail. JayUtah is the closest person here to that idealized state, and I’m sure he would readily acknowledge there’s much of the record he doesn’t know in breadth, let alone in depth.
It is understandable, and even laudable, that someone who is not an expert would listen to reasoned arguments (regardless if the reasoning is wrong) and have difficulty believing that humans walked on the moon using the equivalent of pocket calculators and slide rules over 60 years ago and we haven’t been back since.
I don’t have a problem with someone looking at the Moon and having a hard time believing we ever walked on it. It’s a completely natural reaction - a “reasonable” emotional response.
It is by no means laudable to read some claim that one of humanity’s greatest scientific and technical achievements was a lie, and to accept such claims as reasonable or reasoned without interrogating the premise behind them even before tackling the details of the claim itself. There’s no explanation (taking a common conspiracist argument) for the apparent absence of a shadow in some photograph? Suppose, for the sake of argument, we
can’t explain why we don’t see a shadow there. Is the more reasonable explanation that the Apollo program was faked, and the world’s engineers and scientists are all in on it, or maybe there’s just something about the photograph we haven’t figured out yet?
Or to address your characterization: is it laudable to doubt Apollo because the computing technology used was relatively primitive compared to today’s, a half-century later? Or is it laudable to say, “Hey, I don’t actually know what it takes to control a spacecraft, or even what approach they took. Maybe I should read about it or ask an expert before giving any credence to this weird claim”?
Yes, we landed on the moon, but it’s not crazy at all to see why some people have difficulty believing that given the technology and timeframes involved. Further, the government claiming this feat has a long history of lying.
It’s not crazy; it’s just lazy. Furthermore, the government has a long history of lying
and telling the truth. The “government” (as if it was the monolithic entity fancied by conspiracists) has published reams of truth about Apollo. Oceans of truth. More truth in more detail than you could peruse in a lifetime. But there’s no corresponding body of counter-Apollo truth. There’s just ignorance and lies and fantasies promulgated by conspiracists, and lots of mistakes, and most of them are pretty damn silly mistakes to boot.
I’m not sure if you’ve ever listened to the fake moon landing arguments, but they are reasoned. Not saying they are right, but they are reasoned.
I’ve heard, or rather read, most of the various “fake Moon landing arguments”. No, the vast majority of them are not reasoned. There are appeals to ignorance, ignorant interpretations, baseless assertions, and plenty of outright lies. There are very few that rise to the level of “reasoned”, and they’re
still all wrong. And I’ve seen very few that were even made, or at least argued, in good faith.