Candace Owens says Apollo was a hoax

I blush at the compliment, and readily acknowledge that I routinely encounter people whose knowledge exceeds my own in either breadth or depth.
The renewed historical interest in Apollo has opened up many archives. The Computer History Museum has restored an actual guidance computer found in a trove of cast-off hardware. I've seen it; it's glorious. But it goes to show that what's found on trash heaps matches what's found in documents. And the documents show us a fully-formed, functional space system. What remains of the hardware shows us a full-formed, functional space system. At some point, if it were all fake, at least one of these deep-dive space history nuts would have come across something that was obviously fake, something that just doesn't work. In decades they haven't been able to.

It doesn't surprise me that there are people who think there was ever only one mission to the Moon. That's a compound lens created from ever-distancing history and media attention. It doesn't bother me, either. Knowing that kind of history just isn't important to some people.

As with others, what bothers me is the attitude of confidence arising from ignorance. We're in a post-truth, post-fact era, where many people don't consciously consider that they don't actually know something. So we have people confidently saying it's amazing we made it to the Moon on just one shot. And if you keep taking steps in that direction, you confidently state that it's too incredible to believe, so it must have been fake. I don't know how to convince people that they should inform themselves before shooting their mouths off, but there seems to be a lot of that these days.


Hell, I often find out things about the Apollo programme that I either didn't even know existed, or did know existed, but either had no idea or was wrong about what they actually did. A case in point, the Saturn V instrument ring. I had always visualised it (probably because of what it was called) as a just bunch a sensors used by the computer on board the Command module. Then I saw this video from Destin Sandlin's "Smarter Every Day" second channel where he teams up with Linus from "Linus Tech Tips" and visits the US Space & Rocket Center in Huntsville, Alabama for a visit with Luke Talley, one of the IBM computer engineers who worked on the Saturn V.


Its almost 45 minutes, but for someone like me, its worth every minute.

Turns out the "instrument ring" contains a whole god-damn computer in its own right (the Launch Vehicle Digital Computer) complete with memory cores, batteries and cooling systems!
 
I’m not sure if you’ve ever listened to the fake moon landing arguments, but they are reasoned. Not saying they are right, but they are reasoned.

Maybe we have a different definition of reason? Which arguments are reasoned?

Generally I read arguments from hoax proponents who

1. have never used a camera at night
2. never used a film camera in manual mode
3. do not know what the radiation levels were in space or how they were measured
4. know nothing of the laws of motion
5. think rockets can't operate in a vacuum
6. do not understand what a vacuum is
7. do not know how a computer without a graphics interface works

and a ton of other things.
 
Hell, I often find out things about the Apollo programme that I either didn't even know existed, or did know existed, but either had no idea or was wrong about what they actually did. A case in point, the Saturn V instrument ring. I had always visualised it (probably because of what it was called) as a just bunch a sensors used by the computer on board the Command module. Then I saw this video from Destin Sandlin's "Smarter Every Day" second channel where he teams up with Linus from "Linus Tech Tips" and visits the US Space & Rocket Center in Huntsville, Alabama for a visit with Luke Talley, one of the IBM computer engineers who worked on the Saturn V.


Its almost 45 minutes, but for someone like me, its worth every minute.

Turns out the "instrument ring" contains a whole god-damn computer in its own right (the Launch Vehicle Digital Computer) complete with memory cores, batteries and cooling systems!
For the first half of the first paragraph, I was thinking, "I should mention that SED video about the instrumentation ring".

One of those cool "that's why they did that" learning moments for me was about the Kapton insulation on the LM. The film was deliberately crumpled up by hand before installation so as to minimize contact between the layers, and thereby limit thermal conduction from the outer to inner layers. It's one of those things that, when you hear it for the first time, makes perfect sense, but highlights just how clever and detailed the design of the whole Apollo system really was.
 
The film was deliberately crumpled up by hand before installation so as to minimize contact between the layers, and thereby limit thermal conduction from the outer to inner layers.

Hand-crumpled and signed in magic marker by the crumplers and installers on the inside surfaces of the blankets.
 
Maybe we have a different definition of reason? Which arguments are reasoned?

Generally I read arguments from hoax proponents who

1. have never used a camera at night
2. never used a film camera in manual mode
3. do not know what the radiation levels were in space or how they were measured
4. know nothing of the laws of motion
5. think rockets can't operate in a vacuum
6. do not understand what a vacuum is
7. do not know how a computer without a graphics interface works

and a ton of other things.

My bold. To be pedantic, have never used a camera in BROAD DAYLIGHT in a place without an atmosphere and expect to see stars.

Also, my strikethrough in 7.
 
