Candace Owens says Apollo was a hoax

Wrong about what?

Wrong about anyone calling you an Apollo conspiracy theorist, and wrong about anyone claiming that the pre NTSC conversion tapes still exist.

To be fair, I don't think it's an actual reading compression issue on your part. You simply can't admit that you were wrong about either of those two auto-crucifixion claims.


----------------
Was that few enough words for you?
 
Wrong about anyone calling you an Apollo conspiracy theorist, and wrong about anyone claiming that the pre NTSC conversion tapes still exist.

To be fair, I don't think it's an actual reading compression issue on your part. You simply can't admit that you were wrong about either of those two auto-crucifixion claims.


----------------
Was that few enough words for you?


Wrong. On both counts.

First, it is implied here that my statements were somehow rooted in CT:

The disagreement is over the interpretation of the facts and their implications for the authenticity of the Apollo project.
The argument is that the decision to reuse the Apollo 11 telemetry tapes was so apparently unwise as to be suspicious. Insisting on framing it in hindsight is artificial sustenance for that argument.


Secondly, where did I make any claims about the tapes still existing, or anything related to that?
 
Personally, I'd like to see the best possible examples of this glorious accomplishment.

Yeah, 4K Ultra images would be awesome, wouldn't they?

Too bad we'll never have slightly better images than the ones already recovered by the archive team.

 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, "only kidding" is the catch-cry of right wing morons (including some right here on this forum) who want to say something they are serious about but want cover in case they are ridiculed for it.

Actual skeptics and critical thinkers here have been burned by the bull-**** these half-wits spew so often that they are no longer willing to cut them any slack.
Maybe the critical thinkers left on the forums just interpret right wing statements like autists? It's been going on a long while where the *cough* liberal *cough* posters go on and on about some meaning they infer in some public statement, and then you go over to Republican forums and they aren't taking it like that at all.
 
Wrong. On both counts.

First, it is implied here that my statements were somehow rooted in CT:
Does he specifically say that you are doing that? The thread was started regarding Owens' idiotic parroting of a CT trope.

Secondly, where did I make any claims about the tapes still existing, or anything related to that?
In post #56, you highlighted text from the Wikipedia article about the tapes most likely being erased. Then you wrote, "You folks amuse me. You are so anxious to find a CT devil that you deny basic facts. Too bad they erased those tapes. What a shame".

So what was the point of that post? To express your amusement that you'd found a source confirming what you'd already been told in this thread?
 
That it is mind-boggling that this would be allowed to occur?

Strange that the only people whose minds are boggled about this are conspiracy theorists. Do you really want to throw in with that crowd? Grabbing data from spaceships is in my line of work. I've done it for decades. My mind isn't boggled at all. Old telemetry just isn't that important.

Not sure what you are puffing up about, here.

Not quite sure how your mind being boggled matters. Do you think everyone else's mind should boggle as well?
 
Last edited:
First, it is implied here that my statements were somehow rooted in CT

"Implied." I never claimed you were an Apollo conspiracy theorist and you never said you were. Stop trying to be a victim. That you're borrowing one of their talking points is abundantly evident, which is why I asked if you were interested in having a better-informed opinion. It was under the assumption that you didn't want to be identified with conspiracy theorists. I still believe you don't want to be, but it appears you're more interested in tying everything up in knots that understanding why the curators of that data did what they did.
 
Yeah, 4K Ultra images would be awesome, wouldn't they?

Too bad we'll never have slightly better images than the ones already recovered by the archive team.


Would recommend Dutchsteammachine on Youtube, he's done some great video "conversions" to higher res and framerates. E.g.

 
You can see the moment where somebody opens a door on the sound stage and the wind catches the flag at 9min11s
 
Strange that the only people whose minds are boggled about this are conspiracy theorists. Do you really want to throw in with that crowd? Grabbing data from spaceships is in my line of work. I've done it for decades. My mind isn't boggled at all. Old telemetry just isn't that important.



Not quite sure how your mind being boggled matters. Do you think everyone else's mind should boggle as well?

Again, speaking on behalf of laypersons: it seems like original Apollo data would be...you know, priceless. Sort of like a copy of the gun that Burr used to shoot Jefferson is not that interesting, but the actual gun is. Genuine piece of history and whatnot.

In a way, NASA's practicality is admirable. Instead of saving junior's baby shoes for posterity, they recycled them to advance their ongoing mission.
 
In a way, NASA's practicality is admirable. Instead of saving junior's baby shoes for posterity, they recycled them to advance their ongoing mission.

Because they were never considered part of the record
 
Again, speaking on behalf of laypersons: it seems like original Apollo data would be...you know, priceless. Sort of like a copy of the gun that Burr used to shoot Jefferson is not that interesting, but the actual gun is. Genuine piece of history and whatnot.

In a way, NASA's practicality is admirable. Instead of saving junior's baby shoes for posterity, they recycled them to advance their ongoing mission.
Just imagine though. If it hadn't been for the money they saved on storing those 45 tapes, the ISS might never have been possible.
 
Hey, we recycled the tapes that have the purest data for the most monumental achievement in human history. No biggie.

The least usable data, you mean. And yes, it was a biggie. When Memorex pulled the rug out from under NASA and the Landsat data needed to be recorded or be lost forever -- in any form -- people had to make some hard choices.

And if you find this controversial, you are in the wrong.

Given the total picture of what happened, yes, you're in the wrong. It seems that you desperately need it to be controversial. I do this for a living. It's not controversial. I have no idea why you need it to be.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove quoted breach of rule 11 and response to same
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey, we recycled the tapes that have the purest data for the most monumental achievement in human history.

It was not 'the purest data'. It was a slightly better TV picture. We have very detailed Hasselblad stills and 16mm footage, and mountains of actual data covering this and all subsequent landings..

No biggie.

That's correct, unless you're hell-bent on attaching some significance to it that isn't warranted.



Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove off-topic material and response to same
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do we? I've never thought so, but we are discussing something that's a conspiracy-theory talking point.

The original telemetry from Apollo 11 isn't known to exist, and was probably erased in favor of capturing new telemetry from ongoing missions -- an unfortunate exigency. But not a tragedy or an abrogation of duty, because telemetry tapes are rarely if ever considered frontline data. The embedded camera data is particularly unusable since it requires a dedicated telemetry recorder and the custom-built slow-scan converter (about the size of three refrigerators) to even view it. That's why it was immediately read out into a standard NTSC format (ironically higher resolution and frame rate than SSTV) so that it could be actually used.

If you're not interested in getting inside the heads of the people who designed, built, and operated that system, then so be it. But continuing to labor with a boggled mind under conditions of willful ignorance is probably just going to earn you mockery.

If copies of the original SSTV format tapes were to be found, more modern digital technology could make a higher-quality conversion, yielding better images than those originally seen.

Yeah, that's about it. What you folks are arguing about, I don't know.

It is as though you are seeking to justify an incredibly stupid action.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 11 and rule 0
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah, that's about it.

The operative word is "could." I know about this project. I know the people on it and have followed it for a number of years. They aren't inevitably successful. And back in the day, the ability to do a better readout with digital technology, decades hence, wasn't contemplated. It's not as if NASA destroyed the original data for no good reason. They destroyed it because they were desperate for functional telemetry media and had little other choice.

The original television signal had a low frame rate and a low vertical resolution. Reading it out to NTSC actual up-converts it. However, since the up-conversion used an optical process -- similar to telecines and kinescopes -- there will necessarily be a tone shift. The best they could have hoped for is better gray tones, less contrast.

It is as though you are seeking to justify an incredibly stupid action.

We're opposing your opinion that it was "incredibly stupid." And we've provided the reasons why we and many others don't think it was "incredibly stupid." You simply don't wish to engage with those reasons.

Good for you, I suppose. It is what I expect here...because the only purpose for most is to argue.

It is a debate forum, after all.

That is only second to those wishing to display how much they know...about everything.

I'm professionally qualified in this field. And I've made a special study of the technological history of Apollo and have written extensively on it and made television appearances. I guarantee I know more about the Apollo missions than you do. And from that position of hard-won superior understanding, I can provide reasons why your opinion is ill-informed. Rather than lording my specialized knowledge over you or anyone else, I'm here answering questions and sharing my knowledge with anyone who wants it.

Now you can either decide to be educated by people who are willing to share their knowledge with you in the hopes of helping you form a more informed opinion, or you can wallow in ignorance and snipe from the sidelines. It's pretty clear at this point what your plan is.
 
Last edited:
Hey, we recycled the tapes that have the purest data for the most monumental achievement in human history. No biggie.
Nice strawman. No one here has said "no biggie". I doubt there are many Apollo enthusiasts who wouldn't be delighted to hear that an original magnetic tape had been discovered in some dusty box somewhere, and that it hadn't degraded. That would be cool. As cool as when an amateur astronomer found (most likely) the S-IVB from Apollo 12 in solar orbit - or when large pieces of flown Rocketdyne F-1s were found on the Atlantic floor.

But understand that such a discovery wouldn't really show us anything we don't already know. We could, assuming pristine preservation of the tape, get a recording of the EVA TV broadcast that was slightly sharper, with a bit better contrast, than the best available images we now have.

And keep in mind that NASA's view of Apollo 11 was somewhat different than the public perception. Most people see Apollo through the eyes of a species with a fetish for firsts. First to climb a mountain peak - first to fly the Atlantic... But, while the historical significance of the first landing was not lost on NASA, Apollo 11 was not regarded as the apex of the Apollo Program. It was, to NASA, the last of the Manned Development Missions, after which the real business of scientifically exploring the moon could begin. Hell, the Apollo 11 EVA lasted only about an hour and a half, whereas Apollo17 was on the surface for three days and performed three EVAs totalling 22 hours.

And if you find this controversial, you are in the wrong.
First, that's nothing more than your subjective opinion. Given the massive amount of scientific data, geological samples and high quality images returned by the Apollo Program, the loss of a slightly better copy of a short recording of TV images that we have complete, good quality recordings of can certainly be argued to be a relatively inconvenient loss.

Second, controversial in what way? To the CTists Owens is parroting, the word controversial is very much used in the context of "suspicious" - an implication that something is being obfuscated. If you mean in the context of incompetence, then that's a ridiculous assertion. The Apollo Program was a stunning success. The value of what was preserved far outweighs the value of a (potentially) slightly better quality example of other, still early, recordings of exactly the same event.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 0
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom