Hey, we recycled the tapes that have the purest data for the most monumental achievement in human history. No biggie.
Nice strawman. No one here has said "no biggie". I doubt there are many Apollo enthusiasts who wouldn't be delighted to hear that an original magnetic tape had been discovered in some dusty box somewhere, and that it hadn't degraded. That would be cool. As cool as when an amateur astronomer found (most likely) the S-IVB from Apollo 12 in solar orbit - or when large pieces of flown Rocketdyne F-1s were found on the Atlantic floor.
But understand that such a discovery wouldn't really show us anything we don't already know. We could, assuming pristine preservation of the tape, get a recording of the EVA TV broadcast that was slightly sharper, with a bit better contrast, than the best available images we now have.
And keep in mind that NASA's view of Apollo 11 was somewhat different than the public perception. Most people see Apollo through the eyes of a species with a fetish for firsts. First to climb a mountain peak - first to fly the Atlantic... But, while the historical significance of the first landing was not lost on NASA, Apollo 11 was
not regarded as the apex of the Apollo Program. It was, to NASA, the last of the Manned Development Missions, after which the real business of scientifically exploring the moon could begin. Hell, the Apollo 11 EVA lasted only about an hour and a half, whereas Apollo17 was on the surface for
three days and performed three EVAs totalling
22 hours.
And if you find this controversial, you are in the wrong.
First, that's nothing more than your subjective opinion. Given the massive amount of scientific data, geological samples and high quality images returned by the Apollo Program, the loss of a slightly better copy of a short recording of TV images that we have complete, good quality recordings of can certainly be argued to be a relatively inconvenient loss.
Second, controversial in what way? To the CTists Owens is parroting, the word controversial is very much used in the context of "suspicious" - an implication that something is being obfuscated. If you mean in the context of incompetence, then that's a ridiculous assertion. The Apollo Program was a stunning success. The value of what
was preserved far outweighs the value of a (potentially) slightly better quality example of other, still early, recordings of exactly the same event.
Edited by Agatha:
Edited to remove breach of rule 0