Hand-crumpled and signed in magic marker by the crumplers and installers on the inside surfaces of the blankets.

One of the benefits of dealing with these idiots is that while they ask questions whose answers they have interest in, you get to find those answers out. That's how I learned that the kapton and other cladding was installed inside the Saturn V while on the launchpad!
 
For the first half of the first paragraph, I was thinking, "I should mention that SED video about the instrumentation ring".

One of those cool "that's why they did that" learning moments for me was about the Kapton insulation on the LM. The film was deliberately crumpled up by hand before installation so as to minimize contact between the layers, and thereby limit thermal conduction from the outer to inner layers. It's one of those things that, when you hear it for the first time, makes perfect sense, but highlights just how clever and detailed the design of the whole Apollo system really was.

For me that’s always been one of the fascinations of the early decades of the space programme, it was as much craftwork as engineering. Everything was to use a handy phrase handcrafted. Probably the pinnacle of our thousands of years of craftwork. Today the craft and so on are still jaw droppingly amazing but often only possible because of our advances in computing, they are beyond what we can do “by hand”.
 
For me that’s always been one of the fascinations of the early decades of the space programme, it was as much craftwork as engineering. Everything was to use a handy phrase handcrafted. Probably the pinnacle of our thousands of years of craftwork. Today the craft and so on are still jaw droppingly amazing but often only possible because of our advances in computing, they are beyond what we can do “by hand”.

A common conspiracy claim -- asking why we haven't had manned missions since Apollo -- is that the blueprints still exist (don't they?) and we still have an aerospace industry (don't we?), so why can't we just dig out the blueprints and build the equipment all over again? Among the many reasons why that wouldn't work is exactly the point you touched on: the task still requires human skill and judgment that has been lost. Much of aerospace is still "hand-crafted" in that design documents still don't capture the human element of building this stuff.

My company sells a particular kind of sensor circuit aggregator that lists for $65,000. It's about the size of a building brick. But at that price tag, we don't build a bunch of them on an assembly line and keep them in a warehouse until someone decides to buy them. We don't sell enough of them to make that cost-effective. They're built to order and hand-assembled (albeit from largely manufactured parts). Yes, for regulatory purposes the process of making it is meticulously documented. But that doesn't mean anyone in the company can make out. The people who actually make them are some of our most valued employees, precisely because they have the hand-crafting skills.
 
A common conspiracy claim -- asking why we haven't had manned missions since Apollo -- is that the blueprints still exist (don't they?) and we still have an aerospace industry (don't we?), so why can't we just dig out the blueprints and build the equipment all over again? Among the many reasons why that wouldn't work is exactly the point you touched on: the task still requires human skill and judgment that has been lost. Much of aerospace is still "hand-crafted" in that design documents still don't capture the human element of building this stuff.

My company sells a particular kind of sensor circuit aggregator that lists for $65,000. It's about the size of a building brick. But at that price tag, we don't build a bunch of them on an assembly line and keep them in a warehouse until someone decides to buy them. We don't sell enough of them to make that cost-effective. They're built to order and hand-assembled (albeit from largely manufactured parts). Yes, for regulatory purposes the process of making it is meticulously documented. But that doesn't mean anyone in the company can make out. The people who actually make them are some of our most valued employees, precisely because they have the hand-crafting skills.

I watched something recently about the difficulty of building the Rocketdyne F-1 today. It turns out there's a ton of reverse engineering to do for even seemingly small parts. Often, critical refinements were made during the fabrication of parts by highly skilled machinists who knew from years of experience how to make something work. The design drawings don't tell you about any of those sorts of refinements that were made in order to get some system to work properly and reliably, and are only recorded is some machinist's notes.

I saw an engineer talk about how difficult and expensive it would be even to remake something much simpler than Apollo, like the Concord SST. It would be very challenging to figure out all the "so that's how they did that". Even restorations of wood, wire and linen aircraft from a century ago reveal a lot of expert craftsmanship that isn't necessarily included in the design drawings.
 
Last edited:
I watched something recently about the difficulty of building the Rocketdyne F-1 today. It turns out there's a ton of reverse engineering to do for even seemingly small parts. Often, critical refinements were made during the fabrication of parts by highly skilled machinists who knew from years of experience how to make something work. The design drawings don't tell you about any of those sorts of refinements that were made in order to get some system to work properly and reliably, and are only recorded is some machinist's notes.

I saw an engineer talk about how difficult and expensive it would be even to remake something much simpler than Apollo, like the Concord SST. It would be very challenging to figure out all the "so that's how they did that". Even restorations of wood, wire and linen aircraft from a century ago reveal a lot of expert craftsmanship that isn't necessarily included in the design drawings.

I'm reminded here of an old joke.

A town puts on a historical railroad re-enactment, and the steam engine quits. Nobody can seem to get it going, until someone calls an old retired mechanic. The mechanic takes a little brass hammer out of his pocket, goes to a particular part of the machine and hits it. The machine starts.

Later he submits a bill for a thousand dollars. The city fathers complain, and ask how he could charge so much for just one little tap. He resubmits the bill, itemized: $1 for hammering. $999 for knowing where to hit.
 
A common conspiracy claim -- asking why we haven't had manned missions since Apollo -- is that the blueprints still exist (don't they?) and we still have an aerospace industry (don't we?), so why can't we just dig out the blueprints and build the equipment all over again? Among the many reasons why that wouldn't work is exactly the point you touched on: the task still requires human skill and judgment that has been lost. Much of aerospace is still "hand-crafted" in that design documents still don't capture the human element of building this stuff.

My company sells a particular kind of sensor circuit aggregator that lists for $65,000. It's about the size of a building brick. But at that price tag, we don't build a bunch of them on an assembly line and keep them in a warehouse until someone decides to buy them. We don't sell enough of them to make that cost-effective. They're built to order and hand-assembled (albeit from largely manufactured parts). Yes, for regulatory purposes the process of making it is meticulously documented. But that doesn't mean anyone in the company can make out. The people who actually make them are some of our most valued employees, precisely because they have the hand-crafting skills.

This is why Clinton green-lit the SEAWOLF submarine back in the 1990s. His reasoning was that if those assembly lines for submarines were to close the US would quickly lose the ability to build new ones should the need arise as those skilled workers would move onto other jobs, and the brain trust would retire.

It's like our playing catch-up with hyper-sonics. The Skunk Works was forced to destroy much of their templates for the SR-71 (which remains the fastest air-breathing aircraft) in the early 1970s. Much of our more profound aerospace technology is in our rearview mirror. Weird how that world works.
 
There's better ways to do hypersonics than the way the SR-71 did them. And the US did some productive research into modern hypersonics before shelving the program(s).

I don't think we're playing "catch-up" with hypersonics. My view of that is basically, "show me a nation's weapons, and I'll show you a nation's enemies."

Russia and China have been investing heavily in hypersonic anti-ship missiles because their enemy has an immensely powerful navy predicated on a doctrine of massive mobile air bases. They need these kinds of weapons to go up against a Carrier Strike Group.

The US, meanwhile, isn't facing that kind of enemy navy (yet). Instead, they've been investing in better and better air defense systems. Because that's the kind of enemy they're facing: One with better and better anti-ship missiles. The US "catches up" with Chinese hypersonics not by developing hypersonic missiles of their own, but by upgrading their air defense systems to address the upgraded threat.

The US would develop hypersonics of their own to "catch up" with improved enemy air defense systems that are too effective at countering the older, slower stuff. Interestingly, in this area the US seems to be instead investing in stealthier missiles, rather than faster ones, and stealthier launch platforms for those missiles.

To me it seems like the Russians and the Chinese have been forced to invest in hypersonics because they have so far been unable to produce the kind high-quality low-observable airframes necessary to defeat US air defenses that way. The US doesn't seem to have that problem quite yet.
 
Last edited:
There's better ways to do hypersonics than the way the SR-71 did them. And the US did some productive research into modern hypersonics before shelving the program(s).

I don't think we're playing "catch-up" with hypersonics. My view of that is basically, "show me a nation's weapons, and I'll show you a nation's enemies."

Russia and China have been investing heavily in hypersonic anti-ship missiles because their enemy has an immensely powerful navy predicated on a doctrine of massive mobile air bases. They need these kinds of weapons to go up against a Carrier Strike Group.

The US, meanwhile, isn't facing that kind of enemy navy (yet). Instead, they've been investing in better and better air defense systems. Because that's the kind of enemy they're facing: One with better and better anti-ship missiles. The US "catches up" with Chinese hypersonics not by developing hypersonic missiles of their own, but by upgrading their air defense systems to address the upgraded threat.

The US would develop hypersonics of their own to "catch up" with improved enemy air defense systems that are too effective at countering the older, slower stuff. Interestingly, in this area the US seems to be instead investing in stealthier missiles, rather than faster ones, and stealthier launch platforms for those missiles.

To me it seems like the Russians and the Chinese have been forced to invest in hypersonics because they have so far been unable to produce the kind high-quality low-observable airframes necessary to defeat US air defenses that way. The US doesn't seem to have that problem quite yet.

I agree with your assessment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom